The food was amazing the atmosphere was on point a nice little family restaurant the view was perfect Tori was our waitress and went above and beyond I would recommend 100 percent read more

Excellent home cooked meals! Very generous portions. Owners are on site and beautiful people.

The service here was outstanding. The owner's fiancée was so personable and gave our family the low down on how this place came to be and walked us through all the generations that came before them that had such an impact on how this place started. He was funny and indulged my older parents in all of their conversations and was so gracious with them. The food was good and there was a wide range of options. The specials held a lot of seafood options. We opted for two of the specials: walleye fried fish, 2 oyster baskets. We also got the pierogi dinner. All of the meals came with soup along with their sides. 3 of us got the seafood bisque and one got the galumpi soup, all of which were very good. The desserts were amazing!!! We got both the molasses and snickerdoodle cookies ($2 each), both the tres leches and raspberry cupcake ($2 each), orange chocolate cream pie ($7), apple crumb pie ($7), and salted caramel bar with nuts $7. It was a great spot for us to visit while on vacation. read more

See all

Avoid. Food was not good. Coleslaws cabbage was rotted, golumpke soup came out as a globby room temp sludge, burger was formed poorly and flavorless - came with 8 fries. Cod tasted fresh but breading was rock hard. Total for 3 burgers and 2 cod meals was $91+ tip (110 total, and food was not good. Waitress was nice. They also ran out of ketchup. read more

Goulompki soup and Polish beer worth the price of admission. I am not a fan of tomato base soups and I am also half polish both both the soup and beer were fantastic. read more

Valentines on the Lake - Goulompki soup and Polish beer!. I am not a fan of tomato base soups and I am also half polish both both the soup and beer were fantastic. - Polish Near Me - Olcott, New York

See all

This is a nice family friendly hole in the wall restaurant. If you want some down home good cooking, this is where to get it. From authentic and delish polish food, to other dinners made with love, and now some great new sandwich options. They always have good soups I want to grab to go too. I'm part Polish and was raised on food Polish food. Their pierogis are spot on and delicious...even some unique ones like buffalo chicken or chicken florentine. Last week I stopped with my son and had the more traditional farmers cheese pierogis. They were some of the best I ever had. Even better than what I grew up on. The lazy pierogis and sausage were equally delicious. It's solid, quality homemade food with love, and has a cozy feel. read more

See all

I will never eat pierogis again! There's no point...they wouldn't be this amazing! Completely made by hand, the pierogis are hot, crispy, melty goodness. John was so personable and funny, and the food was absolutely wonderful. According to John, "The entertainment usually starts in about 15 minutes." read more

See all

Great place to stop and eat while enjoying Olcott Beach/ Carousel Park. Staff was very nice and friendly. The food was good. Great selection of unique pierogi flavors. They had polish beers stocked along with the typical American staples. They close between 2pm-4pm to get ready for dinner service. read more

See all

Not a place I would go to again. They only had outdoor seating. You had to walk by the smelly dumpsters to get to the patio. We were seated near the dumpsters and had to move because the smell was so bad. The waitress was very nice. The soups were good. The Pierogis were dry, the pierogi salad was also dry. There were three of us and we each ordered a different kind. When served they were mixed up. They offered to get us the correct ones but since we didn't like them we decided not to get them. read more

We loved their food and the owners went out of their way to make our experience special.

Drove down there twice both times shows supposedly open only to find it closed,fathers day open till 7 pm closed by 6 I will never waist my time driving there again read more

Food in general was mediocre but I will say this the only thing worth eating was their homemade pierogis. Definitely a hole in the whole restaurant, small dark, and dirty. Service was super slow. The set up of the restaurant made no sense. While I was there I saw a lot their potential customers leave because of the confusion and slow service. Anyway, order their pierogi's to-go, don't eat there! read more

Hubby and I had dinner here a few weeks ago and the food was fabulous. Service was terrific too. It is owned by the chef and her mate. He takes care of the service and is really kind and attentive. The chef brought out her homemade banana cream pie to show the patrons and everyone wanted a slice! Presentation of the food is wonderful and we wished we could have eaten more. Doggie bags were a must. We can't wait to go back when the weather is nice enough to walk along the lake there. Great place to eat! read more

See all

What can I say Excellent food !! Delicious polish dinners home made pierogi and many other special dishes . They offer all you can eat spaghetti on Monday nights . They serve a huge portion of a turkey dinner . All home made .last but not least the delicious desserts . I just had a vanilla raspberry cake it was to die for !! They serve beer and wine also . Trust me you won't be disappointed. I took a picture of the polish taco and raspberry cake . I can't forget the staff is great . You won't be disappointed !! read more

See all

My family took me to "Valentine's" for Mother's Day Brunch as I work on Mother's Day. Who doesn't love a buffet?? Cinco De Mayo themed, ok?? Who doesn't love some "south of the border"?? Nacho bar was tortilla chips and a few condiments, cold sausage, burnt quesadilla's, grizzley pork and some item's I was not sure what they were and tasted like micro-wave food, and, my pet peeve, hot food that should be hot and not cold. Full disclosure, breakfast burrito was tasty, but 1/2 breakfast burrito cost $15.95, definitely not worth that as that was all I ate. I was embarrassed that my family paid for this terrible meal. That being said, our young waitress was very nice. I do believe in giving a business a chance, you had yours today. I'm sorry, poor quality does cut it. Maybe out of their wheel house and a Cinco De Mayo is not their genre and should stick to polish food. read more

Heard so much about this place. Both good and bad reviews. Came from a distance too try and the atmosphere was cute and cozy. The waitress is however very nice,was not very good. Forgot parts of our orders,requests for napkins,request too separate bill I could go on. Never came too refresh drinks and when we asked never got. The food was not good the steaks could not chew. I received my meal after everyone was done. My friends was so tough as well and not even asked how meal was,not asked about dessert. Only 4 other people there so I would expect better ‍. Very disappointed. Won't go back. Lazy Pierogis soup not like it should be read more

The food was absolutely amazing. So comforting and home cooked it was some of the best food i have eaten in a while. Bursting with flavor in every bite. From the golumpki stoup which was a thick delicious stew filled with amazing flavor to the homemade old fashioned pierogis which beat legit any store bought ones you can ever buy. I usually dislike pierogis cause the ones in the store are just bad but these were incredible. Perfectly crisp and fried filled with a delicious buttery and seasoned potato. Legit out of this world. Not only that but the two owners are some of the most nicest individuals i have ever encountered. They are so down to earth and kind and also gave us a whole container of homemade cookies for FREE! just because they're so sweet. Which also were very delicious and reminded me of when i would make cookies with my grandma as a kid. The restaurant is super cute inside and has cute little homey decorations and makes you understand where they come from and their values. Also the pricing is extremely cheap considering how high the quality and taste of food is. PLEASE TRY THIS PLACE YOU WILL NOT REGRET IT read more

Valentines on the Lake - Clams Casino Bake with stuffed cheese bread stick. LITERALLY F*cking AMAZING. Mouth watering. - Polish Near Me - Olcott, New York

See all

my dinner was so tough I couldn't eat it. Service was terrible and only 4 other people there at the time. Messaged them and they didn't care. No apologies for anything. spent over 150.00 for an awful meal and owner didn't care read more

The homemade food, cold polish beer and the warm, welcoming owners made this place a hidden gem! The food is phenomenal and all of it is home made by hand. A wonderful find when we were wandering America. John and his wife are both jovial and welcoming people but the pierogis are amazing - just as good as grandma made! You simply must stop by and visit Valentine's when you are in the area. read more

We love this place. The standard-bearing Polish fare is excellent and the chef's never-ending parade of specials are also outstanding. Nice atmosphere, clean, very friendly, and in an outstanding location. read more