I went to Natoli's for lunch and got the Philly Cheese Steak Panini (from the Monday Specials menu) and the Panini Italia (from the normal menu). The cheese steak panini had the typical ingredients and tasted like a decent cheese steak. The Panini Italia had grilled chicken, prosciutto, mozzarella, peppers, and balsamic vinegar. The vinegar taste dominated the flavor of the panini a bit too much for my taste, but the rest of it was good. These paninis were $10 and $9, respectively which were okay prices. This deli is definitely a local spot, as it is a rather small place (although there are several tables to sit at) and is located in a residential neighborhood in Secaucus. Parking is tough, as you have to find a spot on the street. The service speed is a little slow, because they make the sandwiches after you order them, which gives them the benefit of being freshly made. The staff are very friendly and welcoming. The deli also sells a bunch of other basic grocery items including drinks, milk, beans, etc. Overall, Natoli's is a solid local deli to go to for authentic Italian sandwiches. I would recommend it if you are looking for this kind of food in the Secaucus area. read more

See all

Such an amazing experience. Great customer service and really great food! Mo made our time there quite lovely, can't wait to go back! read more

Natoli's - Chicken Parmigiana - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

See all

Best pizza We taste it since we've been here for the holidays! Customer service was amazing it was very clean , hand sanitizer on the tables. Very friendly and respectful.. Wings were amazing Caesar salad was tasty! Highly recommend, Sean & John were amazing! We will stop agin before we leave to Texas !! Thank you y'all ! read more

See all

Everything about this place was so pleasurable! The place was so busy yet the hospitality was phenomenal. The owner greeted us, served us, checked on us and checked us out. All with the biggest smile, warm conversation and saying our names. Fantastic service! Now the food.....oh holy deliciousness ! We got a small cup of homemade pasta fagoli soup and it has to be one of the best soups I've had. It came with garlic bread for dipping and it complemented it so well. The sandwich we ordered had chicken cutlet, arugula, fresh mozzarella, balsamic glaze and roasted peppers! It was so mouthwatering - not heavy- fresh, light and flavorful. Thank you Natoli's for a yummy experience . Not the last for sure. read more

See all

I was in the mood for a nice deli sandwich and this place did NOT disappoint. I called in an order for a prosciutto and mozzarella hero (because what is one without the other?) and the sandwich was ready for me when I came in. There were two cashier areas so wasn't sure the difference, but the 2nd one said he was open, had the food ready, gave me a sample zeppoli (nice and soft, although covered in powdered sugar. Delicious but dangerous!) I called the order for pick up but decided to just eat in, the guy insisted next time to tell him that so he'd get real plates and gave me a bunch of napkins and asked how it was when I finished. Really good customer service. The sandwich itself (all the toppings cost $.20-$1) was about $10 but it was monster sized. They are generous with the meats and cheeses. It was so good I ate it all, and it was too filling. Next time, I'd either get the smaller size or save half for the next day. I also want to get some of their mozzarella by itself to go, since that was a true star of the sandwich. Only downsides: it's on a street corner in a residential area, so parking at lunch time was tough. They have a lot of merchandise for sale, like a small grocery store, but not a ton of tables for dining in, most people probably take out though. The prices are good for what you get. I think the food + the service was outstanding and I definitely recommend. read more

Natoli's - Eggplant parmesan - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

See all

I'm sure many of you have your favorite Italian specialties from a place you say is the best you've ever had. Well until you try Natolis on 7th Ave in Secaucus I promise you that you will change your mind. Try their daily specials which could rival any fine sit down Restraunt or forgive me mom for saying this your home made Italian families traditional meals and soups. Ask for Steve or Alex when you go and tell them your friend Frank sent you and he may share some fresh made pasta e fagioli or a slice of his home made fresh mozzarella. Mangia read more

I had high hopes for Natoli's. Heard a lot about it. The vodka chicken parm sandwich special looked and sounded legit. Unfortunately, it didn't hit. The chicken was rubbery but the vodka sauce was delicious. The pasta fagilio was one of the best I have had. So good and made fresh in house. They also had very friendly staff and made the experience pleasant. Glad I came. read more

Nice family owned Italian restaurant and grocery in a quiet neighborhood . The food was excellent and service was as well. The portions were very big. read more

Natoli's - Spaghetti and Chicken Parm sandwich. - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

The eggplant parm hero with pink sauce was out of this world. First place in a long time that the Italian bread did not fall apart despite how much eggplant, sauce and cheese was on the sandwhich. If you're vegetarian make sure you get pink sauce not vodka sauce, the vodka sauce has prosciutto. Staff was super friendly, overall great vibes read more

Natoli's - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

WOW! Amazing Sausage Egg & Cheese!!! Everything was cooked perfect! Right amount of egg and cheese with perfect toast. Also, good portion of sausages! Made a wrong turn and got lost driving. Just walked in to grab a coffee and decided to order breakfast. They also sell pizza and italian food. Not just a Deli! Can't wait to try their pizza and other sandwiches. Looks very tasty! read more

Natoli's - Amazing Sausage Egg & Cheese! - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

I ate my lunch too fast and forgot to take a picture!! This was our second time ordering from Natoli's and definitely won't be our last! The first time, our company ordered a massive sub sandwich with all the fixins and sides. The delivery person was amazing and helped set everything up. It was absolutely delicious! This order, 2 of my co-workers and I ordered salads. I got a simple tossed salad with tuna salad on top. Delicious. Huge portion, well packaged for delivery and even came with a medium sized slice of Italian bread. 10/10! read more

I got the large half veggies and half pepperoni pizza and cappuccino for delivery. Good price. Deliver to home fast. The pizza was delicious home style and I loved their cappuccino. Only took one off is because the large half and half pizza was made so roughly that the line was not clear between veggie and pepperoni. If it was more professional and neat, it was perfect for me! read more

Great local Italian deli. An immediate sense of family and community from this small shop. My only complaint is that the wait was a bit long. I ordered the pesto chicken panini - so freaking good. Also got the egg salad sandwich on a Kaiser roll with lettuce, salt & pepper. I thought this could've used more salt but good texture. Came on a Saturday afternoon, so not sure why the wait was 20min+ but will definitely back for another sandwich. read more

Food is amazing loved the decor's and ambiance def going back the service is excellent too

Ordered a Chicken Francese and this may be the worst I've ever tried.. Pasta No Flavor and chicken No flavor.. not a hint of Lemon on either the Chicken or the Pasta.. the First and definitely the last time I order from here read more

Often I am at a loss for words due to the kindness of Steve and his employees at Natoli's. All Secaucus residents should make it a point to go out of their way to have their delicious food to support such a compassionate and great business. Food: their sandwiches and hot foods are incredible. The sandwiches are often good in size and flavor, as expected of a Hudson County deli. Pizza is average. Service: If it isn't one of the numerous people asking to help you behind the counter, it's the owner Steve himself. Everyone is always kind and it's a tightly-ran ship. Ambiance: inside is your standard grocer/deli outfit. A few small tables (limited by COVID). Not a lot of standing room at times but that's because there are a lot of people. They have a small patio in the back that is nice and comfortable. read more

Great food excellent service they have big variety and they serve you quick The food is great the workers are nice and the place even though busy you don't feel rushed read more

Love this place! We found this place on Yelp because we wanted to try a Taylor ham and egg sandwich. Loved the sandwich! We will be back when we are back in Jersey. Everyone here is so nice and welcoming, thank you for making us feel right at home! read more

Outstanding eggplant parm sandwich at this neighborhood joint! Worth the trip to Secaucus.

Excellent NJ deli Excellent people & hospitality Soups White pizza or Sicilian Chicken sandwich on roll Daily specials Fresh Cannoli read more

This place was amazing! The seating area is literally a living room but some how managed to seat 8 of us LOL. I'm from Texas and even I was surprised with the portion sizes! The sandwiches are a decent size but are stuffed to their capacity. The meat sauce lasagna was delicious and the size of a 10in plate. If you're looking for a spot that's local and feels cozy like home, this is it. Customer service was great too. For the first time being in NJ, Natoli's was a wonderful experience. read more

See all

Friendly people good food reasonable prices. Lasagna was excellent' so we're the deli sandwiches.

We stopped by for a quick bite and couldn't be happier. Pasta was great! Meat Lasagna, chicken francese and garlic bread. Can't wait to return! read more

Natoli's - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

Very quaint pizza place with delicious Italian pizza and pasta dishes! Employees were friendly and place was very nice. Pizza was best ever!! We ordered the Sicilian pizza. Each piece would have been a meal! It was delicious and very cheesy with just right amount of sauce. We ordered it with sausage and pepperoni. It was so yummy! We took home enough for three more meals! While we were waiting for our pizza we were given a cup of their pasta soup. It was very delicious with lots of pasta and tomatoes. Many thanks to Yelp for suggesting this authentic Italian Pizza parlor! read more

Natoli's - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

This place is a true must go. This is my second visit, and plan on many more to come. These guys are located right near an account of mine for work, and the hospitality, quality food and amazing taste has made this a staple in my visits. The pizza is true quality, and the taste is absolutely incredible. The garlic knots are a great appetizer, and we tried the wings, which no surprise, we're great. Huge thank you to the staff, thesee guys are great and make you feel like family. read more

See all

don't get the hype on the place - tasteless pizza , if that's there own fresh mozzarella they should start buying it from. supplier. No salt anywhere and the crust is too thick, tasteless and seems stale if that's possible. Wings were over cooked dried out. I was starving and still hungry cause I can't eat this food. read more

I loooooooove their pepperoni pizza. Anytime I'm in the neighborhood I go there for the pizza read more

Fantastic local old school Italian deli. The chicken parm sub and pizza were both really good.

Awesome place awesome service and food Quality food treated like I was a family member coming to eat. Really enjoyed everything read more

From PA stopped here to eat! Best meatball sub...huge and all meat!! Husband got sausage n pepper sun... best he ever had! Hometown feel great little place w charm n great food!! Keep doing what your doing!! Highly recommend!! read more

Natoli's - Sausage n peppers - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

See all

Blown away by the amazing food!, Customer service, Respect, authenticity and over all feel good energy of this place! A Gem. service without a doubt. The owner Steve was super attentive and even with the Covid regulations in place, made us feel as if we were at home eating a traditional Italian home cooked meal. Daily specials on the menu and easy parking. read more

Natoli's - Chicken francais italian panini - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

Killer pizza, eggplant parm and chicken parm subs. Super nice folks. What more do you want?

We love Natoli's! When mama got lazy we order food from them! Best food in town! Quick delivery and amazing service! read more

Natoli's - Family dinner at Natoli's - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

Pizza and buffalo chicken wings are fair. The dough was not crispy and it's too thick and sweet?! Didn't like the sauce... not our go to place. read more

Food is always good, regardless if it's a sandwich or pizza, or a hot dish. The one item I do recommend that is my go to, Philly Cheese steak with Hot Peppers and Provolone. their Chicken Parm with Vodka sauce, as a sandwich or with pasta is also really good read more

Natoli's - Philly cheesesteak with Hot Peppers and Provolone - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

Holy breadcrumbs and salami this place fucks! I walk in, get greeted by a couple of Italian stallion studs who promptly take my order. I ordered a chicken sandwich which was as good as it gets. Fucking love Italian delis. The owner, who I think was the father of the two Italian stallions, occasionally came out and kept those two in fucking line. "Ay, who moved the wraps in the fridge." "Not me pop, I was fucking milking the mozzarella..." Come get a sandwich here and shut the fuck up. read more

Not only a place for great NY style pizza but lots of authentic Italian dishes! Steve was very welcoming and gave us a great rundown of the menu of this 42 year old neighborhood fixture! Plain cheese pizza is not really plain when you compare cheese pizzas in the mid-west, LA and AZ. Natoli's is best eaten folded! . The broccoli rabe topped hangar steak was very delicious. All it needed was a few shakes of pepper flakes and we're off to the races! After Steve informed us how they make fresh daily mozzarella, we had to try it! He was not exaggerating! It was perfectly complimented by fresh basil and roasted sweet peppers. We sat outdoors and the total experience was kicked up a notch! Highly recommended!!! read more

See all

The care about the food they pump out . Everyplace makes egg sandwiches, but Natoli's use two eggs and toast the bun with out you asking . Thank you Natoli's read more

Incredible hospitality and Italian hoagie. Done! This is the go-to place. Delicious.

Friend of mine picked up a couple slices including a plain slice and sausage slice. Reminded me of a boardwalk slice, pretty heavy on the cheese, sausage and oil. Not my style that I typically go for, but it seems like their deli sandwiches are their forte so would try those next time read more

Natoli's - Plain slice and sausage slice - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey