There were a few surprises here which I'll share:
1. There's no Penang curry at Pinang restaurant.
2. This is mostly Malaysian cuisine; similar to Thai, but with important differences.
I also learned some new things about penang curry:
1. Its proper spelling is "phanaeng".
2. It's a variant of red curry.
3. It's not Malaysian. It's Thai / Northern Malaysian
A fun place to eat. Decor is cool: dark, wooden, and metallic, somewhat beach-meets-industrial. A little what I'd imagine a restaurant in Thailand would look like. There's a large aquarium with the ugliest, meanest fish alive. My 1.5y daughter LOVES to point at the fish and say "Dis! Dis!" The fish, in turn, try to snap at my daughter's fingers through the glass.
Service is very good and personable. The woman who waits tables is very friendly, pleasant, competent, and attentive. She gets a kick out of a 1.5y toddler loving Malaysian/Thai food. We love her. I believe she is from Malaysia.
Home Made Roti Canai: A-
Roti Telur: B-
Murtabak: B-
All three appetizers have the same *delicious* roti dipping sauce; the difference is what you dip. Canai is the typical "pancake" that you dip into the roti. The Telur and Murtabak are both like square onion quesadillas. They are pretty dishes; however, they both are too thick and lack any kind of flavor. Furthermore, they aren't absorptive enough to get flavor from the roti. I like the canai better, but it should be more crispy. The roti itself is absolutely superb, and the chicken in it is one of the softest pieces of meat I've ever had the pleasure of putting into my mouth.
Vegetable Spring Rolls: B
I thought they were going to be like the raw Vietnamese style spring rolls, but they're the standard Chinese fried spring rolls. Not homemade. Frozen. Mediocre.
Thai Curry Puff: A
Definitely handmade: not frozen! Nicely spiced with curry. The dough is flaky and deliciously yeasty.
Thai Fish Cakes: B-
Unique: I've never had anything like it before. I didn't care for them, but my wife liked them. They are small, rubbery red cylinders. They're very strongly flavored with ginger and fish. It's the kind of thing you either like or hate. I hated, but still giving them B- since my wife liked them.
Durian Milkshake: C+
Unique. I didn't care for it, my wife hated it, but I can see someone liking it. Durian is known to be the smelliest fruit on Earth. People describe durian as smelling like rotten onions, turpentine, and raw sewage.The milkshake will definitely keep the boys out of the yard.. it's more than stinky... it's stanky! Still, if you've never had durian before, you should try it. Once you get over the initial stank, it has a vanilla finish.
Tom Ka Soup: A-
Somewhat close to the tom ka soup that I make. Lots of nam pla... good and salty, but it needs more lime. Some kaffir lime leaves and more lemon grass would be awesome.One of the best tom ka I've had in NYC (by best I mean that it has traditional Thai flavors).
Red Curry: A-
Clearly not Thai red curry. It's not red, and the flavor is like Indian curry. No Thai nuance: no shrimp paste, lemon grass, galangal, all the things we associate with Thai curry. The waitress said it's Malaysian curry. OK, so now I know what Malaysian curry is like! Similar to Indian curry. The thickness / consistency makes this stand out. It's almost a stew. The flavor is very good, and I *love* the consistency. Just don't expect Thai red curry!
Thai Green Curry: C
Very spicy but had no flavor other than "hot". Didn't taste like green curry. No lemongrass. No nam pla. No fish paste. No lime. There was nothing "Thai" about it. I like spicy food, but a spicy dish should have more flavor to offer than raw "heat".
Spare Ribs with Garlic Flavor: A
Beautifully grilled. Expertly cooked: charbroiled but still very juicy. There was just enough fat to really kick up the flavor and keep the meat deliciously fatty but not oily. The perfect ribs. I would definitely order this again without hesitation.
Bun Xao: A
Some physical characteristics of pad thai, but with a flavoring reminiscent of moo shu. There's a dark smoky flavor which reminds me of lapsang souchong tea. It comes with a sweet / vinegary Vietnamese dipping sauce. If you want an awesome dish and are disappointed when a pad thai is dry and no very fishy / limey, then this is a good dish to order (just keep in mind that it's a Vietnamese dish, not a Thai / Malaysian dish.)
Thai Tea: C+
Much too dilute. I barely tasted the tea. A shame. read more