Food is creative and delicious. Staff are really accommodating and friendly as well. Wings are phenomenal as well as their chicken bites. They do Parm, Varm and a bee others. All of which are amazing. read more

great food a bit pricy but worth it. got a big order and everything came perfect. will order again. :) read more

I've tried a few things from NY Firehouse. I usually order to go. They have a wide variety on their menu. I have to say everything I've tried has been pretty good which has me coming back. I actually decided to eat at the restaurant a few weeks ago because I wanted to watch the dunk contest. I was super excited because we had the perfect table directly in front of a 60inch tv screen. I asked the bartender if he could put on the dunk contest and he told me he would on the smaller tv on the opposite side of the room because the couple next to me was watching the Olympics .. whatever not a big deal ... but annoying lol. I ordered the shrimp and the steak tacos and they were very good and flavorful. I would definitely return for those tacos and maybe try the nachos next time! read more

The place is small but awesome. The food is really good. I'm guessing I came on an off day. Ordered the chicken scarp sandwich. It tasted really good excuse bread was really hard like it wasn't fresh. Everything else was great tho. read more

NY Firehouse Grille - Irish nachos - American Near Me - Peekskill, New York

Excellent service. Food was fantastic. Had the turkey burger. And sweet potato fries. Highly recommend. My husband had a sandwich that looks like it came right off of the "Dagwood"cartoon strip - so much meat- more than 8in tall. Highly recommend!! read more

awesome food and great service. The staff is very attentive to guests and the restaurant is very child friendly. Thank you all for a great time! read more

Solid 3 because the Sesame chicken wings were very tasty/fresh and the burger with Swiss was delicious! I also ordered a kids pizza --horrible! It's just a flat bread $7.00 with a-little sauce with no taste and globs of cheese, it was very soft bread too, my 3 year old said "blahhh yuck".. the Stouffer's French Bread is better than what they did! Now, the fried pickles... they are suppose to be FRIED! They were covered in sauce and that's it come on now! read more

This place is like a rustic roadhouse bar straight out of a Hollywood movie, with excellent big screens for watching sports. The bar service is top-notch with premium brands. The servers are super-fast and courteous. But don't be fooled, they have the best hamburger north of PJ Clarkes. The wings here are the best in Westchester County. My brood loves them. They go up to "5 Alarm" followed by "Hazmat." If you decide to go all-out and try the "Waiver Wings", you won't have to prove your courage in any other way. They are so hot you have to sign a waiver in advance to order them! read more

I would say this place is definitely alright. Very acceptable. Food was good, staff was quick. Prices were not crazy. I would definitely go back. read more

Greatest spot in Peekskill! treated us (first time customers) like family. The food was delicious & the staff was incredible. We will absolutely be back and can't recommend this place enough! read more

Wing night is the best here, plenty of other faves as well. Can't wait to get a sitter for date night to enjoy some tasty food.

So sorry to hear about the fire. We are thankful that no one was hurt in the fire or the responders. We are looking forward to the reopening, hoping the insurance and repairs go smoothly. I look forward to having our burgers and ribs watching the Yankees this summer. We will keep the staff in our thoughts and prayers. read more

I can't begin to explain how wonderful this place is to enjoy! Good food Good service Good prices Great location Wings! Wings! Wings! Decor is also comfortable and inviting Great location Short on parking and even that is an issue This place is worth the stop read more

After I posted the review the owner Alex apologized a zillion times over for the mistake made at the counter for pickup. He even offered me a full refund on the order! THANK YOU ALEX! I will be back sometime in the future! read more

Love the Mediterranean wrap, great fries, tots, and onion rings. Friendly service too!

Tried this place for the first time. From the outside looks like a random bar/ restaurant but has a very cool atmosphere inside. Was suggested the Wyatt Earp hot wings by the server and they were spot on!!! Definitely a place I'll come back to and check out again! read more

NY Firehouse Grille - Wyatt Earp 4 alarm wings!! - American Near Me - Peekskill, New York

My family and I have tried this place a couple times because it's close to where we live. The servers, bartenders etc are all friendly and the service is quick. The bar has good selections. The food however is not good. Everything tastes like it was cooked from frozen or possibly microwaved. For the most part everything is bland. The Mediterranean Grilled Vegetable Wrap is soggy, The wings are tasty (especially the garlic parm) but REALLY oily. The shrimp tacos were inedible. Tiny chewy shrimp and the marinade was horrible, like salty cologne. We ended up throwing it out. With all the excellent restaurants and bars in Peekskill, We'd say, skip this place. read more

We were in town and decided to try this place out. I am glad we did. The buffalo wings are really good here and super flavorful. I had the salad and it was filling and flavorful. It is COVID 19 friendly here. The seating is pretty spaced out and I felt comfortable to eat inside. The staff is very friendly here. read more

Really nice place. Sports bar with large, comfortable and attractive interior. Large menu and Excellent Service. Food is very good with good size portions. My daughter who only eats hamburgers and is very picky thought the burger here was great. read more

I've been here several times before and I didn't have such a good experience. This was a couple of years ago when they first opened back up. The wings weren't as good and the prime rib wasn't good, neither was the fries. So I didn't go back for quite some time. Last night was my friends birthday so we went here, I was hesitant but I had such a good time! The wings, I had 4 alarms was spicy and crispy, I had mozzarella buffalo sticks and it was so good! Even the drinks were amazing. The only reason I did not give 5 stars was because it was so hard to get the waitress's attention. We ordered some stuff then had to hunt her down or make someone go to the bar just to get something added to our order. Even after this I had a good time. So all in all, I will be going back. Thank u firehouse grille. read more

NY Firehouse Grille - Buffalo mozzarella sticks! Such a fun appetizer - American Near Me - Peekskill, New York

See all

Quiet. A lot of pride here which I respect, but the food had waaaay to much salt for my taste. I didn't finish it and went about my business. Ordered the Old Bay wings which I thought were going to be lightly seasoned because old bay is salty all on its own, and the lettuce wrap. read more

Came here to catch the Jets Game with my Sports Fan Brother. I'm not really into sports but am sure into Beer. The place is quite laid back and has a simple feel to it. IT has a restaurant portion and Bar section and plenty of TVs to watching grown hell beating the crap out of each other over a ball. Pretty sweet. At the entrance they have this loop of pictures showing various internet Memes and applying them to the restaurant. A pictures of Morpheus from the Matrix popped up stating "What if I told you...You could put Mac and cheese on your Burger?"I Was instantly sold. The ambient must bring a lot of younger patrons. The hostess ( Who also ended up being our waitress) was really nice and gave us layout of the beer selection and had us try on the darker beers I never tried before. They have a create-your-own-burger section in the menu which lets you select the meat (you could even have salmon),cheese and condiments ( I obviously went with the mac and cheese). The burger was delicious and filling and went really well with the beer. After we were done we went to the bar to finish watching the game but encountered a problem. My brother went to buy the round but realized he had forgotten his wallet at home. The tattooed bartender asked for the ID and denied him service. I figured I would buy the round then as I had my ID with me. The bartender then came up to me and snapped at me that I wouldn't be served if I didn't provide an ID for both me and my brother ( Who was already drinking a beer that we got with dinner). The guy was totally in the right but I could had totally done without the snotty and condescending attitude. read more

NY Firehouse Grille - Cheese burger with MAc n chaaaaize! So Good - American Near Me - Peekskill, New York

Food is Delicious. Great reliable and speesy service. Very chill enviornment. Handsome bartenders. Great music. Constantly provides a great time. Entire staff is friendly and courteous and it's a good family enviornment. Night life is fantastic and it's great to catch sports since the separate bar area has a lot of tvs. read more

NY Firehouse Grille - Again Salad wrap.. - American Near Me - Peekskill, New York

So last night I called the firehouse grill to order 60 wings to and soups to donate to Hudson valley hospital for their hard work and dedication due to the covid-19. I told them I was a member of service and unfortunately the wings were over cooked and dry. even though they appreciated it, I felt really bad. so I called to let them know and their response was mind blowing. I talked to Alex and he said that they also felt really bad as well and not only are they going to redo what I did their going to match it. This is what I'm talking about!! this is a great way to give back. Thank you Alex your a stand up person read more

We were in town and decided to order in. We are so glad we listened to the recommendation for Firehouse. The delivery was quick, the food was hot, fresh and absolutely delicious. Unfortunately, we didn't take pictures but will next time we are in town as surely we plan to order again. We had chicken, a salmon dish with butter sauce and capers and loaded kickin fries. We thoroughly enjoyed every last bite. read more

I ordered chicken wings from the menu price on menu was 20 wings $18.00 when I went to pick them up I was told my order was $28.00 due to price increase on wings for the business I was not told that at the time I ordered them they said there are signs all over the restaurant online it doesn't even mention this increase will not purchase anything else there bad business!!!! Well I just revised my rating the manager gave me a full refund just now for my meal he apologized & said he hopes I will continue to patronize the restaurant Thank you Alex read more

Was in the area and saw this place, so decided to stop in for a beer and burger lunch. Everything was pretty good, from the service to the food. Will stop in next time I'm around again! read more

You can't go wrong at Firehouse. The ribs are always great and are light on the sauce, so you can add enough yourself. The wings come in various spices and I love spicy. I've found the 5 alarm is pretty good and manageable. I have yet to try the "Waiver" wings. If you do eat them, it's not like you get a t-shirt or picture on the wall, so there's not much incentive to eat them unless you just like that kind of spice. Just remember, even though you may get it down in one direction, it still has to come out the other direction at some point, which could be MUCH more painful. Eat them if you live locally or have no problem with public restrooms. There is enough variety for the whole family to get what they want - from mac n cheese, to fajitas, to vegetarian options, to Dad's carnivorous fare. The chili was not as good as I would have hoped. Lacked spice and the flavor was not very full. Pricing was very reasonable for entrees and sandwiches, but some appetizers get very pricey - almost the cost of an entree for some. You can sit at the bar and meet the locals or sit in the dining area which has mirrors - so everyone gets a TV view. Definitely a neighborhood gem. read more

Came back for an event and everything was fabulous so I had to update! Next time I definitely know what to order!

.great place for wings and beer. All the food is delicious! My favorite place to go. Wyatt Earp wings are a must try, also white street! Great crispy saucy wings. Nachos are really good too. Great specials almost every day. Must try. read more

This is one of our regular spots. The food is good and the staff is friendly. We eat there and get it to go and it holds up well on the drive home. read more

Visiting the area from Charlotte for work. This place is a quaint local venue and must be popular with locals because the place had a good crowd for a Tuesday night. The menu has a good variety of options and the prices are reasonable. My food was excellent and I will visit again before I go back home. I don't usually write reviews unless the place has something exceptionally good or bad. NY Firehouse Grille earned my time to review it. Best quality:. Great food and friendly service. read more

See all

Great place. Great waiters. Food is good quality. Been coming here for a few years now. read more

NY Firehouse Grille - Irish nachos amazing! - American Near Me - Peekskill, New York

The food was ok, I had a philly cheesesteak that would have been delicious if it had more cheesesteak (barely enough filling for the bread) and the fries were overcooked. My boyfriend had a steak au jus which was, in his words, the best au jus he ever ate in his life. The place itself is cool, with lots of firefighter memorabilia in the decor. It is split into a bar side and a restaurant side. The noise from the bar was very loud, and there were TVs all around the restaurant side, so if you're not a sports fan (I'm not) I would not recommend unless you are going with a group. read more

NY Firehouse Grille - American Near Me - Peekskill, New York

See all

We usually love this place! But I have to say tonight was terrible! Wait was long, food was subpar. I hope you guys come back soon and hope this is just a glitch... we have literally been going here for like 20 years... read more

Always enjoyed the wings and atmosphere here. But I went here on Cinco De Mayo to get the tacos and margaritas on the rocks. Delicious as always! read more

NY Firehouse Grille - American Near Me - Peekskill, New York

The food was great the delivery was fast and great overall very happy the food is absolutely outstanding especially The tater tot's

The food is just alright! The drinks are weak!! And it's a very small bar. I've been here on multiple occasions. And our visits were just alright. This time we went for the fight spent $200 and another "customer" started and altercation with us, So bc he new the Owner they asked is to leave! And allowed the instigators to stay. read more

Just finished eating my bacon cheeseburger and fries delivered more than on-time by you guys. My other half is still yum-humming through this. Thank you read more

NY Firehouse Grille - American Near Me - Peekskill, New York

Food was great! We had our office holiday party and the restaurant was so accommodating! Everyone had a great time. Great place read more