Just stopped in here yesterday morning for an early lunch before heading northwest on the Olympic Peninsula. The bartender Sam was totally LEGIT and we happened to be seated next to the owner Larry who was very kind and helpful when we asked about destinations in the area. The decor fit in well with the old logging community and they had a small but nice selection of beer and liquor. My beef Shepard's pie was very solid, and my friends chicken sandwich was one of the best i have tried in a long time. I'm not sure what it is about their fries, they were delicious and original. We plan to travel back that way again this spring with some more friends and we will most definitely be stopping in to try the breakfast. read more

Good service, good food. Try the pastrami sandwich. Neat atmosphere inside like an old mill

Came here for lunch. Service was great - had the special (chicken sandwich), which was good. But what made this place a 5 star experience was the passion and excitement our server had over the pancakes. That's right, pancakes. He gave us a sample of the 49 Flapjack - it was delicious. Will need to come back for breakfast just based on that taste. read more

Seafood Benedict and breakfast burger were really good. Interesting stuff to look at while you eat. Most Sundays they close early around 3. read more

Love the food here! Very tasty and good portions. I always feel welcome, friendly waitresses. I make sure to visit when ever I am in town.

Stopped here on a Sunday Morning around 8:30. The place was packed however we got seated right away! The waitstaff seem really busy and confused. One person in our party was joking with her and either she did not understand or did not care. Bill for 5 $93.00. I will say 2 had the prime rib special and of course I had the chicken fried steak. Food came fast but the waitress could not tell the difference between the 2 prime rib meals and one had toast on one when he ordered an English muffin. Overall the meal was great however the service left me a little underwhelmed. If you want a funky mill type ambiance restaurant this would be the place to go. My opinion is the Sunshine cafe tops it! read more

I've had some really nice lunches, some really terrible breakfasts, and some very expensive & below average dinners at Old Mill. It's one of those places you keep going to because you know if they do it right, it will be so good. But after the last terrible breakfast - seriously, the biscuits & gravy had zero flavor - we will never be back. There are better, more reliable places in town to get a sandwich or hamburger. Sorry Old Mill... I really, really wanted you to be good! read more

This classic looking restaurant is a hidden gem. We visited this on our loop through the Olympic peninsula. The courtesy was very welcoming and the food tasted great. The house special "Lavender Lemonade" is a must-try. read more

We didn't even know about this place till it was recommended to us by the host at the B&B we stayed at. Came for our 27th anniversary dinner and were pleasantly surprised by the variety and prices on the menu. I had the seafood special and it was delicious! we also ordered the stuffed mushroom appetizer which was very good. All told, appetizer, wine, main course, and dessert prices were fair and service and food were excellent. We will definitely be back the next time were in Sequim! read more

We were here in August and since there were great reviews we decided to check it out. It was on the empty side, and the food took long. I was not impressed with the food (we had fish), and I know we won't be going here again. The decorations are dated, bathroom old and dirty. The waitress never came back, someone else brought our food and we had to stop someone to ask for our bill. We ran into someone else from Hawai'i who was just leaving and they said it was okay and reccomended another place, we should have listened. Honestly I don't know what all the hype is about, the food wasn't good. Maybe breakfast is better, I don't knownor will I ever find out. read more

Always great friendly service, very cool decor. Been here many times as my folks live just a few miles away. Great menu good specials...

This is by far the best grill in the area. Eaten here many times and I am always impressed. The atmosphere is also unique for the area. You will probably pay 10% more than at a chain restaurant, but at chains you get what you pay for. read more

We went in on a Saturday afternoon and the place was dead. Two other customers were there but we still felt a little ignored. Took forever to get water refills and our server/hostess? Not sure which, spent her time complaining audibly in the kitchen. Cute vibe, food was alright, but not good enough for the price! There are cheaper places I would try next time. read more

We were looking for a laid back place with a great atmosphere. We had fantastic service, the atmosphere was perfect and the food was wonderful. We'll be back on a regular basis :-) read more

If I could give more than five stars, I would! Great, speedy service and amazing food! Got the big buck burger and onion rings, and it was the BEST I have ever had. The pretzel bun was so soft, the burger was cooked perfectly, the veggies were crisp and delicious. I don't want p eat any where else! read more

In town for one night and this popped up on yelp. Sometimes it's hard to tell if something is really good or if it's a local rated place but this place is very good! Came for Saturday breakfast... perfect eggs and fantastic chicken fried steak! Great country down home feel and very friendly staff without being over the top. My family is hard to please for a breakfast place and everyone was happy! Thank you read more

Ah it's good to be home, however the feeling isn't complete without a visit to Val and Larry at the old mill cafe I'm greeted with a smile by the wonderful waitstaff, as I adjourne myself to my regular seat at the end of the long wooden bar. In itself an antique. A remnant of the buildings earlier beginning as the keyhole tavern. I read through the menu that I know by heart with no intention of ordering from it. You see it's vals attention to detail.her stubbornness in only using the best of ingrediants,and her multi faceted knowledge of good home cooking that makes me order the same thing every time... whatever she has as a special. I don't precisely recall what I ate on this occasion, but it brings back so many other memories. Her fish tacos, the chicken or beef fajitas , the meatloaf sandwich, yes you heard me right. And who could forget the genious crafsmanship of the Denver benny. Simplicity meets extravagance. I'm not sure if it's the home cooking or the comfortable surroundings that makes the old mill cafe a 'must see' on your itinerary to the Olympic penninsula, but I find myself missing both of them as I look forward to my next visit. Five stars! JF read more

Very eclectic decor; LOVE the hand saws made to look like a ceiling fan! Food was very good; had the crab and shrimp cake burger. Only thing I would change is take off a little of the lettuce and slice the tomatoes a little thinner, as the crab and shrimp cake got a little overwhelmed. I will definitely come again the next time I'm in the area. read more

Went to the Old Mill Cafe tonight. They have Prime Rib every Friday and Saturday. Ordered the Prime Rib along with grilled prawns. Came with choice of starch and soup or salad. Also came with fresh just out of the oven French Bread. Everything was fantastic best Prime Rib I have ever had. Hands down the best in Sequim/Port Angeles. Great seasoning and done to perfection. Was busy but still got fantastic service. You can also make reservations. read more

Hands down best prime rib around! Really cool atmosphere with all kinds of old logging stuff up everywhere. Lots to look at. Our server Courtney was very knowledgeable about everything on the menu and the specials. High end eating in a chill atmosphere. read more

Really great food, family friendly, and cheerful staff. Can't go wrong here! Lots of rustic, old logging paraphernalia to look at while dining as well. Parking is not always the best, hence my one less star. read more

Last few times ive visited there the waitresses treated me terribly. while there managing lacks the essential structure it needs. they need to hire more bussers, they seemed to only have one working and it was very busy, many people we're waiting for a very long time, me being one of them.. also everytime i seem to go there the waiters are really fake and i can tell they just put on a smie and dont actually want to be at there jobs, they need to be a little more professional at there job. I would recommend the oak table to anyone who is in the mood for there breakfast, they have an appropriate amount of staff for the business that they get, the managing is excellent and the food is superb. read more

Horrible service! Snobbish waitress! We went there after visiting lavender farms. Food was ok, restaurant looked nice. but we were extremely upset by our waitress. There were not many guests when we entered, but it took us 15 minutes wait to order our food. We ordered burgers from their menu, which said "You can choose salad or soup, fries or onion rings." We assumed that we can choose both soup and fries for each of us. However, our waitress insisted that the menu means the customer can only choose one of these four options. So we ordered two burgers with only one soup and one onion ring. Later when we were eating our 2 lonely burgers (one with only one order of onion ring on the side and one burger in an empty plate), several elder people came in and sit next to our table. They were served right away by our waitress. We surprisingly found that the waitress ask them how would they like to have their burgers cooked (she did not even bring the question up to us!!!) and she served each of them both soup (or salad) and fries (or onions they choose!)! Our waitress ignored us during the meal (so I could not get a chance to ask for the ketchup), and I had to catch her to ask her to give us check after waiting in our table and waving our hands for 10 minutes after we finished our burgers! We were in a hurry to catch the ferry so we did not even have time to argue with her but left in anger. We could not understand why such ridiculous thing would happen to us. If you do not look like retired rich elders, don't dare to go to this restaurant to get yourself ignored by the waitress. read more

Do you ever wonder what a restaurant owned by an old school logger would be? If you can overlook that the staff may not be groveling at the correct level, for service ranges from poor to bad, the Old Mill seems to alway have good food. Sometimes it is imaginatively conceived, sometimes it is basic fare. It seems to be always good. The owner is almost always there, bussing tables, filling drinks, and chatting. If you want to meet him, and get an education, ask about some of the lumbering collection, or wood strewn about the property. There is heart in this place, the prices are typically high for the area, and help is the constant challenge here. But it is one of the better places on the peninsula. read more

Overall good; lettuce fresh and not iceberg! Plenty of good turkey on my sandwich; taco salad had good variety of veggies, flavor was excellent. Down side would be cleanliness with a hair in the food, I had to ask to have the seat wiped off and the sticky stuff took some good scrubbing-- must've been there weeks! Bread was dry, carrots were dry read more

Don't miss this gem! If we hadn't gotten lost, we would've never have found this place. Consistently good food in an eclectic atmosphere. Charming staff! Visited many times since finding it. read more

This is by far the best place in town to get a salad. Hands down. Love the steak Caesar salad and Crab Louie. The staff are so nice and accommodate most requests. And if you had a bad culinary experience eating Italian in town like we did, just come here and order the clam linguini with pesto (wine) sauce. The chef is great about cooking meals with culinary requests. And we never have to worry about parking, or paying outrageous prices for a meal. Bonus. read more

We've enjoyed this restaurant in the past, but likely will not return. We waited more than an hour for our meal, and it was lukewarm when finally served. We were offered only the breakfast menu (at 1:00pm) although others diners obviously had ordered from a lunch menu. Service was inattentive and slow. Too bad.... read more

Easter Sunday morning. I was a guest for breakfast. This restaurant is a favorite of my host. We were seated right away. Our servers were courteous and their service was good. I ordered the spinach omelet, which was tasty. My dissatisfaction was the meal is carbohydrate loaded. The omelet came with potatoes and another carb side, i.e. choice of breads or biscuit. I am unable to have processed carbohydrates in my diet and so, half of my meal went home with my host. read more

First, I would like to thank my favorite waitress Cortney, an I am picky, cause I was a waitress. , second, I want to give a shout out to the classy, comfortable, warm decor, an last ...The menue...NUMMERS read more

I make it a tradition to come here whenever I am visiting Port Angeles. My aunt and uncle (who live here) come here once a week and are always delighted with the chef, Dave, and his amazing food! They are vegan and he delights in making them special meals and I must say that they are fabulous! (And this is from a meat lover!) His style is rustic and flavorful and he focuses on quality food with quality ingredients. The staff is so friendly and always kind and considerate. The food comes out piping hot and quick! Very good prices with very generous portions. This is great for families and the atmosphere is very calm and quiet. I only wish there was a place like this where I lived. Down to earth people with wonderful hearts and delicious food! I can't wait to come back!! read more

we often stop at the Old Mill for Breakfast or Dinner, this is casual dining at its best

Great attentive service! Also, our dinner was really, really, really good. I was expecting to have little for a big price since I ordered a seafood dish, but I ended up taking more than half of it home! WHEELCHAIR ACCESSABLE read more

If you are in the Sequim area, this is the place to eat! Great funky building, amazing staff and the food is fantastic. Not your usual fare, the chef has a menu that is inspired by his travels! read more

One of our favorites and historically, one of the first places we ate when we moved here. Remains a go to place for brealfast, lunch, or dinner. read more

Last night was the second time my husband and I have tried the Old Mill Cafe. The first time we found the staff to be rude and sloppy. It took forever for our food to come out and even then it was not that great for the price. Second time we were beyond disappointed. The staff ignored us until we took a seat at the bar. The waitress had no understanding of their beer (my husband had the recommended "hoppy black beer"). The margarita that I ordered was undrinkable. It tasted like straight margarita mix. We ordered an appetizer of the coconut shrimp. It took forever to come out and the shrimp was way over cooked. My husband ordered the seafood linguini and I ordered the cobb salad. My salad was decent but over priced. My husband took a couple bites of the seafood linguini before he chomped down on a ROCK! It was not a small rock either. It was about the size of a baby carrot! Our waitress did not know what to do when we showed her the rock. Finally she apologized and said she could either give us a free dessert or discount us on the pasta dish. She did not offer to make him a new dish! At that point we were so disappointed that we did not want to eat anymore so we asked for the discount on his pasta dish. When we received the bill, they knocked a whole whopping $4 off of a $29 dish. Any other respectable establishment would have either offered to remake the dish or removed the cost of the dish from the bill! We were so disappointed with our service and our food. We felt like an after thought to the staff, and they were quite sloppy (dirty clothes with food remnants). We will not be going back ever again. read more

We took our 11 and 12 year old grand daughters her for lunch - they loved their burgers and onion rings (also Italian sodas). my Reuben was the best that I've had in years ditto for my wife's crab and shrimp sandwich. read more