I've been wanting to try Mariner's Landing for awhile now. The location is great. It's right by Olcott Beach. They have outdoor seating in the warmer months. The restaurant interior has a very distinctive vibe, occupying a comfortable space between casual and upscale. They still had lights and a lovely Christmas tree up. The walls are lined with ship models and other nautical accents, and there's a couple of fish tanks, one in a wall enclave with netting and shells, but the ambiance never devolves into kitsch. Our server Desiree was excellent. The food ranged from good to great. My husband's ribeye was cooked medium rare as requested but the seasoning was bland. My fried seafood platter was excellent. The batter was light, crispy and golden, and nothing was overcooked or rubbery. I just wish they had a half portion because it's too much food for one person. The children's menu has a large variety of options. The chocolate cake for dessert was amazing and artfully presented. They do have some local wines, all from Schultz. The menu only shows bottle prices, which were not much higher than what you'd pay in retail. at least for local wines, but I was able to order by the glass. Overall, a great dining experience. read more

I was disappointed with our experience at mariners landing. When you walk in the dining area smells bad, I think the smell was coming from the fishtanks that definitely needed to be cleaned. The food wasn't great, we got fish and chips, the fish tasted freezer burned, and the coleslaw wasn't very good. The fries were good. The waitress staff was average. Overall I would not go again or recommend it in the future. read more

Never was disappointed in a meal. Eat in or take out....always great. Have taken many friends to Mariners and everyone enjoyed the ambiance, friendly service and delicious food. Can't wait to go back again. read more

Hands-down, the best fried fish and grilled fish I've ever had in my life service couldn't be better everyone there is actually a rockstar

We sat outside on a brisk fall day, we had our dog & the lower patio is dog friendly! Our waitress Teresa was very sweet. We ordered French Onion Soup & New England Clam Chowder and they might have been the most delicious soups I've ever had! We split a fish fry & that was also good. Great prices too. read more

Mariner's Landing - Bowl of French onion soup - American Near Me - Olcott, New York

See all

Great seafood restaurant with an amazing location next to the lake. I have seen them open recently, so I'm pretty sure they are NOT closed.

We went a little hard. We were starving. Let's see we got 10 medium wings and 10 BBQ wings which wee alright. We got spaghetti and a meatball which was better then I was expecting. Fish fry was below average. We ate on the roof patio which was nice had a nice view of the lake. read more

See all

The view from the upstairs balcony is really great! I ordered fried zucchini. The zucchini was alright, but it's pretty hard to mess up fried food. According to my companions, the wings were decent as well. The french onion soup tasted like water. There was no salt in it at all. It tasted like nothing. The baked stuffed clams were awful. It tasted like they mixed salsa, breadcrumbs, chopped clams together and called it a day. Just no. They serve orange slices with EVERYTHING. I think the point is to make sure we don't get scurvy, but this is Lake Ontario, not the Atlantic Ocean. Calm down and stop wasting oranges. Actually, maybe the oranges are a smart choice since I'd rather eat a plain orange than that french onion soup again. The service was also kind of slow even though they were not busy. I'd come back to sit on the patio for drinks and oranges, but I'm not bothering with their food again. read more

Mariner's Landing - Fried zucchini with an orange slice. - American Near Me - Olcott, New York

It's a fantastic place, but they are temporarily closed right now due to covid and being off season.

We haven't been to dinner here in a while. It was a Friday and we had a reservation. We were seated promptly but that's was the end of good service! We waited at least 15 minutes to get a drink from the bar. Our dinners were good but our service was terrible. Waitress was more concerned about being outside than waiting on her one table inside. She delivered our food and one drink and that was about it! Needless to say her tip reflected in the the bad service. It's too bad but we won't be going back for a long time! read more

I LOVE their steamed clams!!!! I grew up on them as a kid. Yes you may have your bad days but you will also have your good days. Clams are hard because one day they might be great and the next might not be. It just depends on that batch, doesn't matter how they cook it, although there have been a few times where they were over steamed but overall I love it. read more

Family of 4, waited an hour for 2 burgers and kids grilled cheese and kids spaghetti. Like any American I like to put ketchup on my burger. The label on the ketchup bottle (pictured) looked like they have been refilling it since the restaurant opened. Based on those things not much else I can say about my experience. read more

Mariner's Landing - Nasty ketchup bottle - American Near Me - Olcott, New York

We sat on the upper deck and had dinner - a beautiful evening. Elizabeth was our waitress she did an excellent job. She asked if we wanted to know the specials before she went to get our drinks - very smart - we were then able to order when the drinks came. We were seated, had our drinks, ordered within 10 min. The food was very good with generous portions. Be aware there are 16 steps that not only you have to climb but the wait and bus staff come up and down with serving trays balancing drinks and food. The Draught beer was cold, the clam chowder good, as was the ravioli in red sauce and BBQ chicken. Definitely give them a try. read more

Mariner's Landing - From the upper deck above Olcutt Beach looking at Lake Ontario. - American Near Me - Olcott, New York

What I wonderful relaxing place to eat by the lake, everyone is friendly and the food is great. Prices are reasonable and the service is good. read more

This is one of my favorite places to dine out on OBNY. Excellent service, a very outstanding chef, and what a view in the spring through fall. Very cozy inside during the winter, too. Everything is delicious. Brilliant cocktails and steamed clams, plus steaks. I feel like I'm family there. It feels like they're taking care of family. read more

My wife and I had dinner here last night. The service was spectacular. And the meals were out of this world. I had to seafood Alfredo which was probably the best that I've had anywhere. My wife had to broiled scallops. All of the seafood items were extremely fresh and very tasty. We sat inside and it was very clean and the ambience was very nice. All in all it was a very pleasant experience and well worth a trip there. The menu is wide and varied with everything from a fish fry to steaks And sandwiches read more

See all

We have been by this restaurant many times and decided to finally give it a try. Got there right before they opened and we did not have reservations. We were lucky to get a table but had to sit inside as the outside were for reservations only. Got two glasses of water and waited 40 minutes for someone to take our order. Food was mediocre at best though edible. Total two hours spent and most of the time was waiting. One waitress for inside and outside as the second came in 40 minutes late. We will not be back, so not impressed. read more

We had dinner here this past weekend. I ordered the broiled seafood platter and was not impressed. The scallops were so salty. They were not tasty. The shrimp was good but the fish was dried out. We all ordered the French onion soup and there were huge chunks of onion. My fiancé found a huge chunk of onion skin in his soup. I wish I liked it more since we are out that way often but I don't think we will be back. The decor is dated but tasteful. The restaurant does have a nice atmosphere but the food needs a lot of work. read more

Just waited an hour and only got a drink while everyone else in the place got their food. A waitress finally asked if we wanted menus because no one had written up our order. We left. read more

Had a fab lunch with wonderful service and food. Lamb stew some best ever had and owner gave hint of the chicken/beef base with sherry that really made the stew. The fresh herb bread is melt in mouth yummy. Needless to say this is a return eatery for me read more

This restaurant has a nice charm to it with a wonderful location. It is located directly behind the children's amusement park, so it makes for a nice stop off after giving the kids some entertainment. When we went, I had the fried perch and my girlfriend had the fried haddock. The fried fish (both of them) came with choice of potato OR spaghetti with red sauce. While a little strange, I thought this was a nice option. The perch also came with a cup of New England clam chowder which was delicious. Entrees came with some delicious fresh baked bread. I would say the chowder was a 4 out of 5. The haddock was also a 4 out of 5. The haddock was not huge, but it was well cooked and seamed to be fresh. The perch was good as well, again, about 4 out of 5. Service was prompt and there was a decent beer selection. I would definitely return to try more items on the menu. read more

My wife and I dined here last Sunday for lunch. The service and food were very good. I ordered the chicken and biscuits, which was excellent. And, the views of the lake from the outside balcony, where we were seated, were just beautiful. My only complaint was the size of the toilet stall in the men's bathroom. It was so tight that it was almost to the point of being unusable, and would be for a larger person. Eat elsewhere, if you think that you may need to use the toilet facilities after your meal. read more

Great lunch!!! Stopped here on our way to the carousel park. Very pleasant surprise :-)

Decent local business, I've eaten there many times. I recommend one of their soups (French onion is my personal fave) or one of their steaks. It can get busy sometimes but it's a cute place to go when you want a nice dinner near the lake! read more

We have always enjoyed a visit to this restaurant, whether summer, spring, winter, or fall. The atmosphere is warm, inviting, and, of course, very nautical. Food has always been excellent, as well as the service. Our favorite is the French onion soup and beef on weck. Soup is delicious and the weck is loaded with lots of tender beef. It's a nice drive and pleasant outing. read more

Food was good not so much now! Decor needs brighting.. lighter paint!!!! White, Caribbean blue come on... smells moldy... some big sliding glass doors on the park and one or two on the back to see the lake!!!!! Too dark and uninviting!!!! read more

We live quite close to Mariner's Landing & I have to say it's one of our faves! The food is always excellent, great prices too. While we only make it there sporadically we almost always get the same waitress who recognizes us & greets us warmly. The wait is always minimal & there is a nice bar you can wait at. During the warm weather you can dine on the upstairs patio. Unfortunately the service isn't always the best up there but I blame that mostly to the fact that the poor servers have to schlep everything up & down those stairs lol. The view makes it worth it either way. This is a nice non-chain seafood restaurant. The only thing I could say has room for improvement is the desserts. But either way we rarely have room for dessert after a delicious appettizer, soup & dinner. My recommendations- new england clam chowder, coconut shrimp but especially the seafood alfredo!! read more

refused to move one chair, from an empty table so our party could sit together. 2 chair table had to stay with only two chairs. No wonder the inside was completely empty. read more

Stay away. Food was average. Atmosphere was awful. The inside was hot and sticky. We were told there was a 45 minute wait to be seated but there were empty tables everywhere. No waiter showed up at our table for 10 minutes and we were told that the kitchen was behind and food would take a while multiple times. read more

Well, 25 minutes for one drink to arrive, my girlfriend had to wait 10 minutes more for her drink as they had no vermouth at the bar. This is after having to find the owner to let her know no one had approached out table. Waiters humor, for want of a better term, did not lighten the atmosphere. Nor did it help that he is saying it is all down to a difficult table inside, can only imagine what he is saying to them about me. Oh and the French onion soup was the worst ever. On the positive side the broiled fish and fish fry were good. Not wort coming back for the wait experience read more

Amazing we were driving from Niagara to Seneca. Just wanted a nice hot bowl of soup. stumbled on this place. Very local atmosphere family run everything made on site. Menu look good but being vegetarian few choices. However i was told without asking Mushroom Soup is made with mushroom broth cuz that is only way her daughter will eat it. With the first tasting of just the soup it was so rich & full of flavor. nice large slices of mushrooms not over cook. loved it. My boyfriend had clam chowder look very good & hardy. I wanted to lick the bowl. Jenny great host owner 17 yrs. if you are anywhere within 10 miles make it a destination for a great meal. read more

Who knows how the food is???? I don't...... It looked good on people's tables but I wouldn't know because our server was nowhere to be found. We elected to take in the beautiful views on the second floor outdoor patio. 10 minutes go by...... Someone comes by with water for us. I asked them to send the server over as I had my 6 year who has already patiently waited 10 minutes without any restaurant provided crayons or paper. Another 5 minutes go by...... I ask a server that was serving another table if we could order as by this time we've already been waiting 15 minutes without even a drink order taken. The server said sorry they can't take our order but will send our server over ASAP. Another 5 minutes go by........ We left. No one even acknowledged us on the way out. 20 minutes and we couldn't even get a drink order in???????? Here's the kicker the place was empty. The entire restaurant had 7 tables sat. I will never try this place again. Absolutely no reason why in any restaurant you should ever wait 20 minutes and not even be able to get a drink order taken by a server. read more

I feel bad that I have not reviewed this place in the past as I have frequented the place a few times... Let me start by saying the bar is awesome they have cold draft beer and a ton of different spirits. The food is always very good especially the Friday night fish fry at a very good price. If you can get here in the summer the upper deck outdoor patio is a must great views with great food. read more

The food was pretty over priced for what you get. I feel like the food is on the same level to what you would get at a hole in the wall bar. The atmosphere was nice to see the lake from the patio, but there were so many black flies flying on our food as well as ourselves. The wait time was long for our entrees (perch, and ravioli) and the customer service was barely present. If I make my way around here, I won't be stopping again. read more

Had our first dinner here for Easter Sunday. Service was exceptional! Party of 8 sat inside and we were all very impressed with the food. Chicken Cordon was excellent. fried fisher mans platter and coconut shrimp were huge portions with great quality. All in all very impressed with Mariners and will be back this summer to eat outside on the huge deck overlooking the lake. By far the best restaurant in Olcott. read more

We have tried this restaurant twice, both times we were left standing awkwardly inside while we were completely ignored. We finally left even though there were tables available. Horrible customer service. read more

We visited Mariner's Landing on July 3rd, the night of Olcutt's Fireworks. The menu was varied. I chose the ravioli. It was absolutely delicious, at least 10 large pieces with delicious sauce. It came with a wonderful salad, that included slices of peppers ( red & green), cucumber, carrots, pepperochini, small delicious crotons, and onions. I chose house dressing ( sweet Vidalia onion). I also tasted my families choices, breaded shrimp with cocktail sauce ( at least 10) that included a cup of their homemade clam chowder ( made fresh that morning), my daughter's dish, Clams casino done in lightly fried balls that were so tasty! My husband had a cup of chowder with his beef on wreck and added on house salad. Everyone was happy with their choices and with what we considered to be reasonable prices for high quality food with very pleasant and attentive service. The place was packed, and had a lovely outdoor upper patio as well as a small patio down stairs. Restaurant is decorated with a nautical theme and has daily specials. We eat here occasionally but this was our first time this year. The cook was exceptional with nice hot food done right. Give this restaurant right near Lake Ontario and Krull Park a try. We think you'll be pleasantly surprised. We happen to have found out the owner has won awards for her own cooking; no wonder the food was so good! read more