If you're looking for a great place to eat in Sebring, I highly recommend visiting Nutmeg's Cafe. From the moment you walk in, you're greeted by a warm, welcoming atmosphere with uplifting music playing in the background. Whether you choose to relax inside in the cool, comfortable dining room or enjoy the outdoor seating, it's a wonderful place to spend a meal. The food is absolutely delicious, with an excellent variety of choices that will satisfy just about anyone. And don't leave without checking out the desserts! Their Amish ice cream is fantastic, and the cupcakes are simply amazing. What really makes this place stand out is the staff. Everyone is friendly, attentive, and genuinely seems to enjoy making your visit a great experience. The restaurant is exceptionally clean, well-maintained, and it's obvious they take pride in what they do. Great food, outstanding service, incredible desserts, and a welcoming atmosphere--Nutmeg's Café has become one of my favorite places in Sebring. It's definitely worth a visit. Five stars! read more

See all

This is a quaint, charming establishment that I have been to for both breakfast and lunch. The decor is eclectic and quite lovely. The staff is friendly and helpful with any questions asked. Orders are taken at the counter. I prefer table service but the food is always served hot and full of flavor. Many healthy options are available. The restaurant is clean. Plenty of seating available including an outside patio. I recommend Nutmeg's Cafe. I will definitely return in the near future. read more

See all

Never even noticed the place till I got a ad about it. Stopped in and figured I'd try it out. Cute place. And not too loud. Had a chicken panini and salad. Didn't care for the chicken as it was deli meat. The bread was good and so was the salad. Also a milkshake that was good. Took home a few cupcakes and they were moist and flavorful. Worth the try if you want something a little different. read more

If you are in Sebring, Florida and are looking for a unique, cozy place to have a fantastic lunch experience with friends, family or just some quiet time alone... this is YOUR "go to" place. Everything from their soups and bread, to their freshly made salads are in house made! You can taste the quality difference. Their creative choices in desserts rotate constantly, giving their customers pleasant surprises in new taste sensations! Delicious smoothies are an excellent choice as a "pick me up" when you don't have a lot of time, but still want to put a smile on your face. To top all this off, it is served by an extremely cheerful and sincere Nutmeg crew. I have never seen people who just simply enjoy their job in bringing you great food. Nutmeg's Cafe in Sebring is a haven you should put on your weekly bucket list! read more

Nutmeg's Cafe - Nutmeg's awesome Taco Salad - Cafes Near Me - Sebring, Florida

We came 20 minutes before closing , the staff was quite nice and didn't make us feel bad about it !!! The place is very cute , the outside space is adorable but with this Florida heat impossible to sit in unless they add some fans or something read more

Nutmeg's Cafe - Iced brown sugar toffee late and mocha frappe - Cafes Near Me - Sebring, Florida

Great little cafe with an interesting menu!! One item struck me but I'm a little nutty. I had discovered the great peanut butter and salami sandwich in the seventies and it's still on my favorite!!! However aside from a more "traditional menu " there and behold another trend setter and the great crispy bacon and peanut butter and honey sandwich was available and totally delicious!!! Personally I will use less PB but that's me. This is an adorable and great place with lots of delights.. and coffees!! read more

Nutmegs is a great place for a coffee date We got the Iced Spiced latte and a hot toasted marshmallow coffee along with the Jalapeño popper sandwich and a Rainbow Buddha Bowl. Great service and prices We will definitely be coming back! read more

We just love their sandwiches, and the beet salad with any of them. The place is kind of cozy and the service is really nice as well. If you visit Sebring don't miss it read more

the food is fantastic. I had the roast beef panini and my wife had the mufaleta. the soups are amazing as well

We found Nutmeg Cafe restaurant on BringFido. When we stopped in after a 2 hour drive, I asked an employee if we could eat on the patio with our dogs. I was told yes so I used the restroom and let my husband know. He walked the dogs before coming in. The same employee came out with menus and our dog barked. Without a chance to settle, out storms another employee (maybe owner?) who is clearly pissed. She said, "technically we aren't supposed to have dogs out here, especially if they're going to act like THAT! I'm going to have to ask you to leave." I think there was a polite, customer service manner in which that could have been handled. We could have ordered to go but they clearly weren't offering. We never got a chance to even look at the menu. I guarantee we won't be back nor will our friends. Customer service matters. read more

Clean restaurant, decent service with a walk up and order style. Nice menu items, fresh and delicious. Take home meals available for families. Occasionally service is a tad bit slow but worth waiting. Located on Hwy 27 across from Highlands Regional Medical Center read more

Labor Day morning the service was incredible. I was Treated like the only customer in the place. Food was served quick and done well

This place was recommended by hotel staff for sandwiches and salads. I got the keto salad and it was delicious. I was greeted upon entering, ordered, and received my salad quickly. Employees are very friendly, and helpful. Parking is available on the sides and rear of the building. read more

Nutmeg's Cafe - Keto Salad - Cafes Near Me - Sebring, Florida

This wonderful joint has been rated 4.5 stars for years and they deserve it! I was blowing through Sebring and wanted a lighter lunch, and this is just the place. They are a panini/sandwich/salad place along with some delicious cupcakes. Everything they possibly can is fresh cooked/baked. There are no burgers, and they don't have a fryer. This is about as far away from fast food as you can get! Atmosphere- An eclectic mix of mismatched tables and chairs. I think about ten tables overall. This is a very casual place. Service- They are legendary for their fresh food and also legendary for being slightly understaffed. It takes a while for the food to come out of the kitchen. I wouldn't go here if I were in a hurry, but the food is worth the wait. You order at the register and they bring the food to your table. My very friendly server was simply fine and shared that she was only seventeen. They cash you out at the table electronically. Food- I ordered the one half Muffuletta Sandwich which comes with one side, so I went with pasta salad. That goes for $6.99 and it a very fair price. My sandwich was awesome, and the focaccia bread was terrific. The Olive Salad on the sandwich was unbelievably good. The pasta salad was very tasty, but they need to work on the presentation. In needs some color. From past visits, I don't remember it always being that way. I was full but I'll say again that the cupcakes are killer good here. So much better than fast food and worth a stop if you are blowing down Rout 27 southbound. read more

Nutmeg's Cafe - Delicious 1/2 Muffuletta and tasty but bland looking pasta salad. - Cafes Near Me - Sebring, Florida

My new favorite place for a sandwich. They have a nice selection of very different sandwiches. I LOVE the Bacon Jalapeno Popper sandwich...to die for! Unusual sides like beet salad or English pea salad. The fresh fruit is delightful. read more

Cute cafe. Spacious. Fresh delicious sandwiches and salads. Nice ambiance. Good service read more

See all

The food was excellent. I had a turkey wrap that was delicious. Service was great. It is in an older building and doesn't look like much from the outside, however, the ambiance inside is nice. Great place for a ladies luncheon. read more

Always the best food. A little slow with service, but, worth the wait. Building reminds me of an old A&W root beer place.

What a wonder eclectic little sandwich shop. A very nice setting where not a chair nor table match.. the service is exceptional and the food portions, more than filling. If you are looking for a nice unassuming place to for lunch or breakfast, with a friendly staff, this is the place!! read more

This place is awesome. Nice seating and ambiance. Definitely a go to staple in this town. I tried the acórese sandwich and iced latte

One of the top 2 Reubens I've ever had . We'll be back. Food and price was great. Tried to get there several times, and made it for our first time. Next, we'll try breakfast. read more

We stopped in at Nutmeg's at almost 2pm, when some places are closing but we were finally hungry. I had a tuna salad sandwich w/apples & rosemary on a croissant--delicious! My side item was watermelon. My daughter had a chicken, spinach, & cheese panini, & a side of pasta salad. Everything we had was very good! read more

Was pretty good....limited options in Sebring.....had half a Cuban panini and cup of chicken pot pie soup....both were good in addition to good service... read more

Nutmeg's Cafe - a view of the dining room - Cafes Near Me - Sebring, Florida

Thank you for your thoughtful reply. I can understand the staff not having a good day and am glad to hear there was no risk of foodborne illness despite the food not all being at the correct temperature. My symptoms could have been due to being dehydrated. I didn't have any lasting aftereffects, and might consider visiting again if I happened to be in the area. read more

Great sandwich and pasta salad! Cute spot in Sebring! Staff was nice! Recommend stopping in! I got the Louisiana muffuletta was soo good!

Interesting menu, service is spotty, food can take a long time. Has a healthy feel to menu with several keto dishes. It shows promise and it's kinda new hope they work out the kinks. Give it a fry, but be patient. read more

Wow!!!! The food at Nutmegs is the best food I've had in a while! Our first time here and we were thoroughly impressed! So thrilled to have a great quality healthy restaurant in town, not easy around here...finally! Stopped in for a late lunch and my husband had the Cuban panini and it was outstanding- I had the Waldorf Bowl and it was by far the best salad I've had! Planning on going back weekly to try more of their great selection of food, there's something for everyone here! The inside is uniquely decorated & quaint and nicely separated tables that give you a safe covid space. The staff is very friendly and the service was great! Nutmegs earned a solid 5-Star rating and my only regret is that I didn't come here sooner! read more

See all

I placed a delivery order for my husband after working at a hospital overnight and they were missing his food because of their careless error they were not helpful what's so ever and hung up on me to top it off! You need to work on customer service and being apologetic!!!!! read more

Eat local. Nutmeg's is a small business that focuses on lunch and dinner with a variety of tasty sandwiches and soups and baked items. I knew right off to go with the daily special, which was a tuna melt on rye with sharp cheddar cheese and bits of green apple. It was fantastic delicious. I also got a lemon buttercream cupcake for dessert. Nice and moist, even five hours later back at the hotel. Great stuff. Furniture in the place is an eclectic collection of random chairs and tables, but it works. Good service and a great sandwich. Yummo! read more

See all

Such a great find!! Out for the day and decided to stop for lunch. We'll definitely be back and will make this our destination for a motorcycle ride. We had the Cuban sandwich with potato salad, 3 cheese grilled cheese with fruit, Cobb salad, snickerdoodle cupcake, and chocolate coconut cupcake. All of them we exceptional. The ranch dressing appeared homemade and was probably the best we've ever had. The potato salad was red potatoes in a mustard/Mayo sauce. It was flavorful with just the right amount of dill. The Cuban was loaded with meat and pressed perfectly. The cupcakes were moist with just the right amount of density. The dining area is large and the decor is eccentric. Loved everything about this place. read more

Nutmeg's Cafe - Part of the cute dining area - Cafes Near Me - Sebring, Florida

See all

Good food and friendly staff make a nice dining experience. The sandwiches are wonderful

Very healthful food along with everything you want. Good food for a nice price. The ambiance is not a factor for a lunch place.

Service can be very slow and unprofessional, it's never busy when we have gone. My husband likes the Keto friendly dishes. I don't like ordering at the counter. Building is old and reminds me of a place run by hippies from the 70's. It has a health food vibe to the menu. read more

Friendly people. Awesome food. Keep making the pretzel things! Lol. Definitely try them out Chad read more

Great coffee! Cute place. I really enjoyed my meal and will be stopping by again when I'm in the area. read more

See all

Great lunch spot and place to slow down and enjoy the day! The coffee is great and the sandwiches are delicious. We stopped for a quick rest on our trip and had to catch up with some emails. The staff are nice and the food is excellent! read more

The staff is super nice and the food delish! The beet salad (egg white/dill pickle/watermelon) was unexpectedly prepared way different than I'd seen before but I enjoyed it. The potato salad is delish! I got the muffaletta on panini was very warm & full of flavor! Got a scone to go & it looked delish as well! read more

Polite and helpful staff. Great healthy menu and great prices for what you get. Definitely plan to come here on a regular basis

Absolutely delicious. Slow...who cares! The food is worth the wait!! I am so glad we stopped in by chance. My partner had the Cuban(which he said was the best he has ever had and I agree) I ordered the turkey panini filled with cranberry sauce and stuffing. Amazing. Just wish I would have gotten the whole instead of half. Pumpkin and black bean soup was hearty and warming. If I ever come back to Sebring this will for sure be a place I stop. Also. STRAWBERRY CAKE BALLS!! read more

It's a cute little place and I get rewards from another app for eating there. However the girls there seem disinterested in providing kind, friendly service. Which is important to me read more