I had the pleasure of dining at Noah's on Sunday evening with two of my college girlfriends, and…read morewhat a wonderful experience it was! We ordered several dishes to share so we could sample as much of the menu as possible. We started with a half dozen oysters featuring three different varieties. They were incredibly fresh, and we loved every one of them. The accompanying sauces were the perfect complement. From the Small Plates menu, we ordered the watermelon salad. It was a generous portion and absolutely delicious. Perfect for a warm summer evening. I especially loved the combination of arugula, fresh mint, and both yellow and red watermelon. The cocoa nibs were an unexpected touch that added wonderful texture and flavor. It's not something I ever would have thought to add to a watermelon salad, but it worked beautifully. I can't wait to order it again. Next came the Long Island calamari frito misto with rock shrimp. The lightly battered calamari and shrimp were perfectly crisp, and the addition of fennel added a unique flavor that elevated the entire dish. It was simply superb. We also shared the red crab tacos. There are three tacos per order, which worked out perfectly since each of us could enjoy one. This was another standout. I love crab but usually shy away from mayonnaise-based salads. Whatever they did with this crab salad completely won me over. It was light, flavorful, and absolutely delicious. The Long Island Duck BBQ, served with pulled duck, cheddar grits, and scallions, was another pleasant surprise. I wasn't quite sure what to expect, but it was outstanding. Every bite was packed with flavor, and the creamy cheddar grits paired perfectly with the tender duck. It was another creative dish that showcased the kitchen's talent. We also ordered a side of baby spinach so we'd have a vegetable to round out the meal, and even that was perfectly prepared and very flavorful. When I say everything was exceptional, I truly mean it. Every dish arrived beautifully presented, at the perfect temperature, expertly seasoned, and bursting with flavor. Our server, Jennifer Farino, kept everything running seamlessly despite all of our shared plates and courses. She was attentive, friendly, and made the entire evening even more enjoyable. My friends ordered Hugo Spritzes while I enjoyed a raspberry Stoli Cosmopolitan. The cocktails were outstanding as well. Kudos to the bartender! When it came time for dessert, we asked Jennifer to surprise us with her selections. While every dessert was delicious, my absolute favorite was the cinnamon sugar beignets with bourbon caramel dipping sauce. They were warm, light, and completely irresistible. I could eat them every day! In fact, I'd happily return just for those beignets. We originally had an indoor reservation, but when we arrived we were fortunate enough to be seated outside, where seating is first-come, first-served. It couldn't have worked out better. The weather was beautiful, making for a perfect summer evening. Even the background music was thoughtfully chosen and played at just the right volume, creating a wonderful atmosphere. From the food and drinks to the service and ambiance, everything about our evening at Noah's was exceptional. We all left saying the same thing: this was one of the best dining experiences we've had in a long time. Noah's has truly set the bar high, and we can't wait to return.

Perusing my pictures I realized I never reviewed the great snacks my family & I had here. My…read morebrother, sister & I took my dad out to the north shore for father's day and this was one of the spots we enjoyed ourselves at. I got the Korean Style Duck Wings on special. Fantabulous! My sister ordered the Rhubarb Glazed Baby Back Ribs. Delicious! My Dad got the Local Seafood Bouillabaisse. He thoroughly enjoyed. And my brother loved his Filet Mignon Sliders. A great time was had by us all! Do stop by. Everything was unique & delicious 10-28-2025

I've eaten here a few times over the years when we vacation on LI and each time have enjoyed it…read more This most recent visit was no exception. Service was great and the food delicious -my entree was one of the tastiest steaks I have had in a long time. Everyone enjoyed the solarium-like dining room.

Located inside an Inn. Always a charming place. Has a southern charm feel to me. Love to sit…read moreoutside in the warmer weather but You'll get bitten by mosquitoes so don't make my a mistake, Don't wear shorts. The food is very good. Pork chop special is very good but better to get sauce on the side bc it's a bit sweet. Farfalle pesto pasta dish is very lovely. The halibut is good but not consistent, today was overcooked. Service is friendly, but I asked for hot pepper flakes for my pasta, asked 2x n I never got it. It's not cheap, it's a good meal. at least the seltzer water is free a $12 value. N it's the only place in LI that doesn't charge 3%. Paying by credit card transaction fee.

Our daughter's rehearsal dinner was here a couple of years ago. They did a super job, so we scored…read morea reservation when we were in the area last weekend. Like many restaurants in Westhampton Beach, the tables are close together, which can compromise intimacy and noise levels. We had a rager of a large party next to us who (thankfully) paid up and left within 15 minutes of our seating. The decor is classy without being stiff. The wall art is irreverent satire on renaissance portraiture. Wait staff was attentive & competent. The food was exceptional. We shared a "popover" appetizer. I had lobster bisque and a salmon filet. Others at the table had "chicken for 2" and lobster/shrimp.

Overall a lovely dinner on their lovely patio. Service was a little spotty and instead of filling…read moreour wine glasses with normal pours our server filled them up incredibly high so he wouldn't have to chill the bottle. Not ideal when it's hot out and your wine gets warm. Otherwise though we enjoyed the meal. The lobster burrata appetizer was a hit with the table and we also enjoyed the fish special of the day. We'd certainly go back since the setting is lovely.

I had just gotten off the orient point ferry and was starving. I had a burrata and tomato sandwich…read morewith shallot dusted fries. It was delicious. The fries were wonderful. Will say I got a container of cole slaw and was not a fan. Would highly recommend

The lamb sandwich we had was delicious, although a bit heavy on the salt. This ambiance is nice and…read morethey have lively picnic tables in the back.

Motel, miniature golf and snack bar and ice cream store. How can you lose? surprisingly delicious…read moresimple food, and both fresh ice cream, and soft serve to boot. Great summer vibes

Really good food - to eat next to mini golf or enjoy at home. Especially enjoyed the sweet potato…read morefries and the crispiest fried chicken.

South Edison is just a little bit off the main strip of restaurants in Montauk, but shouldn't be…read moremissed! The service was great throughout, from the host to the servers. They had allergens clearly noted on the menu and when I needed to know what could be made dairy-free, the chef made notes on the menu for me. Very appreciated! I ended up have the rare seared tuna steak with black rice. Very tasty! I ended my meal with the coconut sorbet affogato... would definitely recommend! The ambiance was very chill, with a live performer (Julia Raye) starting midway through my meal. She was very talented and the performance was not disruptive at all. Overall, great experience. Add it to your list next time you're around Montauk!

We gave this place a second try, but we were disappointed again!! Way over priced and very small…read moreportions. Noise level is crazy, food is OK but much too expensive. Service was just OK, with these prices it needs to be top notch. but it's not!! We won't be returning.

Gotta tell ya I was pleasantly surprised at how good everything was here. Different menu than their…read morewaterfront location; atmosphere is rather nice inside and has an elegant English pub or tavern vibe. The wagu onion stack burger was very good as was the pizza. The pizza is fron Peter's next door which is afflicted. Service was very friendly but a little slow. Parking is tough but the whole town is very walkable.

Always a cool place for lunch dinner or just drinks. Right in the water with live music, great food…read moreand great drinks. Cool ambience and excellent views.

Our family loves Ellen's! The food is creative and delicious. One of our favorites on the North…read moreFork!

So we wanted to give Ellen's a shot as they kept showing up as a recommended restaurant in GPO (we…read morelive in GPO every summer). We looked at the menu ahead of time and were excited by the pea salad with watermelon radish and the calamari with cherry peppers. Unfortunately the salad came out with regular radish (big difference from watermelon radish). Just tell us ahead of time and we'd change our order - they said after the fact that they are out of the watermelon radish (the toasted corn was also soggy - seemed bagged or made from frozen). The calamari was good but was missing the cherry peppers - instead they had what seemed like jarred banana peppers instead. Again, not what was on the menu. I guess we were just disappointed when we were changed $22 for each appetizer that wasn't what was described on the menu. This kind of stuff is just lazy to me - it's not hard to serve what's described on your menu and if something ran out, tell us - we'd change our order. I think we'll take a pause on Ellen's for now. I hope this is read and these easy small changes are made as we'd love to come back for what's described on the menu. Positive notes - appreciated the ambiance and the service was proficient, no issues with our server.