If I could review this with less stars... Located on the corner of Blissfully Unaware Ave and Zero Standards Dr Billed as thin crust, its actually under cooked, under proofed, and doughy. When you open the box you expect browned, cooked pizza. You get white, undercooked, flour covered dough. The flavor of the sauce and toppings are actually good but are masked by the sad state of preparation and the obvious fear of burning the food. The hallmarks of poor training. Wings are not crispy as advertised. While the meat was cooked correctly, the skin is nothing short of rubber. Your Pie will be another short lived endeavor. read more

Very good pizza. Love the crust! The service was excellent and the place is nice and clean. A great place to enjoy great pizza!

Hot honey pepperoni was delicious!! The crust is perfect! Would definitely recommend.

Absolutely amazing! This was my first Your Pie experience and definitely left a great impression! Food was absolutely delicious! The pizza was cooked just right and ingredients tasted fresh! Service was very friendly! Overall pretty chill atmosphere! Definitely recommend! read more

Your Pie Pizza - GREAT WHITE w/ Spinach and HOT HONEY PEPPERONI - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, Georgia

Came in to get pizza with my sister tonight. The pizza was good, the same as any location. The staff was not the most friendly but they weren't rude of course. They just kind of seemed to be in their own world a little bit and seemed a little confused when ringing up the order. I always order the kids pizza because I the full size is too much. Most places don't like when you order from the kids menu but I have never had a problem ordering a kids pizza at any location. I even worked at another location in college and we were told it's fine. Lots of adults would get the kids size, sooo yeah I still always order that! They do still give you a gelato cup with it as well, but I usually don't take it because I don't love ice cream or gelato in general (except a few flavors at certain places). Birthday cake gelato is one of the ones I actually love. They had it tonight so I had to get some! 10/10 recommend if you haven't tried it! This location is in downtown Monroe. There's parking along the street or public parking lots right down the street. read more

See all

This is the best pizza I've had in years. Great people, better food. Grand ambiance with lovely lighting.

I ordered a Greek Salad from Your Pie LMFAO, and they need to go back to school to know what a Greek salad is. First time eating with them, and if this is the crap they sell as a fake Greek salad, I will not be returning! Where's the feta cheese????? You advertise it was on it????? Pasta is dry as cardboard. Where's the marinara????? You guys can't make food and leave out the key ingredients. Really???? This was a rip-off meal. I wish I could give it NEGATIVE 5 stars! I will not be returning, and I advise others not to waste their money in this place! read more

Your Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, Georgia

See all

Great Service from ALL Employees even without the Manager there. Great Pizza and Galitto!!

fast fast fast!!!! always friendly.... pizza is always perfect!!! best ranch in all the land read more

Received three delicious pizzas and salad for the Hospice staff and they all loved it very much great flavor and cooked right!

Not to be too complaintive but a bit disappointed. Visited this location last evening. The employees seemed a bit frazzled even though it was only after 5 and the restaurant wasn't even that busy, someone literally dropped on the floor the cooked pies of two in our party so they had to start all over again. For some reason when my wife and I received our pies the crust was cooked yet the toppings were lukewarm, we suspect they sat on the counter because they forgot to serve them. With the prices of restaurant food being what they are and with the issues we experienced there really is no reason to pay a return visit, at least to this location. read more

My wife and I first ate at Your Pie for there "soft open," which I thought went really. We came back after there grand opening and were pretty pleased. We did find a few inconsistencies but nothing that kept us from continuing to eat here over and over. Some of our slices were cut really irregularly and the dough in the pizza was slightly undercooked. After letting the owner know he was quick to make changes and fix the issues. Since the opening I think we have been back nearly five times. Having never eaten at another Your Pie location we will continue to check out other locations and return many more times to the one in Monroe! We really love how customizable the pizza's are and also Your Pie is really affordable! read more

Your Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, Georgia

See all

I used to like this place, but recently it has gone down the tubes. Ordered one of their new 14" pizzas online and it wasn't ready at the time promised. They didn't even get started on the special 14" dough until I got there. The person working on the dough was going at a snail's pace and even worse the person putting pies in the oven was slinging the ingredients everywhere. They re-did some pies, but others they just let go with now burning ingredients in the oven. It wasn't busy when I arrived and it looked like they had more folks on duty than needed. I got tired of waiting and asked for a refund. It took a while to figure out that part, but then they didn't remove the tip I had placed online. Lesson learned, never tip online. I had to wait longer for them to call the manager to figure that one out. They said they refunded it to my amex, but it did not show up. I'll be disputing with amex as these folks have wasted enough of my time. I'm a local and have seen so many places go out of business. It's hard to tell if this place will make it as they seem to struggle with service and food quality. Too bad as it used to be very good. read more

The worst of the worst. Wish I could give a minus10 rating. No greeting from the workers. The 14" pizza had the bottom and crust burnt black. Will never be back again. The owners and management (if there is any) should be ashamed. The place only had young, no social graces, inattentive workers. This place should be closed down by the health department. read more

Well I placed an online order for the 14" pizzas and I ordered 5. Instead, I received 10 10 inch pizzas. They told me they ran out of 14 inch pizzas. If that was the case, why not call me and let me know so I can cancel my order? The order was placed online and you have my phone number. This was for a customer lunch. It was ridiculous Walking in with 10 10 inch pizzas. Not to mention the bill was over $100 and they did nothing to fix this. Never again. What a joke. Barely any ingredients on the pizza. All this is is a Subway like version but for pizzas. Terrible. read more

Please don't expect your order to be correct. I've ordered several times from them and it's never correct. So if you're not into wasting tine waiting for an incorrect order to only be followed up with empty "I'm sorries" followed by to effort to fix quality review issue, I suggest ypu find another pizza place to be your go to. ​ read more

We love this place! Simple pizzas and salads...fresh ingredients. Customer service is good and it is always quick in and out for lunch during weekdays. Chill place for a simple date night. read more

The food is delicious it was just a little pricey. Would I go again, maybe. My favorite dish is by far the pest pasta!

Not impressed with the cleanliness or the staff. Slow evening and the place was a mess. There was a severe lack of management. I saw female employee come out of bathroom with another male of a single stall bathroom. There were friends of the staff just hanging out. My pasta came out cold and they had to reheat it. Place just needs someone to give direction and some training. read more

Great spot. Great food and fresh ingredient. Service is nice and friendly and the place is always clean.

Service was on point. very kind and cordial employees especially Cody. please give Cody a raise, he's such a nice fellow and a great employee. read more

We went today! No air conditioning No ice for drinks! No manager on duty!!!

I'm going to preface this review by stating I am not a negative Nelly. I typically read reviews then average out the bad ones. However when it comes to this Pizzeria the negative comments are justified. My experience is a combination of things gone wrong at the same time...a bad app designed by yelp, lack of communication from GrubHub and horrible management at the pizzeria. I placed my order in Yelp for pick up. Yelp assigned my pick up to GrubHub who then delivered my pizza to the wrong address (app never confirmed the delivery address!)...none of these things were the pizzerias fault. However after speaking with the manager on the phone and asking them to remake the order only to arrive and have the manager tell me they cannot make the order and I need to get my money back from Yelp. I clarified that I was willing to pay for the new pies and that I would speak with yelp at a later time. The manager told me to go get in the order line...I was like SERIOUSLY!!! I will truly miss the little shop down the street (best pizza since we moved to GA) which is how we even ended up here, But I will NEVER step foot in this place again. Just horrible customer service overall and the manager was rude...just RUDE!!! read more

Always an excellent place to grab food! The building is charming and well kept. The pizza is a perfect size, and I've never had a problem with service. An overall good place to hang out with friends and family:) read more

Great service! Great pizza! Quaint environment! Love their salads and gelato! Lots of drink options!

I used to love Your Pie! I think that's why I'm so disappointed with today. I went in to grab a salad and the employees behind the counter were all huddled up talking and didn't acknowledge my existence when I walked in. One boy was literally sitting on the counter scrolling through Instagram when I walked in. He stayed there doing just that the entire time I was there. Overall the customer service was terrible. I don't think I'll be back to spend money here. read more

New ownership has unfortunately torpedoed this previously top-notch little restaurant. Not only has the service been poor but the facility looks unkempt. Rear entrance is awful now, no lighting (light bulbs in fixtures help), floors that belong in an Athens dive bar (bar tar?), restrooms, etc. Hard to even get food now since they are so slow. Hope these new owners sell soon to someone to bring back the higher standards. read more

My husband and I love this place! Food is great and the place is super cute!! His favorite is the bbq pizza and I love the nat.

The food was great and I love the idea of building your own pizza. However, one of the servers had fake dreds dragging over-the-counter and into some of the little serving cups. I never saw it go on a pizza, but it doesn't take much imagination. It was disgusting to think about. read more

This used to be one of the family's favorite pizza place in Downtown Monroe .. however I've noticed that they started to be stingy with the ingredients.. But what really vexed me is that i went there today and bought a Pesto Turkey Panini to go. Got home only to open it up to find 1 slice of turkey meat (and not the good kind of turkey meat but the cheapest) ,loaded with basil pesto sauce and the bread burnt.. taking it back tomorrow and gonna get my money back plus speak to a manager.. read more

Talk about great food and service in beautiful downtown Monroe! I went to the one in Watkinsville thinking they were all the same. Wrong! Monroe got it hands down. Fresh ingredients and nice staff. Pricing is very reasonable and friendly environment. Have been a repeat customer since they opened read more

We order two small pizzas for a total of $11.75 that included drinks and a sample of ice cream great deal and it was very good. We will be back again soon. read more

I took my family to this location the first week it was open. The place was running like a fine oiled machine. The staff was friendly and well trained. The line was out the door when we first got there and we were a little concerned with how long it would take to get our food. However we made it through the line quickly and got our food with in 5 to 10 minutes of ordering. I had the Nat and my wife came up with her own clever creation. She truly made it "her pie". I have been back 2 more times and had the same experience. I would highly recommend this spot to anyone in the area. read more

Shay is amazing, she is such a good worker and helped me so much! Pizza was so good and beer was amazing! Go say hey to Shay!

It says something about a business when the only negative thing you can say was "My pie was not sliced into exactly equal slice." Same ultra quality ingredients, same extremely attentive staff, same cooking precision, and same exciting ambience. If you haven't come here do yourself a favor. read more

Great staff. Great food. I like to fully customize or get a pre built pizza. I have also tried the pasta and sandwiches you cannot miss.

I ordered takeout yesterday. I ordered the Ischia pizza and a large Greek salad. When I got back to work to eat was disgusted. The pizza was terrible. The salad was a pile of lettuce with chicken. I am vegetarian. I paid 20 dollars plus a tip. When I complained they insisted that they got my order correctly and gave me a free entree coupon which I tossed in the garbage. I could say more but I will leave it as my first experience was horrible and will never eat there again. read more

My wife and I have been to one other Your Pie location a few times before and have always enjoyed the food, but found that the wait was a bit long. This location blew away our expectations--fast service even though the place was packed, great food, extra care taken for my wife's gluten-free pizza, the works. Very clean, too. There were at least two employees actively cleaning the dining area the entire time we were there. This Your Pie is a step up from the other location we used to go to. Five-star food and service! read more

I came into your pie for dinner last night. Aubrey and Abby were very patient while i was picking out toppings. Also, I specifically asked for my pizza to not be to crispy and i believe it was Morgan on register and oven and she made sure it was cooked well. read more

We ate there during the preopening and it was so good. I ate The Nat and it was delicious. Husband had a custom and he really liked it. The renovations are on a next level! It has a real easy feel and so well done. I'm so glad Monroe has a nice place to go! read more