I took out of town guests there for dinner Wednesday night. I've been there several times a year since they opened many years ago. The food is always consistently good but they have fallen out of bounds on their wine mark-ups. We ordered a bottle of Piattelli Reserve Malbec. It was $38 when this wine sells for $10.49. The traditional restaurant mark-up is 100%, OBL marks this up 345% (and you tip on that mark-up as well). I can't support egregious restaurants, that fleece their customers. There is an old saying, Pigs get fed, Hogs get slaughtered. https://www.totalwine.com/wine/red-wine/malbec/piattelli-premium-malbec/p/113999750?s=2302&igrules=true read more

Conflicted, you are? Hmmm? ...this place is a cheesy strip mall suburban-mom-vibe hangout, with a sub-standard atmosphere, location, and layout. I guess the thinking was, hey, were cool, check out our blue antler chandelier. Wants to be hip...I guess. Not Hip. Not at all. Don't @me. The food, pretty great. - Diablo eggs - how could you not start with..possibly end with those? There may be a slice of ole Beelzebub in it. Ole devil. He he; - Fried avo - all of the women-folk in my life love em. If there was ever any left for yours truly, I would let you know. - Roasted Beets - Yes beets. And more beets, please. WTF, is this Severomorsk? - Multiple salads, Taos, Nats...something with apples in it. Great. - Green Chili Burger - Generic, right? Nope. I have ordered this 5 times-ish, it is amazing. Defies some natural laws. In foodie parlance: perfect burger eat-mouth. - Something green chile chicken enchilada stack? - Dang cousin, this is reelz. I love this. I feel like you blend it up and make a dip out of it. Or just eat it the way it is served. Pretty great. It's wanna-be, strip-mally atmosphere should NOT be overlooked for the quality of the food. I don't generally rank service, but the service here has always been very good for both takeout and table service. Professional and attentive. read more

I have been back a few times since my last review and every time has been a great experience. Most recently I organised a work dinner here and also had a great experience. Kathryn was helping me with the reservation and had everything sorted for me. Originally we had the back room booked which has an $800 minimum but when our party size dropped by almost half she was happy to move us into the restaurant and didn't charge us for the room. As it turns out, we got the room anyway, with no minimum because it was open and had extra tables in there, not just ours. I was a bit put off by the two young girls seating everyone, they wouldn't seat us till 1/2 our party had arrived even though the table was already ready for us. But I managed to get past that. We had a few appetizers to share, the pork taquitos, sweet and spicy shrimp, friend avocado and buffalo chicken flat bread. Highly recommend the last two. I had the lamb for my main and it was delicious, especially with bacon gnocchi and Brussels sprouts! And for 11 people, who all had a few drinks, the bill only came to $500. Winner! read more

The food is really good and so is the service. This place is always packed and I am not big on the lighting and how cramped it feels. We keep going back though because of the meals! read more

Tried OBL's new weekend brunch menu -- it was awesome! Had guacamole toast and my partner had huevos. Bloody mary and mimosa, too. Everything was great. Service was great. Atmosphere was great as always. Try it out! read more

I was in the neighborhood to meet up with a friend and had never been here so it was a great find. I don't remember exactly what I ordered but we took advantage of the happy hour and I recall thinking I would like to come back here to try more options. I know it was a good cocktail at least. Service was good and the atmosphere was easygoing. read more

Arrived for a Saturday morning brunch. The dining room setting was a bit dark. Air conditioning came on part way through our visit which made it somewhat uncomfortable for early May. It took almost 45 minutes to receive our food after we ordered. My plate, chorizo biscuits and gravy, arrived barely above room temperature. The gravy had congealed and basically had the consistency of warm American cheese; I could actually lift up "gravy" and see the biscuit beneath. The biscuits were so hard it was difficult to cut them even with a knife. The side of fried potatoes was barely wam to the touch. The other meals in our group were satisfactorily warm, but I believe mine had been prepared early and set off to the side for most of our 45 minute wait. I got the waitress's attention, explained the situation, and sent the meal back. I told her I did not want a replacement. Not once did she apologize nor did a manager ever come to the table to inquire about my poor food. I will never go back to OBL. read more

We went out for our anniversary dinner- my husband got the meatloaf and I got ribs. Both were mediocre unfortunately. The ribs were very overdone, I had to ask for a steak knife to cut each rib off, which even with a steak knife was difficult. I only ate half, my husband tried a bite and said it was like beef jerky and how did I even eat as much as I did. On the plus side the broccoli and mash potatoes were great! We let the server know and asked she tell the manager. The manager gave us 20% off the bill. Can't say that I was impressed and pretty sure I won't be coming back. read more

The salmon entree is one of the best salmon dishes I have had. Perfectly cooked and all of the accompaniments were complimentary and not overbearing. Service from the bartender was amazing! read more

We are from out of state visiting family in Highlands Ranch. We went to dinner at Old Blinking Light for dinner. Our food was so delicious. Our waitress was so pleasant and efficient. I very much appreciated that she asked if anyone had any food allergies that she should be aware of. I have food allergies and very much appreciate her making sure I was taken care of. We started with an appetizer of roasted beets. They were so good. They have a good variety of items on the menu so everyone can find something they like. We will come back again the next time we come to Highlands Ranch. read more

This is a very nice restaurant in the Town Center in Highlands Ranch. I always go at lunch and sit at the bar. I like the shredded beef enchiladas with both the red enchilada sauce and the green chili, Christmas Style. The service is always good, and food is wonderful. read more

Very very good Went for restaurant week n so worth. Service was good, place wasn't to loud, highly recommend and we will be back read more

See all

One of our favorite places in Highlands Ranch with a fun vibe. Good place for a date or to meet friends!

The food is really good, the service is sometimes spotty. One time I pointed out an error between what they charged us and what was quoted on the menu and the waiter just shrugged it off and didn't offer to fix it (I pointed it out before he took my payment, so it wasn't even after he ran my card). He just acted like there was nothing he could do and like it was my fault there was a difference between their menu and my bill. That made me pretty upset and didn't really want to go back and spend so much money with them. Yes, it's pricey so we spend a lot of money to eat there and to quibble over a couple of dollars seems a bit insane. However, it was more his attitude that really irked me. read more

We were running errands in the area and thought we would check out the restaurants in the area. Yelp recommended Old Blinking Light. The waiter, Danny was fantastic! We ordered some soup and the chicken nachos. The green chili unfortunately delivered cold and was a thick goopy, tasteless mess so that was a surprise for a green chili! Even when re-heated it was like campbells condensed soup. The chicken nachos arrived with a light brown congealed paste on top that didnt seem to be cheese at all but had that consistency and no flavor. The chicken was cleverly hidden in this river of goo and each piece about the size of a pea. This nonsense was poured over top of a mound of chips, nothing beneath the first layer. That was it, nothing else on the nachos except for the pico we has asked for on the side. No jalapenos, nada! Truly, a bizarre experience that noone else should have to endure. Except for Danny of course who was delightful and fortunately we ordered tequila sodas or it would have been a complete loss. read more

Broke my tooth here on meat in the pazole. Told to call and every time i did no answer or told person not there. Should not take years to get ahold of someone. read more

Love this restaurant. Would have given 5 stars, however after going in this evening they changed how they are providing their menu. Their menu in the dining room is not complete and is missing items that are in their bar menu. We almost left when we noticed that the things we can for where not showing on our menu. Thankfully our server reassured us we can still get the items. read more

Just a chill place; used to go here quite a bit in my 20's- great atmosphere, good service and decent prices. Usually do appetizers and their menu has broadened and all super good; great place for girls night or after work. Parking garage; not sure what else you want recommend! read more

We ordered from the Restaurant Week menu. We had the salmon cakes, chili soup, and southwest salad as our appetizers, all of which were very good. The main courses were terrible. The chicken was dry and plain, the strip was a strange texture and very fatty, and the Mahi Mahi was flavorless and covered in a mango chutney that tasted like it came out of a can. Thankfully both desserts were excellent. The guacamole we ordered was never brought out, but it wasn't on the tab and probably wasn't any good anyway. Overall very disappointing. read more

Old blinking light seems like a Texas style restaurant. All the food is very good and a little spicy. They have local taps, brunch, lunch, dinner and a full bar. My only issue is the attention to detail. For example the salt and pepper shakers are very dirty, half the light bulbs are out or missing in the bathroom and the staff is grumpy AF. The raspberry Mohito I had was delicious, they use a purée. Overall I would come here again but I would hope that they did a little cleanup. read more

Old Blinking Light - Smoked salmon benedict and breakfast burrito - New American Near Me - Highlands Ranch, Colorado

OMG--WHAT A GREAT DINING EXPERIENCE!!! :-) First time at Old Blinking Light and the place was packed and vibrant! Came to use a Groupon that was going to expire. We're greeted, checked in and seated right away-glad I made a reservation! Our server was Jenny and she was friendly, courteous, and efficient. We didn't have to wait long for anything!! For appetizers we ordered the sweet-and-spicy chile-dusted popcorn shrimp with chipotle aioli and honey, and the mahi-mahi ceviche served cold with peppers, avocado and chips. Both were so freaking good and the ceviche was the best I have had in Denver!! The portions were a very good size too. My daughter ordered the Achiote--and-citrus-marinated pork served over a chimichurri sauce with mashed potatoes and house vegetables. It was tender and delicious! It was such a huge portion it looked like she hadn't even made a dent in it. She had to take some home--now she has lunch for tomorrow. :-) I ordered the New Mexico red-chili-crusted salmon with cilantro green rice, calabacitas, pico de gallo, and lime and again, the portion was huge and it was also delicious. To end the meal, we had the OBL Mud Pie (oreo cookie crust stuffed with coffee ice cream and topped with oreo cookie crumbles, toasted walnuts, chocolate sauce, whipped cream, and a cherry). The portion was HUGE!! I think four people could have eaten it and left the table satisfied. From start to finish it was great. We left the restaurant with a big smile on our faces. Even with the drive (I live close to Tamarac Square), I would come back, even without a coupon (and that is saying a lot!!). Our compliments to Executive Chef Christopher Hansen and his staff!! read more

See all

The overall experience was ok, the portions were bigger than expected. Service was ok, not super attentive. The decor is really nice and unique, cool atmosphere. Quality of the food was just ok, not sure I'd go back based on that. read more

So yummy and happy they were open with a very warm patio during COVID restrictions. We had the Buffalo chicken flat bread pizza, green chili Mac and cheese and a special of gnocchi with cream sauce. Great food great service. Great experience! Thanks Old Blinking Light read more

See all

Old Blinking Light makes the very best Brussels sprouts I have ever tasted in my life.......those bring me back over and over!

Another great place in Highlands Ranch. We love to go there because their employees are attentive. I have to point out the gentleman that works there running waters since they opened this place. He will never leave you thirsty! Food is amazing. Great job! read more

Very hip-country interior. Large rustic-wooden tables with clear coats and lots of corrugated steel and other hip-looking decorations. Wait staff are friendly, helpful and sharp looking. Food arrived quickly, correctly and was served with flair as well as being hot and fresh. The prices are on the high side so the wife and I only come here on occasion but enjoy our dining experience thoroughly. read more

A friend and I stopped by quickly to grab a drink and a snack, so our visit was short and we didn't see much. I didn't see a Dirty Martini on the cocktail list but I ordered one and it was average. The Nachos had great toppings with a nice kick of spice but the chips got soggy pretty quickly. We sat on the patio and were able to see the mountains in the distance. We also got to check out the surrounding business - There is a Coldstone in the plaza, so if you can't find a dessert on their menu, you have options! read more

Old Blinking Light - Dirty Martini - New American Near Me - Highlands Ranch, Colorado

See all

Food is descent but the service sucks! The management walks around in a power trip, treats the regulars like part of the furniture and for the prices they charge, the food just isn't worth it! They mad changes to the menu... but honestly theres much better places in town. This place had its run but its time time to turn in the towel for this sad place!! read more

Been 3-4 times the last few years, always forgetting that the food is just that- forgettable. Nothing exciting. And yet expensive a chicken sandwhich is almost $20. Never again. Tons of other options in a 1 mile radius. read more

Appetizers are awesome! Try the tempura shrimp and the ribs, first class! Great service and good people! read more

Old Blinking Light - Tempura shrimp - New American Near Me - Highlands Ranch, Colorado

See all

A really nice local bar and restaurant, was full of friends and neighbors. They were very kind! All ages but many +55. My apple orchard ales were refreshing! I also got the Fish n Chips. It was really Yummy! Good fish, delish sauce, great fries!! Service was friendly, polite, fast. I hope to go back soon! read more

Dined here with my fiancé tonight. Service was quick and cheerful. Food was fresh and yummy for the most part. Kitchen was super fast. Modern yet chicly rustic interior had a nice ambiance. We tried: Deviled eggs, not nearly as spicy as the menu had me thinking! These were "okay". Not too interesting or flavorful but not bland. One white was very firm and I didn't enjoy that, nor can I explain why it was like that. Brussel sprouts! Soooogood. I would get them again. Fiancé loved them too and he usually dislikes cooked brussel sprouts. I loved the crispy crunch and the balsamic glaze. Great together Fish n chips, fresh and hot fish under a mountain of great skin on, thick (but not wedges) fries! Fish was superb with lemon aioli and some of those Brussel sprouts from the app. Pulled pork and sweet potato fries were delicious. My pork was more chopped plus pulled which I was minutely disappointed by, but the meat was nice and lean. Sauce was rather bold. Nice quality pickles. The sweet potato fries were amazing with the smokey chipotle aioli! Fiancé had a Titan IPA draft and it was really nice he said. Over all we enjoyed everything and are looking forward to returning. read more

See all

Great food, for price and size. Really good attention to details and combination of ingredients are great. The place is clean and service is good. Pizzas was simple but great. The ceviche was awesome appetizer. read more

Great staff and service is always awesome. Everything I've had to eat here (which is almost everything since we have been coming in for 10+ years) is always very good! read more

Went for dinner, Friday, Nov. 4th. Guac & chips appetizer was very good, as was the house Marg. My dinner, King Ranch Chile Enchiladas was only OK. The rice and beans were good. Cheese filling in the enchiladas was lacking and generally tasted like a bunch of tortilla dough. Dessert of Bourbon Vanilla Bread Budding was only ok also. Definitely lacked sauce. For a great version of this, check out Smoking Fins' bread pudding. Even adding half the amount of sauce that they use would be an improvement. Overall great atmosphere and wait staff. We'll be back. Lunch a few weeks ago was definitely better. read more

Had dinner here last week for the first time. I was impressed! They had both indoor and outdoor seating. The indoor seating was spaced well for social distancing if anyone is concerned. It appeared the wait staff was somewhat overwhelmed but they busted their butts to provide excellent customer service. Loved the Oven-Roasted Beets as a starter so I would recommend. The King Ranch Casserole was good if you like enchiladas. The favorite at the table was the gluten free BBQ chicken pizza. We liked it so much we ordered another one to have some leftovers for home. We will definitely go back. read more

I've come here twice. I've not been disappointed being a foodie and this day (back in August) I tried their New Mexico/an Posole.... Plate lickin' Good! Although I didn't literally do that, I would have at home. Love this ambiance, considering that I am from LA and I feign for places like this everywhere. I'm grateful this place exists, compared to chain restaurants in the area. read more

See all

I came here on a Friday evening and waited more than an hour for a table of 2 even tho they had lots of tables open (reservation no shows?) My frienD and I split 2 dishes: Po Boy with truffle fries: this was just average. Sauce waS ok. I would highly recommend not spending the extra $ for the truffle fries bc they were not very good Mac and cheese: this was also just meh, flavor was pretty bland Overall I probably wouldn't come back, I wasn't too impressed with the two dishes. My friend, who eats and likes all food, agreed on the assessment of the two dishes read more

The review is for service only. We decided to give them another try after couple bad services we had before the year before. Have to applaud the consistent of their Bad service no matter how many times we have been there. We left sitting on the table for 20 minutes. No eye contact from any waiters/waitress. The one star is for The busgirl since we got water right away. We really want to like this place but it's time to move on... read more

Nice variety in the menu and great service. Our party of six was in and out in about an hour. I had the halibut, which was the special, and it was really good in a light butter caper sauce on rice with asparagus. Our table also enjoyed the blackened shrimp Caesar, the NY strip, ceviche, southwest pizza and tacos. Everything was tasty and fresh. Sine it's in the neighborhood we will make this one of our "go tos"! read more