With about 45 mins till close (3p) I was stressed, trying to examine the menu as quickly as possible. The person I believe to be the owner, suggested their specials. At the top of the specials list was a hoagie with pepper turkey so I pivoted to creating my own Turkey Hoagie on a roll with extra Swiss and the works. The owner obliged and a woman on their staff started on my order. Apple Pay is available although cash is preferred. They have their own parking lot, and plenty of indoor seating. My Hoagie was $13.47, and quite delicious. Next time I'll ask for light mayo, mustard, oil and vinegar. Overall I'm happy to report that even close to closing time On a Roll Deli is serving it up. Looking forward to coming back and trying a BEC. Signed, The Happy Hour Huntress read more

See all

Asked for a low fat lunch meat recommendation for a sandwhich. They said they did not have any lower fat lunch meat. I asked for a liverwurst sandwich, they said they didn't have any. Ok. So I settled for two smoked turkey sandwiches...one on a hard roll with lettuce and mustard; the other, on rye bread with mayo, lettuce and tomato. What did we get? When I got home and unwrapped the sandwiches, BOTH were on hard rolls with mustard (no mayo, no rye bread), and CHEESE (which I did not adk for or want). Both had tomato, lettuce, and RED PEPPERS which we did not want). Both sandwiches cost $20.00. We won't be back. read more

This place is clean and the staff is super friendly. Very inviting and great food. Food: Roast beef - 4.5 out of 5 Chili - 4 out of 5 Service 5 out of 5 Try this place out it's quality and reasonably priced! Eat here or take it to go! read more

Best Mozzarella sticks ever! Beer battered not breaded and always crispy. Sandwiches are always big and fresh. Friendly service.

Greatest Sandwhiches in the Hudson Valley. Went here almost 2 years ago and still remember each bite. They will actually put meat on your Sandwhich unlike other delis Go here right now. read more

Absolutely incredible food and staff. We went there for breakfast and they can serve anything any way you want. I had bacon, eggs, and hash browns. Best potatoes ever. My son had the Smoke Bomb sub and said it was to die for. My husband had a breakfast sandwich that was great. The owner is so nice and the restaurant and bathroom is clean. We will be back! read more

On A Roll Deli - the outside of a restaurant - Delis Near Me - Highland, New York

See all

Great Italian deli. Friendly and efficient staff. Tons of gluten free choices. Subs are huge.

Great sandwiches and nice people. I wish I lived closer, I would be here every day. 5 stars.

We love coming to Highland so much. As residents of PK we often frequent activities in Ulster County. Coming over the bridge and heading up 9W, you'll see On a Roll Deli on your left. We first visited here about six years ago for the first time, prior to their renovations. Loved our coffees, egg sandwiches, and lunch wraps. It became a regular stopping point for us on our way into Highland, and also on our way upstate via the thruway. I even stopped here on my way to my bachelor party near Lake George. The guys in our group were pretty amped and rowdy, but after we got out food, we all ate in silence - a sign of great food. The new renovations doubled their size, making social distancing easy. Order by phone and pick up in person. I recommend their wraps but you must try The Roman. Check their Instagram for up to date photos of the daily specials. We saw a photo of their BLT once and made the trek up from the HV Rail Trail just to get it. read more

2nd visit. 1st was good for breakfast. This one was bad. Had turkey sandwich for lunch. Very very skimpy. Barely 4 slices of turkey. For 8 bucks I would expect a decent deli sandwich. Not so ! Sandwich worth more like 3-4 bucks like at Stewart's. Not a 8-9 dollar sandwich. Stewart's pre made beats this. Very sad. Will not return for lunch. read more

Not gonna lie, it's a pretty good deli. Boar's Head products, sliced thin, talented sandwich builders, even if the proportions are a little off. Reason for the one star is it's a ripoff. I mean, a blatant ripoff. Several times I've been in there and when the owner charges me he'll just shout a number at me without even touching the register. So last time I got a pound of ham and a half a pound of american cheese. TWENTY BUCKS he says. Seriously? In what world?? Hard to argue when there's no prices listed anywhere in the store. But let's do the math... A pound of ham should be what - 11, 12, 13 dollars? Even if we assume it's 15 dollars? That means american cheese is 10 bucks a pound? Nah, that's my last time in that place. On top of that, owner is rude and likes to act tough and for some reason is "always busy" no matter what you order. Which would be cute if he wasn't ripping off customers and putting the money in his pocket instead of the register. Better delis in the area for sure. read more

Came here for a quick easy lunch it was great till the last bite it left me feeling bad so I got a drink a felt better so if you get a phille cheese stake get a drink this was better then last time read more

On A Roll Deli - Phille cheese stake - Delis Near Me - Highland, New York

Got take-out from On A Roll Deli on Sunday morning. I was not happy with the sandwiches I ordered, which were simply not constructed of quality ingredients. The bread was especially egregious. Quality: Since we were spending the day hiking, figured I would grab some sandwiches for a quick lunch on the way. I was surprised that so many places were closed on Sunday, but eventually found my way to On A Roll Deli. Maybe I made the wrong selections, though that should not be the case when I ordered off the specialty sandwich menu, but the two sandwiches I picked were not very good. I selected the Sicilian Combo with prosciutto, soppresetta, provolone, capicola, and roasted red peppers, and the Chicken Cutlet Delforno with chicken cutline, fontina cheese, capicola, and roasted red peppers. The problems started with the bread, both sandwiches I ordered were on subs. They were dense, dry, and the proportions were all wrong. Honestly, it was hard to tell if the sandwich was any good because eat bite was all bad bread. The Sicilian Combo seemed like a pretty standard sandwich, but could have used some vegetables thrown on, particularly lettuce, tomato, and onion to add some freshness and crunch. And the chicken cutlet on the Chicken Cutlet Delforno, had far too much breading, just intensifying the already bad proportions. Quantity: Large sandwiches, but mostly bread. Value: No prices are listed on the hanging above the counter, but most sandwiches fall between $10 and $14. Ambiance: On A Roll Deli is located in the small Upstate New York town of Highland, not far from Poughkeepsie. It is a massive sandwich shop, unnecessarily big in my opinion. They three tables outside, then a massive indoor space, which had just a few more tables. They then have a counter with a visible prep area, and a kitchen in the back. It was not a natural space, with the amount of fridges along the left wall laughable. I assume it was a gutted convenience store, and they haven't figured out how to use the space yet. Crowd: Just one other person grabbing a breakfast sandwich and coffee. Service: The guys behind the counter were fairly quick putting together my sandwiches. Parking: Private parking lot in front of the store. read more

See all

what a shame this place use to be so good I went today and ordered a chicken cutlet on a roll the chicken was non-existing it was nothing but breading and mayo for 16 dollars with a drink not cheep for a low quality sandwich. read more

At first I thought it was good it was it really was good after it was really hard I have a stomachache and I do not recommend please do not come here unless you wanna throw up don't come read more

Would give zero stars if I could. This place is a complete rip off. I have ordered multiple times and the order is never the way it was on the menu. Fail to tell you when they don't have ingredients for sandwiches. The owner is rude. I was charged 30 dollars for a turkey BLT and a classic Italian combo. Never have I ever paid that much for a good sandwich, but this was a crappy sandwich. Called owner in hopes of getting a refund or some money back since once again sandwich was not as stated. He asked me if it was still good, that's NOT THE POINT. I'm so over this place and will tell everyone I know not to give them their money. read more

We stopped there for a sandwich on Saturday afternoon. Lots of choices, so it was hard to decide. We finally decided on the smoked turkey caprese - and it was delicious! The only thing I wasn't thrilled with was the fact that the sub roll had sesame seeds. I am not a fan of sesame seeds on my bread. Prices were a bit higher than most places, but the quality definitely was better. We will definitely be back to try some of the other items from their extensive menu! read more

If I could rate zero stars I would. The fact that it is so over priced for basically cheese on a hard roll is outrageous. I ordered a sausage egg and cheese And the sausage was burnt and like rubber the egg was no where to be found and it was basically a piece of melted cheese on the hard roll. I'd be embarrassed to serve that to people and call it a SEC. if I could post the photo I would. never again. read more

I have tried this spot a couple times. They are rude and expensive. Go down the road on 299. A bunch of ladies run that spot. They are nice and prices are normal. One time I ordered a chicken sandwich and a drink which was around 20 dollars because they charge you a credit card fee. I just went in there and tried to order a bacon egg and cheese on a gluten free roll and he said it was going to be around 13 dollars without even blinking an eye. Really? Well can you not charge me 13 dollars lol. Can we work something out? I said, oh forget it and was about to order just eggs but he just left and went to the next customer.he seemed irritated. read more

Getting the New York deli experience. I'm glad we chose here to do it! Delicious hot Italian sub! Not a fancy place just delicious. read more

On A Roll Deli - a sandwich and chips - Delis Near Me - Highland, New York

This place is definitely on a roll. Display the prices if your gonna charge $19.00 for a sandwich. Really!? Tasted ok but small and way overpriced. Another place trying to make up for covid losses. Didn't give me napkins either! read more

Clean fast service and great food Breakfast and lunch OP en at 6 am Had cod sandwich great read more

I purchased a sandwich today it was a wish me sandwich it wished it had had a chicken cutlet in it very very thin chicken cutlet and to my surprise I purchased a 9 ounce bag of corn chips for five bucks the guy told me chips are very expensive nowadays. So basically what I'm telling you is if you go there you've been warned. Customer service wasn't the best either read more

The food here used to be great, but the last three times I have ordered food I found multiple blonde hairs throughout my sandwiches. Turns out the girls enjoy playing with the food before serving. Won't be coming back. read more

I was having some friends over for a luncheon when I lived in Highland. One of my guests managed a five star Italian restaurant in Westchester County and knew exceptional products from mediocre ones. I wanted to get some Italian deli for cold appetizers, so I ordered some prosciutto (lean and flavorful), parmigiano reggiano cheese (nutty and crumbly, as it should be), roasted red peppers (done perfectly) and mushrooms stuffed with gorgonzola cheese (to die for). I also took home some mozzarella cheese for a caprese salad, with tomatoes, fresh basil, oregano and balsamic vinegar. Everything was outstanding, but the best reaction I could have imagined came from my restauranteur guest, who stated that it was among the best Italian deli she had ever tasted!! I had to agree with that assessment as everything was amazingly good, and I have yet to find a deli to duplicate that experience. read more

I usually take my lunch breaks in Highland and I'm so glad I stumbled upon "On A Roll". It's a classic Italian deli and every sandwich I've had was fresh and fantastic. I usually get there around 3:30 and they lose at 4 but you never feel rushed because the staff is so friendly and accommodating. read more

Had time to kill spent driving around the area and was driving around aimlessly looking for a place to grab a bite to eat. Seeing the "On A Roll" sign, I made the U-turn and stopped in. It turned out to be a great decision. This is a WORLD CLASS sandwich shop... and I'm a sandwich connoisseur. This place is a real hidden gem for you folks in Highland. If I lived across the river, I'd buy the toll pass just to get across the Hudson as often as possible to eat here. The staff seemed to know everyone that hit the door... and treated me like a regular even though I was 1,200 miles from home. The sandwich specials looked great, as did the deli counter. If I was staying in town longer, I'd have bought some stuff from the deli counter to take with me. As I was just in for lunch, I had one of their special combos. I actually can't even recall what was in it - but it was spectacular. Great ingredients - the bread and meat were terrific - and a great little setting to down the sammy while chatting with the employees. I love this place. if I'm ever back in the area - or even anywhere close-by - I'll make a point of climbing the bluffs of the Hudson up to Highland to stop back in at On a Roll. Can't stress enough how much I enjoyed the staff here. They were really great. read more

Can't believe this place didn't have a page on Yelp yet! I would have guessed it for a neighborhood fixture. Just moved into town, and after driving past this place countless times, decided to stop by and give it a try. It's a pretty old-school Italian deli, where the scent of cheese and cured meats is the first thing that hits you upon entry. They have a variety of classic sandwich combinations, as well as a rotating cast of deli specials. I tried the italian combo, which has thin sliced Cappy ham, soppresata, pepperoni and provolone. Dee-lish. The interior is standard, just your classic deli set-up with a few tables, a cooler case full of beverages, and a rack of chips. They have a whole variety of italian products for sale, including big jugs of olive oil, dried salami, and tinned italian tuna. You can also buy cold cuts and cheese by the pound. The service was friendly and the prices are just right for what they sell. read more

Walked in there at 12:15 for lunch. I scanned the chalkboards for a sandwich and landed upon the Sicilian Combo - Prosciutto, Soppressata, Provolone, Capicola, and Roasted Red Peppers. It's fantastic. They put a balsamic glaze on it to give it that extra zing. The meat is sliced nice and thin. The roll is fresh. The peppers give it plenty of juice so it's not dry. Overall a great sandwich! read more

On A Roll Deli - Sicilian Combo - Prosciutto, Soppressata, Provolone, Capicola, and Roasted Red Peppers with a balsamic glaze! - Delis Near Me - Highland, New York

See all

Rude. I stood at the counter to buy some beverages and was ignored for a good 2-3 minutes. The employee was chatting with the delivery guy. Both saw me and ignored me. I returned my beverages to the cand left. read more

Amazing customer service! The food was tasty and made quickly as well. They have a lot of options to choose from, food and drinks.

What a pleasant surprise driving through town on 9N! We are healthy eaters and explained what we wooden wooden wine on an egg plant wrap and a tuna fish wrap and the honor roll deli folks were fantastic! Are two wraps were freshly customized and were absolutely delicious. Kudos to the young lady who took our order and made our sandwiches. We thoroughly enjoyed them on our long drive back through the Catskills to Rochester New York. Thank you!! read more

Prompt service and the best sandwiches I have ever had. Clean and friendly with reasonable prices.

Great breakfast sandwiches. Very fresh bread. Lots of seating and large windows let lots of light in from the East. Italian sandwich options look very good too. Also have a large assortment of cooler drinks read more

Hands down the absolute best overpriced food ever!! I mean WOW Who knew a 20$ egg with a thin slice of bacon on side no drink could be sooo worth it. If your pockets are deep and wanna stay skinny this is the place to go read more

Stopped in a few weeks ago for breakfast and then again last week for lunch. For breakfast I had egg & cheese in a roll and lunch was turkey on a roll. Extremely reasonable prices. Both times I went in, a crowd of us came in at the same time. I was super impressed by how quickly they got us in and out. There is some seating if you'd like to stay as well. read more

Could have used a little more oil & vinegar but a decent Italian combo!! A good place for a quick deli bite!

Our first time here. Very spacious and clean, and an extremely warm & friendly staff. My mom got an avocado BLT (her go to) and said it was the best one she's ever had.. bread toasted perfectly and everything! I got eggplant, roasted red peppers, mozzarella, oil & vinegar on a whole wheat wrap.. also great! Definitely would go back. read more

I've been to this deli several times. Every time, the service is inattentive, sloppy, or outright rude. They make good sandwiches but they don't have a clue about customer service. I went by there about 1/2 hour to closing one evening after a long drive. They were preparing to paint after closing. They refused to serve me although they could have and they could have waited another 1/2 hour to get started as well. Maybe they are happy with the customers they have but my business is going elsewhere. read more

Classic deli, great sandwiches and salads! Well run and great service by employees. Plenty of drink choices in the coolers as well.