I don't know why we never came last year but we finally tried it and will definitely be back. Prices are high but comparable to anyone else that serves lobster rolls. My son enjoyed his Connecticut roll. I had the California lobster roll with avocado and wasabi crema. So good. They come with house made chips seasoned with Old Bay. Very good. Not greasy. Next time I want to try the lobster tots. They have a cooler with soda, beer, and wine minis, as well as a slushy machine. Service is fast and friendly. Lots of outdoor seating. The location at Olcott Beach is great. It's right by a small ferris wheel, and in walking distance to the shops, beach, carousel park, and Krull Park. A great addition to the town. read more

Olcott Lobster - I was a little late taking a picture of his Connecticut roll. - Sandwiches Near Me - Olcott, New York

See all

I've been hearing so many great things about this establishment from my friends that we had to finally make our way up here to partake in what I've been told are some absolutely amazing rolls. Well I'm happy to say that I was not deceived, these were fresh and of good size ( we got the sampler). I was most impressed by Connecticut roll and the Fire roll, the New England wasnt bad just didnt hit as hard as that buttery or spicy taste. The kids tenders and tots, the little yelper crushed those and left super happy. The only meh thing for me was the clam chowder, I love a thick chowder and the misses loved this one because it wasn't. We agreed to disagree on this. But absolutely great experience overall and we are looking forward to visiting the new Lewiston spot next. read more

Olcott Lobster - Lobster roll flight - Sandwiches Near Me - Olcott, New York

See all

We had a blast here a few weeks ago, service was fast, nice seating outside, live music and the lobster was delish! The homemade chips also very good, the seasonings on them were very yummy. read more

Olcott Lobster - Outdoor seating - Sandwiches Near Me - Olcott, New York

See all

Usually would never get a lobster roll outside of New England/Maine but this is delicious! Service was friendly, attentive and quick. Outdoor seating only. Nice spot next to the Ferris wheel. Filling eats before exploring the village shops. read more

Olcott Lobster - Flight- Connecticut (buttered), Calabrian (spice chili), New England (lemon chive aioli) - Sandwiches Near Me - Olcott, New York

See all

Stopped here with my mother to give em a try, I'm the roll was soft buttery and they weren't stingy with the lobster meat I just forgot to order butter to dip my roll in. The potatoes in the salad was a little hard in my opinion which I didn't like but had a good taste. Biggest downside was the burger which my mother ordered , I would advise not to order that but nevertheless I'll be back for another roll! read more

See all

We visited Olcott Lobster company on a nice summer weekend. They have a few tables indoors and a large patio. The patio was perfect for the day we visited and they had love acoustic music. We ordered the lobster flight to split, were given a buzzer and told it'd be about a 35 minute wait. It was nearly a 35 minute wait down to the minute! The rolls were loaded with lobster that was cooked perfectly! My boyfriend liked the Connecticut roll best (just buttah) and I liked the Olcott Fire roll best (calabrian chili butter); the New England roll (lemon chive mayo) ranked last for both of us. We did not think $36 was a crazy high price for the trio. There is an extra charge (I think it was 3.5%) for using a credit card. Cash is king! read more

See all

I just recently heard about this place so was happy when we were in Olcott this past weekend & had the opportunity to go there. We arrived around 5:00 on Sunday. There was a long line waiting to get inside. Luckily it was a beautiful day & the crowd around us with friendly. Once inside our order was taken & we went out to the patio to wait for our food to be delivered. Again a bit of a wait. On to the food. Their speciality is lobster rolls. We ordered the lobster roll flight. It included the traditional New England roll, a hot Connecticut roll, and the Olcott Fire roll. This way we were able to try them all. They were loaded with huge chunks of tasty lobster. No skimping here. All worth the long wait!. My advise, try to avoid the busy main meal times. Or just sit back & enjoy your time near the lake while waiting. 2025-63 read more

See all

Reminiscent of a New England oceanside Lobster Shack. It's all takeout with no inside seating. Pleanty of tables and picnic benches outside. It was a bit of a wait to place our order and for them to prepare it but it was worth the wait. The rolls have a lot of Lobster meat in them. There are different sauces including a hot pepper sauce that really spiced it up. They have other things on their menu including items for people with you that don't like or eat Lobster. NOTE: A word of warning. They charge an extra fee if you pay with a credit card. Next time you go to Olcott, it's a must place to stop. read more

See all

Cute place tucked in among other small business right at the head of entrance to Olcott. You can park along the main street, a small lot in front, the row of parking on Lockport St or park in the village and walk over. I arrived right around noon, the line was out the door and the patio full already...the doors had just opened! My goal for this mission was the lobster BLT I saw on their menu posted on Instagram. So far there doesnt appear to be a website, so following their social media is the way to go. Right now the process is fairly simple, the main entrance is the door between the other shops. Upon entry you'll walk up to the open kitchen and ordering counter. After placing your order your name will be taken and the food will be brought out to you. Currently there is only patio seating, most likely due to the seasonal nature of the area. After what seemed like a short wait, my food was nearly brought out to me. Although I would devour so many things, being a lobster lover I ordered only the lobster BLT. The lobster BLT is magic. Iceberg lettuce, tomato, bacon (perfect balance of crisp and fatty) between two well toasted slices of bread. This sandwich is magical. (The only thing to make it more magical would be a spread of Miracle Whip. I know! Im a salad dressing gurlie). But really, this sandwich needs nothing but a hungry person to consume it. read more

See all

We visited for a late lunch, and while the prices were a bit high, my daughter thoroughly enjoyed her grilled cheese. My lobster roll was satisfactory, and the service was acceptable. read more

Food was decent, a bit pricy for me and I didn't get lobster. Burger was surprisingly delicious and quite large. Service was ok as it was a beautiful day and they were busy, but many tables that arrived after us were served before us. We ate outside under an umbrella but it was too hot imo to eat outside. Noisy, as there's a Ferris wheel right next door. Those I was with that got lobster said it was superb read more

Absolutely delicious! Enjoyed everything we had (lobster roll flight, lobster bisque, and fried shrimp with handmade chips). Plenty of seating and relatively quick considering that it was busy. Well organized. Plenty of beverage options. read more

See all

This 5 star rating is on the food only.... IT WAS THE BEST LOBSTER IN NYS !!! The lobster was absolutely fantastic... I had the lobster flight ... Which includes: 3oz Maine lobster roll ( cold lobster ( like with mayo ) 3oz Connecticut lobster roll ( warm lobster roll with butter ) 3oz of lobster roll with Calabrian chilies- The homemade chips were good The Hawaiian slaw was good... If you want anything better, you'd have to go to the state of Maine... and you'd get the same thing...annnnd have to travel hundreds of miles to get it... Now let's talk about the restaurant.... 1st off, I'm not sure if this is actually a new place as I would have thought it's ... just an unknown place. There is no indoor seating... all outdoor... Which would have been nice but the Canadian wildfire smoke up north in olcott was a tad heavy, so it woulda been nice to eat inside... but there is no inside 2nd'ly .. the wait line was long, no shade... stood in line for 45 minutes just to get in the door, then you look at the menu on the wall and immediately order and pay right then and there at the register and walk outside to about a dozen mismatched outdoor tables, some with shade umbrellas , some not. Then you wait for the woman bringing food to you for another 20 minutes ( not too bad ) but she gave me anxiety watching her run around like a chicken with her head cut off.. I unfortunately had gone during peak lunch hours... ( when we left the establishment, I looked back ((3:30pm)) and there was no line ) But it was delicious... I gotta admit...lol . It was worth the wait in flavor alone... There was a two person band playing and that was great - it wasn't too loud... just enough to enjoy my meal... The price I paid for these lobster meals was appropriate for what we got - definitely in line with the standard cost of lobster. I was a little puzzled as where the restaurant was because I could not find a sign, so look for the small ferris wheel on the left side of main st and it's right there. I did get a punch card, three punches down, nine to go and I get a free meal!!!! read more

See all

The food was fresh and abundant. The servers are very pleasant. Always a pleasure to eat there. The outdoor atmosphere adds to the eating experience. read more

Super cute place with excellent lobster rolls. Lines are usually long but they move fast. Prices are very good. Highly recommend the lobster roll flight. read more

Olcott Lobster - Sandwiches Near Me - Olcott, New York

Well priced for lobster rolls, and they tasted great + fresh. Surrounding Location is beautiful. The shop itself is a little small so they work with what they got. The workers are amazing and polite, it's not often you get greeted at the door. Highly recommended read more

Was Just at lewiston branch, menu said you get chips with lobster rolls. We got a lobster flight. We got a servor who was new and knew very little. We were pretty much ignored and told via proxy no chips for us. $130 not well spent on a first time visit with service like this. We even had wait to get our check as no one should make eye contact at the bar. read more

Olcott Lobster - Note their menu says chips with the lobster rolls and nowhere does it say it's not part of the lobster roll flights which are all smaller - Sandwiches Near Me - Olcott, New York

Nice outdoor seating and atmosphere for inland lobster. Service was good. Gives a little feel like you are in Maine. Lobster roll flight was great! Lobster Bisque and Potato Salad were great as well! read more

lobster roll flight and loaded tater tots were sooooo good!! go before it gets busy because it gets pretty hectic in there. definitely worth the money though! cute little area read more

Olcott Lobster - lovster roll flight and loaded tater tots - Sandwiches Near Me - Olcott, New York

This restaurant popped up on my FB feed, had to come check it out. Very cute little place with outdoor seatings only. You order at the counter, they bring the food out. Menu is almost all lobster related, some shrimp. Sides with tater tots, chips and slaw. I got the lobster rolls flight to try all three types of lobster rolls, Maine, Connecticut and Olcott (spicy). I also got the Hawaiian slaw, coleslaw with pineapple chucks. Each lobster rolls in the flight has 3 oz meat, if order just one roll, it has 5 oz meat. They didn't skimp on the meat at all. All freshly made after you order. All tasted delicious. Service is friendly and quick. They open at noon, I got there at 11:38, and I was the 5th, at 11:50, there were more than 30 in line. It's not a place you linger, so it moved pretty fast. Parking can be in the lot by the restaurant or in town. They charge an extra fee for using a credit card to pay. Menu prices are for paying with cash. read more

See all

My wife, daughter, and I drove up to Olcott Lobster Company for the first time yesterday. It was a nice 40 minute ride up there on a beautiful late summer day! We found parking and joined the very active line which moved along steadily. A pleasant young staff member brought out copies of the menu for us to look over prior to ordering. We waited in line for 30-35 minutes before placing our order. We were given "beeper" device and found a table on the back patio area. The 15-20 minutes for our order to come out passed quickly as we chatted and listened to a really nice pane that was playing on the corner, so visitors on both patios could hear. Our food was delivered to our table by a friendly young lady who was eager for us to try it. My wife and daughter enjoyed their Connecticut Rolls as much as I loved my Lobster Roll Flight (New England Style (cold with mayo), Connecticut Roll (warm and buttery), and Olcott Fire Roll (warm and buttery with Calabrian peppers)). We also enjoyed their Connecticut Rolls sides that we tried which included the House Made Chips with Old Bay Dusting, the Hawaiian Slaw (SO GOOD!), and the Tator Tots (deep fried with a nice crunch and tender potato center). Thank you, Olcott Lobster Co., for bringing a little bit of New England to this beautiful area. You have done an incredible job in your debut year for absolutely nailing the feel and flavor that I would expect to find in a coastal New England hot spot. We will be back before you close for the season! read more

See all

A surprising delight in Olcott. After browsing through all the lovely little shops, came across this gem. Food is great. Not overly expensive for lobster...and you get plenty in the bisque and overflowing the bun in the lobster rolls. Worth a stop here. read more

Delicious lobster rolls with amazing service. The flight was the bomb!!! It was a great experience all together. read more

Olcott Lobster - Flight Roll - Sandwiches Near Me - Olcott, New York

Went for dinner. Arrived at 4:30 on Mother's Day when they opened following a brunch. I ordered a lobster roll, my husband ordered clam chowder and potato chips. I had a question about the chips that came with the lobster roll. My husband's food arrived, my order never went in... Waitress didn't pit my order in. Received it 30 minutes ater my husband finished his order. Offered to comp our drinks, but we had paid for them at the bar before sitting down. Soup wasn't hot, beer wasn't that cold. Waitress offered us cheesecake. I'm starting a diet tomorrow and my husband is on a specific diet. read more

Staff is nice. We waited in a long line outside the shop. But that was nothing compared to waiting for our food. About half an hour later, it showed up and was lukewarm -- with no butter for the Connecticut lobster roll. The first time I went it was amazing. The food came out fast and perfectly hot - with extra butter. The homemade chips were also great. However, my husband ordered the grilled cheese with lobster sandwich and the cheese wasn't even melted. Also, they had run out of lobster bisque and clam chowder. My husband never wants to go back, but we were there about an hour before closing and it was super busy. Still, that's no reason to not be consistent in serving a roll at $24.95 with appropriate warmth. read more

High marks fir trying but the lobster rolls are just meh. I know lobster rolls having spent my boyhood summers on the Maine coast, parents retired to the Maine cost and we have vacationed regularly on the coast. The Olcott version trys hard to recreate the experience and the rolls contain generous amounts of lobster meat but the lobster meat lacks the sweetness of freshness and ultimately is just ok. The long line moved reasonably quickly and our order was ready within 15 minutes. I hoped to find the real deal but conclude this is a so-so knock off. It is also about 35% cheaper than the Maine version and is just 10 minutes from my house. So it has that going for it. read more

Absolutely excellent. The food was delicious, fresh and also very high quality. Every single employee was so helpful and pleasant. There were five in our party. We had several flights and the surf and turf. We also had the house made chips. There was not a thing that we had that we didn't love. My favorite was the surf and turf, the sauce that they used was just delicious. This is worth the drive. Can't wait to go back. read more

The food was absolutely amazing and delicious! The service was impeccable! My mister raved about the lobster roll for at least three days. I had the fried shrimp with the homemade fries. EXCELLENT FOOD; EXCELLENT SERVICE. Everyone there was complimenting their food. Kudos to the entire staff read more

For a starter, the lobster bisque was delicious. It was thick and creamy, loaded with chunks of fresh, sweet lobster. I chose the warm lobster roll. It was served on a toasted and buttered New England style bun. Chunks of lobster meat on top, with a sprinkle of seasoning. It also included homemade, seasoned potato chips. I'll definitely be going back next season. read more

First time there and the lobster was soooooo goooooood. Will definitely be back. The drinks were also good, and the view was beautiful

If you want a great lobster roll in WNY...this is the place. It was definitely worth the drive and the wait. We stood in line for a half hour ordered; then the food was delivered in about 10 mins. I had the lobster flight, my wife stuck with the warm Connecticut Roll. All the lobster meat was tender and sweet. The rolls light and toasted brushed with butter. The Connecticut Roll was our favorite because it was warm and came with melted butter for dipping which just enriched all the simple flavors of lobster and butter. The chips were crispy and lightly seasoned. Next time I will have to get the tots. The place is small with limited seating outside. When u arrive grab a table while your partner stands in line. If the owner can scale up; they should move to a larger location to have a separate line for takeout orders. The Olcott Lobster Co. does Lobstah Rolls Right read more

Oh my gosh. I thought I was on Cape Cod. Best lobster roll ever. Service was great! Worth every penny!

Service was outstanding. Little ambiance. Food not so great, left much to be desired, not worth the high prices.

This restaurant is a must when you go to Olcott. My husband and I went and had the regular Lobster Roll and were blown away! There are 5 oz of lobster in each roll and it is so fresh and sweet! There may be lines but the wait is worth it. My advice is to get there as soon as it opens and the wait is shorter! Thank you Michelle and company for a wonderful experience!! read more