Quaint cupcake shop that start you off with the base cupcake and then you can pick what type of frostings and extras etc. It's kinda like the Chipotle of cupcakes. My standard for cupcakes are different than the general masses as I feel like the ENTIRE cupcake should be a complete entity taste wise and one component shouldn't outshine the other. For example, the toppings and icing they put on top of the cupcake is STELLAR but the actual bare cupcake itself tastes like one of those cakes box mixes like DUNCAN HINES, or PILLSBURY. The entire cupcake should be good not just one half component of it. Nevertheless they've got all different types of candies, bon bons, they bake wedding cakes, and host private parties so what do I know‍. Apparently DUBLIN loves the hell outta em because it was constant traffic of folks in and outta there making purchases. read more

See all

I had a wonderful time at the 'Bake and Decorate Your First Birthday Cake' class! Linda and Tom both provided excellent hands on experience with baking a cake from scratch, making icing and decorating a cake. They gave tons of helpful tips and tricks throughout the class and I left there feeling empowered that I could take this on myself at home! Would recommend to anyone looking to get into baking and decorating! Oh, and the cake turned out DELICIOUS!! read more

Our CupCakery - Bakeries Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

I went there for a friend's birthday party and our instructor was so snappy and almost sounded mad. I honestly don't think you should come here for a birthday party read more

Ordered cupcakes and cake for graduation! Very yummy!! Highlight recommended the speciality cupcakes. Great option if needs to be GF! read more

Our CupCakery - Bakeries Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

What a sweet little shop to pick up some sweets! They have a huge menu of both cupcake and frosting flavors. You can customize whatever flavor combos you like and then they frost them to order. The cupcakes come in three sizes - mini, standard, and king. They have several flavors of the day, including gluten free, and peanut butter was my favorite. They also make custom cakes and have all kinds of class offerings. They even do tea parties, private events and kids camps. They are open to the public Wednesday-Saturday. Sundays and Mondays are by appointment and Tuesdays are for scheduled preorders. read more

See all

I placed an order 2.5 weeks out, tried to cancel in less than 24 hours. Our Cupcakery manager told me over the phone no refund at all, then hesitantly offered me 50% refund. They kept 50% of my money on cupcakes that they never made for me. Awful customer service. A consumer should be able to cancel an order two weeks in advance and get a refund. Our cupcakery website makes it difficult to see and find the "all sales final" notification which I believe is misleading and unethical towards consumers. Instead of baking classes, our cupcakery should be taking customer service classes read more

We stopped in for cupcakes for the kids, and the kids loved them! I tasted a tiny bit of the cake part, and it was soft and spongy -- just what you want in a cupcake. Our CupCakery specializes in custom cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and other desserts. They have a make-your-own cupcake menu, where you can customize your cupcake to fit your exact preferences. They also sell pre-made cupcakes, as well as decorated sugar cookies, brownies and more. While we were there waiting for our cupcakes to be made, a bride-to-be and her family came in for a cake tasting. So, they do wedding cakes, too! Our CupCakery is one of the stops on the Dublin Irish Fairy Door Trail. You'll spot the fairy door in the window of the shop! read more

Great place very talented group. I can rely on them on delivering customized cakes the way I want them for any occasions I have been a customer since 2016 and never regretted using them. read more

Our CupCakery - Bakeries Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Oh my goodness that heavenly smells inside of this business! This is an unusual review because I wasn't there to buy anything but waiting for a jump on my car. They let me wait inside of this business and keep my phone charged up while I was waiting for Pop a lock to show up. They offer classes and make custom baked goods lots of displays up of wedding cakes that they have done and it all looks gorgeous read more

What a gorgeous shop, filled with delectable looking and smelling treats! We came in as we were strolling through historic Dublin, and the glass case was full of tasty treats, including not only the cupcakes (the chocolate peppermint, yum!) one would expect from the name, but also some cookies, brownies, buckeyes, and the like. They also offer a nice party/event space in the back, which looked like it was set up for an upcoming event at the time of our visit, and it looked really nice. They also offer custom cakes and cupcakes, as well as public and private classes. The staff was so kind, friendly, and helpful. We would love to stop in again. read more

See all

The most adorable cupcake shop in historic Dublin! I stopped to in pick up half a dozen cupcakes for a friends birthday. All the flavors are listed to make it easy to choose when it's your turn in line. I like how they don't frost the cupcakes until you order them - makes sure the frosting stays fresh and you get to choose the type of frosting you want! Their season apple cinnamon cupcake was decorated perfectly and tasted delicious! I've seen ads for some of their classes and tickets can be a little pricey so I've yet to go to one. It does look like they host private events though, they had things set up for a birthday party when I stopped in. I also inquired about cupcakes and cakes for our wedding and the woman working was nice enough to walk me through the process and even gave me a copy of the Columbus Wedding magazine in which one of their cakes was featured. read more

See all

I've been to several bakeries around Columbus in search for the best. It took me too long to find this place. It's in a little town, easy to get to, lots of parking around. This place has a build-your-own cupcake with several sizes and types of cakes, icings, and toppings to choose from. The flavor is full with sweetness (but not too sweet) and the atmosphere of it being a small bakery makes it more enjoyable. The owner is very sweet and welcoming. I wish this place was open more often through the week. read more

Our CupCakery - This was a cookie dough cupcake, and two birthday cupcakes with a vanilla cake pop! - Bakeries Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

Went to a cookie decorating class in 2/2/25. I like the fact they were very into cleanliness and handwashing. I also ordered chocolate cupcakes with caramel and chocolate icing and cake pops with mermaid sprinkles. The class was fun but would not recommend anything other than a class. My cupcakes did not taste very good. In fact the bottoms of some of them were discolored ( lighter brown), meaning they were old or spoiled. Either way they were not edible. By the time we arrived home, the glob of icing had slid off three of the cupcakes. I did not order these with sprinkles and nonpareil balls, but had sprinkles all over them. I should've looked at them before we left the shop. I can't stand sprinkles especially nonpareil balls. Why would you do that? The colors were different from the cake pop colors. So someone thought that I should have sprinkles and nonpareils on my cupcakes? Gross! The cake pops looked fabulous but were only half baked and gooey to wet on the inside. Had to throw those out too! I paid $70 for a dozen cake pops and 6 cupcakes. Definitely not with the money that I paid. I will definitely not be going back there! Don't waste your time or money! I should have taken pictures but was so disgusted that we just trashed them all. I don't usually leave reviews but anywhere is better than that place in terms of taste. They do great work in terms of decoration but very disappointed by the taste and the fact they were not cooked properly. The cake pops were for my granddaughter. read more

This review was sitting in my drafts from at least a year ago, wanted to post it. I have not been here. However, I have been calling around all morning in search of sugar-free baked goods. Even those that show on their website that they have them, upon calling, have revealed that they do not have sugar free options. However, this is the only place that has had any. I was in search of cake for my mother's birthday. Although, as it was last minute and they aren't open Sundays, they weren't able to help me, at least they do have sugar-free options. As my mother is diabetic, this is very important. Just wanted others to be aware, as my personal search seemed to be fruitless until I called here. read more

I can't say enough good things about my experience with this bakery. First, their customer service was top notch. They made everything so easy for me and the price was great. The donut cake for my sons 1st birthday turned out even better than I thought it would and then best part? It tasted so good! Everyone at the party agreed. The smash cake was a perfect size and complimentary! We will be ordering all of our cakes from here moving forward! read more

Our CupCakery - Bakeries Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

I cannot say enough good things about OurCupcakery and the people who work there! We have used their business for everything over the past 12 years including our wedding, baby showers, and birthdays. They always deliver a beautiful and delicious product. The customer services is second to none - always friendly, helpful, and prompt with their responses! We have also enjoyed attending some of the special events they have hosted including a macron making class, gingerbread house building, and princess tea party. The events are always well organized, reasonably priced, and so much fun! The staff is extremely kind and wonderful with my young children. I can't recommend this shop highly enough - they are just the best! read more

I happened into Our CupCakery walking through Old Dublin, and was really pleased with what I saw. I purchased two different cupcakes (Black Forest and Guinness) and enjoyed them both. I was thrilled when they were also a vendor at the wedding show I went to at Franklin Park, and my wife and I ended up getting our wedding cake (Black Forest, because it's seriously soooo amazing) and a ton of cupcakes for them. The cake was delicious and all of our guests loved it, too. I've since used them for birthday parties and other holiday parties, and still stop in now and again for a cupcake when the craving strikes. The only reason I gave 4 stars was for a very small issue for my wedding, where the cake was late. Everything ended up fine, but it could have turned into a big problem. I would still recommend this shop for event or just for walk ins. read more

Our CupCakery - Panda Cake for my wife's 40th, along with strawberry lemonade and chocolate iced vanilla cupcakes. - Bakeries Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Tastes amazing and also just did an amazing job with communication and design planning. read more

Our CupCakery - Chocolate and vanilla Cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

My only visit here was for a cake decorating class, which I enjoyed. It was in the evening, after the shop was closed to the public. The woman in charge (I believe an owner) was very witty and easy-going. I thought we would be in the kitchen, but they had us sitting at tables in the front room. We were given 2 cake layers, which we trimmed up, frosted, and designed. We learned the proper way to fill a pastry bag and how to decorate with frosting flowers. I learned a lot and will probably put it to good use when I put my mind to it. :-) I don't shop in Old Dublin much, but when and if, I will definitely stop back in to get a cupcake. The flavors looked great and it is a cute shop. read more

Our Cupcakery has been so amazing to work with. I had a wedding during COVID and we went from having 280 guests to 28 guests. They were so accommodating and willing to work with us, and did an amazing job on our cake. We then reached out to them again for my baby shower. The picture I sent them, was identical to what they showed up with. I highly , highly recommend them. They are so sweet, reliable, great customer service and their cakes / cupcakes are always fresh and delicious!! read more

See all

Laura and her team at the CupCakery in Dublin are incredible! My mum and I had a vision for a pretty complex wedding cake (photo attached) and Laura helped us design it so that it was a sturdy structure but left our guests wondering how we did it! Along with a jaw dropping design, she also helped us enhance the cake with simple elements such as the dark red flowers and special piping and shine. Her attention to detail is unmatched. Throughout the whole process we felt as though we had a family member helping us design and create an incredibly memorable cake that my family and friends still talk about! read more

Our CupCakery - Bakeries Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

We walked in after craving something sweet and this little place exceeded expectations. The cupcakes were delicious and decorated beautifully. read more

I'm gluten free so I go here for the GF cupcakes. They are usually sold out of a lot of them but they definitely hit the spot.

I just got my birthday cake and I love it. When I was talking to Linda over the phone, she really listened to everything I wanted and talked to me on how to make it look and taste better. She gave me time to decided on prices and flavors. The cake looked awesome too. The only thing I had a off opinion on was that the buttercream was too sweat, so if your not a big fan of it get something else. But I loved it over all. The store was also very very beautiful and I would love to live in it. read more

Our CupCakery - My birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

Another shout out to cupcakery poor customer service! Just received my $30 fee for canceling my cake order three plus weeks before my order was to be ready--(was told product had not yet been purchased for my order, but she had to pay her staff to help place my two sheet cake order) and was never informed of cancellation fee when placing my order! I will continue to spread the word on their poor business practices!!!!! read more

I had several variations of cupcakes at a wedding and they were delicious. When I had to return the cake stands after the event they had orange creamsicle as the flavor of the month (I think). The assorted sizes made it super easy to buy a big one for my daughter and a sampler size for me. They were fantastic. Not dry or tough, but light and with just enough of the moisture in the fluff to melt in your mouth. Highly recommend especially since I am not much of a cake fan as this exceeded my expectations immensely!! The wedding cupcakes were delish too- lemon with raspberry, white with strawberry filling and chocolate. Beautiful arrangement of them as well. read more

Our CupCakery - Orange Creamsicle Cupcakes! - Bakeries Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

I recommend Our CupCakery. Our cake design matched what we wanted exactly. The flavors, pumpkin spice with cream cheese and vanilla with almond, were delicious. Laura had great customer service. read more

My sister and I were visiting Dublin this past weekend and found this place while walking around exploring the town. We decided to stop in and it was a fun experience! We got to pick our own cupcake flavors, filling, frosting, and toppings and they were put together right in front of us! So fun When we went back to our hotel to eat them that night, I'm not even kidding, they were the best cupcakes we have ever had! The cake flavors were decadent and moist, and the FROSTING... So freaking delicious! How delicious? So much so that we trekked through the pouring rain the next day for more! Some for us and some for our family. All of whom said the exact same thing about them being the best cake they've ever had! Idk what they put in them, but it's magic! The store itself is adorable too! They have a separate area in the back for classes and parties, a separate area for wedding cake tastings in the front, and cute displays of their work all over! The only thing sweeter than these cupcakes is the owner! She was a true delight and took time out of her day to talk to my sister and I like we were old friends. I think we found a new tradition every time we visit Dublin now! :) read more

I was scheduled for one of Our CupCakery's adult cake decorating classes. Despite the high price of the ticket and the long distance I had to drive to get there (1.5 hours) I was still excited. (I don't get to do this kind of thing very often living out in the country like I do.) But then a snow storm comes through and my rural area doesn't have any salt to treat the roads...I didn't want to risk my safety for a cake decorating class. Who would?! So I thought it would be a reasonable request for the owners to transfer the ticket to another date or to give me a credit. Simple, right? No! I knew it was last minute but I clearly explained where I was coming from and the difference in the condition of the roads. This didn't seem to make any difference to them. Instead of listening to ANYTHING I told them, they made an excuse that the next available class opening isn't until May (not sure why that prevents them from good customer service) and that the local weather wasn't bad for THEM. (Oh good! I'm so happy they didn't need to worry about crashing their car into a random Amish buggy on an icy back road.) So they basically stole $48 from me. read more

We used Our CupCakery for our May wedding and all three flavors we used were a huge hit!!! The coordinator, Sarah, was incredibly easy to work with and provided very quick responses. I highly suggest supporting this local bakery and enjoying their many delicious flavors! read more

Our CupCakery - Wedding dessert table with wedding cake. - Bakeries Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

This bakery came highly recommend. so I choose almond cupcake with almond icing faintly had the almond flavor, orange cupcake over cooked vanilla icing had an odd taste, cherry chip moist with vanilla icing which had an odd taste. DON'T WASTE YOUR TIME OR MONEY. OR YES, IT TOOK ALMOST 40 MINUTES TO GET THEM ICED AND OUT THE DOOR, WE WERE THE SECOND PEOPLE IN LINE.. the cake almost reminded me of a box cake and the icing like it had way to much powder sugar yuck!! read more

We used Our CupCakery for our wedding cake and cupcakes one year ago. Everything went smoothly and everyone loved the cupcakes! For our first anniversary, my husband had the top tier of our cake remade. The cakes taste amazing and prices are very reasonable. read more

This place is adorable. My coworkers and I were in town for a meeting and stopped in to check it out. The cupcakes were delicious and still warm when the handed them to us. Very creative flavor combinations and filling options. There is even a make your own cupcake bar. read more

See all

The owner was exceptionally friendly and helpful, and she walked me through the whole process. There were so many flavors and colors to choose from! The cupcakes were delicious and were a hit at my party. Definitely will be returning read more

This is my favorite bakery in town. I always go here to order cakes for all of our birthdays and special events. Our favorite is lemon with raspberry filling but we venture to other flavors too. Totally recommend. read more

I highly recommend the Cupcakery. I did extensive research (tastings!), received many quotes and decided on them based on their great flavor. I could not have asked for better people to work with planning a covid wedding. I am thankful for their flexibility and support. The cake and cupcakes the day of tasted SO GOOD! The lighted display was worth every penny. I am beyond happy with my choice!!! Thank you thank you thank you!!! Cant wait for my anniversary cake! read more

They did such an amazing job with our wedding cake. It tasted absolutely amazing. Looked phenomenal. They were on time and absolutely professional and great customer service wise. Our guests were raving about how awesome the cupcakes and cake! read more

Our CupCakery - The cake table - Bakeries Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

Terrible. Emailed for a wedding cake tasting. Prompt response. Responded to an email with the flavors we wanted to try. No response. Sent the same email again days later. They finally responded. Set up and paid for a tasting 2/25/23. Day of, received a text from Laura stating she had to cancel because her husband and child were sick. Said we could pick up our tasting box to-go, even though we wanted and paid for an in-house tasting. Her text also stated that the other workers wouldn't be able to help us as they were busy w another event. Annoyed, picked up the box. Very small bakery. Upon walking in, there was a cupcake class or something being taught to 8-10 children. It was super loud and all their parents were standing around in the small area.. right next to the "wedding consult" table/corner we were originally supposed to have our appt at. Literally stuffed in a corner with a whole class of screaming kids a couple feet away. Not what I envisioned for our wedding cake tasting. You think that they'd have a clue as to not book a wedding tasting & a kids class in the same time slot. And then relay that no one could help us w our event bc they were busy with another event, that was apparently more important. Took our box of four cupcakes, left. Frosting was hard, idk how long they had been sitting there on the rack waiting for us to pick it up. It was also very thick and sugary, not light and airy at all. Strawberry cake definitely tasted like boxed cake mix, there is no way that was homemade. Which leads me to believe everything else is boxed mix too. Champagne flavor cake mix was disgusting, I had to spit it out. If you're looking for a wedding cake bakery... this ain't it, sis. 0/5 I do not recommend. Quality and taste are lacking considerably and they more or less skate by as a "quaint local bakery". Hard pass from me, never again. And definitely not at my wedding. read more

I'm not sure if I arrived at Our CupCakery at a bad time or if it simply wasn't my thing, but I was not impressed at all with the cupcakes we got on Saturday. Brett P and I decided to take a cupcake tour of Columbus, and this place was my least favorite of the weekend. I ordered a red velvet but I also tried his half and half. I wasn't impressed by either. They both had icing I could only describe as bland, and they left a film on my tongue that I compared to how I feel after eating Long John Silvers. I do intend to try it again because my experience was negative compared to the other reviewers and if it improves I'll check back in. But for now I can only say that I was totally underwhelmed. read more

For a place that focuses on Cupcakes, I was more than a little disappointed with my experience here. I took the bait and tried a mini half-and-half cupcake, which was touted as their specialty. The cupcake is half chocolate, half vanilla in both cake and icing. It's not a bad idea, and definitely looks interesting, but the taste left a lot to be desired: it reminded me strongly of store-bought cupcake mix with generic brand icing. I had a few bites of the red velvet cupcake and was also very disappointed. The texture was a bit off-Not exactly dry, but lacking a freshness that I'd expect from a bakery. The make your own cupcake bar is a neat feature, but if you're expecting a Willy Wonka-style confectionary you'll be disappointed. It's basically a few cupcakes to choose from, a few icings to choose from, and some hard candy and sprinkles to top it off. Kids might like it, though it's probably not a good idea for germophobes. Unless I have a reason to be in Dublin walking down High Street, I probably won't bother going back to Our Cupcakery. read more