When I was living in Navarre Beach this is the pizza spot we enjoyed. There isn't many restaurants in the Navarre area & this is one of the better ones. It's not really NY pizza but it's pretty good. Better than Hungry Howie's. Love the supreme hand tossed. Recommend. read more

NYPD Express - Supreme. New York Tossed style. - Pizza Near Me - Navarre, Florida

Great pizza very much taste like NY pizza, great crust and hand tossed. Nice environment and great service. Very reasonable prices . You can get by slice, wow like NY slices are prices. read more

See all

We tried the garlic knots, Bianca pie and and the NYPD club. The club pizza is delicious. The Bianca pie was very dry. I've had pizzas without a sauce base from a number of places and this was the only time I've said it was dry. The flavor wasn't bad though. The garlic knots were dry as well. A dry, flavorless piece of bread. I may give them another shot next time I'm in Navarre but first impression I could've gone elsewhere. read more

The pizza. Was divine. Superb. The gf option was spot on and since having to do the gf thing, this pizza hit it out of the ballpark. Most of the time I'm all "gimme the box! That tastes better than this nonsense!" But not with NYPD! Will order from them next time we're there! read more

Gooey cheesy hand tossed right in front of you. Doesn't get any better than that. Salad was also fresh. Pick up line was crazy as everyone was ordering to go. Service was good. read more

NYPD Express - Pizza Near Me - Navarre, Florida

This use to be the New York Pizza Depot but they moved and changed their name. Still great pizza. It's New York style pizza. Nice crispy crust with plenty of flavor while not being greasy. read more

See all

Last time we ate here was during the day, not crowded and pretty good. This time it was night so it was busy and seemed short handed. Salad was a little sad, cheese steak was a good portion but too salty. The waitress was very kind and amicable, if stretched a bit thin. She took off our salad and apologized for the issues we had, including the 45 minute wait for our food. read more

NYPD Express - They cooked the basil WITH the pizza... - Pizza Near Me - Navarre, Florida

See all

After a long day of travel my kids wanted pizza and I wanted easy so what did I do? Go to Yelp to find an amazing pizza place nearby. This spot did not disappoint! I ordered online as the phone number listed on Yelp wasn't correct so I went to their website and was able to order that way. I was a little disappointed that the pizza I was really interested in for myself wasn't available but oh well. I ordered some garlic knots, half deluxe half meats as well as a Greek pie. Can't do without the sauces so I made sure to order some garlic butter and some tzatziki sauce. Online it was showing like it could be 75 minutes until my order was ready but we went ahead and left just in case it didn't take that long. It was a short 15 minute drive and we waited just a few more minutes and I got a notification that my order was ready. The inside of the Resturant is such a cool place! You can watch them tossing the pizza dough right in front. There are several tables and high tops to sit at. It was full when I went in and was quite loud so I was glad I did carry out. I got my pizzas and was on my way back in a matter of minutes. The pizzas were amazing. The garlic knots? Wow. I don't know if it was from the long travel day or if they were really that amazing but I'd definitely get those every time! It was like a cinnamon roll without the cinnamon and slathered in garlic butter and Parmesan salty goodness! So so good! Highly recommend the garlic butter dipping sauce also. Probably the best I've had. Overall a really great experience for our first meal at Navarre beach! If pizza isn't your thing they also offer several salads, calzones, stroms, pastas and sides that I'm sure are equally as good! read more

See all

A major improvement from the old location. I had the Stromboli which was huge and delicious. The server was attentive and even gave us a free dessert for a unusual wait for our food. read more

This Pizza place has excellent and delish food and really great employees, As for ambiance it is awesome

Place is super cute. Staff looked friendly! Waitress was fantastic but the fly problem is disgusting. Couldn't eat the pizza there because of how many times my date and I had to swat flies. At one point there was five flies sitting with us at the booth! The cheese sticks 10/10 as well as the pizza. Just get it to go! The atmosphere could be so nice if they got an exterminator asap! read more

NYPD Express - Fly - Pizza Near Me - Navarre, Florida

We ordered carry out online because apparently the majority of people in Florida don't know there's a pandemic going on. No masks worn by employees or patrons, and zero attempt at social distancing customers is being made. Pizza took 40 minutes longer than quoted and the pizza was just alright. read more

Our favorite pizza around. We got our take-out order quick and enjoyed it at the picnic tables at the beach. The new space is beautiful and look forward to enjoying dining in one day. We ordered a classic cheese pizza, which was delicious. The crust/dough is particularly tasty. We also love their dessert - fried dough with powered sugar and raspberry sauce - yum, yum, yum! read more

Pizza was good & NY style. Got Take out and they sent a text when it was ready. We all enjoyed the pizza. I like the single topping pizza better than the margherita pizza. It's a good place read more

Great menu, great service, and my kids love drawing on the paper tablecloth. We go every week!

First time ordering from here. During the quarantine of 2020. Drove from Gulf Breeze for the food. The mrs. wanted a margarita pie and they have them. She said it was the best margarita pizza she has every had (14"). I got the deluxe (10") with extra sausage and extra onion... I think next time I'll ask for quadruple sausage & onion. Tasted great non-the-less. Very fresh toppings. Also git 4 garlic knots she had 3 of them, so them must have been good as well. read more

See all

They can be a great place to dine but can also be horrid. Who ever heard of putting blue cheese dressing on a gyro sandwich. Uggh.

TLDR: wait times are increasing and pizza quality is decreasing, especially after the transition to depot/district. We have frequently eaten/ordered take-out/delivery from NYPD over the last two years. We were really hoping that the opening of the district would improve the speed of delivery from NYPD. We completely understand waiting an hour or so on busy nights for pizza... but when the restaurants sole purpose is now only delivery and it now takes over an hour and a half for pizza that arrives to the house stone cold and you only live two blocks from the store? Things need to change! Not worth driving down to the new location for pick up when their estimated time for pick up isn't accurate either. We will no longer be patronizing NYPD. read more

One of my favorite pizza joints. Always hits the spot. My go to pizza is usually the meat lovers. I like that the meats are not chunky. Toppings are always plentiful and they never short you on the cheese which is a biggie for me. Tonight I also was in the mood for the a white sauce pizza and went for the Bianca, added chicken and bacon. It's a ricotta base which is not really my thing but overall satisfying. Next time I will try the Alfredo specialty pizza. Oh and I love the new location which has a spacious dine in. If you're looking to do takeout you're better off picking it up yourself as they stay busy and delivery time can be 1.5-2 hours. read more

NYPD Express - Bianca add chicken and bacon - Pizza Near Me - Navarre, Florida

See all

We have been here many times. In fact i started going here when they were in their old location. Well today was just a bad experience. I The hostess was so rude it made me angry every time she walked past me. She did not smile at us and greet us when we walked in. I told here there were 3 of us. She got the menus and silverware and walked to a table very quickly and put them down without looking at us. My granddaughter was at the table my daughter and i were not there yet. She walked away without a word. I thought maybe it was just the way she was but i watched her her smile and speak to others. I promise is looks could kill we would have been gone. There are only 2 reasons she could have acted that way to us. Hopefully i am wrong but it was really bad. The good was great as always and out waitress was great but it only takes 1 person to ruin your visit. If i visit again and she is the hostess i will turn right back around. Good luck with that little girl working for you. She is gonna be ride to the wrong person one day. read more

Very disappointing! Called to ask about specials and was told the 2 for $22 was available dine in or carry out. Get dressed go in, sit down to be told it's carry out only. Ok so we will place a to go order. Go to register...can we get the 2 for $22. Ok you want the $24.95 family pack? NO WE WANT THE 2 for $22. Ok your total is $29.95 UH?? So the pizzas are $22 but the total is $29.95? Yes tax! Ummm tax isn't that much. Well with tax that what it comes to. She gets manager...Manger says oh our prices have gone up. But the advertised deal is 2 for $22. Oh well the prices in our computer are correct. Our prices went up! After being told we could dine, the waitress telling us the 2 for $22 was the special and the chick at the register...no one here has a clue. Manger was two busy to even care. Extremely poor customer service! And manger could careless and is part of the problem!! We should have made the drive to Pensacola to go to Sky's pizza!! I don't care how good the pizza is bad customer service always leaves a bad taste in my mouth! Won't be back! read more

We ordered delivery tonight after a hectic day. I was chasing my toddler around and was surprised to hear the door bell ring so quickly after I placed our online order and BOOM our dinner was here! Even with the rain outside that took no time at all. I was trying to keep my daughter from bolting out the door and the man delivering the pizza was so kind and helpful. We had the deluxe pizza, salad, and a gyro tonight. Everything was absolutely wonderful! Thank you so much for dinner and for your polite staff. We will definitely be back. read more

Very Good Pizza and very good garlic knots and fried ravioli. Only negative thing is no more fried z Update 10/07/19: We visited Navarre one year after this original post. Pizza was amazing! read more

We are new to the area and were looking for a new pizza place. We came across NYPD and haven't looked back (or looked any farther for pizza). Garlic knots are hot and buttery. The wings are done to perfection every time. The pizza always has just the right amount of "crunch" to the crust. The marinara has a warm, red wine note to it. The only reason NYPD doesn't get 5 stars is because I'm saving my 5 star review for, well I'm not sure, but I'll know it when I eat it! But eat at NYPD, it's consistently good and the staff is friendly. read more

Giving 3 starts but food was a 10 very tasty. Staff is young and some look to be in training still but very friendly over all. Decided to try this place we went during lunch in Dec 2020. Our server wore a mask but as I looked around while eating noticed some of the staff didn't hence the 3 Stars. Food was amazing loved the garlic knots and the Marinara sauce we were told along with the breads it was made in house wasn't sweet nor acid tasting like most marinara sauces. Not many patrons so our food was served fast. Will have to try meat lovers pizza in the future. read more

Had lunch here on a Saturday an it was great! We got sum pizza an bread. Service was good an fast. Will eat here again!

Fresh from Stone oven! Don't let their location fool you, this place has Awesome Pizza and Awesome lunch specials daily! Monday kids Eat Free Tuesday is 2 for 2 available , dine in, Take out, Delivery 1 free 14 or 18 Cheese pizza with purchase of a speciality or 3 Topping of Same size ! Fantastic value especially being it's our favorite pizza New York Style with being fresh made on Stone Oven. Appetizers a huge list. Calzones Pizza Rolls. Stromboli Pasta Chicken parmigiana Fettuccini Alfredo List of Salads Plus more! Very affordable for families! If you are in Navarre just take a trip across the street from Publix. They are located across street! read more

NYPD Express - NEW YORK PIZZA STONE OVEN THE BEST MENU AND PIZZA AROUND - Pizza Near Me - Navarre, Florida

See all

Ordered pizza and garlic knots at 5pm on a Saturday for delivery. The driver arrived around 640pm with freezing cold food. The margarita pizza we ordered didnt really have any flavor and the garlic knots hardly had any garlic. Overall disappointed. read more

NYPD Express - Margarita pizza, delivered cold and little flavor. Disappointed. - Pizza Near Me - Navarre, Florida

Best pizza we have had in a long time, crust was crisp, lots of toppings and the sauce was very good. Garlic knots were delicious also, we ordered them twice! Cool atmosphere inside. read more

Their location across from Publix has always been really great. The new location in harvest village has not been the same. We have had pizzas for times from there now. Each time they were way under cooked. The Dough was white and gooey on the bottom. Not cool. read more

Great pizza but I also love the garlic knots. Excellent service too. To bad they don't deliver to Mary Esther, but the short drive is worth it. read more

People in Navarre are either NYPD people or Sals people. We're NYPD fans. Great pie and really friendly staff. Get the garlic knots!!

Polite staff. Perfectly cooked crust. Great sauce and cheese ratio. Great presentation as well. Over all excellent pizza. read more

NYPD Express - Personal 10inch pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Navarre, Florida

I love this place. It's all good but my favorite is their Alfredo. Definitely the best pizza I've had since moving down here.

This pizza was awesome!!!!!! Seriously excellent. And this was during covid. Highly recommend if you like NY style pizza. Fresh ingredients, just awesome all around. read more

We had the half cheese and half deluxe hand tossed pizza, small garden salad and chicken wings. It was all delicious!! The freshness of the vegetables was obvious and the pepperoni/meat on it was very good. The service was great and with a smile, she kept our glasses full with our water and soda. The people were all nice and really excited to have our business. The location is easy in and out if you want they deliver, we are here only for a week but we will go back. read more

NYPD Express - Pizza Near Me - Navarre, Florida

While staying in Navarre we ordered pizza from here and we all enjoyed! The pizzas were hot and delicious. We ordered the meat lovers pizza and the Bianca pizza. Along with that, we had some wings and a house salad. Everything was great! It was a Saturday night so the delivery took a little over an hour, which we anticipated. The delivery driver was very friendly and brought the pizza right to our condo. If we are staying in the area again, I would definitely order from here or go in for a sit down meal! read more

Best pizza in Navarre!!!!! Delivery was in 20mins, couldn't have picked a better pizza place read more

NYPD Express - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Navarre, Florida

See all

We rolled into town after 3 days of driving, set up camp, and went looking for pizza. We landed here and ordered garlic knots (really good) and a Margarita pizza and an Alfredo pizza. The Margarita pizza was excellent and the Alfredo was pretty strong. Service was okay, our waiter must have been distracted with some personal things because he kept forgetting things. Overall it was good pizza, but will order out if we return. read more

Pizza is descent but I've always found it to be a hassle every time I visit Navarre, always some basic customer service fumble. This time they moved and didn't bother telling anyone who called in for pick up that they moved and they didn't bother changing their address on Google maps or Yelp. They just scrawled a sign on the door at the old location. So when I got there, there were literally four other families either picking up for wanting to dine in that went to the old address. When I called them again, they said they were still "working out the kinks" at the new location. Basically sounded like it was my problem, not his. Dude, you're a pizza joint in a tourist town. Half the people you serve don't know where you are and look you up online. your address is literally the one thing you have to get right. Pizza is okay, though. But the price just isn't worth the "kinks" anymore. read more