Went to Old Scratch after a 5K and honestly, it was a GREAT decision haha! I customized my own pizza with mushrooms, sausage, and bacon, and there were so many options to choose from. The place is super spacious, has a bar, and the service was really speedy. And the pizza?! SO SO SO SO SO good! Their homemade ranch is also chef's kiss and definitely worth trying. If this place were in Vegas, I would probably be here every week haha! Thanks to the staff for a welcoming visit! read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Custom Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Beavercreek, Ohio

Nice clean establishment. Generous parking. Pizza.... a bit overpriced for what you get. Pizza itself is probably a 6 out of 10. very skimpy on toppings. For such a small menu you would think they would do better. Do yourself a favor and skip it. So many better pizza joints in Beavercreek. read more

Pizza was very good. We got two Dayton's, which are their pepperoni pizza. Very good! We got the kids cheese pizza and regular cheese as well. Wait staff that brought our pizzas out were very friendly and attentive! Indoor and outdoor seating with tv's inside and windows to watch the pizza made and cooked. read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Traditional Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Beavercreek, Ohio

See all

Just wanted to add to my old review. This place never disappoints. The food is delicious. The service is awesome and it's the best place to eat and chill. I love coming here. read more

See all

Thursday afternoon lunch with a craving for pizza. Had the cesar, roasted cauliflower, the dayton (pepperoni) and angry beekeeper. The cesar was solid and the roasted cauliflower was really good. The char on the cauliflower was nice it could have used a little more heat. The pizzas were good. The crust definitely could have been a little more crisp. The flavors were good and the pizza was not greasy. The only feedback is that I have honey hints on pizza before and they work best with some spice, there was no spice and that made the pizza a little too sweet. read more

See all

$3.14 Pi day cannot be beat! Thanks Old Scratch. We sat at the bar and Remi was fantastic. We were mesmerized by how hard he works and stays communicative and pleasant throughout. He's a keeper! read more

A fine spot for a group get-together, definitely something for just about everyone here!! Check out their menu ahead of time, then line up and place your order at the counter. It appears what I ordered, a veg. pep rally pizza and Mediterranean salad are no longer on the menu, but they were both GOOD, and hope they'll make a reappearance on the rotating menu. Lots of fresh choices for meat lovers and veggies alike. Some tasty cocktail choices as well, worth trying them out as you wait for your yummy, freshly made pizza!! **Also worth noting that they were SUPER nice about letting me wait inside for AAA on a cold, snowy night, even as they were getting ready to close down, when I went to leave and discovered that my car's battery was DEAD, DEAD, DEAD!!! read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Mediterranean salad - Pizza Near Me - Beavercreek, Ohio

See all

We've been to the other Old Scratch locations, but never this one. We love it because they have a variety of items for everyone. Service is always great. Everyone working is kind and helpful if you need it. I love the laid back, open feel of Old Scratch. I will say my pizza today didn't feel as it was made with as much love as it normally is, but it was still delicious. read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Father's Day dinner. Vegan, gluten-free Mr. Scratch. - Pizza Near Me - Beavercreek, Ohio

This could be my absolute new favorite place for pizza. Man oh man...such a great pie. Toppings are appropriate. Crust is 10 out of 10 with its flavor and flex. You walk up to the counter and place your food order. Also, GF praise...Their GF crust is legit and my daughter absolutely LOVES it! Again, 10 out of 10. Good amount of pizza options. They offer sandwiches. Their salads are great. We had their house salad last time and it was awesome. We haven't ventured into their appetizers yet but I am told their baked cauliflower thing is well worth it. The drink options are awesome. Their ciders are great. I ordered an old fashioned (a speciality of theirs and it was fantastic). The place is chill. Lots of seating. High tops and longer tables and seats with windows looking into where they make the magic happen. I would definitely add this to your list of places to try. Super good. A bit pricey but quality backs it up. You will not be disappointed. Check them out...we are planning on going back...soon AND often read more

See all

havent been to this location. Parking lot looked empty there was 4 people in front of us and it took the food a while to get to us. other than that the food was great and the soda fountain worked. read more

We stopped in before a play for a quick dinner. Same night as a UD basketball game. Place was super busy but the manager was cleaning tables and we were directed to a clean table without delay. The pizzas were great as expected and I had one of the best old fashions I have ever had in a pizza joint. read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Honey pepperoni pizza was great - Pizza Near Me - Beavercreek, Ohio

We were taking our grandchildren to Owen's play place and were looking for a place to eat nearby. This was .2 miles away and was a wonderfully clean place for us to eat lunch. The kids pizza was delicious and we enjoyed our thin crust pepperoni pizza. We enjoyed the side salad that we could share... Three sizes make sharing simple. The restaurant was clean everywhere including the bathroom, even the baby changing table. They also had high chairs and small steps for our toddler to reach the sink. The service was friendly and efficient. Team.lead by manager, Joe seemed to enjoy their jobs. Peter was tossing pizza dough and Corinne welcomed us as we entered. We will definitely be back when we are in the area! read more

See all

8.2 out of 10.0 Excellent pizza! Brick oven flavor adds SO much to this pie. Crust is very good. Sauce is just right. Cheese is very good. No flop but a cracked fold. Dough is a little too thin but still very good. So yeah, a solid 8.2! My Scoring System: * Always a large cheese or margarita pizza * Always made to order * Always eaten at the establishment * Always eaten while fresh and hot 9.0 or higher = Travel out of state or 4+ hours for the pizza. This is World-Class Pizza! 8.0 or higher = Travel 1 to 3 hours for the pizza. This is Local Legend Pizza 7.0 or higher = Local pizza that is a go-to. Very good pizza. 6.0 or higher = If you're already there then you go for it. It's not a bad pie but you're not going out of your way for it. 5.9 or less = Worsening levels of MEH. Gas station heat lamp to school lunch lady pizza. You'll feel the dead weight in you. Hard pass (pun intended). Atmosphere and service adds/drops up to .5 points: Add 0.0 for polite service Add 0.1 for good service Add 0.2 for great service Add 0.3 for phenomenal service Add 0.4 for legendary service Add 0.5 for epic service that can only be done here Subtract 0.1 to 0.5 for meh, distracted, bad, awful, and find another job, respectively. read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Old Scratch - Pizza Near Me - Beavercreek, Ohio

The pizza was real doughy in the middle. Tried to pick it up and the cheese ran off of it. The outer edge was burnt black I've ate pizza all over the country. It's the worst pizza I have ever eaten. read more

Visiting family in the area and decided to check out Old Scratch Pizza. We were greeted with a smile and enthusiastic hospitality. Ordered the lunch special and ordered three pizzas (Elliot, Dayton & Angry Beekeeper). The pizzas arrived at the table in a few minutes after. Everyone enjoyed their 9 inch pizzas. They were delicious! The dough was soft, the tomato sauce was spiced perfectly and the mozzarella had crazy pull! The pepperoni was crispy and full of flavor on the Dayton. The restaurant has plenty of space to accommodate a large group of guests. Place was very clean. They also have a bar and soft serve ice cream for the kiddos for dessert! Overall we had a very nice experience at this restaurant! Will definitely visit when we are in town again! Highly recommend! read more

Old Scratch Pizza - 9 inch Angry Beekeeper and Elliott pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Beavercreek, Ohio

See all

Second time here love the pizza still enjoy the other location better. Food/Drink: fire, roasted, thin crust, artisan type pizza. Pizza: delicious, and a perfect crust crunch. Dinning Area: Pretty large, open, area. Benches, large counter, double closed off entry way so mo breeze. Plenty of seating! Prices: Alittle expensive but worth it. Parking: Private and plenty of space. Bathrooms: Bathrooms were clean and regular size. Atmosphere: During the weekday lunch rush, it was a huge snow storm so this would be unfair. It was empty. Staff/Attendants: Staff overall was young, and unsociable. Not like the children of my generation. Relatively attentive but otherwise boredom stricken. Decent experience... 7/10 read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Beavercreek, Ohio

See all

Love Old Scratch and I am excited they have come to Beavercreek! Especially since it is way closer to me than the Dayton or Centerville locations. It is operated like the other locations and has the same great atmosphere. Friendly staff willing to explain how Old Scratch works for those who are new to this restaurant. We got several pizzas including the prosciutto arugula and Angry Beekeeper. Both are go to favorites! Everything was as delicious as usual. Hint-get a ranch dip for your crust! Totally worth the .50! Hint #2: you can add arugula to any pizza and if you haven't tried it-do it!!! Edited to add: my guys all said this was probably the best pizza we have had from Old Scratch and we go ALL THE TIME and love it! Great work Beavercreek Old Scratch! read more

See all

Pizza is amazing! I order the White Mushroom and add prosciutto for the most authentic prosciutto e funghi I've eaten since Vicenza, Italian. Their sandwiches are so good, I'll order one for lunch the next day. It never makes it. read more

Hands down, my favorite pizza place to go when I am in Ohio. We decided to go for an after work group social. Parking isn't a problem as there is plenty. Seating is easy as the place is just huge. It looks like a converted garage. Let's get to the goods or goodies! I settled on a meat lovers style pizza, and guess what... you can customize it however you want. I removed the bell peppers and added the lemmon dressing seasoned arugula salad in the middle. My coworker suggested that I make mine extra crispy since I added the arugula salad in the middle. Wow! My pizza was amazing, and of course, the leftovers later that evening were also awesome. Great place to go, and yes, I'm told the beer is great. Just check out my lovely pizza. read more

Got the Elliot Cheese pizza with salad the other day in Beavercreek. My brother got the same thing. It was burnt on both pizzas only thing good was the salad. I was at same Scratch about a year ago and the pizza was also burnt. The Scratch in Dayton I ate many times and never had a burnt pizza. read more

I ate at the bar and the service was great. Very much a family owned vibe. The pizza was decent. I thought the crust was a bit undercooked, and they were spare with the toppings. I know you can't overload a wood-fired Neapolitan pizza or it will be soggy, but I think they swung a bit too far to the light side with regard to toppings. A bit longer in the oven and a little more generous with the toppings and it would have been great. read more

This is my favorite pizza. I love rotations of pizza, appetizers and adult beverages.

Great pizza and amazing salad. Service is always wonderful too! We ordered to go and they brought it out to the car. Was ready on time!

Very good pizza. Excellent salad. Online order for pick-up was 15 minutes late. Will I return? Yes. read more

This is our go to pizza place. We had a GC and had some trouble but the manager took very good care of us. He made us feel valued customers which is why we keep going back. New to the menu is the Twister pizza. We love it! The Dayton was loaded with pepperoni. No complaints. All praise we ordered out so I don't have any comments about the restaurant but always find it comfortable and neighborly. read more

Slice of Heaven has earned its reputation as a pizza lover's paradise. From the first bite to the last, every aspect of the dining experience is thoughtfully curated to ensure maximum enjoyment. Whether you're a local resident or a visitor passing through, a visit to Slice of Heaven guarantees a memorable and delicious journey into pizza perfection. Ambience is amazing, Staff is amazing! love love love this place. Pro tip best pizza is the Angry Bee Keeper add extra mozzarella, and add pepperoni. also the cauliflower appetizer is phenomenal! read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Beavercreek, Ohio

So delicious that we went back the very next day! Our first visit we placed a pickup order online and arrived ahead of it being ready so we went and had a drink at the bar. The bartender, whose name I never got, was very upbeat and friendly and told us about the local Dayton vodka and whiskey when I asked about the bottle. The pizza we ordered was called The Angry Beekeeper (tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, spicy salami, house-made hot honey, olive oil) and was a wonderful combination of ingredients. The crust was flavorful and perfectly crisp. I also got a house salad (romaine, red onion, cucumber, cherry tomato, chickpea, croutons, creamy italian dressing) which was served with warm pita bread. The salad was fresh and I really enjoyed the dressing. The next day we went back to dine in. The dining room was full but the ordering was super organized. I ordered the exact same thing :) read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Beavercreek, Ohio

Best visit to Old Scratch yet! Like some others who have had droopy pizza here, I asked for a recommendation on how to order that might prevent the experience in the future. The cashier was so helpful, explaining their cooking method as being Midwest Neapolitan style that is intended to be a little softer, and I simply need to order well done. We had the Deluxe well done and it was so good. It had a little more char but didn't taste burnt still had a great chew without being droopy. Success! The patio is fantastic & we are excited to visit more often. Now we just need the powers that be to approve their application to serve wine & liquor on Sundays. read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Deluxe pizza well done - Pizza Near Me - Beavercreek, Ohio

Great pizza. Service is fast and all the staff is super friendly! Old scratch is always our go to pizza restaurant. Makes for a great and easy casual dinner date! read more

My first time at this location on a Friday in January. I lost power in my house, and had to find a place to A) have lunch B) power my all day call. They have plenty of outlets under the bar, and I wanted to be out of the way of others eating, so I propped up at the bar side close to the pizza ovens after putting my order in at the front. I ordered a Mediterranean salad (half) and a margarita pizza. Knowing that I would probably take most of it home, I asked for a box for the pizza and the salad in a to-go box. The salad was not my favorite of theirs. To be honest, I thought I had ordered a different one that we usually get at the downtown location. It was good, but not the one I wanted. Lol The ingredients were fresh and the salad dressing was light. The pizza was perfect. It was lunch so I was able to get the 9" version. True to Old Scratch's reputation, the crust was crisp and the toppings were hot. Fantastic, oven baked pizza. I was able to stay until around 3:00 without taking a needed spot. The bartender was on top of filling my water and more than willing to help if I needed. The building is slightly louder than a regular restaurant. When it fills with people, it tends to echo. I did have in ear buds and could hear my call just fine, but if you have members of your party who are hard of hearing, you may see if they are comfortable. read more

See all

the pizza was way to thin to the point where the toppings fell off and the bottom was soggy and had about 8 slices of pepperoni every bit way to much. very good customer service on the other hand and was clean. read more

Always fabulous...one of the few places that get it right...I truly don't have anything negative to say ...thanks Old Scratch!

P. S BTW, the vegan shroom was to-die-for!!! My fav. I want to try some sides. They look great! read more

One of the best pizzas I've had in a while. we had the Angry Beekeeper and margarita. Both excellent. The only bad part was getting a beer or drink! I decided I didn't want to wait 10-15 minutes like other people waiting to order one at the bar, no table service. They weren't even that busy at the bar itself. definitely losing money there. 3 beers probably would have doubled their bill to us. sports bar vibe inside, casual dining, but nice. definitely do the pizza there again. read more

First time there, last time there. We walked in and quickly realized t's a Golden Corral for pizza. Ordered pizza but you have to order drinks separately. When you check out from ordering your pizzas they will ask you for a tip. Having never been there I assumed there was some sort of table service. Tonight was a Sunday but it did seem busy. The cashier suggests a table. Before we get to that table it's taken by people ordering drinks from the bar. The cashier frustrated but sends us to another table. We goto that table only to find it's still dirty. Waited a little bit but nobody is cleaning tables. Cashier hands my wife wet wipes. I got frustrated, WTF did I tip for, why did they ask for a tip if I have to clean my own table, order my own drinks on a separate tab and bring it all to my my table (which we had to share). Went back up and asked for my money back which they provided quickly and without incident. read more

We love Old Scratch Pizza. It doesn't matter whether we eat in or pick up to eat at home, their pizzas are fresh and delicious every time! When we eat in their service is amazing and it's always a fun place to eat! read more

I love the food at old scratch. We eat here probably every week The pizza, the salads and appetizers are great. read more

Great food! Great atmosphere! Crew was incredibly friendly and courteous. Thank you

Delicious, we love the pizza, staff is friendly and accommodating. Restrooms have been clean every time we have been here, overall restaurant is clean well organized and pleasant. We are regulars almost weekly read more

Great beer and cider selection. Salads and pizza are always excellent. Not the fastest service even when not very busy. read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Beavercreek, Ohio

See all