I've been here a couple times now and I've gotta say, it's a great spot. Calzones are solid and…read morevery ample in proportion (as other reviews have mentioned). I ordered a white pizza with Italian sausage for my last visit. Very nice crust, was cooked well through, and the sausage worked perfectly on the white pie (in my opinion). If I put on my Portnoy hat, the pie was a *bit* on the greasy side and didn't really have a great shelf, but the flavor more than made up for it. The staff I interacted with were super friendly and welcoming, the restaurant's a good vibe as well, and pricing is more than reasonable. Will be back!

The cashier taking my order was really nice. Funky vibe inside…read more Wasn't sure of the size of the garlic knots so I ordered a large. Full sized knots and then some. We ate those for days. Decided to get slices since it was my first time, probably would have been better off getting the whole pie itself due to the prices of the toppings. Overall good pizza. Wouldn't be upset eating from here again.

The customer service is always amazing. My family and I have been there a couple times and we love…read moreit, even when it is busy they are very nice. The place is clean and nice. We went when it was pie day and even then they were so nice and the food was amazing. The pizza taste so delicious. I definitely recommend this to everyone. food 5/5 service 5/5 location 4/5 indoor seating 5/5 outdoor seating 3/5 ( it depends where you seat because there are some smokers and then the wind

Great pizza! Out of the ordinary, but the dill pickle pizza is ‍. Highly recommend if in West…read moreAthens.

Pizzas were good, service was quick and kind. The inside is a bit small, only 4 seater tables…read more Crusts were not thin but not super thick either. I'll be returning to try more pizzas.

Fix the drink machine ! food was good air conditioning wasn't working well. Overall ok experience.read more

Like most college towns (I suppose), Athens maxes out the quantity on pizza choices, but the…read morequality often lags behind. That's been true for as long as I can remember, because I grew up here and I'm pretty damn old. Automatic Pizza has to be on the high end of the Athens pizza quality scale, though. Enough so that, as I explain in most recent Yelp review I wrote, we'd drive halfway across Athens to pick up a pizza from here even though there was a neighborhood pizza joint just up our old street. Housed in an old corner gas station that has since served time as the Black Forest Bake Shop, among other things, Automatic goes for the New York style and does it better than most places outside of New York and the Northeast do it. Good sturdy, flavorful crust with zesty sauce, the large size (18 inches) is massive clown-shoe pizza that is totally foldable, the way I want to eat this style of pizza. The staff has always been friendly, too. Parking is a bit of an annoyance. There are like three parking spots, and the cross-streets don't have much in the way of street parking. Four-stars-plus.

The food is phenomenal and speaks for itself. Their subs are made with fresh ingredients and more…read morethan a meal for anyone. And the pizza is heavenly. But.....their staff that I have encountered the last two days are the man reason I will remain loyal to them. The personableness and kindness I received the entire time I was there is what is missing in a lot of the world these days. They are two blocks from the hospital and I was going to stay the night with my grandmother. Both took the time to ask about her, talk about my situation, and make sure I felt like a friend before I left. I didn't place an order and wait for it to be handed to me. I was talked through a menu I was unfamiliar with. And I was treated like a human being. Can not wait to return.

THE BEST pizza in Athens ! Great crusts -…read moreloaded with ingredients Good sandwiches Always helpful personnel Free parking Outdoor tables

We were looking for pizza and glad we stopped in. This is an old school walk up and order kind of…read moreplace. Tons of pizzas and sandwiches and pastas to choose from. We got the Peppinos special - it had a lot of toppings and was really tasty. We also got at Stromboli which had a good amount of cheese. The salad is a little bar where you help yourself...I loved the crunchy bacon bits - definitely nostalgic ! I heard someone order a pitcher of beer - we just had fountain drinks but that is a great add if you're looking for pizza and beer! The food was ready very quick after we ordered and there were a lot of tables to choose from To sit and you can move tables around if you have a lot of people. The restaurant is set up like an older cafe - and really just felt comfortable. Highly recommend if you're looking for a pizza place in Athens!

Loved this place. Order your pizza for the buffet and take whatever you want, the concept works…read more The pizza was great. I also had a salad, which was really tasty. When I'm in Athens, I'll be back.

Went here on a recommendation of the pizza bar. Walk in and the place is definitely old school…read morepizza restaurant. Our server asked if there were any pizzas we wanted on the buffet. Our niece wanted the Hawaiian and we asked for Philly cheese. The first trip to the buffet tried the pepperoni and cheese. Both thin slice and good. Our two requested pizzas were then put on the buffet. The Hawaiian was good and the Philly cheese did not have green peppers. It was ok. The garlic knots are good. Our server was very nice and checked in throughout the meal.

I was hoping for a quick slice and a beer after a long flight and shuttle trip. I was NOT…read moredisappointed! I ordered one Sicilian and one Neapolitan slide and a draft Miller Lite while I watched the World Cup. Fast friendly service and two HUGE delicious slices! Fresh mushroom too. The vibe is true pizza joint and it delivers with good food, friendly service and plenty of space to enjoy.

In terms of value/price + convenience this is 4-5 stars, but in terms of actual flavor of the…read morepizza, a solid "3" ("Good" in my book). Old school booth dining, fast service, pay at the counter before you sit. Friendly crew working, prepping the pizza right in front of you. Buy it by the slice, thin or thick crust--I got a slice of each, very filling (esp that thick crust). $2 draft beer including craft--this is a beer/drinking/college town for sure, it seems. If I were 20 years younger in college I'd be a regular, as a tourist this was cool for a cheap quick dinner before a concert.

I have been several times and service and food is always good? Love the pizza. The food is a great…read morevalue for what you get.

Don't waste your time, effort, or money. We placed a pick up order, and I waited in the restaurant…read more45 minutes after the pickup time for the food to come out. The staff was nice, but the best they could do was tell me it would be another 15 minutes. Three times. I finally walked out without my food. It was game day in Athens, so I get that's it busier than usual, but come on. Pathetic