I had the pleasure of dining at Noah's on Sunday evening with two of my college girlfriends, and what a wonderful experience it was! We ordered several dishes to share so we could sample as much of the menu as possible. We started with a half dozen oysters featuring three different varieties. They were incredibly fresh, and we loved every one of them. The accompanying sauces were the perfect complement. From the Small Plates menu, we ordered the watermelon salad. It was a generous portion and absolutely delicious. Perfect for a warm summer evening. I especially loved the combination of arugula, fresh mint, and both yellow and red watermelon. The cocoa nibs were an unexpected touch that added wonderful texture and flavor. It's not something I ever would have thought to add to a watermelon salad, but it worked beautifully. I can't wait to order it again. Next came the Long Island calamari frito misto with rock shrimp. The lightly battered calamari and shrimp were perfectly crisp, and the addition of fennel added a unique flavor that elevated the entire dish. It was simply superb. We also shared the red crab tacos. There are three tacos per order, which worked out perfectly since each of us could enjoy one. This was another standout. I love crab but usually shy away from mayonnaise-based salads. Whatever they did with this crab salad completely won me over. It was light, flavorful, and absolutely delicious. The Long Island Duck BBQ, served with pulled duck, cheddar grits, and scallions, was another pleasant surprise. I wasn't quite sure what to expect, but it was outstanding. Every bite was packed with flavor, and the creamy cheddar grits paired perfectly with the tender duck. It was another creative dish that showcased the kitchen's talent. We also ordered a side of baby spinach so we'd have a vegetable to round out the meal, and even that was perfectly prepared and very flavorful. When I say everything was exceptional, I truly mean it. Every dish arrived beautifully presented, at the perfect temperature, expertly seasoned, and bursting with flavor. Our server, Jennifer Farino, kept everything running seamlessly despite all of our shared plates and courses. She was attentive, friendly, and made the entire evening even more enjoyable. My friends ordered Hugo Spritzes while I enjoyed a raspberry Stoli Cosmopolitan. The cocktails were outstanding as well. Kudos to the bartender! When it came time for dessert, we asked Jennifer to surprise us with her selections. While every dessert was delicious, my absolute favorite was the cinnamon sugar beignets with bourbon caramel dipping sauce. They were warm, light, and completely irresistible. I could eat them every day! In fact, I'd happily return just for those beignets. We originally had an indoor reservation, but when we arrived we were fortunate enough to be seated outside, where seating is first-come, first-served. It couldn't have worked out better. The weather was beautiful, making for a perfect summer evening. Even the background music was thoughtfully chosen and played at just the right volume, creating a wonderful atmosphere. From the food and drinks to the service and ambiance, everything about our evening at Noah's was exceptional. We all left saying the same thing: this was one of the best dining experiences we've had in a long time. Noah's has truly set the bar high, and we can't wait to return. read more

Cute restaurant but when you walk in, the seafood hits you . The service was extremely quick but this place is overpriced. We had the steak which came with potatoes and sea scallop in a corn mixed at the bottom. Food was good but the sea scallop for around $50 only came with 6. Steak was perfectly cooked to what we asked for - medium rare. read more

Noah's - Skirt steak - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all

Perusing my pictures I realized I never reviewed the great snacks my family & I had here. My brother, sister & I took my dad out to the north shore for father's day and this was one of the spots we enjoyed ourselves at. I got the Korean Style Duck Wings on special. Fantabulous! My sister ordered the Rhubarb Glazed Baby Back Ribs. Delicious! My Dad got the Local Seafood Bouillabaisse. He thoroughly enjoyed. And my brother loved his Filet Mignon Sliders. A great time was had by us all! Do stop by. Everything was unique & delicious 10-28-2025 read more

See all

Cute restaurant. They have an amazing happy hour at the bar. The bartender was very sweet and patient. Would recommend the burger hummus, and beet salad. For dessert - the flourless cake was amazing! read more

Noah's - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

Service was fine. Staff was cordial & professional. Unfortunately, the burger that was ordered to be medium rare came out well done. If a well renowned restaurant can't make a good burger, as asked, I wonder how their other dishes come out. read more

We came to Noah's for the warm lobster roll listed on their menu, but unfortunately it's only available in the winter. We ordered the olives and shishito peppers instead, which were both delicious but a bit over-seasoned. The wait staff was fine, and we enjoyed sitting outside, which made for a lovely atmosphere. I can't speak to most of the menu since we only tried appetizers, but the location is nice for outdoor dining. We will post more travel guides, photos, and videos from our Greenport trip and other locations at https://ourownpathtravel.com and on YouTube at https://www.youtube.com/@OurOwnPath read more

Noah's - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

The food was good and the bartender Alexander was super cool and very nice. The happy hour was sufficient even for full meal. My issue is with the bartender Kimberly. She was what some might call nice nasty. Our bill was incorrect and when we brought it to her attention she was rude implied we were trying to get over. We pointed out that they had not charged us the happy hour prices for the happy hour drinks we ordered. She said she had given us the happy hour prices for the wine, as if it was not happy hour and she was giving us something. We pointed out it was still happy hour. She said l, oh my mistake I thought it was Monday (ok, everyone makes a mistake). My husband then told her you haven't been particularly kind to us. She said well I've been nice to you most of the time and then walked off with attitude and didn't come back. Not sure if this place is accustomed to African American customers but can't help but wonder. She clearly wasn't pleased with dealing with us. Maybe just a bad day? Otherwise, great place and good food. read more

I loved it. The wine was great, and the food was great. The environment is lovely. I had the most delicious duck mousse and a slider of filet, creamed spinach and hollandaise sauce. So good. It was my birhtday and very happy to have eaten here. My husband and I really connected here for the first time in 2012 so the place has a warm place in our hearts. read more

Took my wife her for her birthday during restaurant week and had the most amazing dinner. The appetizers were all delicious (especially the spicy tuna bites). And dinner and dessert just kept getting better with a delicious espresso martini to top it off. The staff also could not have been friendlier. Jennifer was a pleasure and super friendly. read more

Noah's - Chocolate cake and beignets - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

First time being here after it was recommended by my son and daughter in law. I can't say enough about the staff. Our server, Leslie, was incredible. She, along with the rest of the staff, was friendly and checked on us every step of the way. Our dinners were exceptional. I had the mussels, the roasted garlic, and the marinated olives. Oh, and oysters as an appetizer. My wife had the risotto. Everything was delicious. The dining room is spacious, and even with every table full it wasn't too crowded or loud. Highly recommend! read more

If I could give this restaurant ten stars I would!!! From the moment we asked if there was room for us, the hostess immediately made us feel welcome. She asked if preferred to eat inside or outside. Because it was such a beautiful night, we decided to dine outside. Our table faced a quaint post office with views of the Main Street yet offered a buffer from the public so we had space to ourselves. There was an outdoor heater hanging from the eaves for chilly nights. Leslie, our server, went above and beyond in the hospitality department. She proudly shared how their restaurant offered farm fresh meals with ingredients grown straight from the owner's backyard garden. Her personable nature made us feel more connected and deeply appreciative of our food. I ordered the squash blossoms and the filet mignon sliders. They were simply outstanding! The squash blossoms had an herb infused goat cheese filling. The blossoms were cooked to perfection! The sliders were open faced on brioche bread. The portion size at first seemed meager until I started eating and realized I couldn't finish my food! The filet mignon slider made an amazing breakfast with scrambled eggs the next morning. My husband ordered spicy tuna on flash fried stick rice as well as a bleu cheese burger and fries which were gluten free. He was in heaven! He said everything was cooked perfectly, and it was the best sticky rice he's ever had! From the luscious drinks to the savory, farm fresh meals, this exquisite restaurant is simply a MUST go-to in the Greenport area!!! read more

See all

Had not been for a while and found this restaurant is better than ever. Leslie and Jason were our servers and both were friendly and terrific. Will be back soon! read more

Nice place in town for shareable plates or a sit down meal. Very spacious. Service was good, did not have to wait long for food to arrive. Food was yummy, especially the Crescent Farm Duck BBQ and the filet mignon sliders. I enjoyed my drink too, as I had asked for it to be made on the sweeter side - Cosmo. If back in town again would come back if for a quick bite as they had a lot of shareable plates. read more

See all

Noah's was incredible! The food was exceptional. We ordered the mussels to start and the broth they came in was so delicious, we couldn't stop talking about it. For the main course, we ordered the swordfish with fingerling potatoes. It was very well prepared and the dish was very light, leaving enough room for dessert! The affogato was great and the biscotti that came with it was even better. Service was very sweet and attentive. We sat outside since it was a warmer day, but still appreciated that the heaters were on after the sun went down. We did go on a Sunday night, so it was a bit quiet, but the food definitely made up for it. I would definitely come back! read more

Noah's - Steamed PEI Mussels - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all

Our first time at this restaurant. It had come highly recommended. They were right!! The atmosphere and decor was comfortable and pleasant. The menu was varied with much to choose from. The food preparation was excellent and so was the service. We loved this place. read more

Phenomenal. We shared multiple appetizers (small plates) as a group of four. Everything was delicious, presentation was good, and tasted as described, with fresh ingredients. We got the Crab stuffed deviled eggs, the Local oysters, Spicy tuna bites, Gorgonzola Rosemary fries, Jurgielewicz farm duck bbq, Port belly pot stickers, Steamed PEI mussels which was a decent size, and two deserts. Spicy tuna bites were almost perfect, just need a little salt on top. The gorgonzola rosemary fries came with a delicious sauce we wished we had more of. Everything else was great and certainly farm to table. The two desserts we got were the Cinnamon sugar beignets and the Toasted s'mores dessert. The beignets stood out the most with the salted caramel dip that came with it. We were hoping for more of a mezcal taste from the Blood o' marg drink but overall the food was so amazing here and our waiter was really good to us. We will definitely return. read more

Noah's - Cinnamon sugar beignets and toasted marshmallow dessert - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

Four of us went to Noah's over the weekend. Food was ok but not spectacular. The service was fast and efficient but lacked almost any interaction. The ambiance was ok. To be fair we were seated in the back near the kitchen doors and the bathroom so it wasn't optimal. I guess there was a lack of flair or character to the place that was a little disappointing. Not a disaster by any means but it was...ok. read more

Best meal in Greenport. Fabulous dinner. Superb service. They accommodated a large party with ease. Great diverse menu. read more

Noah's - Seafood stew at Noah's - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

Noah's is one of our favorites to go back to when we are in Greenport. I forgot to take photos of their cocktails but they are just as good as the food. The tofu skewers and corn risotto will always be on our order when we return. The service and staff are very friendly and check in a good amount while you are dining in. The couple next to us must of been there for their anniversary and they kindly gave them celebratory champagne for the occasion. 10 out of 10 would recommend to any friend to go here. read more

See all

I've been coming to Noah since it first opened. The food was good and the service was solid. However, we were seated near the restroom this time, which took away from the overall experience a bit. I think adding some partitions or visual barriers could help make that area feel more comfortable. Overall, though, it was still a good visit read more

Noah's - Crispy Hoisin Glazed Tofu Skewers - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

Came here with my partner for his birthday and the experience exceeded every expectation. Leslie was an absolute delight whose recommendations didn't disappoint. Excellent service and I'm still drooling over the chocolate cake. read more

Noah's - Linguini with Local Little Neck Clams* - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

We recently had Dinner at Noah's to celebrate my wife's birthday. Everything was fantastic. Our Server, Jennifer knew that we had spoken to Sunita when we made our reservation, and knew about our recently diagnosed food allergies. They took great care of us and everything we ate was simply delicious, as always. We can't wait to be back again soon. If we lived nearby, we would be there more often. read more

Friday 6pm Came here to avail of the happy hour specials at the bar . We tried some of the specialty drinks to wash down the appetizers we ordered including calamari , french fries with blue cheese - not my preferred way of having fries , thicker cut with blue cheese ). Service is ok , place is good but from what I've seen, it's cozier at night . Every time we passed the place , the place seemed pretty busy . They had outdoor seating perfect to enjoy the weather while people watching with an almost water front view. Didn't fancy the flies by the bar area but I guess tis the season ( warm weather ) . Curious to know how the dinner options are , maybe next time . read more

Popped in for a quick lunch. Waiter was really attentive and friendly, food came out quick. We are on a very restricting diet and they completely accommodated us. Love the prints in the building. Everything was delicious. read more

This was my first time here and it won't be my last. We made reservations for fathers day and when we arrived we were seated promptly and had a choice of sitting indoors or on the patio. The waitress arrived and took our drink order and explained what was on the menu and the specials for the day. She was very helpful and kept checking on us to see if we needed anything. I ordered the bouillabaisse and it was absolutely delicious, my son got the filet mignon sliders that he said were cooked perfectly and melt in your mouth tender. My daughter ordered the rhubarb glazed baby back ribs that was excellent and Chrissy ordered the korean-style duck wings that was absolutely fantastic. I will definitely be going back to try something else out on there menu. read more

See all

A lovely place with a reliably flavorful menu that satisfies adults and kids alike. My 11-year-old loves this place. He says: "This place is so sigma. I had a kobe burger and it was delicious! I fanum taxed it all! My parents and I have been going here for 10 years and never fail to be happy when leaving. 5 stars!" Agree wholeheartedly. --Mom read more

I've been told many times I should dine at Noah's...unfortunately every time I tried I had another engagement arise. Today I stopped in for a quick drink and I was not disappointed! I had an espresso martini that was perfectly made by the bartender Daniel. He was so engaging and my martini was so well made I decided to opt for another drink. Had a dirty martini the 2nd time around and was once again very pleased! We were short on time so we didn't have time to stay for dinner but a super sweet server Mara came by and brought over some bread and butter and let me just say...wow that sweet cream made me a dairy lover! lol. Honestly, I can't wait to come back here and have dinner. The service and atmosphere was superb and I look forward to having a delicious meal and another amazing experience!! read more

Noah's - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

Update 7/14/24 Went back and things were ok. Service not so good (waiter seemed angry at life) - but food overall was good. Bbq duck with grits were the star - all else was good, not great. Probably going to take a break from Noah's next yr. (We live in GPO seasonally). read more

I have a new favorite place in Greenport. Here are the must haves. Crab stuffed deviled eggs, cheese board, and Filet mignon sliders! Great spot our waitress Leslie was fantastic and gave us great recommendations. read more

See all

We looooved our dinner experience at Noah's! We had a 7pm reservation for five on a Friday night and we were seated right away. There were a few empty tables; not sure a res was necessary but I imagine in the summer one absolutely will be. The food was wonderful, the waitstaff were equally as wonderful. The oysters were so fresh and some of the best I've had on Long Island in a while. I had the cassoulet for my meal and it was divine. I asked the waitress about it and she said cassoulet is always in the menu but the preparation changes seasonally. A girlfriend ordered the mussels and said they were the best she's ever had. We ordered a round of shots; one of the girls in our party was pregnant so she didn't order one, the bartender made her a non-alcoholic one so she could celebrate with us and I just thought that was such a sweet thing to do. It was a pricier dining experience but I think it's probably on par with the area. I will absolutely be returning to Noah's. read more

Noah's - Duck Confit Cassoulet - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

The Quick: Loved the spot! We had a few different appetizers, one was better than the next. The bartender was great, and had good recommendations. The specials were delicious, overall a fantastic spot and I must visit if you're in Greenport. My only complaints that they only offer happy hour specials at the bar, even during the pandemic. It's freezing outside, if locals are willing to sit outside (during the week) it would be nice if they would honor the happy hour -- that way we don't have to leverage indoor dining if we feel uncomfortable. Still, I rate this place highly and can't wait to return. Support local and support small! read more

See all

All around great food, service, and ambiance and one of my favorite restaurants I went to while visiting greenport. I loved that so many of the ingredients came from local farms and were simple dishes but done very well. Will definitely be back. read more

See all

Food was tasty and well prepared Service was lacking - slow and waiter did not follow thru on his commitment to save a strawberry shortcake for one of our guests read more

First time visiting Noah's & it did not disappoint! We order a ton of the small plates & all were delicious. The devils eggs are a must! All of the seafood was super fresh. Don't thing you can go wrong with any of the options on the menu! The service was great & staff was very helpful in picking options for the table. The restaurant has a bar & plenty of seating. Would def recommend a reservation. read more

See all

Great experience at Noah's. Went for happy hour on a Thursday. Bartender Serg was wonderful and knowledgeable with what on the menu could be prepared Gluten Free. Started with clams and oysters. Super fresh and locally caught. The stuffed devil egg was AMAZING!!!! Roasted corn was delicious. Filet sliders came out with the bread on the side for my husband as well as the creamed spinach. I had the filet with the sauce. Cooked perfect and so much flavor. Only thing I would not get again was the octopus. The octopus itself was good but the mix of flavors were in competition with one another. Too much going on making it not taste appealing for me. I highly recommend trying Noah's and look forward to returning. read more

See all

Nothing short of a disaster. It was an abominable dining experience that left us deeply disappointed and frustrated. We ordered raw oysters and clams, followed by four shareable plates. It took more than 30 minutes to receive the first two plates and another hour for the rest. The octopus was tough. The crab taco was nothing out of the extraordinary. To make matters worse, we had to flag down several wait staff and the hostess to get any action on our food as our waiter was missing in action. Clearly, the kitchen was in full meltdown mode. Although the manager comped the last two dishes, that did not make up for the intolerable wait and lack of service that ruined our evening. I cannot recommend this restaurant to anyone. Avoid if you value your time and dining experience. read more

Amazing food with an amazing atmosphere! I would 100% come back and the food was beyond great!

Today was my second time at Noah's and I was so glad to be back! Their large menu of small plates and more offered many options. Our favorites today were the roasted whole garlic clove with bread, delicious clam chowder, crab cake, and spring vegetable risotto. We also had the flourless chocolate cake with vanilla ice cream for dessert - YUM! The interior is clean and pretty, and the service was attentive and wonderful. Looking forward to dining at Noah's the next time we are in Greenport! read more

The food was so good, the lobster was fresh a don different from any lobster roll I've ever had with vanilla extract. The fresh seafood is delicious. The service was great, we sat outside and it was great to have view of greenport. read more

Noah's - Lobster Roll and sliders - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

Overpriced for the quality and presentation. We reluctantly paid over $30 for fish and chips that looked like something you could have gotten at a ball game. The fries tasted like they were frozen and then just heated up. The portion size of fish was small. I also had the crispy duck confit. It a very small piece of duck on the bone with a fruity salad. The salad was ok and the duck was crispy but the near $40 price tag left much to be desired in flavor and portion size. The raw oysters were tasty but small $3.50 each. For a bill over $100 (no alcohol or apps) we were disappointed with the mediocre food that came out. We've gotten better meals for half the price. *Staff was friendly and accommodating! No complaints there. read more

Noah's - Duck confit - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all