Been a fan of Plaza Pizza for decades . They were the go to place for the football. Well.... We were very disappointed Believe they changed the dough, because the crust was not what we were used too. We order a pie with sausage onion and extra cheese. Think they forgot to add the extra cheese. The pie just seems dried out. Hope they go back to the old dough Or will need to find another pizzeria read more

Sub standard. Floppy crust & poor flavor. Almost $10 for 2 slices and a drink. Waste of money. read more

Plaza Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

Great pizza, great great pizza. Large slices, got me a cold cheese slice, was perfect! I do miss the Northeast and its food!!!

Very fast when I called for a pickup. The time window was accurate and I didn't have to wait. The pizza itself is very yummy . The cheesesteak pie is what me and my usually get. It is humongous. One slice is enough for dinner. The service behind the counter is nice and personable. Commented on my corgi coin purse. This is one of the better pizza places I've ever been to. Highly recommended. read more

Plaza Pizza - Large Cheesesteak Pizza (sorry I took a slice before taking a picture) - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

If i could put 0 Stars i would... First of all the food is being prepared without gloves, the people working there will work the register, scratch they behind and then go and touch your slice with their dirty bare hands! And the crazy thing is, if you ask them to use gloves they will insult you and talk nasty to you... the ambiance is one of a dirty unorganized spot that will make you feel ripped off... read more

We came here for a quick dinner, service was ok. I ordered 3 slices and garlic knots which were all good. Margarita slice was ok, needed more basil in my opinion. The veggie sliced pictured was pretty good think of a deep dish with tons of veggies on top! My child enjoyed their slice of pepperoni and the garlic knots were good as well. Good spot for a quick bite that won't break the bank & decent pizza. read more

Plaza Pizza - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

See all

QUALITY PIZZA FOR YEARS, Plaza is now my go-to spot (again)!!! Offering many slice/pie varieties with a thick/crisp crust and a great ratio of cheese:sauce:dough, Plaza Pizza delivers great value for a meal at lunchtime or dinner. Having lived in Secaucus many years ago and having tried MANY other pizzerias in New Jersey since then, one great thing about finding a new job near the plaza has been re-discovering just how satisfying a slice or two for lunch at Plaza REALLY is! I got two slices of their white pie for lunch and each one was a meal in itself. One was delicious for lunch and the other was just as good for dinner being reheated again. Returning for lunch a few days later, I felt like a kid in a candy shop eventually picking out the chicken veggie for a slice. It was just what was needed to get through the rest of the work day. The end of the week called for bringing some pies home for family dinner, so the plain and white (pictured) were the choice and they were both thoroughly enjoyed by everyone. The 20-minute drive took some of the crisp away, and I'm sure a quick pop in the oven would have restored that (as it did EXCELLENTLY with the leftovers a couple of days later), but arriving home that night to a hungry audience nixed that option. LOL Growing up in Queens, there are still some pizzas there that I prefer over Plaza's, but having tasted a LOT of New Jersey pizza over the past 35 years -- I can honestly say that theirs is one of the best I can find on this side of the river. I believe it may be even better than it was when I frequented it all those years ago!!! (There is certainly more variety than there was back then!) KUDOS!!! read more

Plaza Pizza - Plain pie was prepared well with a great cheese:sauce:dough ratio (even with a thick crust)! - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

See all

Good spot. It has been a long time since I have been here but it was just as I remember. My slices were large, tasted great and came out quick. read more

Plaza Pizza - a slice of cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

Very below average pizza. It does offer excellent parking and surly servers. It's got a lock on the Secaucus market, so why change?

Plaza Pizza is run by a rather unpleasant individual. As soon as we walked in, he said "we're closing soon, this is all we got." Okay that's cool, man. Your Yelp hours are wrong, then. We got one cheese, one Philly cheese steak, one broccoli, and one Buffalo chicken. The only one I really enjoyed was the cheese pizza. The others were just too salty and too much for me. I would just recommend keeping it simple here and being in and out. read more

This place just knocked it out the park!!! Just ordered the Chicken Francese and a slice and it was amazing! Me and my girl are picky because places will give you a bland flavor Butter noodles and call it chicken francese.. the flavor kicks and it came with 2 big chicken breasts.. the guys working there were friendly too and the place was pretty packed.. it was fire and I will be going again for sure.. good vibes all around read more

Ordered chicken Marsala and spaghetti with garlic bread.Told 45minutes. delivery,got it in 30.Piping hot,fork tender. Not 5 stars because the Marsala was a little weak.Will order again and ask for more wine in it. read more

I came here bc I was in a pizza mood tonight and tried another pizza shop in town.....let's just say the poor experience at the other shop left me hanging and wanting a solid slice even more than when I walked in. So that's how I wound up here....in need of a solid plain slice, that's it. I was served two slices that were extra well done at first so I gave it back and the staff was nice enough to replace it. The slices were solid, nothing special but not bad either. Got the job done for what I needed after the horrific experience I had 20 mins prior. Decent ingredients used and big slices which is always a plus. read more

Been going here for local pizza since my childhood. George is a great guy and cares about his customers. I order takeout from here about twice a month. The pizza is consistent. Personally, I am a big fan of their cheese blend, and find the sauce and crust are well-balanced. Not much grease like some other spots. Plain pizza, sausage pizza, stuffed pizza, etc. are some of my go-to's and they don't disappoint. They are on time with orders and are always kind and personable. Recommended. read more

Waited an hour to receive the pizza i received it cold, real cold. When I called the store they said it's cold out so what did I expect. When I asked if I can get a replacement of a hot pie , I was told it would be another hour wait. Since I already waited an hour I decided to keep it and heat it in the toaster oven . Not calling them again. Not concerned at all that as a 14 year repeated customer I was not happy with the result. read more

The pizza is great The Greek salad is a favorite of mine Clean I've been going to plaza pizza for 30 years with my family read more

The pizza is Mediocre but the attitudes that the owners have our terrible they have to treat their work era like crap because the way they treat their customers is unreal I just had someone hang up in my ear after I made an order of 50 bucks!!!! Terrible Just Terrible We need a new Pizza spot in Secacus read more

Just ordered pizza from here. And for a simple large cheese pizza it tasted pretty good. Delivery driver was nice! No complaints here.. surprisingly pizza was still hot when it got to me.. maybe next time I'll order something else off the menu.. they did me justice! read more

Plaza Pizza - Large cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

Terrible Costumer Service looks like they are doing a favor selling you a pizza I Hope the Owner's Open up their Minds for a New Era now Days Bad reviews take you out of business as quickly you begin be very careful pay attention on how you treat costumer they are the ones responsible for your business to keep up with open doors read more

Plaza Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

Plaza Pizza is a popular pizza spot in the center of the town of Secaucus. Plaza Pizza has your general pizzeria offerings and have a pretty good overall slice. Unfortunately, coming from growing up on it, I only realized now as I got older how rude often times the people behind the counter are. Reasonably so, as there are the occasional kids who goof off, but were on more than one occasion disrespectful to myself. I say you can go there for a slice, but don't expect any good customer service. read more

Interesting reading previous reviews about this pizza joint in my hometown. I have been a resident of Secaucus my whole life and pretty much seen the town change, in food variety. That being said, I love pizza where it can be a problem. I called Plaza Pizza for a delivery (half pepperoni and half veggie pizza, size large). The guy on the phone was not the nicest person, but he got to the point and I wanted to make my pizza order. Before I could tell the man on the phone to add $5 as tip (I was paying by card) he hangs up, "Yea, give it 45 minutes." I called back, told him he hung up on me and added $5 for the driver. It was my little accomplishment; don't just hang up the phone pal. It wasn't 45 minutes but 30 and the delivery guy was great. The pizza....was good. I enjoyed it very much. I believe Plaza Pizza's strengths are the plain pizza, the toppings/variety and quick delivery. Plaza Pizza can learn on being a bit nicer to it's customers. I gave the place 4 stars because it's my go to for pizza in Secaucus (minus 1 for a hint of rude customer service...at times.) read more

Plaza Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

Definitely a good slice of pizza. It's definitely a little saucier then I prefer, but still a good slice. Felt like this place could be a little tidier. I didn't feel too comfortable sitting in there to eat. While it's not my favorite place, it's ok for a quick bite of you are starving. read more

Plaza Pizza - Plain slices. The pizza is saucy. I prefer less sauce, but still a good slice. - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

See all

Best pizza on earth keep up good work plaza pizza you pizza is the best it's the best food I ever ate in my whole life every time I eat it I finish it and eat more pizza read more

What can I say, let's start with if we are in the middle of World Pandemic why are there so many tables on top of each other. Can't sit comfortably, ordered a regular slice told the guy just a little warm I don't want it hot at all. Apparently that's a concept too difficult to understand, came out of oven blazing hot with to much grease for me, into the trash it went. And the order of garlic knots I ordered didn't seem appealing to me either. That's a place I won't be going back to. read more

I am so glad I have found this place! I have tried them all... this is the best pizza in the Secaucus area. Everyone behind the counter was super friendly and accommodating! read more

This place was good many years ago when I was in H.S. (early 2000's) now not so great. Pro's are; they are open later than other pizzerias in town and plenty of parking! Also they are not cheap when asking for dipping sauce. It's the nostalgia for me. Feels like an old Pizza parlor, it's the vibes maybe it's the benches or the tiny tv in the corner. read more

Great place to grab a slice in Secaucus. The parking lot gets pretty busy at lunch time during the week. Once you find a spot, the line moves pretty fast inside. You can eat there, but it is more of a pick up spot. The pizza is served hot. The slices are very generous in size. The dough is a little thicker than classic NY/NJ pizza, but still very good. Just more of a sturdy crust. I would return again. read more

Plaza Pizza - Plain slice to go - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

On 8/29/23, I went to this place in Secaucus, NJ , I ordered two slices, and Garlic Knots. As I started to eat the garlic knots--a hair was on my food. I told one of the guys at the counter, and he said, I will replace the garlic knots, I told him I didn't want it anymore, he didn't even apologize for the inconvinience, then said next time you come I will give you the garlic knots. Really bad service--the right thing to do was an apology and get a refund for the garlic knots. I will never go back to this place. Poor Service. read more

I used to go there weekly 4 slices, plus order delivery around 2X a month. I was always very happy with the delivered dishes. But not any more. Around the spring of 2022 the delivery food took a dive. watery sauces, hockey-puck burgers, breaded French fries, dried out chicken cutlets, rubbery calamari. etc. but, as always, fast delivery. Get your groove back, kids! Still the tastiest pizza in town! read more

The pizza was good. Couldn't ask for anything else, but when we were leaving the guys accused my boyfriend of not paying for his slice. Sour taste in poor service. read more

20yrs later this place is still the best in town' i wouldn't recommend anyone to go anywhere but plaza pizza. food was excellent and i'm glad nothing had changed, read more

Plaza Pizza is ok the wait times are medium but the food is good sometimes though the food tastes a bit bad because its on different days because these poor employees have to work hard everyday and sometimes have to make pizzas fast to make everyone happy. read more

Good spot for a quick lunch or to grab a slice. Pizza tastes good. Nice display of different types of pizza. Also the chicken parmigiana sandwich is good too. The crispy chicken on the sandwich is made in house. Always a good sign when the chicken isn't pressed chicken. read more

Plaza Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

See all

Food is great, but the man who answered the phone was very rude. Would only eat here out of convenience again.

For starters, whomever answered the phone for delivery orders was extremely unprofessional and rude. Didn't ask for a name but it was a female. Excited to try a new place my co-worker and I decided to give this place a shot. We both ordered the fettuccine alfredo pasta with high hopes that it would be delicious. But the apple fell very far from the tree. Both of our pastas were tasteless, it tasted like just plain boiled noodles. It was as if the sauce wasn't even there. Absolutely no flavor whatsoever. We tried to make it work and add salt and pepper but unfortunately that didn't even work. Definitely never ordering from this place again. At least have proper customer service and be amiable over the phone if your food is tasteless. What a shame. read more

Plaza Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

Good quick bite place, good slices and garlic knots. The staff is rude and it sucks that it has to be that way!

I ordered a Caesar salad w chicken. The chicken was very good, cooked perfectly.. my main issue is the amount of dressing... literally overwhelming. I could hardly eat the lettuce because it was DROWNING in Caesar dressing.... forgot to ask for the dressing on the side and immediately regretted it. read more

Plaza Pizza - Caesar salad - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

Best pizza In Secaucus and with all the pizza places we have here that's saying a lot! This is my go to place whenever I want pizza. They also have hot meals & wraps. Plaza pizza has very reasonable prices. They deliver and have booths and tables if you'd like to eat in. I highly recommend them. read more

See all

(Visitors need to post more photos of their amazing food) Visiting from California, searched up pizza places and found this gem. You will NOT be disappointed!!! Pizza was HUGE and super tasty. Service was great, you can buy two liters of soda which is cool for families. We had chicken tenders, garlic knots and a massive Philky cheese steak pizza for with a 2 liter for about $40.00 we will be back!!! read more

See all

Simple menu Very good pie! Reviews don't have to be novels Simplicity PIZZA IS GOOD, GO GET SOME! read more