Delicious sandwiches and great prices! Loved the crumb cake too . Great spot would recommend!

Have had two great sandwiches. Chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers and arugula. Had another great sandwich tonight. Energetic and friendly staff. read more

Ill make this short and sweet! I needed to get a Covid Test for work and heard about Riverside medical having rapid tests in Seacaucus. I Got my test (which was negative) and my best friend from California was visiting and staying in Seacaucus. We decided to get lunch being we were all in the area. Being unfamiliar with the area my wife looked up places and had heard about a deli (I forgot the name) but it was packed. So being we were all starving at this point she then looked on google maps "around me" that we can dine outside and found Natolis. From the food to the staff to the hand washing station outside, to the feeling at home, this place was/is amazing! We literally were back 3 days in a row for Cappuccinos and lunch. Best Cappuccinos you could find! This is now a regular MUST stop at least once a week if not more when we are able too. Every time we try something different, its always a 10! Pizza, pancakes and bacon, antipasta (which my wife says its the best she has ever had) it is all so delicious! The fact Steve who is the owner, his nephew Nicky, Lisa (who makes the cappuccinos the best!), and the rest of the staff makes you feel at home is a bonus! It is also a byob for your pasta dishes. I will post all the items we have had and everything was a 10+. Love this place and cant wait to visit over the weekend!! Wish we took more pics but were greedy! read more

See all

Terrible pizza... Thick, undercooked, mushy and no flavor Absolutely one of the worst pizza ever tried read more

Good place to stop by to grab a bite, owners very friendly, a maze to find the bathroom , other than that is a good quick stop eat and go...

Eggplant as a pizza topping is not the same as chopped up breaded Eggplant made for your Eggplant parm dish. Get with the times people, your customers expect fresh veggies and meats on the pizza not your leftovers. And the servers attitude was priceless. Not returning here. Disappointing after having enjoyed their pizzas home delivered. read more

We were teaching a medical course at the meadowlands sports complex and were told to go check this place out. It was amazing. Best chicken sandwich special I have ever had. Amazing pizza and the cannoli is better than anything I had visiting Italy. We ended up buying pies for the entire class. Ask for Steve. He took care of us and treated us like family. Will be going back to them every time we are in Jersey. read more

Natoli's - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

Super amazing food reminds me of back home in Bensonhurst nice Italian deli great people the owner is so nice and very helpful I recommend this place definitely best place to eat in Secaucus read more

Ordered delivery from here several times, always very pleasant stuff. Large pizza pie is better than the small pizza pie. Pepperoni and sausage calzone is huge and great. Chicken/prosuttio/fresh mozz panini is excellent and love the pasta figoli soup. Cannolis are also yummy. read more

Stopped by here today and boy was it good... We had a veggie supreme pizza and Italian Hero with fresh Mozzarella... Both were amazing! the customer service was great and the owner was great to talk to. These old school corner delis are a dying breed so enjoy them while they are still around especially this one!!!! read more

Natoli's - Italian hero! - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

Amazing pizzas, their Philly cheesesteak and buffalo wings are to die for. I tried the burger and I was OK. Their delivery service is very timely read more

Stopped here on a Sunday afternoon for lunch. Asked for a hot supasad with fresh mutz and roasted red peppers. Guys behind the counter said no hot, only sweet supasad. Tried the fresh mutz and it was ok. Bread was good. All in all, rather drive around the block and go to Giovanni's. read more

Natoli's - Sweet supasad with fresh mutz and roasted red peppers. Good bread. It was ok sandwich. Nothing great. - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

Second time here and it is amazing!! Paninis are the best!! I will be back!! Very friendly and feels like family

Yummy!!!!!!! I really like this place. Found it on accident. I had chicken parm sandwich. It was really good and huge!! My husband had a Cuban. Home made old school deliciousness!! Will definitely return. read more

Natoli's - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

Please be forewarned, if you're not from the area and you find yourself craving Natoli's, you'll be driving out of your way to come back. I know because I use to work nearby like 20 years ago, but still come back. First off, I have to mention the service. Yes this is an authentic Italian deli/pizzaria with 10 tables...but the "OUTSTANDING SERVICE" is better than any restaurant I've ever visited! If you're eating in, order at the counter, have a seat and relax. They'll bring your food to your table. I come here for two things, phenomenal PIZZA and they're amazing sandwiches with fresh mozzarella, numerous choice of toppings etc. The chicken parm sandwich is the best too. Act like a local when you come in, walk over to they're bread box area and pick out your roll/bread and hand it to the counter person when placing your order. They have daily lunch/dinner plates specials and cater of course. If Steve the owner is in, don't be surprised if he comes over to say hello and make sure all is GOOD. Not sure why Natoli's is two dollar $$ signs, should be $....ENJOY! read more

Natoli's - AWESOMENESS!!! - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

Natolis is a great place to eat the service is quick and dosent keep you wating. It is affordable and the pasta and pizza is delicious. read more

Natoli's - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

Best catering ever!!! We hosted our daughter's 2nd Birthday and catered food for 30 people from Natoli's. We chose Natoli's because they have an unparalleled buffet package, an array of items to choose from in their catering menu and more importantly everyone I spoke to including Mr. Natoli himself were very friendly, courteous and helpful. At the party, they delivered the food and set up the buffet with chafing trays, hot water and heat to keep the food hot throughout the party. Food quality and quantity were excellent, everyone loved the food. We had a great experience and would definitely recommend everyone. Our menu was Caesar salad, roasted baby potatoes, stuffed shells, penn a la vodka, chicken francais and cheese pizzas. Mr. Natoli was generous to send complimentary tray of grandma pizza and rice. Hands down the winners were potatoes and the chicken. I must say I love the pasta. Also, I would definitely recommend their cannolis, they are fresh and yummy. read more

Natoli's, it's been over a year since I met you and I'm still in love. I've never been to the actual deli before (we usually get delivery), and finally got a chance to go in. I love the old school Italian ambiance. It's a decent sized deli with a few tables. The service was great, very nice guys. I ordered a pizza and a meatball parm and schlepped it all the way back to Hackensack. The pizza is still the best in NJ, and my mom said the meatball parm was delicious. My only complaint (nothing to do with Natoli's) is that parking can be a bit tricky. read more

This place is Great!!!. The people are so nice an considerate. Waiting for our pizza a gentleman brought us a cup of pastafagioli, excellent!! I love this place already. And the pizza was awesome. read more

I just had a slice and a drink. Great little corner shop. The slice was good and the people were super nice/polite.

Yum Authentic Italian food,all so good and very welcoming staff and management!My first time here & definitely won't be out last.

A number of colleagues and I stopped by here for a group lunch. The dish I ordered was huge in portion and super delicious! The customer service from 1 to 5 stars is 10 stars! I live in Seattle and I'm only in town for a couple of weeks but I'll definitely be coming to Natoli's again. read more

Very old fashioned establishment on a side street where finding it is difficult. Pizza is just OK.

Anything here is friggin delicious! Ordered a number of their specialty pizzas for parties, never disappointed - Buffalo chicken, regular cheese, or fried eggplant, alllllll good Calamari is phenominal, pastas are all great (must eat it there though) and the sandwich's are really good too for the price. Lunch prices are out of this world but I always end up ordering full price which still isn't a lot. For a local pizza place this place is no joke they take the quality very seriously and you can tell the moment you walk in. read more

Got to try the buffalo chicken sandwich when you come here. Great local joint the has great food. Parking is on the street, but worth the effort read more

Ive been here twice. I had two different salads, the broccoli roll, spinach rolls, stromboli, tasty rice pudding, had a slice of pepperoni pizza, fresh bread and handy grocery items. Customer service is always great!! Keep up the good work!! read more

Natoli's - My chef salad!! It was so filling!! - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

Best-tasting pizza in town, hands-down. I don't order from anywhere else. Deliveries have typically been timely.

Amazing customer service backed by incredible food! Small family owned feeling and every person who walked in was made to feel special. I am from Las Vegas, but will go out of my way to stop here when I am in Jersey. read more

The best neighborhood deli /restaurants in all of NJ. Everything that you'd expect and more.

Always a great experience eating here. A great family runs this place, the food is well prepared and quite a treat. My kids love to stop by here often, the only shame is that they don't deliver out of town I would be on the phone ordering constantly. Stop by you will love the food. read more

The food, people and atmosphere are truly Top Notch! I was beyond satisfied with my meal and would recommend Natoli's to anyone passing through Secacus. I'm a sucker for Good Italian food and this place deserves the full 5 stars in my book...yum! read more

Lasagna. Calamari. Chicken parm. Eggplant parm. Pizza on and on and on. All your Italian comfort foods and dinners. Love this spot. Been coming since 2000 and have never been disappointed. People all friendly and welcoming. Seating is tight but it's worth the wait. Food is fantastic. Meat lasagna is my go to dish. Yummmm. read more

Found this restaurant via Yelp! My dad and I loved it. We were in the mood for a great sandwich and Natolis delivered. Super at home feel, and the food was great and inexpensive. I'm upset I don't live closer as I have craved their heroes since coming here. Everyone was super friendly, and I'll definitely be back! read more

Ordered from here twice. The first time we got sandwiches and salad and it was really good! The second time we got pizza. The pizza was okay, kind of doughy. I'd order here for hot sandwiches again. read more

This place is a neighborhood staple! From the classics bacon-egg-cheese on a roll sandwich in the morning to their extra cheesy pizza--this place is a must! Friendly service, great reputation and Italian homemade favorites! read more

What's up with all the 5 stars here? People, the food is just average, especially the pizza. If you want better pizza go to Il Fornos in Secaucus. If u want better fresh mozzarella go to Giovannis in Secaucus. If you want desserts or bread go to Vitos in Secaucus. So, as you can see that Natoli's is just sub-par to all these places. read more

Based on the excellent reviews, I guess my expectations were too high. The food was excellent. The location is a bit odd though-- a corner market that has tables in the middle of groceries. The bathroom is upstairs in what seems like an apartment or office for the owners/staff. And the water is in a cooler but they have to get it for you, which was confusing, since you get the ice first. I think. The prices are also on the higher side, comparable to a nice fancy Italian restaurant. But these are my only gripes. We ordered the calamari -- delicious. We got the chicken Parmesan over cheese ravioli -- also amazing. And hubby tried the pizza and meatball sub -- he was very happy. You order first at the checkout counter, sit and wait, then pay after at the counter again. Everyone was super friendly and busy. It definitely doesn't have that restaurant or date night feel at all, but if you want great food or takeout, this is the place. read more

Awesome family owned deli. Great food, great service.....can't possibly say enough good things!! read more

This place is the hidden gem of Secaucus. I can't say enough good things about this place. You don't have many great options in Secaucus that are local and good. Mostly chain places, etc...bleh. I have been here a few times now and each time I get something different and each time it's delicious. I've had pizza, rice balls, croquettes, hoagies all beyond outstanding. The Buffalo Chicken sandwich is amazing it is like a BBQ sandwich meets buffalo with a side of awesome. The pizza was big and delicious a sweeter sauce but plenty of it and just good. Definitely the best pie in Secaucus. I work around here so it's nice to have a good local place and not have to rely on Wendy's and Chipotle. They have a ton of different options besides pizza and hoagies and some great daily specials. They are also part bodega with basic household needs, etc. The best part about Natoli's is the people who work there. They are the most genuine and kind people. They know their customers and actually care which is becoming more and more rare. You can tell it's family owned and operated and they want people to enjoy themselves, the food and the atmosphere. If you are in Secaucus for anything skip every Chili's, Red Lobster, etc you come across and go to Natoli's you won't be disappointed. Honestly, this place just gets better and better. I eat here oh, 3 times a week easily. You need to get the roast beef on garlic bread it is a game changer. They always are there to shake your hand and ask how you're doing. I wish every restaurant/deli/bodega/hot dog stand used Natoli's as their litmus test on how to operate! Parking is on the street so it can be a challenge at peak hours but it's really not that big of a deal. read more

I came here a few weeks ago to try and nurse a couple of my hungover friends back to life. I got 1 chicken soup, a bacon, egg & cheese & pork roll, egg, & cheese. The breakfast sandwiches are made on rolls. I really enjoyed mine. It was filling, just what I needed, and I felt wonderful and revived after. Natoli's seems to have a lot of stuff, like a deli/convenience store combo. It also seems like there's a nice sense of community here, in that everyone seems to know each other and are friendly. I saw someone picking up these GIANT subs. Looks like it'd be a great place to get catering from. I have a feeling that their pizzas and italian dishes are amazing, so I'll have to go back sometime and try more. read more

Natoli's - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Secaucus, New Jersey

See all