Service, food and ambiance, all a 10! We'll be back. Also, the drinks are unreal. We sat upstairs, as we didn't have a reservation.

I've eaten at Nine One Five twice in the past year. Both times was very delicious, but I think a little expensive for what you get. The menu has a very large tapas small plates section, which in my opinion is the best. My first visit, We tried several small plates and they were all more delicious than our main entree. My favorites were the beet salad, gnocchi, asparagus, and butternut squash ravioli. It was all amazing. The main entree menu is much smaller, which the only item interesting to us was the ahi tuna. The yellowtail is a whole fish with the head and full body, I wish they had a different preparation of the yellowtail. Our second visit we skipped all entrees and only ordered the "Devils" appetizer , which is bacon wrapped dates with blue cheese dipping sauce. It was very good, but small. And also ordered 2 pastas as our main course; the beef Pappardelle (which was good) and the tortellini de casa (which was amazing with ricotta stuffing and truffle cream sauce). Our first visit we spent way too much money. The small plates add up quick ( $13-$20) each and the entrees are average $35-$40 a plate. Even the pastas were $32 each. Overall the food was delicious, especially the small plates and pasta. The prices are a bit too high for us to come back frequently but if you're willing to splurge then I'd recommend this restaurant. read more

Nine One Five - Ricotta truffle tortellini, amazing!! And beef papardelle - New American Near Me - Key West, Florida

We started at mangoes and no one even acknowledged us so we ended up coming to nine one five and boy are we happy !!!! It was thanksgiving so they offered a special menu. One of us opted for the swordfish and the other the turkey dinner. Wow. the turkey dinner was probably the best we have ever had. Then we finished with the pineappe upside down cake and their special ice cream made by a local place. WOW, it was delicious. read more

Nine One Five - Turkey Dinner. Swordfish & skinny margarita - New American Near Me - Key West, Florida

Outstanding Key West dining. Just goes to show that no matter how many times you visit Key West, there are still great restaurants to be enjoyed. The menu is varied. The indoor/outdoor dining options are nice, especially in Key West. Our server was very friendly and competent. Our meals were delicious. The food being delivered to other tables also looked very good. Looking forward to a return visit. read more

See all

I'm honestly in between 3 and 4 stars here. I made reservations a couple of weeks in advance and they sat us outside in a corner by what smelled like sewage. The waitress herself was very attentive and polite. The drinks we chose were refreshing, but over priced. We shared the she crab ravioli, which you could tell was homemade; pretty good! We also shared the key lime bar, which was one of my favorite desserts on the island. It was fun, but nothing compared to other dinners on the island. The sewage smell was a real downer. read more

See all

This is a favorite of our's whenever we are in Key West - usually at least 2 visits here per trip if that tells you anything. The service is top notch - everyone cares about you when you dine with them. The bartenders are absolutely the best (Natasha, Juls) - talented and fun. Ambiance is romantic and you can sit inside, outside or on the balcony. Lots of options here but I highly recommend getting yourself reservations as it is a popular spot. The food...OMG the food! Lobster Ravioli, Devils (bacon wrapped dates), Soul Momma's Seafood Soup (my absolute favorite), the Clams, the Calamari, Key Lime Pie and even the Burger. This food is simply amazing. If you haven't been here before, please give them a try - it is well worth it. read more

See all

Stopped here for dinner on our first night in Key West. They have a cute outside area and the inside area is also very nice. Our waitress was fantastic and prompt. They had people refilling your water constantly which I love cause it was sooo hot. I got a dirty martini and it was good. The food was amazing. My absolute favorite was the tuna tacos appetizer. This is a must stop for dinner when you are in the area! read more

See all

Fantastic food - get the mama soup; Get a manhattan with the local rum. Great service

Great service and food. Enjoyed both the steak and fresh fish. Would definitely go again, especially when the weather is nice to site outside. read more

Found this one on a stroll down Duval Fabulous food and great ambiance. We dined outside weather was great in December and the service was excellent! read more

See all

We saw this place advertised at our hotel on their channel dedicated to food and entertainment. We then read the Yelp reviews and took a chance to dine here for dinner without a reservation on Friday night. We lucked into getting a table for two inside at the bar area. The restaurant is a gorgeous two story house loaded with charm and decor. The doors and windows are left wide open and the 8pm dining time made it cool and comfortable. All of the terraces were packed full. Make a reservation to avoid disappointment. Service and food were excellent! Chris and I ordered the gnocchi, the lobster tostadas, the key lime bar for dessert and a variety of their specialty cocktails and wine selections. Simply put, this place is AWESOME!! Our server was so attentive and kept us stocked up with food and beverages. True five star dining experience!! Don't miss this place when visiting Key West!!! read more

See all

What a great spot. Our server was fantastic she was suggestive and helpful, made great recommendations on food and wine. Chefs special was truly great and the mussels were so unique and delicious. read more

Love this place never ever had a bad experience my favorite part is up stairs at the bar hugs local hang out

THE BEST CRAB CAKES EVER! Hands down. I had a mocktail that was divine and partner ordered lobster mac and cheese. Talk about decadent. Service was attentive and friendly. Lovely historic home and great food! read more

The service was kind of slow, but everyone was nice. Has a great ambiance & good views of Duval if you sit outside. I got the She-Crab Ravioli which was pretty good, and my fiancé had the Pappardelle which was just okay. We got the Duval Limeades for drinks and they were good as well! Overall would definitely eat here again. read more

See all

I ordered the she crab ravioli! Nice size ravioli with a big "Texas Toast" for dipping. The sauce was luscious! Hubby got Ahi Tuna. Also a nice size meal. Indoor and outdoor seating which is elegant and trendy. You don't feel like you are on the "strip" of KW. Service is wonderful. Was recommended by many locals for a good reason! read more

The place was set up nicely. I ordered the Airplane Chicken and was a little dissatisfied. The chicken was dry but flavor was good. I did try the Devils and surprisingly how good that tasted. It is Bacon wrapped around a date. In a cream sauce. Friendly servers, pricey food. I would not go there again due to the menu selection is limited. read more

Great food. Fun atmosphere highly recommend. Recommend highly trying some of their craft cocktails.

Head upstairs to the speakeasy! Cute and cozy bar with deck seating in the front or back. The bartender was friendly and attentive. We tried their cauliflower bites and would love to go back for dinner downstairs! read more

Great service even better food. I got shecrab ravoli with an old bay Parmesan sauce. I'm from Baltimore and they nailed the sauce. Perfect amount of old bay. After I was done there was quite a bit of sauce left and the waitress brought me baked bread to use on the sauce. My wife got the wahoo and it was fresh, and cooked to perfection. Place is a 10/10. I'll be back for sure read more

Nine One Five - She crab ravioli - New American Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Overall Amazing! Every item on the menu is phenomenal, the vibe is upscale casual, service is outstanding and you are guaranteed to enjoy your meal/experience here! read more

Food was good but customer service was lacking. When we arrived on 3-22-25 we were asked if we had a reservation. I said no and the hostess looked down her nose at us and said they were booked up despite no one being there. Now this attitude ticks me off. We did not look like homeless people and my money spends the same as everyone else. We were dressed like everyone else. I turned to my husband and told him they were booked up and we needed to go someplace else. Hostess then says there are tables upstairs but they are first come first serve but "we could try". Went up and there was one couple there eating. Had to track down our waiter (literally got up and walked inside to the bar) to ask for more drinks. Food took almost an hour despite there not being many people there. For $170 I expected better service. Plenty of other places to eat in Key West. read more

Some of the best food and drinks I have ever had. We had Jules as our waitress and she was just a sweetheart and her recommendations were perfect. I highly recommend trying them. read more

Popped in without a res and were able to grab a table upstairs. Super cute, open space, nice vibe. Burger was delish and the caramel cheesecake was out of this world! Great service too!! read more

This is a little gem in a busy market in key west Fl every one is trying to get your business but you would never think that a restaurant could have great food and service lots of possibilities and last minute accommodation food great ambiance was same read more

Horrible! They could not honor our 6 pm reservation for 2 so they offered to let us sit outside in 90 degree heat or a seat at the bar. A group ahead of us had a few extra people which they accommodated at our expense. This is NOT a high end restaurant! read more

While the place had charm and the service was excellent, the food left a lot to be desired. Most dishes were mediocre at best, and some were outright bad. The asparagus was overly greasy and smothered in pancetta, lacking any real flavor. The fries were lukewarm, unseasoned, and came with forgettable sauces. The mussels were the worst--we couldn't finish them, and I was violently ill just a few hours later, confirming something was definitely off. I might return for a drink, but definitely not for the food--especially not at those prices. read more

Very tasty meal with a decent wine list and great martinis. The dishes were all good but fell short at times in terms of size. For example, the bacon wrapped figs were much smaller than others we've tried at other restaurants. They were tasty but the small size made them greasier than usual. The hits at the table were the grilled octopus, tofu caponata, and the cappuccino martini. Definitely make reservations as they are usually busy. Highly recommend: tofu caponata, cappuccino martini read more

See all

Amazing food and service! Went off season and discounts were super! Definitely a must not miss for Key West.

Great food and ambiance. Well worth the try. Went on a co-workers recommendation and was very pleased.

Food and service could not be better. Really! Sat outside on second floor porch overlooking Duval street. I will come back.

Food is so delicious. The service is super quick and friendly, and the restaurant is stunning. Would recommend. Only thing is the portion was small! read more

Nine One Five - Tortelloni De Casa - New American Near Me - Key West, Florida

We had one of the best dinners ever! We had the ravioli and tortellini for dinner and I couldn't pass up the Oreo cheesecake for dessert! Everything was 10/10! read more

Nine One Five - Oreo cheesecake - New American Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

This restaurant is so good that we came back twice. The second time we waited to sit which we knew was worth it. the appetizers outstanding. The meals are incredible. The service is so good. Everything about this place just hits the mark. read more

First off- make reservations! We came the first night and it was an hour wait at 8pm. This is in a home with a beautiful patio. (The only problem are the cars with loud music.) We made reservations and arrived a few minutes early and were promptly sat. The waiter came immediately to give our drink order and tell us the specials. We had the fish boat with the fish of the day and the whole yellowtail snapper. For dessert a port and the lemon bar. The fish boat had the most amazing risotto and the yellowtail had a wonderful sauce. This was the best dinner that we had in Key West. Highly recommend. read more

Nine One Five - Whole yellowtail - New American Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Absolutely awesome! Such a cool spot. Food was delicious, especially the pasta entrees. Service was great. Good for a fancier dinner in Key West. Recommend a reservation! They get busy with not too much seating read more

ORDER DESSERT! WOW! Service was kind, I'd say this is one of the nicer spots in key west. I would've eaten here every night of our stay, but it's hard to get in without a reservation. Very classy, small but fresh menu. read more

Delicious food! Kind staff. Beautiful restaurant. If youre looking for a classy sit down dinner establishment in Key West this is it. The ahi tuna gravlax was phenomenal! We got that, the mussels, calamari, asparagus, the mongolian ribs and lattes. All were bomb dot com except for the ribs, which were just ok. A little pricey but that's expected for nicer restaurants on Duval St. read more

See all

Nine One Five was the perfect choice for dinner date. Location is away from the loud side of Duval which makes it better to enjoy your dinner. I had the please of having the Mongolian ribs along with Brussels & Sweet Potato Hash. The food was great, small portions but good. Servers were very attentive and have great suggestions. Will be back in the future. read more

I have no idea what is going on with the reviews for this place. My wife and I went here partially due to the positive Yelp reviews. Mistake. My gut told me this was a tourist trap. Located right on the main drag of Duval, it draws in the foot traffic. Seems to leave them with little motivation to put out a decent product. We sat on the top deck (great view). That's the positive. The drinks were terrible. My wife didn't finish hers. The burrata was generic. Our mains were bland or just not good (pasta dish, seafood soup). I'm angry that I spent $200 on this tourist trap. I hope I save one of you the same experience. Stay away. read more