Holy shmoly, I love this place. I am not usually in this part of town, so I honestly was not sure how I would be received when I walked through the door. But the staff was incredibly welcoming right from the start, and that alone earns them five stars. You never know what to expect in a new neighborhood, but they set the tone immediately. The vibe of the restaurant is very comfortable. It is the kind of spot you walk into after a long day or a productive day and you just know you are about to eat something good. It feels like a family run place, even if it is not actually run by family. It has that warmth. You can tell it is an important part of the neighborhood. I even noticed pictures of community members on the wall, which says a lot. Now, the food. There is hot food, cold food, and plenty of items you can take home. I ordered a chicken parmesan sandwich, and let me tell you, it was the size of a skinny football. I am not exaggerating. It took me almost a day and a half to finish it. It tasted exceptional, and I actually had to stop myself from eating the whole thing in one sitting so I would not slip into a food coma. One tip, eat it while it is hot. That is when it is at its peak power. My friend agreed with me about the overall vibe and quality. If I am ever in the neighborhood again, I will gladly go out of my way just to try more of their dishes. You do not find spots like this easily. New York City has great food, but a place with this combination of warmth, quality, portion size, and charm is rare. In another city, this could easily be a reservation only spot packed every night. Here, it fits perfectly in the community. Great job to everyone there. Keep up the good work. Cheers. read more

Definitely worth it! Every time that I've been here, I have tried something new and I have never regretted it. I brought a coworker here and he said that it was the best pizza he had had in his entire life, and he still thinks of that pizza. I started coming here because most of the pizza joints that I've had on the island have closed and I usually stay in Secaucus when I visit the area, since I'd rather take a bus or pay a toll than pay the extremely high room rates in NYC! All of the staff are great, it can get busy, but assuming you're able to stand in line, they will get to you. Just don't be a jerk to the staff! The owner rightfully protects his staff from hostile customers! Just writing this makes me want to visit and pick up a Chicken Parm sandwich with a Vodka Sauce or a pepperoni pie. read more

My beautiful wife located this place and when i tell you, i thanked her all the way home. Lets start out by walking in the door and getting this homely, old school italian feel. It was 40 mins before closing on a Sunday, the complete staff still made us feel lived and welcomed. They went through the menu with us, they described anything that was needed. Let's get to the beautiful ambiance, we sat outside and had a nice romantic evening together. The food was beyond delicious. I got a chicken cutlet parm with vodka sauce on a huge hero. The flavor was on point, texture of vodka sauce was NOT overwhelming. The amount of mozzarella they put on it was perfect to where it had a nice even melt. My bride ordered an eggplant wrap drizzled with sweet balsamic glaze. Cant wait to have to go to NJ for something again just to enjoy this place one more time! read more

Natoli's - Chicken parm w vodka sauce - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

See all

I've eaten from Natoli's three times. The first was a crispy chicken cutlet sandwich, the second was a penne and chicken parm meal and the third was for two slices of pizza. The chicken cult sandwich was delicious. Even with the condiments and lettuce in the sandwich the chicken was still crispy. Very, very good. 5 stars. The chicken parm was good but definitely not the best I have had. Chicken was crispy but I thought the sauce was on the bland side. 4 stars. The pizza was just okay. The slices were big which was good but the bottom of the pizza was flimsy. It may have been because I brought it home in their small box so maybe being in the box made the bottom of the pizza less crispy/a bit soggy? I'm not sure. I had to add salt and garlic to the slice which I never have to add salt to pizza. Honestly, probably better for your health but I cannot get over the soft bottom of the pizza. 2.5-3 stars. The restaurant is a small convenience store as well. Many family photos on the wall and grocery store products along the wall and in the refrigerators for purchase. I love family-owned restaurants and this place does a great job staying true to that vibe. The employees were attentive and friendly. If you are in the area, try one of their sandwiches! read more

Natoli's - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

See all

Amazing incredible always and forever. Best white pizza ever! Can't say enough good things.

Amazing eggplant slice, slower service, quality unmatched. Friendly and helpful staff who make sure you're taken care of. Small inside, order ahead! read more

First time trying a pizza in the Secaucus area, I was definitely not disappointed! I normally do not like a slight thickness to crust, but this crust at Natoli's was soft, slight crunch and flavorful. The white pie is definitely one for any foodie to try. The perfect balance of ricotta cheese with baked mozzarella. You definitely can tell also when an establishment uses superb cheese, Natoli's is on point ! Quick delivery and the pie was perfect temperature. read more

Natoli's - White Pie - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

Came for my comfort sandwich (a chicken cutlet fresh mozz LTO mayo on a long roll) and was very pleased with my lunch. I think we might like this more than Gio's haha. The chicken cutlet was perfectly cooked and no yucky bits of any of that. Just good chicken. The service is I guess on the slower side but I didn't mind. It was 25 mins for 2 sandwiches but the bread was so perfectly crusty I immediately forgot about the wait after the first bite. They have some slices by the front and such which looked good. will be back for those. Adorable little place which is definitely a hidden gem. read more

See all

everything is amazing....food..service..and ambiance....everyone hs family....you can order anything from great italian sandwiches to great pizza..pasta...salads. you name it!!! just go....you will love it... read more

This place was great. I ordered two pizzas on Friday. One was a regular cheese. One was gluten-free for a coworker. The gluten-free pizza was very good after trying a piece. I was helped by an Italian guy who I assume was one of the owners. He was extremely friendly and very nice. He gave us plates, napkins, and seasonings for the pizza which other places do not do. The inside of the place had an old school Italian deli vibe and I can't wait to go back to try one of their sandwiches that look great. read more

When we decided to stay in New Jersey during our NYC trip, we knew we had to try some Taylor Ham. Natoli's had some seriously good reviews here, so it seemed like a no brainer. We decided to share the Taylor Ham & Egg sandwich and the Chicken Parmigiana sandwich. After about a 20 minute wait, they were brought to our outside table. They were both really, really good. The chicken parm was a gooey, cheesy mess but man was it ever tasty. Ditto the Taylor Ham & Egg. I loved how the ham had been crisped up on the griddle. Really terrific. The service was above and beyond, too. It's definitely not difficult to see why Natoli's is so highly regarded. read more

See all

Due to the high star rating we drove here from NYC on our way upstate. We give them a 3.5 rating. We bought lasagna and an Italian hero. The lasagna was okay- so much cheese but they make their own mozzarella which is nice. The lasagna noodles were over-cooked, not mushy but too soft. We weren't sure if there was ricotta in it, but their was a lighter more liquid white cheese in the center. There was also ground beef, but we like sausage but that's just our own preference. The Italian sandwich had Thumann's cold cuts- which is used in Jersey. The cold cuts were good but the bread is horrible- soft, gummy, like a subway sandwich or grocery store roll! Why????? How hard is it to get good bread? They had Diet Manhattan Special and ravioli from Queen Anne in Brooklyn- why not get bread there or at an Italian Bakery? We drove to Uncle Guiseppe's and bought crisp Italian bread and transferred the inside- which was so much better. Natoli's is old school Italian ambiance with great service, but it's nothing to return for so we won't be back. read more

Come here any time on business in the area over the past few years. Every dish has been delicious. Treat everyone like family. The daily specials and desserts are great. read more

Love it here. Great Italian deli, chicken parm with vodka sauce is unreal. They really do have a killer vodka sauce - like no other around. Never had a bad bite here. Catering is amazing here too - big sandwiches, big trays... soup, salad... you name it, these guys will do it & perfect!! This is a must go!!! read more

This was a masterclass on service. Wow. The food was 100% better than expected... and the people are amazing. read more

See all

Best of the Best. My grandma slice was one of the best I've ever had - with a terrifically unusual sweetness in the dough. Service here is 10/10. "Robust menu" is an understatement, not to mention the nearly full stock of grocery items. Great indoor and outdoor seating areas. Pondoros and Panetones hanging from the sealing? Say what?! read more

Natoli's - Grandma Slice - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

I didn't want to eat at chain restaurant and was looking for a neighborhood Italian deli . I found a gem , the service was excellent and respectful.i sat outside to relax and they brought my delicious Hero sandwich out to me . The sandwich was terrific. I enjoyed looking at all the photos and memories on the wall. I will return if I can read more

Amazing and friendly service. Awesome food. Save this as a local favorite when going to the stadium.

Worst panini ive ever had! Live here for my whole life and I know the food in this town is terrible but come on man.. do better! The balls to send this order out shows the character of the staff ... Waited over an hr for 2 sandwiches and i get. 2 pieces of chicken w ZERO mozz and LITERALLY 3 sun-dried tomatoes w dry ckn and a drop of pesto sauce !! (Ordered the Pesto Panini Not the first time I've gotten terrible food from here . Ckn parm i got few months back was similar. Spend your$ somewhere else this place has been slipping for yrs. I used to get my bfast sandwiches here all the time til i would constantly get eggs and bacon that tasted like it was cooked 3x over read more

Natoli's - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

Natoli's Deli is the kind of neighborhood spot that turns ordinary lunch into an extraordinary experience. This isn't just a deli--it's a Secaucus institution that delivers big on flavor, personality, and pure deliciousness. The service is as warm as the sandwiches are hot. The staff moves with that perfect blend of efficiency and friendliness that makes you feel like a regular, even if it's your first visit. Avoid the Lunch Rush: Hit the deli before 11:30 AM or after 1:30 PM to dodge the crowds Natoli's isn't just a deli. It's a Secaucus landmark that proves sometimes the best food comes from the most unassuming spots. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this is a must-visit destination for sandwich lovers. Mangia! read more

Amazing food and service! Just went here for dinner for my birthday and had an amazing experience overall. Food came out delicious and cooked well. Our waiter was on top of her game and made sure to check in often to make sure everything was okay and if we needed anything else. Highly recommend! read more

Always great service. The pizza and Italian subs are perfection. Every time I am in the area it is my first stop!

Needed a quick bite to eat so we stopped by. As soon as we came in, what I presume was the owner, greeted us immediately. He told us the specials and popular picks. He was attentive and patient. The service overall was great and speedy! We ended up getting two sandwiches. The portions for the price you pay is very good and the taste is perfect. The menu has a lot of variety and they're very accommodating if you need any substitutions. Recommend stopping by if you ever need a good bite read more

I'm always on the lookout for a good jersey Italian deli and this one is currently at the top of my list. Their pesto panini is my favorite thing right now, and I've ordered it at a few other (still very good) delis closer to me and it's just not as good! The service is awesome, they're always so friendly and personable - just really makes the experience more enjoyable. The space itself is a little tight but plenty of seating inside; and more seating outside on the sidewalk which is nice! We ordered to go, and ate outside but it looks like they do actual table service too. The pizza was really good, huuuge slice, everything was hot and fresh, but as I mentioned that pesto panini is my fave. And it comes with fresh made chips?! obsessed. read more

See all

Visiting the area. Found this gem tucked away. Classic Italian deli, love it! Service old school and amazing!

A great hidden gem for soup, sandwiches,heros and all things you expect from a nice Italian deli. The place is clean the workers behind the counter are attentive and gentle and not pushy read more

Food was great, friendly people, relaxed home like atmosphere. Staff was very helpful and talking with the owner was a lot of fun. Definitely recommended as well as willing to come back when in the area. read more

Natoli's - Sausage Parmigiana w/peppers & onions. - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

See all

Natoli's is a standout Italian spot in Secaucus that really delivers on both flavor and atmosphere. The menu is full of classic Italian dishes, from fresh pasta to hearty entrees, all made with quality ingredients. I tried the chicken parm and a side of their homemade pasta, and both were cooked perfectly with rich, satisfying flavors. The staff was friendly and attentive, making the dining experience feel welcoming and relaxed. The ambiance is cozy and inviting, ideal for a casual dinner or a small gathering with friends. Natoli's strikes the perfect balance between traditional Italian comfort food and a neighborhood dining vibe you can tell they take pride in what they serve. Highly recommended for anyone craving authentic Italian in the area. read more

I'm here at least twice a week to get a hero, chicken cutlets or soup. The staff is great & the prices are reasonable.

What a great deli. First time visit and won't be my last. If you're in your way to MetLife, stop by here for a fire sub. I had a Buffalo chicken hot sandwich with ranch. It was so so delicious. It's a big sub. Not too saucy but not dry at all. Bread was perfectly toasted. They have other options as well like pizza and pastas. The service is friendly and helpful. They have seating inside too with other items for sale plus it seems to be family- friendly and we love that. Don't miss out on this spot! read more

Old school family run Italian deli, store, and restaurant. Order the soup of the day (Pasta Fagoli) and it was hands down the best I've every had. The pizza was amazing and fresh. The customer service was top notch and was very attentive to us. The owner even stopped by to chat with us. Lots of locals going in and out while we were there and it's clearly a neighborhood favorite as the staff knew most of them by name. They have daily specials and great looking sandwiches. The toughest decision you'll make will be what to order. read more

See all

Great food outstanding service, Steve and his staff are the nicest people you'd want to meet.

I ordered delivery, and have to say that they were as nice as can be and delivered fast! My only issue was that the pizza just... wasn't good. The toppings were fine, but the dough and sauce tasted watery; which was a new experience for pizza. read more

We came in with a large crowd and the staff was very accommodating. Was visiting from out of town and this was the kind of neighborhood Italian restaurant vibe that you imagine when thinking of a legit New Jersey Italian experience. With such a large group the food came out relatively quickly and the food was probably the highlight of the experience. The food was fire. Got the chicken cutlet, arugula and mozzarella sandwich. Delicious. read more

Got off the highway on way home from DC to get a taste of the local flavor. This place was crowded but the food was really delicious. I had the marinated steak and eggplant special sub, it was enormous and mouth wateringly good. Fresh pasta salads, real homemade arancini, gargantuan pizzas, and lots of friendly local folks. One of those spots where you wish you had multiple stomachs lol. read more

I was in town for a Jets game and stayed at a hotel near here and gave this place a try. It was fantastic!! The sausage and peppers sandwich WAS something to write home about. I had to send pictures to my buddies back in California to show them what a real sandwich looks like! Don't get me started on the fresh mozzarella.... Had a cannoli and cheesecake as well and guess what? Both delicious! If you are on the fence, don't pass this place up!! read more

This place was amazing! What a gem....great food and the staff was friendly and took ownership offering specials and recommendations. Will be back....tonight!! read more

Natoli's - Soup of the day sample. - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

The food, service and vibe at Natoli's is outstanding. Personable and helpful staff, immense amount items of snacks and food to choose from! I'll be back again for another slice read more

Cute lil joint and the perfect place to stop for some pie. It was quick n fresh. 10/10 one of the best slices I've had in a while. Service was lovely and sitting on the patio in the perfect summer weather... I couldn't have asked for more read more

Natoli's - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

See all

The Italian roast beef subs were delicious. Roast beef was rare and plentiful. The Italian sub how a good combo of meats and cheese.