Old town Pizza serves pizza by the slice, and I've always wanted to try this place after driving by it on Rte 59 so many times. Finally in a Saturday, we stopped in to grab lunch to-go. There were a few pizzas on their rotating oven, but the man behind the counter said that sausage was on its way, fresh out of the oven if we were okay with waiting a few minutes, so we did! We also ordered some boneless wings. Our lunch, for 2 adults (about $21 total): boneless buffalo wings 1 slice of sausage 1 slice of sausage + 1 liter of soft drink Their single slices are $4 each, and they have combos for pizza plus a drink e.g. pizza plus a can or plus a liter ($5-7 bucks). They had Pepsi or Mountain Dew in their fridge. Old Town Pizza serves no nonsense, fresh, quality food! Their pizza crust for their single slices is thiccck and it was so filling. Lots of cheese for the cheese lovers out there. I got a side of marinara bc once I got to the crust, it became breadsticks that I could dunk into the sauce. (Pro tip!) My husband's loves locally owned pizza joints like this. They have catering and also locations in Schaumburg and Lombard. We will be back to try their other items like Italian beef, then Sicilian style stuffed pizza, the "butcher block" thin crust, and panzarotti (fried calzone). I am having a lot of fun trying out all the local pizza places around Naperville, having moved to the area earlier this year. I'm glad we got to make a stop by Old Town Pizza. OTP satisfied our pizza craving, and we will be back! read more

Old Town Pizza - A slice of sausage fresh outta the oven! - Pizza Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

When I'm craving a buffalo chicken pizza, Old Town is my go-to first choice! Fair pricing too! Friendly staff, customer focused.

Been eating here since it was called Taylor St. Pizza. They've gotten so skimpy with their toppings I won't eat here anymore. Literally like 10 pieces of sausage on an XL. Too many pizza places around here to be doing that! read more

I love the slices but please do more veggie like mushroom , green peppers & onion . It's always sausage or pepperoni & lots of vegetarians out there . Thank you read more

Probably the best pizza in the area. You will love your pizza from here. I drive out of my way from Plainfield to get pizza from here. You will be satisfied! read more

The food was really decent. I ordered a half cheese pizza topped with mushrooms and onions with the other half with sausage. The crust was delicious and perfect. No complaints. I liked the service with was excellent customer service even though it was a delivery. The order came quickly and the pizza was still warm. read more

Love the crispy crust on their pizza. Service is always quick and the have a decent price. I been visiting Old Town for many years and it still as good as it was pre Covid. read more

Always good. My favorite is the cheese lasagna with a side of sausage. So delicious. Service is always great and never been disappointed. Highly recommend. read more

We ordered a meat ball sandwich and a chicken Parmigiano sandwich. I'm giving one star because the meatball sandwich was edible, but the chicken parm was absolutely horrible!! Couldn't even chew it! read more

If this was the first pizza i had in my life i would think "what's the big deal about pizza?" This is what i imagine prisoners would make with commissary ingredients. It's as if aliens made what they thought pizza was. The crust is basically bread. Bad, terrible, angry bread. The cheese was a melted glob of whatever white cheese the food distributors sell at end of quarter that every other restaurant refused. The pepperoni ratio was INSANE. basically none. Which turned out for the best as the one i tasted was a bland, uninspired flavorless disc of worthlessness. I'm reminded of chuckie cheese pizza. A wonderful place for children but terrible place for food. With all due respect to whoever concocted this atrocity; you've bastardized whatever recipe your poor gramma made so lovingly during the depression out of whatever scraps she could find behind the soup kitchen. Please kind owner, let it go. This is not your gift. read more

It's been a long time since I've been here. I picked up a thin crust pepperoni pie. I forgot to ask if they put the pepperoni on top of the cheese, like their slices. They don't, and the pepperoni didn't seem plentiful. I found they undercooked the pizza. There was no color to the cheese or the bottom of the crust. I would consider it parbaked, as it needed to go back into the oven. It tasted kinda doughy otherwise. read more

See all

Great Pizza in the neighborhood. Well worth every dollar spent. They also have pizza slices.

Bait and switch advertising with their free appetizer coupon if you text a number. Showed text at pickup as it said to do to receive free appetizer up to $6 value and the guy said they don't take that anymore even though it was on their website I ordered from an hour earlier. Guy was extremely rude and said he told owner to take off website as he walked away from me before I had paid forgetting the fact I had to pay. I asked him if he wanted me to pay and came back, ripped the card from my hand and swiped it and walked away. Wish I didn't have as much integrity as I do because I could have just walked away without paying. Will never order anything from here again. read more

We've been a fan of Old Town for years but the last 6 months have been horrible. We have had pizza delivered to us with no sauce, pizza completely under cooked and tonight, we ordered a simple order of a 12 piece fried chicken and we were shocked when the driver said it was $38 plus tip, $44. I ordered over the phone. To check after receiving the chicken, I went online. 4 pc = $10.95 8pc = $15.95 so 12 should have been much less than $38.90. The cashier decided to put the order in though as 3 orders of 4pc for $10.95 in order to rip us off and take advantage as we were not in front of the pricing online. When I called and questioned the order taker, he stated and I quote "you ordered it, you received it and you paid for it...nothing more to discuss!". Beware, they are not honest and food has gone way down hill". read more

This place is conveniently on 59 so we ordered one for the first time yesterday. We got the double dough crust, which is of course thicker than thin crust and thinner than thick crust! The base was a good thickness / consistency but the actual crust around the edge was a bit too doughy and not really browned enough. The sauce had a pleasantly spiced taste to it, though. We forgot to ask to have it cut like a pie and so it came in that tic-tac-toe grid cut that I have only ever seen in the Chicago area. I really don't understand that because then most of the pieces that have crust attached barely have any toppings on them. This place also has sandwiches, wraps, pasta and more. read more

First time customer. I stopped in for a slice to go, got the beef and giardinara. Was fresh, delicious and huge for a great price! The guy working behind the counter was very friendly also. I'll be back! read more

Ordered a pizza for pickup. My family likes Little Italian's thick crust Italian beef and giardiniera so we thought we'd try this at Old Town. Meh. The dough is good but we had next to no beef on the pizza, the sauce is bland and the giardiniera wasn't hot. I've had their thin crust in the past which is much better. I'll stick to little Italian off Bailey for my signature pizza though. read more

Today's lunch from my favorite pizza joint in south Naperville. Small thin crust pepperoni, mushrooms and onions $20.00 this place never disappoints. read more

Old Town Pizza - a box of old town pizza - Pizza Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

See all

Alright, being new to area we were working on home improvements in our home. We were up for pizza. Our go to pkace, which we so enjoy, closed early! I guess we are in the boon docks, lol. Anyways, first time customer at Old Town Pizza Co. We ordered in. Wow, crust was awesome, our cheese and Pepperoni toppings were perfect. Customer service and delivery was terrific also. We will be teturning here! I recommend this pizza in Naperville. And to think they are only 1.1 mile close to us. Very affordable and you receive a lot for the money not to mention great tasting pizza! read more

Pretty awesome pizza! Thin crust was nice and crispy cheese was oooy gooey nice amount of toppings...fast service. Totally recommend read more

Great neighborhood joint. Good variety of food from appetizers to sandwiches wraps pizza and even calzones. Food is cooked to order and always fresh. In fact, most items take a while to prepare so I recommend calling ahead or ordering ahead or online. They do have pizza by the slice readily available. The Italian Beef pizza with hot peppers is awesome. Pizza crust is really thick. read more

I love my pizza. If I was stranded on an island, I would want an unlimited supply of pizza. But please, not old town pizza.... My husband and I were both disappointed and I personally am confused by all the great reviews. There was no sauce on our thin crust pizza. Like literally 5% of our pizza had sauce on it. And that 5% had no taste to it. Not salty, not sweet, not anything. The crust tasted like salt-free saltines- no flavor whatsoever. The cheese was really thick. And for that reason, I was excited and thought okay, there may be no sauce and the crust sucks, but at least there's a lot of cheese. I am a cheese freak- I love cheese. I would bathe in melted cheese (and suffer the acne break outs later) but please, not in old town pizza cheese. This was the most flavorless cheese I have ever tasted on a pizza (in this area at least). The pizza was so utterly disappointing, that the next night, I felt the need to order pizza from one of my usual places lol. No shame man. Like I said, I love my pizza!! And sadly, I will not be choosing old town pizza again for my pizza cravings :( read more

CUSTOMER SERVICE IS NOT THERE SPECIALITY...... ordered pizza online at 5:37pm on a Friday (9-27-19) as of 6:48pm pizza still hasn't shown up and we called the store 7 times and no answer........ read more

6/9 update: gave it another chance and there's been improvement! More sauce, not as dry, more flavor. ---- It's not often that I rate a pizza place two stars however, as tough as it was to not give a good rating... it really is worth two stars. If it wasn't for the great service and kind staff, it would be one star. Pros: Great service. Great location. They offer an XL pizza "18". Cons: Not enough sauce. Slightly dry crust. Pizza overall was dry. Taste was bland. read more

This is the second time I've ordered this place and I love it! I got the cheese burger this time and it was awesome, a little strange the bacon was crumbled but I'm not complaining. My boyfriend got the cheese dog and he said it was very good as well. I love the cheese fries, I always get the cheese on the side and they give you more than enough and I love that! And the cheese sticks are so delicious. The only thing that I would change is that they has a better ranch sauce, I'm a weirdo that likes ranch on my fries. Highly recommend this place. read more

Old Town Pizza - Love these cheese sticks - Pizza Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

We just recently started ordering from the Naperville location. I have been ordering from the Lombard location for years for my employees. Everyone loves the specialty pizzas. Just this week they ordered burgers. Claim they are the best ever. Always felt that a restaurant could only be good at one thing either good pizza or bad burgers. They said this was the first chain to cross over boundaries. Can't wait to try myself soon. read more

We really enjoy the pizza from here! We moved to Naperville 3 years ago from Chicago and this is our go to spot. Very authentic Chicago style thin crust pizza! read more

Consistently disgusting every time we order from here. The pasta is swimming in grease, my meatballs were hard as a rock and frozen, our wraps are always made completely wrong, I would rather eat dog shit. read more

We ordered a pizza last week for the first time from this restaurant and couldn't wait to try it when we got home after picking it up. IT WAS DELICIOUS. Best pizza we've had in years and we've tried a lot. We use to drive over an hour to buy our favourite pizza but the last time we did, we were disappointed as the flavour just wasn't the same. This place will save us a lot of gas and driving time and we're so happy that we tried Old Town Pizza Co. We have recommended this place a few times since last week and we're picking up another one tonight. Yummy! read more

I been trying to reach Joe and have called 5 times. He is never there as it states in his response

Solid pie, lots of other options too. I usually get double dough and ask it done medium well so the cheese browns up a bit.

We were looking for something different, so we decided to order form Old Town Pizza a couple of nights ago. Pizza arrived quicker than we expected, and it was very delicious. We ordered a large pepperoni and a large sausage pizza and they were WAY bigger than the larges we normally order. We had the double dough crust I think it's called - and literally one slice will fill you up. We still have leftovers in the fridge. Would definitely order again. read more

I tried their pizza first a few weeks ago. It was ok. Wouldn't eat it again. I thought I'd try their pasta to see if maybe that would be better. It is the worst Alfredo I have ever had. They used pene pasta, which eh, ok, but it was so soggy! Way over cooked. The Alfredo was like they took a can of condensed cream of chicken and poured it over the pasta. I literally made a dinner of the little loaf of bread because the Alfredo is sickening. Complete waste of money. They don't even make their own Italian dressing. If you are used to decent Italian food, don't eat here. It's not even in the same category. read more

Good PIZZA. The people who work at the front counter and phones are so nice and helpful! read more

Old Town Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

OVERRATED!!! Just had a large half Cheese half Pepporini + medium Cheesy Beef for a total of $35. There was no beef on that pizza. Go to Portillo's for beef it will cost you less than $5. I called the manager to explain italian beef shortage pizza and he tried to say that he helped make the pizza and there was plenty. Calmly I explained to him that there was beef on maybe 20% of that pizza to which he replied that there was beef. I again calmly countered that the pizza was lacking beef AND THEN HE HUNG UP THE PHONE. AYFS WTF who does this to a first time customer. Just called him back cause I was pissed. This time I am comped $10. IDK what to say. Enter at your own risk I guess. read more

Despite being under new ownership, little has changed about this location. Their pizzas pretty good, little too much cheese and not enough sauce. The crust is passable, but it really doesn't have any flavor. Getting a slice is the way togo. Their "Cheesy Beef" or Sausage is the way togo. They make an Antipasto Salad that could kick Chuck Norris hairy a$$. Get it with Greek dressing and you're good to go. Old town is nothing amazing, but I love ordering a couple slices and salad from them whenever I don't feel like making some food or cant decide on the limited delivery options in Naperville. read more

Watch out for this place, no taste to the pizza or lasagna. Lasagna does not offer any meat sauce or meat period! Word to the wise, to all the pizza connoisseurs and lasagna connoisseurs this place is lacking, to say the least without getting rude. read more

I'm blown away by the deep dish/stuffed pizza here. It's definitely the best I have had.

I have ordered pizza from this place a few times, and while it's not terrible, there's nothing special about their pizza and there isn't anything that makes it stand out from the rest of the pizza joints in the area. The cheese to sauce ratio isn't very balanced and the sauce they do put on there is somewhat sour/tart. The guy answering the phone is always friendly and polite. I will perhaps try another menu item next time I am in the area. read more

Delicious! We got the hand-rolled crust, one individual with just cheese and a small with pepperoni and we were not at all disappointed. I could eat thus crust daily and never get sick of it delicious! Highly recommend. read more