may 27, 2026 our large peperoni and mushroom pizza was burnt. did a pick up order after work got home opened it and it was black around the edges and th bottom. tried to reach a manager and was left on hold, spent 28 dollars and tip for inedible pizza. read more

The pizza is around the same quality as you'd find in a mall food court, but is priced as if it's a sit-down restaurant with table service.

When you judge a pizza, you really have to base it on a "whole pie" and not just a "slice". I've been here three times and ordered a couple of slices two times and a whole pizza the last time. The first time the slices were heated up great and the second, not so much (too burnt). The last time I ordered a whole pizza and loved it! I will definitely be back for a forth time!!! read more

The pizza was perfect. Perfect toppings. Perfect crust. Perfect sauce. Delicious. The only off putting thing was the art. Otherwise amazing. read more

Killer Crust Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Georgia

Incredibly fresh pizza! The place was small but perfect for a small family. We were served well by the waitresses! We will definitely return! I recommend this place if you love pizza like my family and I do. read more

Killer Crust is a really cute spot for a quick lunch with lots of fun pop culture art on the wall. The white pizza is pretty good. The problem is that the crust, contrary to the name, isn't killer. Ideally, pizza crust should be crispy outside yet fluffy inside. This crust has a uniformly dense texture that is more like a cracker. read more

See all

Spotted it during the grand opening. I like the location and the pizza is really good. Cheese pulls are an A++ and the slices are a very good price for what you are getting! Single cheese slices are only 4 dollars btw! read more

See all

Their pizza is good. I particularly like that you can purchase by the slice, and ask for it to be lightly baked -- no burnt crust. Also, when I visited, the restaurant was super clean and orderly (including the bathroom). Finally, they were playing good 70's music. Nice vibe! read more

We ordered online and it was quick service and the staff was nice and the food was seasoned and cooked well! The service was quick but did not sacrifice in flavor or quality of the pizza! Drove about 15 minutes home and our pizza was still hot and crunchy. Only complaint is they are light with marinara sauce! But so far one of the best pizza places I have been able to find in Georgia !! The restaurant was clean and seemed well maintained, decorations were fun and modern. read more

Killer Crust Pizza - Custom small pizza! Red sauce, cheese, Feta cheese, garlic, and pesto well done - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Georgia

See all

Let's talk positives first. The staff was friendly and helpful. The pizza looked good and the flavor was good. Now the not so positive, if your name is Killer Crust, then you need to make sure you have a killer crust. The crust on our slices was soggy in several places and then when you got to the top of the slice, it was very hard. Another thing to note is the restaurant is very small. We will likely try this place again. read more

I have eaten here before and it was delicious. Picked up a pie on my way home last night and the crust was burned on the bottom. Very disappointed. read more

This place has some of the best pizza in the area. It stands out from the big pizza companies because the ingredients are a notch above.

We tried this place for the 1st time today. oh...my...goodness!!! So good!! We got the chicken and waffles pizza. The crust was amazing. So crisp. We would get this again but can't wait to try the other flavors as well. The owner, Justin, was there and was so nice. The restaurant is clean and pretty neat. If you like pizza you need to visit here!! read more

Pretty expensive for what you get. Greasiest pizza of my life and there was no killer crust going on ... was told 30-35 mins on pickup so I waited and shouldn't have, pizza was cold. Local customers. We MIGHT give in another try ... one day read more

Best pizza I've had outside of Chicago and it's still close! Very courteous staff and clean place. The only downside is limited seating. Keep up the good work. read more

Service was great as well as the pizza only thing we recommend is adding some type of spice sauce for those who love to dip their pizza in something spicy but other than that we loved it and will definitely be going again to try more of their pizza read more

Killer Crust Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Georgia

See all

Came for a quick lunch. Pizza was so good! The service was amazing. Definitely recommend there lunch combos! read more

Killer Crust Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Georgia

Good pizza flavor choices, quick despite being busy, good atmosphere,, and great service

Awesome pizza. Very friendly staff. Pizza was loaded with toppings and the crust is perfect. We will be back for sure. read more

Killer Crust Pizza - Meat pizza - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Georgia

Been wanting to try this place since it opened. We were so excited to try it today and boy were we disappointed. With just one other group of people in the restaurant we waited 25-30 min for 2 small pizzas. Paid $45!!!!! And it wasn't even that good. Greasiest pizza I've ever head in my life. Literally dumped grease into the ranch when I went to dip. Crust was not intact killer. I've had better pizza from the QT. Definitely would not recommend. read more

Service! Boy who doesn't value his job. Dirty! Food put on counters where unloading dirty dishes next to it. One was over cooked. Crust taste like frozen pizza. Fully loaded or Ted's if you're looking for quality pizza! read more

Excellent pizza with plenty of toppings and great crust. The staff was nice and helpful. The salad was good but the dressing was nothing special. Highly recommend! read more

Best pizza in Athens Georgia, the service is top notch and the decorations are beautiful.

The name says it all. I had a wonderful experience all around. The pizza was amazing. The owner was top tier and the vibe of the entire place was on point. I just moved to the area and this visit was one of many to come. 10/10 read more

When ordering online be sure to actually select which toppings you want. for instance.. if you see the menu item that says 'calzone', it is NOT already complete with toppings inside. You need to check all toppings you like. I saw calzone, and said, cool! I want to add the topping of banana peppers. Nope.. I know I have a part in this, but I think it should be stated somewhere on their menu that you will need to select all the things you want in it. I don't have anything else negative to say about this place. they were extremely welcoming, it was clean, the cooks were busy and kind, and the pizza my mom got was amazing. I however, did not enjoy my bread, cheese, and banana pepper calzone. I was expecting a calzone in its entirety for $11. unfortunate that all toppings add $1.50, so an $11 calzone can easily turn into well over $20. I'm partly the problem, but wanted to make sure no one else makes the same mistake. great addition to Oconee area! read more