Paid $100.00 + $20.00 tip for appetizers, two desserts, and three of the worst meals ever. The crab claws were mostly flavorless breading, my grouper was overcooked and bland, the grits were a huge disappointment. My son ordered the chicken alfredo. While he said it was okay, it was more like eating paste, lol. I don't remember what my husband has but it was not something he'd order again. Then the biscuits were so heavy, you could bust out a window with one. read more

Not what I expected seemed outdated and food was not that good. Service was as lacking on communications and delays in checking on us.

Great Food and Service. The price is reasonable and the quality is superb. This is a locally owned restaurant that continues to be a top choice! read more

Second tennis tournament trip to Dothan, and future trips will routinely feature dinners (plural) at Old Mill. The food was excellent. Our large group enjoying everything from the seafood pasta, v good salmon, to filets and prime rib w rave reviews. The onion soup was a winner and if there was a weakness it might have been the side salads but really no deficiencies. The service and the wait staff were efficient, friendly and expeditious. Don't miss this place!!! read more

Old Mill is a classic restaurant in Dothan. They offer very affordable steaks and seafood that taste great! The service staff has always been friendly and attentive. read more

Food and service were great. Have never had a bad experience here and the wait times aren't too bad compared to other places.

Delicious food. Great service! Friendly and knowledgeable staff. Quiet atmosphere.

Dark, echo-y and the gumbo is overly salty with crab claws in it. That means you have to find the crab claws, remove them, and scrape the crab off. The fried chicken was dry and fatty. Not recommended. read more

Old Mill Restaurant - Gumbo with claws swimming in it. And something slimy. - Seafood Near Me - Dothan, Alabama

The Old Mill has been a Dothan tradition. It has been a mainstay in the community for years. It's decor is pretty simple and looks like the way it sounds. It is very clean and nice. My entree for the evening was a prime rib with fries and salad. The first part of the meal was the homemade yeast rolls. Best rolls ever! Nice, soft, fluffy, and goes well with butter. Nothing like Texas Roadhouse or Logan's rolls. Salad was pretty basic- lettuce, cheese, tomato, cucumber, crouton, and red onion. The best part was the homemade ranch. Prime rib was prepared excellent and the au jus and horseradish was a good complement. Fries were good but the frozen variety. My meal was a 5 star from the Old Mill. If you are searching for food, it is a good choice. If you are looking for an experience to go with your meal, you might want to consider elsewhere. read more

Stopped in after a day of BMX as a hole e restaurant is a tad out dated has a bit of a moldy odor (probably the carpet) over all staff was pleasant food was solid. Hit the spot read more

Hands down THE BEST restaurant in Dothan. The food was amazing. We had a large party and the service was top notch.

Asked about this place at my hotel,& front desk said it was really good - especially seafood dishes. I started with the gumbo, which was very flavorful. It is filled with vegetables- so the seafood is not the star of the dish - but from a flavor standpoint it was very good. Had the shrimp & grits, and it was really good! Parmesan cheese sauce topped the grits, and there 8-10 decently sized shrimp that had a unique smoky flavor adorning the edges served with a slice of toasted bread. Very flavorful, portions are good size, and price is just right. Good food - good value! And....the staff was fantastic! Very friendly and helpful. Overall very nice experience! read more

Not fancy but food and service is worth going to. Variety of menus is good and was a good experience.

What a wonderful experience great service and the stake was amazing so were the crab claws

Loved the food! Loved the service! Our waitress Amanda G. was outstanding!! My husband, son, and I had the shrimp and Grecian Grouper, NY strip and the crab cakes!! The food was beyond wonderful. We had plenty to eat and had to take some home. We went the night before Mother's day and I even received a free Strawberry Short Cake. We will definitely be back!! read more

The food was hot and fresh. The service was excellent. My wife and I split the Steak and Shrimp plate and ordered fries, baked potato and broccoli as our sides. They cooked our steak exactly to order and the complimentary rolls they bring out as an appetizer were fresh and delicious. It's a great local spot and I hope to return again next time I am in Dothan. read more

Delicious Grecian grouper, gumbo, crab & shrimp appetizer. Very fresh food, fast and courteous service, fun come-as-you-are cozy atmosphere. Great break from the routine. read more

OMG! I am a frequent business traveler and decided to check this restaurant out while in Dothan (takeout). I WAS NOT DISAPPOINTED!! To my surprise...EVERYTHING exceeded my post flight expectation. I had the ribeye, veggies, baked potato and salad. WOWZERS!! The flavors were so awesome I actually ate the peppers (and I never do that). I literally called the restaurant after and asked the hostess to give my compliments to the chef and manager on duty. I will surly be back when in town! read more

Looking for a steak on the way to my hotel and this came up. Glad it did. Service is good to the point of being adorable. And my steak....if we weren't social distancing I'd run back to hug the cook. read more

Old Mill Restaurant - Ribeye mixed veggies - Seafood Near Me - Dothan, Alabama

I absolutely loved the dinner rolls. The crab dip was good, but served cold (not what I was expecting). The fish was great as well. This is a little, family-owned, secret gem of a place. I'll come back here for sure. read more

Per usual I rolled into town on business and hit up Yelp for some grub, I landed on old mill. Got there asked to sit in the bar and they allowed it. Waitress came in short order and took my drink order and was cheerful and delightful. I ordered the swimmer and bull, I think they called it grouper and steak, it was on point. I got the broccoli and veggie skewer and they were really on point. I didn't want that I wanted some fried taters but wife said I was fat so I ate the veggies and they were great. Waitress was attentive and cheerful and all was well, 5 stars and I'll eat here next time I'm in town. read more

Dinner last night with a guest. Service was fast and friendly. Prices are a bit higher than expected but, servings are very generous. I had the crab claws. Guest had shrimp. Both were delicious. Nice sides too. I'll be back. read more

Very old outdated inside, and dirty as well. Seafood platter was frozen seafood. The best thing was probably the bread. Would not go back.

Old Dothan restaurant that is sometimes difficult to use especially on family oriented holidays. Food and service is very good.

Love this go-to restaurant in Dothan! The atmosphere is warm, the food is the freshest you can get, and the service is always attentive and I honestly couldn't ask for more. I can't pick a favorite between the grouper straight-from-the-gulf or the Angus beef hand cut steaks. Oh, and the stuffed flounder and seafood alfredo are to die for! No need to dump a gallon of garlic salt on top read more

Old Mill Restaurant - Chicken Picatta! Yum! - Seafood Near Me - Dothan, Alabama

See all

We went here tonight snd sat there for twenty minutes and no one came to our table. Four waitresses walked right by us and never greeted us or took our drink orders. Maybe they should put the three teenagers at the front who were playing on their phones to waiting on customers. We won't be back. read more

This place was recommend to us. The restaurant is a tad outdated but seems to be a local gem. The food is pretty good. I had steak and shrimp, which I was only able to eat half of because it was more then enough. The prices are reasonable and is a good place to go if you want something other then chain restaurants. read more

Old Mill Restaurant - Steak & Shrimp - Seafood Near Me - Dothan, Alabama

Had dinner tonight at Old.Mill in dothan al. Great food thanks to Tammy for the service. Will be back soon.

This wasn't a WOW experience but it wasn't bad either. The restaurant was clean and well maintained although outdated. It is fair to say that they are not going for high ratings in the ambiance department. I had the crab claw dinner (4 oz portion was plenty!) and they were some of the largest crab claws I have ever had. The breading was a little heavy but overall pretty good. They have grilled veggies as a side choice and they were super yummy. If you are a bread person you will like the rolls that they serve. For all of you Pokémon Go Peeps not only are they a pokestop but they also give free items based on your level (I am a level 15....I know know...I have teenage boys...and I got a free order of cheese sticks). Annie was my server and she was fabulous! read more

Old Mill Restaurant - Crab claw dinner (4 ounce portion) and grilled veggies. - Seafood Near Me - Dothan, Alabama

Best spot in Dothan!! Absolutely best steak in the world. Really nice people, really great food!

My favorite place in Dothan for steak or seafood. Great service and everything on the menu is excellent!

Home field. Big steaks, certified black angus with a proprietary sauce. Yeast rolls, hot and fresh. Fresh REAL grouper. This is where you go, if u want genuine gulf seafood, without the beach prices. Sides are good, and apps are strong enough to stand alone. Stuffed grouper is my wife's favorite. read more

Old Mill Restaurant - Main hall - Seafood Near Me - Dothan, Alabama

See all

Moved to Dothan, from the West Coast, to live near a lady friend of mine. This is my favorite restaurant in this big town so far. Been here three times, twice for dinner and once for lunch. Loved the professionalism of the waitresses and the food for dinner. The lunch that I had was fine, but the service wasn't as good as those two times that I went there for dinner. I still like this place, especially their grilled chicken breast with sauteed mushrooms. read more

We got to Old Mill on a Saturday night around 5:15 and waited only about 10-15 mins to be seated. Hostess wiped down all used menus throughout our wait which was nice to see! I chewed on a bone in my stuffed flounder (which tasted great) so I couldn't finish it after that. The broccoli and rolls were very good and portion size was good. Service was great. read more

Sooo the decor is outdated but the 94 health rating made it doable. No personality but plenty of potential. Service was okay in a straight to the point kind of way. If people only knew the difference a smile can make. The time to receive my food was fine. I enjoyed the simple salad and the shrimp arrived on time. The meal was a bit basic lots of plastic cups for condiments and the baked potato simple and plain. No bacon or cheese. If you're looking for simple lunch during work hours it will do. read more

Old Mill Restaurant - Shrimp with baked potato. Lunch 10.99 - Seafood Near Me - Dothan, Alabama

See all

I love this place. The food is always excellent. The service is always friendly. Best steak in town.

Our party all had Prime Rib cooked differently, all cuts cooked exactly like we asked. Shrimp was cooked perfectly. The sides and salad are amazing. The employees are very nice. For the quality, worth every penny. Amanda G, our waitress, was super cool and made you feel comfortable with her welcoming personality. read more

The food is good but the real sleeper hits here are the yeast rolls and the fried chicken fingers. Scared of looking like a child by ordering chicken fingers for dinner while your peers are requesting surf and turf? Make up the difference by ordering the best item on the menu, the fried crab claws. read more

Traveling for business, I had two different ribeye steak dinners over two nights. The first night I ate at Longhorn Steakhouse, the National chain. The second night was at the Old Mill restaurant. I ordered the "Outlaw ribeye" at Longhorn and it was juicy with amazing flavor, I didn't need to add anything to it. The ribeye at Old Mill was not so juicy and I kept adding pepper, salt and eventually steak sauce to try and add flavor. The baked potato at Old Mill came wrapped in aluminum foil and the cheddar cheese was dark and hard, like it wasn't fresh. Sour cream was delivered in a plastic packet, like a fast food ketchup packet. The baked potato at Longhorn was bigger, fresher and had more taste. The decor at Old Mill is old and very plain. Nothing you would be proud to bring your wife or a date too. They are in desperate need of a Chef Ramsay makeover. The hostess at Old Mill seemed like the teenage daughter of the house greeting you, without a smile, wearing blue jeans, an around the house top and a sweater tied around her waist. There was no ambiance and no music. I primarily listened to a very loud kitchen staff banging pans, laughing and joking. This will be my first and last visit here. read more

The best filet you've ever had- especially if Bob is grilling. Their chicken Alfredo is DELICIOUS & even better the second day. (Because you WILK have leftovers.) Fried crab claws are a must before your meal. Don't eat their bread pudding unless you're ready to crave it. read more