Service is great, such A Great selection of whiskeys. Had the half lamb rack, so juicy and flavorful .the candid carrots was a great accompaniment. They have very comfortable chairs and I wish there was a bit more liveliness to the sports bar as there were tons of football games on that were not playing at that time. It's still pretty season.Maybe it'll change when regular season starts. I hope so , cause I'd like to come back again. read more

Oak Barrel of Eagle - Lamb and candied carrots - American Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

This is the worst! The waitress spilled my food on the table and then proceeded to put it back on my plate She said the table is clean. Then there was no offer of replacement food. Again, the worst ever! Can you imagine what must happen in the kitchen? So, so disappointed and disgusted. read more

The service was great. I mentioned that the steaks were slightly overcooked to the waitress, which 2 of the 4 were more than slightly overcooked, but not a big deal, just to let them know the steaks are coming out that way. Everyone at the table ordered medium. The owner came out and told us the steaks were not overcooked because they temp them. She acted like we didn't know what we were talking about, she looked at my daughter's steak and said there is a slight pink there that indicates medium, the rest of the 6 of us could not see any pink, mostly gray, should have taken a picture. My steak was drenched in sauce and tough, it was one of the very well-done steaks. If the owner can learn to take constructive criticism, they might be able to pull it together, hopefully they do. On the plus side, our waitress was awesome. read more

Great happy hour spot with good prices on beer and well drinks. I love the old style vibe in the bar area and multiple TV's playing sports and pool table and shuffleboard for entertainment. Unlike some other places in Eagle, they have a sign "Everyone welcome here" which I appreciate. The pork nachos were delicious even if portion a bit small. I recommend! read more

Oak Barrel of Eagle - Pork nachos - American Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

I visited the restaurant side on this trip, but would probably do the lounge side next time. Looks a little more lively and you can get the full menu sitting at the bar. Ordered a half order (8) of the meatballs and the Signature salad with chicken. Both were good. Always tough to fully judge a place just by appetizers or salads, but based on this experience I'd go back and try an entree. read more

Oak Barrel of Eagle - Meatballs - American Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

See all

5 stars for being dog friendly. They brought two water bowels to our table on the patio for our pups. Their patio is also on the shade said of the building so it was cool for dinner. Nice water feature next to the patio too. Waitress was attentive and friendly. Cocktail list is ok, nothing too fancy. Decent beer selection and wine list looked extensive. Salmon was hot and cooked well. Sauce was delicious. Had to try the "crispy fries" and they were good. Chicken sandwich was decent, nothing to write home about. Brussels sprouts were good. Would dine here again, especially with pups. read more

See all

This review is only for the lounge side; I did not visit or see the restaurant. The lounge has a nice, homey feel with warm wood tones, pool tables, plenty of seating and friendly service. Obviously you seat yourself. I was surprised to see it pretty empty for a Wednesday night, but it worked out to our favor since we had a large party of 20+ people. Happy hour prices and specials are not posted anywhere that I could find, but the bartenders happily listed them off (I can't recall them, but there's deals on beer, wine and well drinks only). I had a Blue moon on tap, with a glorious orange wedge. The beer was perfectly poured and had excellent flavor. I wasn't in the mood for the lounge fare, but luckily you can order from the full restaurant menu from the lounge. My friend and I opted to split the Signature Barrel burger.with cheddar cheese, bacon, brown mustard, onions, lettuce, tomatoes and a patty that is grilled to your liking (medium). We asked for a plate to split the burger ourselves, but the bartender was nice enough to put in the order as a split order without an additional charge. Our burger and fries were split and served on two different plates, which was greatly appreciated. The burger had a nice flavor though a tad under seasoned and a notch more than medium-didn't blow my socks off, but it's a solid burger. The fries were the star, as they were crunchy, yet pillowy soft inside, covered in a lovely batter. I wouldn't mind going again and trying out the restaurant side, it was a nice visit to the lounge. They only had one bartender for a large crowd and she hustled really hard to keep everyone happy...I just felt bad that she didn't have much help. read more

Oak Barrel of Eagle - Signature Barrel burger with cheddar cheese and fries - American Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

Great place to hang out! The service is also really really good, one time there was only one worker at the oak barrel and they were able to serve everyone in the bar efficiently and with lots of kindness! read more

haven't been here in years because my last experience was bad, but friends with a dog want to go since dogs are allowed. This restaurant is divided into two sides, the lounge and the dining room, which are separated by the kitchen. There were seven of us and we sat in the lounge area and ordered dinner. I have to say that all seven of us were extremely disappointed in our meals. I ordered the salmon, stuffed mushrooms and a cup of clam chowder. The salmon was dry and had zero flavor and no presentation when delivered. It was literally a white plate with the fish and a little sauce. Oh, and some onion and carrot shaving. No mashed potatoes, no veggies, just a small slab of fish. The stuffed mushrooms were undercooked and also lacked seasoning and flavor. The clam chowder wasn't any better. My wife ordered two tacos at $2.50 each, although the bill had one at $3.00. They were served on cheap store bought stale shells. The meat was horrible and there were hardly any toppings. Her chicken tortilla soup was a complete joke. It was a watered down broth, a couple of tomatoes and next to no chicken. I could go through everyone else's meal, but I think I've made my point. I don't like giving bad reviews on a restaurant, but I'm hoping the management will see this and make some needed changes before they run themselves out of business. The only positive thing was our waitress. Our group will never return. read more

We've eaten at Oak Barrel a few times and it's been I'm inconsistent but decent; around 3 stars. Tonight was terrible though. Chowder was bland, bread mealy and cold and entrees were overly rich. My wife's steak was ordered Medium Rare but served cooked through and gray in center. Roast potatoes super salty. Request for no butter on grilled shrimp was a challenge for server/kitchen. It's an ok place for a drink on the patio, but I would not recommend eating there. It's a crapshoot at best. Much better, more consistent, options nearby, read more

We would give it a 5-star review if the Guinness Cake wasn't so inconsistent. Too dry at least 40% of the time.

We had nice dinner a week ago. My 8 oz steak was very good and the Brussels sprouts also very good. The wine list is very short. They did not have several of the wines on the list. My husband ordered the steak med rare and shrimp. The shrimp were not that good and his steak was well done. The mushroom risotto was delicious. Our waitress said she would send over the owner but the chef came by instead. He was very kind. Gave us 1/2 off on my husband's meal and a free dessert. We really wanted to support this restaurant, so we came back with friends. I really don't what happened. My husband and I ordered the signature steak dinner med rare - made sure they understood we had a challenge last time. It took a long time. They brought both of our dinners out together. Mine was perfect and my husband's was vey well done. Our friends ordered the 8oz steak - rare. His came 20 minutes after the rest of our dinners arrived. Good thing we had 2 bottles of wine. Our friend's dinner finally arrived. It was not rare. Everyone was done eating and my husband's dinner had still not arrived. I told them just take it off the grill we need to go. So a little while later they gave it to us in a to go box. I did ask them to comp it. And after a while our waitress came back and had taken it off the bill. This restaurant has potential but they need some organizing. This dinner took 2 hours. One more thing they never brought the bread that came with our meal. I put the time into this review because I hope they get it together. read more

The signature burger with candied bacon is the best burger I've ever had. The shrimp scampi is always cooked to perfection. The French fries are so crunchy and delicious. We always enjoy the food and the great service at Oak Barrell. read more

We reserved a table for 13 weeks in advance, and upon arrival were ushered into a chilly room with a dirty tile carpet floor. We needed to rearrange the tables so that we were able to sit together. We asked the waitress for the room to be warmer and were advised that it was not possible.The tables were old and worn out, and the old chairs had stretchy red covers on which came off when sat on. The waitress was patient with us while we chatted but soon disapeared and we had to find her to place our orders. The food was tasty, but all of us who had soup, apart from one who ordered chowder found the soup to be luke warm. After a while, and I kid you not, many of us had runny noses it was so cold in there. I was rubbing my hands together to try and keep them warm. I don't understand why our reservation was accepted if there wasn't suitable accommodation for a larger party. I won't be going again, someone clearly couldn't care less. read more

Oak Barrel of Eagle - The litter on the floor. - American Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

I have gone to Oak Barrel multiple times, same with my husband and friends. We went the Saturday before Christmas and it was the busiest we've ever seen it, which was awesome! Atmosphere was good and welcoming, our server was nice but a bit absent-minded and had to come to our table multiple times to check that the order was correct. My drink was incredibly expensive with only two ingredients- versus some of their speciality cocktails had tons of things and were cheaper...bit odd but okay. Our (four of us) biggest issue was the food itself. The bruschetta was amazing and the meatballs were decent. My salmon was fine and friends' steaks met with their approval. My husband's steak, not so much. He asked for a rare to medium-rare steak - we got a medium to almost well done steak. He told our waitress and she said if he wanted they could redo it, but he was the last served. So he told her no, he didn't want to make the kitchen have to redo it (with how busy the night was) and make the rest of the table wait. Not entirely sure we will be back unfortunately. Edit update due to comment response: Thank you for the comment! We did enjoy our time for the most part for sure! To answer a comment - the check was not adjusted. read more

We went for an anniversary dinner. The staff was attentive but we were very underwhelmed by the meal. The restaurant could use a refurbish as well. read more

Food is always good and consistent. Staff is friendly and nice! We've eaten many times here and yes we recommend. read more

Been here many times, food, fantastic, ambience, cozy, and relaxing, makes you feel like you wanna stay for a while. Service is wonderful.

Very nice place to meet up with friends for drinks, apps or dinner, they have pool tables in the lounge. Has a hometown feel, and the drinks are great make it a point to check it out. read more

Great food and service. You can tell they don't cut corners in the kitchen. I had the signature burger today for lunch and it was outstanding read more

We stopped in on Sat. it wasn't crowded and it was so relaxing, I ordered Veggie Soup with bread, but my friend had Salmon, she said it was so good, and I loved my Soup. We will be back! read more

Service was great food delicious I order chicken Alfredo with added mushrooms so yummy it was cold outside but as soon as we walked in there was a cozy gas fireplace going which took the chill off. We will be going back read more

If you like lemon drops you should have Kaitlyn make one for you. Even the happy hour well vodka lemon drop is on the top of my list

Went to the lounge on Valentine's Day. Not what I was expecting from a lounge. Kids running around the pool table area and a dog on a leash next to me at the bar. Server was nice, meatballs were cold. read more

Courteous and friendly staff. Mushroom appetizer was very good. Had steak and mushroom risotto dinner. read more

Oak Barrel of Eagle - IPA - American Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

We stopped here for an early dinner on Saturday. The staff was friendly and welcoming on a chilly afternoon! We started with Pinot Noir which was excellent, and bread, which was pretty good. My husband loved the pork chop and the potatoes! I got the chicken and risotto. The chicken thigh was very good as was the risotto but unfortunately the chicken breast was pounded thin and was dry. Overall, it was a good experience although I hope they improve the timing on cooking the chicken. I am sure we will be going back! read more

Oak Barrel of Eagle - American Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

See all

Went in on the bar side a few weeks ago, with a friend just for a drink. I'm telling you, THE SERVICE. The people who run that place are STELLAR. Amazing hors d'ouevres. I had the mushrooms and I think I dreamed about them for a week. Drink was just right. I will be going back...Taking a friend to dinner. In fact I've taken her there before. We're both particular. Totally friendly vibe, with excellent food and service. THEY SHOULD GIVE LESSONS. read more

Oak Barrel has great food and great ambiance. We take our friends there because they like the gluten free options! Our meals are always spectacular! read more

The food is good, service has always been great every time we have been at Oak Barrel. Love that they have a dining side and the bar side. We will continue to frequent Oak Barrel. read more

Lovely place. Too expensive for what you get. No happy hour, even though it says so on the websites.

First time. Meatball appetizer, bruschetta, signature salad and for desert, bananas foster. All dishes were superb. We will be back to try their other dishes. Bruschetta has home made crostini's, very delicate and crunchy. read more

Service, atmosphere and food were incredible. We sat out on the patio overlooking the creek. It was gorgeous. Loved the homemade dressing and. I had the Oak barrel special salad with cilantro, lemon dressing. Their dressings are homemade and the vegetables were extremely fresh. My husband had the salmon and a side salad with broccoli. It was extremely good. read more

Best server ever, Richie thank you! Visiting from out of state, having happy hour with my sister for her birthday. The blueberry bread pudding was delightful! The chocolate martini was the best I've had in a while. Great experience. read more

Oak Barrel of Eagle - Blueberry Bread Pudding. - American Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

Love this place! My husband and I took our two young children here on a whim last Saturday night after seeing they do Gluten Free options, but it was far better than we expected. Staff was friendly and attentive. The atmosphere was pretty and the booth seats were comfortable. Our Server knew all of the gluten free options as well as other allergy information and was very patient and helpful to us as we questioned her about the menu trying to decide. They have gluten free pasta options, hamburgers bun options and gluten free marinaded steaks. Even gluten free options on the charcuterie appetizer. We all loved our meals. And the food came before we even finished our appetizers. Menus were updated last month so I took photos of it. We will definitely be back. read more

See all

Very disappointed. Overly priced for mediocre food. Waitress unaware of happy hour prices and menu. Waitress sat with friend/family member our entire visit in patio area. Once bill received nothing we ordered was happy hour pricing other than margarita. We asked waitress several questions of happy hour which she was unaware. We paid same amount at yard house and received so much fabulous food along with 2 drinks per adult with lots of appetizers and still spent more money here. The patio area was nice and drinks were delicious. Ambiance outside was great, however we will not return. read more

Ordered takeout tonight for the first time. Had pork chop and shrimp scampi. Food was excellent, pickup was quick and easy. Haven't been able to dine out in a while due to illness. So wonderful to have a great dinner! read more

Very delicious and also accommodating to special food needs. The patio is a delightful place in the afternoon, along with one of their cocktails. read more

Something nice you may have missed. Oak Barrel of Eagle is an unassuming bar and restaurant. Everyone knows how difficult it is to put up Christmas lights when the peaks on your house are 50 feet tall with a 6 foot ladder. Jim, what's does this have to do with Oak Barrel? Good question. After my friend came over and helped me put 'em up rather than pay $400 dollars for some goof ball the hang my lights up for me. I told him I would take them to dinner for the help. So much a better deal, right? Anyway, we chose Oak Barrel of Eagle, and were not disappointed. It's a bit hidden from Downtown, and if your drive too fast on 44, you may miss it. We had a 7PM reservation and came early to also try the bar. In the bar, (different hours BTW) Barrel has a nice selection of beers on tap, and a good wine selection. The guys had a beer while the ladies took on some prettier drinks. That said, we had a nice time in the comfy leather seats, many TV's, and pleasant help while waiting for our table at 7. It was ready, but we wanted to do the bar first. At 7 we wandered through the hall over to the restaurant. It's a nice room with many booths, another small bar, and some tables. We were given a booth and had a spirited young waitress. We enjoyed giving her a little bit of a hard time as we sat down. A good sport was she, and she dished it back in good spirit. We were all laughing in short order. She went over the specials, which sounded good (Filet and Cajun shrimp), and the night's soup. We all went for a steak of some kind. Mine was the menu Filet, wife has the special, and friend had the New York cut. All very good. The menu Filet comes with a wine sauce and herbed butter and salad. All were just perfect. They also get top marks for glassware. I don't think you could have bad glass of wine in the wonderful glasses they serve you with. I had the house Cabernet, it was quite good and at a good price. The whole evening was a success. We all enjoyed our meals and the top notch service. Who can ask for more? You can! All you have to do is stop in. You will be pleased I'm sure. Lunch is also quite good, I have had lunch there a few times with a similar experience. Happy eating! Final thoughts: Recommended Added touches that would be nice? Table clothes. read more

Oak Barrel of Eagle - a closeup of the label - American Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

What a pleasant surprise! I stopped in at the Oak Barrel late afternoon. It was a cool oasis on a hot day. I tried their Paloma which was made with some fresh mint. It was delicious! Their Salmon Ciabatta Sandwich was also very tasty. The sandwich had a generous portion of nicely cooked salmon that was perfectly seasoned. I chose a side of fries that were also delicious. Anthony recommended the Guinness Chocolate Cake for dessert. The cake was not overly sweet and was served with vanilla ice cream. I couldn't have asked for better service. Anthony took great care of me - he checked back with me to ensure I was enjoying everything. Kudos to the Oak Barrel of Eagle for a great experience! read more

See all

My husband and I arrived at 430 on 4/26/25, and requested that we not be seated at a tall table or a booth because my husband is a disabled vet and his knees won't allow him to sit in those table types. We told the staff doing the seating of the issue and asked for a low table (there were low tables in the bar area.and only two customers in the whole place) the seater declined to sit us there because those tables were for employees and turned us away. Discrimination against the disabled, not good. We won't be back again. read more