Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    New York Beach Bagel

    4.5 (2 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    New York Beach Bagel Photos

    Recommended Reviews - New York Beach Bagel

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of J d.
    0
    122
    0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - New York Beach Bagel

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bagels 319 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Schmagel's Bagels

    Schmagel's Bagels

    4.3(329 reviews)
    3.0 mi
    $

    Super fresh Bagels! Great Service…read more Vacationing in St Augustine. Stumbled upon this all day breakfast and lunch shop. It was so good, I went back the next day! The variety and quality of the bagels is great. Catherine, and crew are welcoming, personable, and professional. The outside patio is perfect for enjoying the weather in the mornings in St. Augustine. Come early... The bagels always sell out!

    ​Located right in the heart of the historic district on Hypolita St., Schmagel's is exactly what…read moreyou want from a neighborhood bagel shop. It's got that classic, no-frills, "hole-in-the-wall" charm that feels authentic amidst all the tourist spots. The outdoor seating area is a total win--it's perfect for people-watching with a breeze while you fuel up for a walk down St. George Street. ​ ​I went with a classic plain bagel. The texture was spot on--chewy on the inside with that essential slight crunch on the outside. ​Sometimes bagel shops treat coffee as an afterthought, but the iced coffee here was smooth, bold, and served over plenty of ice. It stayed cold even in the Florida humidity. ​The line can look intimidating because the space is small, but the staff moves with impressive speed. I was through the line and outside at a table in less than 10 minutes. They've clearly mastered the "morning rush" flow. ​ ​If you're visiting on a weekend, get there before 10:00 AM. They are known to sell out of certain bagel flavors

    Photos
    Schmagel's Bagels
    Schmagel's Bagels - Whole wheat everything bagel Egg, white American cheese, and scallion cream cheese.

    Whole wheat everything bagel Egg, white American cheese, and scallion cream cheese.

    Schmagel's Bagels - Menu

    See all

    Menu

    Sweetwater Coffee Bar and Gallery

    Sweetwater Coffee Bar and Gallery

    4.8(157 reviews)
    2.9 mi
    $$

    These folks consistently go above and beyond to take care of us when we are in town visiting our…read moreFlagler student. Theo food and coffee is delicious and they are so kind. There's always a little bacon treat for our pup. If you are in St. Aug visit Sweetwater!

    An Absolute Gem in St. Augustine! If I could give Sweetwater…read moreCoffee Bar & Gallery ten stars, I would! We rolled in on a ridiculously hot day just 15 minutes before their 3:00 PM closing time. We were celebrating my sister, so we ordered a bunch of fun drinks and sheepishly asked if it was okay to just finish them while they closed up. They didn't just say it was fine--they made us feel completely at home! Here is why you absolutely must stop in if you are in the area: The Drinks: We had a blast tasting everyone's orders. My Lavender Lemonade was completely on the money--exactly what I needed on a sweltering day! The Amazing Staff: Ashlynn was an absolute doll. She was so sweet and accommodating, even at the very end of her shift. Above-and-Beyond Hospitality: The owner, Mike, is simply awesome. He came over to chat, found out we were celebrating my sister, and hooked her up with a free refill! But the magic didn't stop there. We mentioned we were having a party for my sister later, and Mike went out of his way to give us bagels and this marvelous butter-flavored cream cheese that was literally to die for! He even packed up some extra so we'd have plenty for our bagels later. I cannot wait to come back to St. Augustine just to stop by this wonderful place again. I absolutely love it here. Please make sure you add it to your itinerary (just remember they close at 3 PM!).

    Photos
    Sweetwater Coffee Bar and Gallery - Eggel Bagel on everything bagel

    Eggel Bagel on everything bagel

    Sweetwater Coffee Bar and Gallery - Egg bagel on a cheddar jalapeno bagel with eggs, cheddar cheese & bacon.

    Egg bagel on a cheddar jalapeno bagel with eggs, cheddar cheese & bacon.

    Sweetwater Coffee Bar and Gallery

    See all

    Island Donuts & Bagels - Had to increase the saturation on this photo to show you how purple it is!

    Island Donuts & Bagels

    4.6(255 reviews)
    0.9 mi
    $

    How have I not reviewed this place before! My husband and I come to St. Augustine every year and…read morethis is one of our must stop breakfast spots. This trip was no different. We came here on Labor Day and were greeted with a line out the door. We were not surprised as it typically is this busy on a holiday weekend (when we come), but the line moves fast and the parking moves even faster. It's a cute, beachy, dog friendly donut shop that has outdoor seating. I typically wait in line while my husband scopes out outdoor seating for us and our pups. I ordered two coffees this time. One was a regular coffee and the other was a snickerdoodle for my husband. He loved his so much that he ended up getting a refill even before I sat down with our food. Mine was delicious too! I ordered the Boston cream, Zebra, and Strawberry chocolate donuts. They were cooked to perfection and the Boston cream was delicious. I also ordered a breakfast sandwich on a bagel. This took a little bit of time to make, but I knew that going in based on how busy it was. Highly recommend this too if you're not a donut person because the sandwich was delicious. We will be back!

    Located directly across the street from The Hilton Garden Inn on A1A you will find a great spot for…read moredonuts, bagels & breakfast sandwiches. The variety of donuts is amazing and if can't find something you like then it doesn't exist. I had the caramel frost donut which had some salt in the frosting. The donut was airy and the frosting was decadent. My wife had the Boston Crème and said it was fantastic! It's walk-up counter service only and the folks here are friendly and get you your order very quickly with a smile. This establishment was recommended by the folks at Beachcomber's located on A Street. So locals helping locals! Cool to see & hear! Sorry, no pics as we ate them as soon as we got back to our room!

    Photos
    Island Donuts & Bagels
    Island Donuts & Bagels
    Island Donuts & Bagels - Cute little shop & table seating outside

    See all

    Cute little shop & table seating outside

    New York Beach Bagel - bagels - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...