We've ordered delivery from Paradise Pizza a few times now and they haven't let us down! Their tuna melt is perfectly buttery and crispy, exactly the way it should be. My husband loves the chicken parm sub. They also make a great pizza and has become one of our go-tos for pizza delivery. read more

I really like the food here. Service is always great and the ambiance is cozy in the bar and decent in the restaurant. Parking is pretty good if you go behind the restaurant. The specialty pizzas are special and the traditional foods, mostly italian inspired, are good family preparation. Pricing is reasonable. I've never had any complaints in more than 20 years of coming here. read more

Had takeout just once and the pizza was good. Want to call out their gluten free, cauliflower crust pizza. Had with pepperoni and it was excellent. Crust was tasty and baked perfectly! read more

10 STAR RATING+++++++ My husband and I just moved to Wallingford a week ago. Where to order a good pizza amongst an embarrassment of riches?...Meaning," Who Ya Gonna Call," on a Friday night and who will even deliver? Boy did we luck out!!!. PARADISE PIZZA came to the rescue! A quick and easy method ordering online from their easy to read menu. An easy check out and a printed receipt telling me that our food would be delivered in forty five minutes. Less than that time our very nice delivery person delivered our food steaming hot. I ordered the Sicilian pizza although my husband wanted a plain large round Pepperoni pizza, however, no complaints, it was piping hot and scrumptious. The two steak and cheese grinders were also hot and boy were they delicious.The Cobb salad was added to our order for lunch tomorrow, but I took a few bites just to see how good it was and boy it was good. I wanted to give a shout out to this wonderful Pizza Restaurant. Paradise Pizza will be our continuous go to and deliver restaurant.They have lots more of everything, including regular food.) read more

Horrible customer service, my elderly mother accidentally ordered food and when I called to ask for it to be cancelled they were rude and wouldn't assist. they charged her for the order even though it wasn't finished. my mother lives 35 minutes away and couldn't drive there to pick it up. Based on the customer service alone I would never eat at this establishment. They mis treat the elderly! read more

Have been going here for several years now, probably 15+ times in total. Quality and consistency at a good price every time. We get a large bacon and onion pizza which always has generous toppings. The buffalo wings are pretty good too. read more

The pizza is decent here, and the crust is magnificent. The grinders are outstanding as well! Glad to find this place right on Colony Rd. Sure, it's not a lot to look at, but you're here for good FOOD right? read more

Paradise Pizza - Steak Combo and Cheese Grinder with mayo, lettuce, and tomato. - Pizza Near Me - Wallingford, Connecticut

The large salad was too big for us. Today we got three slices of cheese [pizza and a small salad. Pizza was wonderful as usual. The small salad was freshly made with lettuce, red onions, black olives, strips of green, bell peppers, grape tomatoes, and 2 packs of Ken's Blue Cheese dressing. It did not disappoint. Paradise is our go-to pizza place. read more

I was in the mood for pizza and Paradise had the best ratings for pizza spots near me. I placed my order via Ubereats and it took about 45 minutes for me to get my food. My cheese pizza was alright, not particularly bad but not great either. read more

Great pizza, generous toppings , stealthy service, and a hearty work ethic! We had a recent winter storm and was mild in comparison to even a storm we had this year, already, and the amount of closures of business was nothing short of stunning. I have never seen a world of such weak business owners and lazy workers such as the community here in Connecticut. This was practically one of the only restaurants - or fast food joints - that opened. I talked to plowmen who were absolutely flabbergasted at the weakness of local business. Nevertheless, I will tell all you other restaurants in the area, especially pizza places, that my go to place now is Paradise Pizza, just for their work ethic alone, not to mention good food. You all should be ashamed of yourselves shutting down for absolutely no reason whatsoever! Thank you Paradise, we will be coming back quite often from here on out. read more

Ordered some delivery pizza for our awesome friends who helped us move this weekend. Pizza came within the time frame they said (30-45) and the delivery guy was friendly. We got 4 pizzas which was exactly the right amount. Prices were pretty normal (total was $50ish?) Pizza was very good. Good texture and crust - not too thin or thick. I had a few slices of regular cheese pizza the day we had it delivered and enjoyed it. The next day I reheated some veggie slices and they were delicious! They included some breaded slices of...eggplant? Breaded something that was soooo good. We had asked for no broccoli (good call, my friends )but I think they also don't put olives on their veggie pizza which is super too. Good veggies! I'll definitely order from here again next time we want some pizza at home. read more

Congratulations. I've decided to increase your star ratings because the customer service is always great and you've added additional salad selections. The pizzas, wings, wraps, salads, soups, calzones, desserts, pastas are all good. I order a lot of salads. The California salad, a new addition is soooooo good with grilled chicken. A small salad fills me up and they stuff the container. They make the best grilled chicken for salads. Very tasty. If you're in to bread, try the garlic knots. Bet you can "knot" eat just one. Although they're in Wallingford, they deliver to North Haven. The delivery time is the typical 35-40 min and the delivery guys are the best delivery drivers around. If ordering pizza for groups, look or ask for their coupons. They have great deals. read more

ordered two meatball grinders for delivery and they were great and hot! quick and professional delivery person!

Pizza was good. However they put on double the cheese and not much sauce. I personally like the sauce more than the cheese. If you love more cheese than sauce this is the place for you! read more

Went back to Paradise the other day for Mother's day. Pizza was as good as always. Bbq pizza was pretty standard but the crust was awesome. Perfectly cooked. Meat pizza was really good. Loaded and all the toppings stayed on the pizza. Very friendly folks behind the counter as usual. Great job guys! read more

Great service - very polite! Prompt delivery within the given time frame. I ordered delivery and got the bone in buffalo wings and the seafood pizza. The flavor of the wings was great, but they weren't very crispy at all - rather soft. The pizza was yummy - could have used a bit more garlic but that's personal preference I'm sure - however it arrived barely warm. All in all, I'd order from here again & recommend - but next time I'd request my wings extra crispy during the ordering process. The pizza I just heated in the oven for a few and it was fine. Don't know if they could utilize some convection bags or something in the future to prevent this from happening if it's a recurring thing. read more

We got the shrimp scampi, meatball sausage parm sub, grilled chicken combo sub and they were all so delicious!!

This place is a gem among a sea of other pizza places. We regularly order their burgers, which are massive and delicious. Their fries have a very unique crispy batter and their other fried foods are great. I'm also a huge fan of their chicken caesar salad, I don't know what makes it so good but the chicken is marinated and the lettuce is always really fresh and crisp. I'm a harsh critic but this place is a staple in my diet and the delivery guys are fantastic and funny. I only wish their menu included more fried seafood because that's not easy to find around here. read more

We ordered delivery from this place and I was pretty happy with it. We got a medium pizza and some garlic knots. The pizza was good, no super-thin crust (which is fine with me) but not the best I've had. The garlic knots were a bit different than typical knots but they were delicious. I definitely want to try more things from this place in the future. read more

I love the food but a most as great is the owner.He really values his customers and will go out of his way to correct a problem if there is one . unlike fabis the food is good but the owners disrespect their customers and will fight with you if you complain . CHOOSE PARADISE THEY WILL TREAT YOUR RIGHT read more

Needed a quick pizza and salad. Found paradise pizza on yelp; so happy that we did. The delivery was super quick and the food was delicious. Highly recommend for quick pizza delivery. Also, the summer salad with avocado and corn is to die for! read more

Aeden is the nicest person I have talked on phone for a food delivery. We ordered the tri sampler, paradise special and the eggplant parmigiana. Absolutely loved the food and the service! Highly recommend this place for a quick bite and customer friendly food home delivery. read more

I was on a business trip and stayed at a local hotel.... I used Grubhub to order from here... I ordered a small pizza with extra cheese and onions, a caprese salad, 2 cans of Dr Pepper and 1 bottle of Powerade( I needed some more beverages for the room), I also asked for a bunch of paper plates, utensils and napkins for the hotel room.... The delivery came in about 30 minutes, everything arrived, minus one can of Dr Pepper, which wasn't the biggest deal in the world(although I do have an unhealthy obsession with DrP!). I called the restaurant just to let them know they missed it, wasn't really wanting a refund or for them to come all the way back for a can of soda...the person on the phone apologized and I started to eat....(btw, about 15-20 minutes later a very nice delivery boy knocked on my hotel room door and gave me my coveted can of DP!!! He came all the way back for 1 can of soda!!! Thank you!). They give me plenty of paper plates, utensils and napkins... The Pizza was great! Being a chef and from Jersey/Philly/New York area, I know good pizza too. The Crust was thin, crispy and tasty; the sauce was zesty and tasty and the cheese and toppings were plentiful cooked well. The salad was huge! Lots of tomatoes and fresh Mozzarella, and the greens(romaine and basil) were fresh and crisp and they gave me plenty of dressing...it also came with a few garlic knots...although it was bountiful, it was a little "plain"... just romaine, mozz, tomatoes and basil... if you are listening Mr. Owner one chef to another...maybe mix in some spring mix lettuce with the romaine and atleast one other ingredient(red onions? Grilled veg? Just Something else). All in all this is a great "pizza joint" for middle of know where Connecticut with great customer service skills! read more

OK, ok, ok. after all of your glowing reviews, and after getting many crappy pizza's delivered to my house, I tried paradise pizza. I said I would and I did. Gonna start with the negative first. y'all told me this was new York style pizza, it WAS NOT. The menu said "jumbo" buffalo wings, they WERE NOT. Your reviews may have had me expecting a bit too much, That being said, here are the positives. It was an ok pizza the guy on the phone was great, gave me a large pizza deal with wings instead of a small with wings for the same price. delivery guy was wicked cool. Wings were not jumbo NOR amazing, but were good and although just slightly over cooked, I prefer that to undercooked...LOL you are gonna have to trust me on that one. Food was quick, food was ok, delivery guy cool. Bottom line, I will add this to my rotation of delivery places. Looking forward to trying again with different types of food. If I wasn't used to amazing New York style pizza, they could have gotten 4 stars. Given that all the other delivery places now suck in Wallingford/Meriden area, I am looking forward to trying other stuff from them. I am gonna be honest and maybe break a rule or 2 here, I hope I don't hurt any feelings. The pizza from minervini's on quinipiac street is Wallingford was better as far as the New York pizza goes, but I didn't like their wings and their garlic bread was terrible. so I will get my pizza from minervini's but can't wait to try other options from paradise!!! I heard I can get a good burger and fries from there and I love fried veggies, so my next review will be about that. read more

The food is good if the young girl is working the front counter. If the owners wife is working the front counter you will get an attitude and your food will probably be wrong. I'm not usually one to leave negative reviews but I won't be back. Customers are your business, treat them well. Also , after the 50th time don't get their order wrong!! read more

Wow! What a great find after having to make a quick stop on our road trip. They made our slices fresh, great sandwich made to order and they were open on 4th of July. Very friendly and polite people. We had two slices of cheese. I wanted two more but we had to go. read more

Grew up in Noo Yawk with plenty of Italian relatives cooking real Italian... it makes finding a good pizza joint outside of the 5 boros tough. Recently move to this area and tried Paradise Pizza. Quick delivery, great service, got the orders right... and the pizza got raves from everyone. We tried lasagna, stuffed shells, manicotti, calzones, garlic knots... delish! The potato skins? Perfect. In a week we ordered twice... Prices were great. two medium pies for 9.95 each? That's New York pizza that tastes like I remember at prices like I remember. Grazie mille!! read more

This place i found by looking on the web the food is excellent and they are always friendly on the phone the drivers are very pleasant and im ordering for the second time today. Im homebound and like i said try it. A touch of heaven read more

For Wallingford this is the best DELIVERY pizza no question! Fast, accurate, reasonably priced and good!! I'm not saying their pizza is amazing but if your in Wallingford and need pizza delivered, this is the place to call! read more

Great food! They have great grinders and salads. The staff is always friendly and online ordering is easy. Thanks!

I love this place, everything about it is good, from the owners to the delivery drivers everyone is pleasant, working nights across the street we tend to order from there often and almost exclusively, everything I've ordered there and believe me between myself and my co workers have probably eaten everything on the menu and always find it fresh and delicious, read more

I got the margarita pizza and it's was so good I ate half of a small all by myself and their smalls are pretty big. The staff was attentive too which was great. read more

Pretty good pizza! Delivered in a timely manner into north haven! Delivery man had cool accent. 10/10 would order again!

If you want a good pizza in town or any other good foods go to Paradise pizzaOn route 5 I eat there all the time I love all their food and they have good soups and your pizzas are excellent and so is everything else so get over thereBelinda Hayden said soAnd so did my friend Christine read more

Had Paradise Pizza deliver several party pizzas and salads for a small work gathering. Delivery was right on time, pizza was very hot, and salads were fresh and appealing. Everybody thought the food was very good. read more

The pizza, salads, stuffed breads, grinders, & garlic knots are so good! Great staff, delivery is on time, etc

Cheese Pizza tastes like microwave pizza. It was rubbery and could have been cooked more. The cheese was white and the crust was doughy. You can tell they don't use fresh ingredients. Nice friendly service but I didn't like their pizza. read more

I'm not from Wallingford, but I travel for work so I try a lot of delivery places! I rarely write Yelp reviews unless they really stick out. This is one of those places. I got a calzone and it was fabulous, whatever ricotta they are using or making is primo. I got a small and it was huge so you really get your money's worth. Keep it up ! read more

I order an onion pizza from them well done and it's perfect every time. I've had other pizzas on their menu and can say I enjoyed every one of them. Their french fries are great and special. They are crispy with a great tasting coating and if you don't watch yourself you'll eat them all and there is a lot. My husband loves their calzones and, what I call, the carnivore pizza. Great staff and always happy to see you. read more

Wonderful pizza, incredibly friendly staff, great prices. I used to work down the road in North Haven, and would stop here once a week to eat and chat. Definitely stop by. read more