Cancel

Open app

Search

Natoli's

4.5 (411 reviews)
InexpensivePizza, Italian, Delis
Closed • 7:00 am - 9:00 pm
Updated over 3 months ago

Order Natoli's Takeout or Delivery

Natoli's Photos

NATOLI'S ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Casual
Moderate noise
Outdoor seating
Good for kids

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Natoli's

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Chicken parm w vodka sauce
Paul D.

My beautiful wife located this place and when i tell you, i thanked her all the way home. Lets start out by walking in the door and getting this homely, old school italian feel. It was 40 mins before closing on a Sunday, the complete staff still made us feel lived and welcomed. They went through the menu with us, they described anything that was needed. Let's get to the beautiful ambiance, we sat outside and had a nice romantic evening together. The food was beyond delicious. I got a chicken cutlet parm with vodka sauce on a huge hero. The flavor was on point, texture of vodka sauce was NOT overwhelming. The amount of mozzarella they put on it was perfect to where it had a nice even melt. My bride ordered an eggplant wrap drizzled with sweet balsamic glaze. Cant wait to have to go to NJ for something again just to enjoy this place one more time!

Ivette V.

I've eaten from Natoli's three times. The first was a crispy chicken cutlet sandwich, the second was a penne and chicken parm meal and the third was for two slices of pizza. The chicken cult sandwich was delicious. Even with the condiments and lettuce in the sandwich the chicken was still crispy. Very, very good. 5 stars. The chicken parm was good but definitely not the best I have had. Chicken was crispy but I thought the sauce was on the bland side. 4 stars. The pizza was just okay. The slices were big which was good but the bottom of the pizza was flimsy. It may have been because I brought it home in their small box so maybe being in the box made the bottom of the pizza less crispy/a bit soggy? I'm not sure. I had to add salt and garlic to the slice which I never have to add salt to pizza. Honestly, probably better for your health but I cannot get over the soft bottom of the pizza. 2.5-3 stars. The restaurant is a small convenience store as well. Many family photos on the wall and grocery store products along the wall and in the refrigerators for purchase. I love family-owned restaurants and this place does a great job staying true to that vibe. The employees were attentive and friendly. If you are in the area, try one of their sandwiches!

White Pie
Chris A.

First time trying a pizza in the Secaucus area, I was definitely not disappointed! I normally do not like a slight thickness to crust, but this crust at Natoli's was soft, slight crunch and flavorful. The white pie is definitely one for any foodie to try. The perfect balance of ricotta cheese with baked mozzarella. You definitely can tell also when an establishment uses superb cheese, Natoli's is on point ! Quick delivery and the pie was perfect temperature.

Chicken Cutlet (Grilled or Fried)
Ivy C.

Came for my comfort sandwich (a chicken cutlet fresh mozz LTO mayo on a long roll) and was very pleased with my lunch. I think we might like this more than Gio's haha. The chicken cutlet was perfectly cooked and no yucky bits of any of that. Just good chicken. The service is I guess on the slower side but I didn't mind. It was 25 mins for 2 sandwiches but the bread was so perfectly crusty I immediately forgot about the wait after the first bite. They have some slices by the front and such which looked good. will be back for those. Adorable little place which is definitely a hidden gem.

Chicken Parmigiana sandwich.
David N.

When we decided to stay in New Jersey during our NYC trip, we knew we had to try some Taylor Ham. Natoli's had some seriously good reviews here, so it seemed like a no brainer. We decided to share the Taylor Ham & Egg sandwich and the Chicken Parmigiana sandwich. After about a 20 minute wait, they were brought to our outside table. They were both really, really good. The chicken parm was a gooey, cheesy mess but man was it ever tasty. Ditto the Taylor Ham & Egg. I loved how the ham had been crisped up on the griddle. Really terrific. The service was above and beyond, too. It's definitely not difficult to see why Natoli's is so highly regarded.

Grandma Slice
Ant R.

Best of the Best. My grandma slice was one of the best I've ever had - with a terrifically unusual sweetness in the dough. Service here is 10/10. "Robust menu" is an understatement, not to mention the nearly full stock of grocery items. Great indoor and outdoor seating areas. Pondoros and Panetones hanging from the sealing? Say what?!

Special chicken arugula

See all

Photo of AJ C.
4
59
2

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Tim L.
66
6
0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of T B.
51
3
0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Excellent sandwiches and authentic Italian food. Great customer service and good delivery time.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of B B.
0
1
0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 11 of 11

Natoli's Reviews in Other Languages

Ask the Community - Natoli's

Natolis - any plans to join a delivery service like yelp or uber eats?

No not at this time.

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 161,573 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Plaza Pizza - A slice or two (or three, LOL) of their white pie is a meal onto itself.  Creamy and delicious!!!

Plaza Pizza

3.1(150 reviews)
0.4 mi
•$

Came here after a long day of work and it totally hit the spot. I was in the area on a work trip…read moreand my co-workers and I wanted to grab a couple slices before we head back to CA. This place was great. The people working were having a good time, joking around with us and making us feel at home. The Sunday night football game was on and we all just had a great time eating a couple slices and enjoying our last night in NJ. Will definitely be going back when we head back over next year!

Formal Complaint Regarding Customer Service at Pizza Plaza in Secaucus, NJ…read more Today, October 24, 2026, at approximately 11:00 a.m., I visited Pizza Plaza in Secaucus, New Jersey, to purchase a slice of cheese pizza with bacon added for an additional charge of approximately $1.50. Unfortunately, this experience was yet another disappointing encounter with the same cashier, a gentleman of Colombian descent. This is now the third time I have visited this establishment and experienced what I consider to be an unacceptable attitude from him when placing the same order. On the two previous occasions, the cashier gave me unpleasant looks and explained that they could not keep making this order because bacon gets used up quickly and they are very busy. Although I found his attitude inappropriate, I chose to let those incidents go without making a complaint. However, today, the same situation happened again. When I placed my order, he once again gave me an unpleasant look and made a comment to another employee directly in front of me. I found this behavior extremely disrespectful and unprofessional. I want to make one thing absolutely clear: I am not asking for charity, nor am I asking anyone to give me anything for free. I am a paying customer, and I expect to be treated with basic courtesy and respect. The item I requested is listed on the menu, and I am willing to pay the additional charge for the bacon. I am simply asking to purchase the food I want and pay for it, just like any other customer. What I find particularly offensive is that every time I place this order, the cashier looks at me with disapproval and makes comments to another employee right in front of me, as though I am doing something wrong by asking for an item that is on the menu. This behavior is unacceptable and makes me feel unwelcome as a customer. Being busy is not an excuse to treat customers disrespectfully. If an item cannot be prepared or an additional ingredient is unavailable, that can be communicated politely and professionally. There is absolutely no need for unpleasant looks, inappropriate comments, or behavior that makes a paying customer feel uncomfortable. I have given this establishment multiple opportunities, but after three experiences like this with the same employee, I am extremely disappointed. Customers should be able to place an order from the menu without being made to feel uncomfortable or disrespected. I hope management takes this complaint seriously and addresses this matter appropriately. Every customer deserves respectful treatment, and no one should leave a business feeling humiliated simply for ordering food and being willing to pay for it. Thank you for your time and attention to this matter.

Photos
Plaza Pizza
Plaza Pizza - Spaghetti and chicken parm.

Spaghetti and chicken parm.

Plaza Pizza

See all

Tom's Delicious Pizza

Tom's Delicious Pizza

4.7(29 reviews)
2.4 mi

I not only love the food but the service is amazing. The two men who work in the front are not only…read moreamazing workers but very kind, professional and patient. This spot is always packed with people. I truly appreciate their patience especially with the high schoolers who act like assholes.

There are some good hole-in-the-wall pizza joints and some GREAT hole-in-the-wall pizza joints…read more This place fell into the "great" category and was actually one of the few times where I did NOT look at Yelp's reviews of a business prior to coming here. And this is none other than "Tom's Delicious Pizza". Located directly on Summit Ave (and tucked in between 17th St/18th St) in the heart of Union City, NJ, this small pizza business has been dishing out mouth watering pizza (by the whole pie or the slice) dating back to 1998 (according to their website). Best of all, they have very generous hours of operation being open Monday-Saturday from 11am-10pm and Sunday from 12-10pm. I came here during the evening of Monday 10/13/2025 at around 6pm. Since it was a cool, windy autumn day, I wanted to find something in close proximity to my Airbnb. This part of Union City is fairly easy to get to (foot, car, transit, etc.) and doesn't get too busy. However, the inside is very small with only a few seats to enjoy your pizza. Their menu is quite extensive for being such a small place. They carry traditional and unique pizzas (in various sizes) as well as wings, fries, tenders, mozzarella sticks, hot dogs, burgers, pasta, and even seafood! However, my lady and I were just craving a piping hot pizza (by the slice) and this place absolutely satisfied our cravings! The guys that worked behind the counter were great as I ordered a slice of their "Chicken & Bacon" while my lady went with a slice of "Pepperoni". Prices here are very reasonable as my slice was only $4 while hers was $3. Once our slices were ready, we proceed to sit down, add our mozzarella & Italian seasoning, and were ready to indulge. I have got to say that this place is legit amazing. Some people say that this best pizza is in NYC but New Jersey is also up there at the top. The slices here are a traditional thin while they did not skimp on the toppings. And the crust had that amazingly consistent texture; buttery, crispy, and absolutely heavenly. All in all, "Tom's Delicious Pizza" is not only delish but the service, prices, portion, selection, and nostalgia of this place made it feel as if I was in an old school neighborhood pizza parlor. And if you just happen to be in Union City, NJ (which is roughly a 15-minute drive to NYC), definitely give them a try. With that said and done, I am giving this small business a perfect five-star rating.

Photos
Tom's Delicious Pizza - Chicken/Bacon

Chicken/Bacon

Tom's Delicious Pizza - Galveston pizza, crispy crust. Small one.

Galveston pizza, crispy crust. Small one.

Tom's Delicious Pizza - Chicken/Bacon

See all

Chicken/Bacon

Natoli's - pizza - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...