I really like this pizza! My husband and I usually order two pizzas (cheese & pepperoni) so we can…read morehave some leftovers. I'd definitely recommend checking this place out for the pizza. It's a great alternative to all the bar pizza in the area! :)

This place is great. Sub, pizza, salad, you can pick it up in 15 minutes. Decent quality…read moreingredients. They remember your name.

I don't recommend this place due to a complete lack of accountability and poor customer service…read more I placed an order through their website using the Slice app and received a confirmation text saying it would be ready at 6:08 PM. Since the location was only about 6 minutes away, I left at 6:00. I initially went to the Brockton location, but they didn't have my order. I immediately called the Whitman location (the correct one linked in my confirmation), and the owner/manager told me they didn't have my order either and suggested it might be at the Brockton location--which I had already confirmed wasn't the case. After checking again, I called back, and he said they would "look into the Slice app" since they hadn't received the order and would start making it, with a 30-minute wait. By then, I had already been waiting about an hour. When I arrived, I was told they hadn't even started cooking my food. The manager said it would be another 20 minutes and made a dismissive comment about possibly making my order sooner if they finished someone else's first. There was no apology, no accountability--just attitude. After waiting even longer, I finally got my food, only to have the owner try to blame me for going to the wrong location, even though I had contacted the correct one right away and was told the order wasn't there. He then claimed the Slice app "doesn't work properly" and that I should call instead. I later contacted Slice, and they told me the owner reported that I went to the wrong location and they couldn't accommodate me--which is not true. If the Slice app doesn't work, why use it at all? This experience was frustrating, time-consuming, and handled very unprofessionally. I won't be returning or recommending this place.

Supreme is the best GREEK pizza in Whitman. They also have really good salads here. We love the…read moregold fever chicken salad. Kids love their pizza as well !

The outside of the restaurant now says Hook Pizza but the boxes still say Peel Pizza. We are…read morevisiting in town and stopped to grab something quick. We ordered 2 calzones, cheese bread sticks and 2 sodas. I couldn't believe when we got the bill. The meal was 74$ before tip. They charged us 3.12$ per topping. Sadly, the food was terrible. The calzones were doughy, barely any topping and mine had pepperoni in it, which I didn't order. The cheese bread sticks were more like crackers, very thin and not much flavor. I absolutely would never recommend this restaurant.

Best pizza in the area we go there every time we head through Scituate…read morePrepared on time, served hot wonderful The chicken wings are the best

Can't talk about ambiance because we got delivery. However the pizzas we got were very good…read moreespecially the Hawaii. The food was also delivered to the almost to the minute of what they promised. The delivery guy was very friendly also Definitely will get again

Mehh. Average pizza. Nothing great about it but nothing terrible either. I've had both better and…read moreworse... It's greek style pizza which I'm very particular about as I feel it's easy to mess up the flavor/texture of the crust. I've had both a plain cheese pizza and a half cheese/half mushroom pizza. The pizza with the mushroom slices tasted better than the plain cheese (IMO). Regardless, I would still recommend checking it out and deciding for yourself ;)

We stopped in while visiting family and needed a quick, kid-friendly spot before a long drive…read morehome--Anthony's was perfect. Huge pizza slices (seriously, massive) made it easy for everyone to get what they wanted, especially with separate checks. Whether you're dining in or grabbing to go, it's fast, casual, and hits the spot. Solid choice for families, groups, or anyone just craving good pizza without the fuss.

I had to try the biggest slice as I have heard how delicious it was. From the friendly cashier…read moreexplaining each slice was so helpful! Oh my gosh! I got two slices of hot honey roni ricotta and I am blown away. I spoke to the owner who I think is Anthony himself, and this is a family recipe for over 50years! Keep it up Anthony's! I'll be back soon!

Pizza was exceptionally good, not really a fan of MA pizza being from NY but this was the closest…read moreI've found so far. Crust was done well, perfect thickness good amount of cheese and sauce. Cheesy bread was very tasty, (would of liked the marinara warm - it was cold ). Chicken tenders were not dry at all and the sauce was not overpowering. All and all will definitely be going back. Delivery is a bit too slow for me - (1.5 hrs) so I went and picked up.

When my online order was made incorectly, they refused a refund. I had been a customer of ten…read moreyears. I will never eat there again. The cusotmer service they showed was terrible. Do not order from here. Ive gotten plenty of wrong orders from this place and said nothing. They have a problem with their online ordering, but dont want to hear about it. Instead theyd rather loose a good customer. They can fuck.

Pretty consistent, good variety of pies, efficient staff and everyone is pleasant…read more Loses a star bc they don't put enough sauce on their pizzas. I have to custom order it every time and the last two STILL wasn't enough. If they pay better attention to their custom orders it's a high 4 star place.

Good quality food and prices fairly. They are quick with orders and rarely disappoints.read more

I wrote a nice review on this pizza shop awhile ago and at that time I rated it one of the best…read more I ordered a pizza there the other night and they changed the crust and it was awful. It tasted like cardboard and was thin. I called them and asked why they changed the crust and was told it was the same. No way was that the same crust. They offered to give me my money back and I said, no that's not the reason I am calling, I just wanted to give you a heads up because they will be losing customers like myself. She said, we want to make it right so I suggested the only way was to get back that original crust they had. Why do restaurants change a product when it's delicious? To save money? Thinner crust? Omg, wake up , you are going to lose money.

This is a great family owned restaurant great food and for a while reasonably priced I would…read morerecommend this if you're close to Abington or Brockton