Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Old Colony Pizza

    4.6 (5 reviews)
    Closed 10:00 am - 9:00 pm

    Order Old Colony Pizza Takeout or Delivery

    Old Colony Pizza Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Old Colony Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Pizza is good and came out pretty quick everyone had pretty chill vibes. Pizza lunch combo was only 6$ and sum change definitely worth it !

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Old Colony Pizza

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 11,875 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Anthony's Pizzeria & Deli - Street sign - a few parking spots out front, more out back

    Anthony's Pizzeria & Deli

    4.1(27 reviews)
    1.1 mi

    We stopped in because we were starving and short on time before heading to our nearby destination…read more I had picked this place because they had the highest reviews in the area, and I even told my son that on the way in. Service was OK. I think because I tipped at the time of the order the food was brought to the table. The woman was on the phone when we got there, so we waited a little but it was ok. It was all just ok. The pizza we ordered was burnt and not the good kind of char you expect from a brick oven (and as someone who loves Pepe's, I hope I know the difference). Still, we ate it because we had already paid, and we didn't have time to go anywhere else. The salad was just okay, though I will say the ranch dressing tasted homemade, which was a nice touch. The bacon was stale The biggest downside was the cleanliness. The restaurant was dusty and dirty. There was a steady stream of people coming in and out for takeout orders the whole time we were there, which makes me wonder if our experience was just a fluke, or if the regulars simply like it that way. As we were leaving, my son turned to me and said, "Mom, I thought you picked the place with the best pizza." I laughed because he was right, this time, the reviews were wrong, for us at least. Would I order again? Probably not. But the atmosphere and steady business made me curious enough to maybe give it another shot, just with very lower expectations. And for take out.

    really excited to try this place after seeing they sell slices, a rare sight in connecticut! i…read moreordered a bbq chicken slice and a bacon/onion slice which i enjoyed! i did order their pork belly and calamari and it smelt veryyyy fishy which was a little off for me. the pork was great and crunchy but the calamari was a bit chewy, no flavor, but the marinara sauce helped but still disappointing for $11. we also got their egg rolantini and it was too bad but not my favorite. i would definitely come back to try the pizza again and sandwiches.

    Photos
    Anthony's Pizzeria & Deli - Frontage @ night

    Frontage @ night

    Anthony's Pizzeria & Deli - Storefront at night

    Storefront at night

    Anthony's Pizzeria & Deli - Storefront

    See all

    Storefront

    Little Rendezvous - Tomato pie

    Little Rendezvous

    4.3(241 reviews)
    2.9 mi
    $

    Great spot. Not what I expected, I once lived in New Haven and am used to destination pizza. This…read morewas much more unassuming and better set up as a take out, but did not disappoint. We arrived early on, what I thought was off hours and ordered in person, the wait time was 4 hours. I don't live far so it was easy to come back. The dining area is tight and pretty basic, so plan on wooden bench in limited space if you are dining in. I would also recommend calling way in advance with your order. As far as pizza goes, I have had the opportunity to sample most of the high profile places and understand why this place deserves to be on the list. The crust is pretty fantastic and overall a really good pie. When we went, there was no line. The grab and go was super simple, cash only. Order ahead, plan accordingly, and enjoy.

    136 year old oven! Wow! Was there at 11 AM and the service was excellent. Two guys working the…read moreplace. The man who worked the register made sure that we were satisfied. Old fashioned decor with old pictures on the wall and well worn but sturdy wooden tables. Pizza was a 3.0. We think that it had too much sauce. We prefer a balance of sauce, cheese and crust. It had the taste of oregano, which we do not want on pizza. We prefer garlic in the taste to oregano. The price was reasonable and it was prepared in a reasonable amount of time.

    Photos
    Little Rendezvous - The dining room.

    The dining room.

    Little Rendezvous - Pizza

    Pizza

    Little Rendezvous - Service counter and kitchen

    See all

    Service counter and kitchen

    Fuoco Apizza

    Fuoco Apizza

    4.1(197 reviews)
    4.9 mi
    $$

    I'm in town on a short business trip and made it a point to check out Fuoco Apizza after seeing it…read morefeatured on Barstool Pizza Review with Dave Portnoy--and I'm really glad I did because he was absolutely spot on. I ordered a large cheese pizza, and it has to be one of the best I've had in a long time. The crust was perfectly crispy with just the right amount of char, not greasy at all, and every bite was packed with flavor. You can really tell they use quality ingredients and put care into every pie they make. It's that kind of pizza where you immediately know you'll be thinking about it later. Honestly, I wish my wife and kids were here to try it with me--they would've loved it. I'm from California, and I can say I haven't had many pizzas back home that compare to this. It's that good. In fact, I ended up coming back a second time before heading home because I just couldn't pass up another chance to have it again. That alone should say everything. On top of the amazing pizza, the employees were friendly and welcoming, and you can tell it's a family-owned business that takes pride in what they do. That kind of atmosphere makes the experience even better. If you're anywhere near the area, I highly recommend stopping by Fuoco Apizza. Whether you heard about it from Barstool or not, it absolutely lives up to the hype. You won't be disappointed.

    Wait time, lack of seating, prices…read more An hour and 10 minute wait for two small pizzas?! (As long as eating dinner at 3:15 pm on a Friday doesn't bother you...try it.) We drove to New Haven and were eating our pizza in less time at one of the more popular/well-known places. Seating is almost a waste of time. Maybe there's enough seating for 25 people?! You need to get to know the people next to you because you're basically at the same table. Prices are shockingly high for what you get. With the sheer amount of pizza-places within a 2-10 mile radius of Fuoco - you're better off giving another establishment a try. Try Half-Moon in Wallingford. The pizza is delicious, less of a wait time and there's actually room to eat and relax.

    Photos
    Fuoco Apizza - 8/11/23 First time here. CAN'T be any worse than last night's disaster at the place 100 yards away.

    8/11/23 First time here. CAN'T be any worse than last night's disaster at the place 100 yards away.

    Fuoco Apizza - Pepperoni and green peppers

    Pepperoni and green peppers

    Fuoco Apizza - Storefront

    See all

    Storefront

    Old Colony Pizza - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...