Food and service is always 10/10! The sweet buffalo pizza will be one of my last meals if I'm lucky. They are always so kind and deliver without issue even though I'm the next town over. read more

A very good place to get a sub or pizza. Unfortunately, closed on Sundays. I'm very picky and my order was made perfectly and delivered earlier than expected. I highly recommend them! read more

Sweet Buffalo chicken pizza was one of the best pizza's I have ever had- definitely a must try. I have never had sweet Buffalo but I saw a review about it before trying this place for the first time so we decided to try it and like I said it was amazing. If I'm ever in the area I'm 100% coming back just for this. Great service as well thank you! read more

Big ol' calzone and a well-received plate of chicken tenders with seasoned double-fried fries (you know the kind) for $24 delivered. Not a bad deal at all. The 'zone - the original Spicy Chili Chicken with fresh pineapple - is said fried tenders hunked out, tossed in sweet chili sauce and layered with provolone (?) and a handful of mozz, piled up with pineapple and baked in to the world's biggest Hot Pocket. Blue cheese on the side. Here's the thing: flavorwise, it wasn't my bag. There's no tomato base to bring acid or herbs to the mix, and no ricotta to smooth out the sugar chili sauce. So it was, in essence, oversauced chix tenders and some cheese in a bread pocket. Again, not my bag, but was it well-made? Yeah, it was. And the wife digs those flat, crumb-breaded tenders, so bonus points. I would order again, opting for a more traditional pie - the bake is solid. read more

Blue Moon Pizzeria - Chili chicken with fresh pineapple calzone - Pizza Near Me - Norwell, Massachusetts

See all

Had the chili chicken and pineapple pizza tonight, wow!!! Delicious! Barbecue chicken last week was on point. Had a little balsamic glaze on it that when mixed with the onions and barbecue chicken and sauce made for an amazing taste! Honest review , a must try if you are in the area ! read more

Great place, excellent service and amazing food. Stop by and try it out! You won't be disappointed

Good pizza can be hard to find but great pizza is even harder to find. Tried Blue Moon for the first time last weekend and it was GREAT! We had the Sweet Buffalo Chicken and we did a meatball and roasted pepper combo. Both pizzas were perfecting made and were delicious! The crust was so tasty! Can't wait to try some of the other pizza on their menu! I highly recommend you try Blue Moon Pizzeria! read more

Delicious pizza and salad. Wish we had tried them sooner! The delivery driver was so polite. What a great representative for the company! Will be ordering again! read more

Ordered the sweet buffalo chicken pizza for delivery. First of all, took almost 2 hours for it to get here. Pizza was still good. If you like sweet pizza with a side of spicy it's a great choice. A little disappointed it arrived only mediocre warm. There's better pizza places around Norwell. Would probably be better if I had went and picked it up versus having it delivered. read more

Best, most consistent pizza in the area. Owner is super nice, staff are great. After one too many black bottomed pizzas from my old pizza place I tried them and won't go back! read more

This place is awesome. The white pizza and sweet Buffalo chicken were so good! The Greek salad was such good quality. It was our first time here and we'll definitely be back ! read more

Our go to pizza delivery spot since we moved to Norwell last year. Delivery can take awhile when it's busy, but the the pizza is consistently very good. I always get the Sweet and Spicy buffalo chicken and my wife the Caramelized onion. Definitely recommend it read more

Blue Moon Pizzeria - two pizzas in a box - Pizza Near Me - Norwell, Massachusetts

What a wonderful establishment! Recently I heard it was under new management and I was intrigued. Well, I showed up after being away in Texas for several months and decided to try the sweet buffalo calzone and Gorgonzola salad (my family ordered a meatball panini, Greek chicken salad wrap and a buffalo panini, and pizza). I called and was given a 20 minute wait time and when I showed up it was ready and piping hot, cooked to perfection. Im not kidding when I say it was probably the best food I've had all year. The sweet buff is truly addicting and the salad had all the right ingredients to be absolutely delicious. My family said the same about the rest of the meal. I was really impressed with how clean and organized the shop was, considering everything going on, hygiene is key! The actual pizza shop was really nice- I love what they've done renovating the counters and walls but still keeping the famous blue moon blue walls with a fresh coat of paint! The phone girl was so sweet and the new owner was there himself, making sure everything was going smoothly due to the current guidelines in place. Honestly the food was amazing, I think I'm going to cry when I have to go back to Texas!!! Safe to say I will be eating here multiple times a week while I'm home!! read more

Pizza is decent, but the person answering the phone sounded miserable and hung upon me after I gave her my name and delivery info. The delivery boy over charged us by several dollars. I would recommend another pizza delivery! read more

This place used to have great pizza and subs now it's consistently not good. Over the past two years I gave Blue Moon numerous chances for redemption but after another bad experience yesterday I am cutting ties with this formerly beloved local pizza shop. read more

This used to be our favorite Pizza joint in Norwell but those days are gone. It is either under new management or the owners do not give a dam anymore. If you order delivery you get charged for the service and then the food is cold and if you are very lucky .....you actually get what you ordered. Our last 3 orders have been messed up. If you like getting Surprise,cold Pizzas, this is your place. For me, I will rather drive the extra 10 min to place where I know I will get what i ordered and I am served without attitude. Name says it all once in a Blue Moon you get your correct order read more

Visiting the south shore and stopped by this pizzeria for lunch. I've heard good things about their pizza, but we opted for some panini sandwiches to go. The two we tried, turkey and the vegetarian with eggplant, were subpar to say the least. For nearly $10 a sandwich I would have expected more filling in the sandwiches. Perhaps that was a mixed blessing because the ingredients that were included were over cooked and left the two of us with indigestion. The bacon was off, the eggplant over cooked, and the flavors just didn't blend together well. read more

Blue Moon is my go to spot for pizza. I find their sauce to be just right. Delivery has greatly improved. Best pizza in town. Thanks to the staff for their work during this crazy times. read more

Showed up after extremely late with an inside out pizza box (???) saying "Ron" on it, for pepperoni. Pizza was mediocre at best. Good for a laugh but not much else. read more

I rarely if ever write a review. Hoping that this helps other people out. The food? Great. Never had a bad thing from this restaurant. However make sure you have the time to drive over there and place your order and wait for it. If you are planning on calling it in just save yourself the time and call somewhere else. No exaggeration it is easier to get a hold of a breathing person at the RMV then it is to get someone to pick up the phone here. read more

Lots of comments about business under new management, it is and I have noticed! Positive change for a business is not easy to effect at first when you are just trying to grab your breath after a huge leap of faith. These gentlemen have done it with such grace and strength. Excellent pizza, friendly staff, and great delivery. Give these gentlemen the benefit of the doubt it's worth it. read more

Food is good, and service is quick, but literally EVERY single time I have ordered something from Blue Moon, they get something wrong in the order. Every time, without fail. The people who work there are nice, and I haven't had any issues while ordering face to face (which I almost never do anyway), but every phone order has gotten something wrong. Whether its an order outright missing something (eg no chicken on salad), including the wrong topping (grilled instead of crispy chicken, one cheese instead of another, one soda vs another) something is off. Most of the people who take the orders over the phone and do the delivery seem really, really young. Like high school age. read more

This place rapidly became a Norwell institution. Their pizza is pretty good but the move here is to get the sweet buffalo chicken calzone. You definitely have to be int he mood for something sweet, but I have yet to have a calzone quite like it. It's delicious. I also love their Cape Codder sandwich - a chicken salad with cranberries on ciabatta. Yum! read more

Love the owner and the food has been good each time we've ordered. My only disappointment is the young helpers who answer the phone. They need some training on how to answer the phone and how to treat customers. No "thank you" nor "your welcome"! Just ordered some food and I felt like I was really annoying the girl who picked up the phone. I said thank you and she just hung up!! ‍ read more

Owner is such a friendly guy and the pizzas are always great. Pepperoni will always be my favorite but the chicken and fries pizza is yummy too. Buff chicken calzone is definitely my favorite item on the menu. My go to pizza place in Norwell. read more

So disappointed...delivery time is getting longer and longer every time we order. They say 45 mins to an hour (which is bad enough)...it's now 1.5 hours after we ordered (on a Wed night, not even a weekend night). Update: delivery person just called and said 'your address does not come up on my GPS'. Are you for real?! Now 10 minutes from 2 hours for delivery. Unbelievable. Blue Moon...hire more delivery drivers! read more

Have been waiting over 2 hours for my food, did not warn about longer than usual wait times at all, but reading their reviews, it appears to be their norm to take FOREVER. Will NEVER order from here again. Even talked to the owner and he said "yeah, sorry, we've been busy." OKAY, that's fine, but WARN your customers. Don't order unless you want to starve first. read more

All done with Blue Moon. Delivery time is often quoted as 30-35 mins, yet consistently delivered 1- 1/2 hrs later, cold, and after closing. Unfriendly, unhappy staff on the phone. They repeatedly say they are too busy and "sorry", but this is a pattern. read more

We started getting pizza from Blue Moon several months ago. We usually get their white pizza which is excellent with some fries or some other appetizer. The pizza is very good and so are the apps. The service is always friendly and our orders are ready in the time they tell us. read more

Pizza is delicious but due to the girl answering the phone I will never go there again. First time I ordered delivery she was abrupt and when I tried to explain entrance is in back of house she ignored me. I know this because when the delivery guy showed up he went to the front! Did not even try the back. I had to go outside and fetch him. Tonight I called again. Same girl. Rude and kept yelling she couldn't hear me and then told me call back on a landline! One, I don't have a landline and two I just hung up the phone with another Norwell friend and she heard me just fine. I'm not sure what her issue is but I work in Customer Service and her attitude is totally out of line. Ordered from Boston Pizza online. So much easier and no attitude to deal with. I can see from other reviews that she is an issue to everyone as is the delivery. If they care about losing customers they may want to rethink training their staff. read more

First time trying this place was last night. So glad we found it! Pizza was amazing. You can tell how fresh the dough and toppings were. We will be coming back!!! read more

Blue Moon has lost my business. Used to be my go-to spot for years. Kept giving them second chances but as of lately, the pizza is so unappetizing and not worth the $$$. PAPER THIN and extremely dry like eating cardboard. Felt like I was breaking my jaw just trying to bite into a slice. read more

best pizza on the south shore, and they have free-to-play mortal kombat arcade machine! try their white pizza or their pesto pizza++ i've caught a lot of local farm trucks making deliveries to blue moon when i stop by the adjacent dunkies in the morning. seriously FRESH. read more

Blue Moon offers a great variety of pizza - the crust is tasty and never to greasy. We love the fresh ingredients. We tend to pick up a margherita, a sweet & spicy chicken, and a white pizza with a couple of freshly made salads. We've never been disappointed! read more

Took an hour for a delivery of one cheese pizza. Pizza box was inside out and entire base was burnt. Delivery guy was nice. Other reviews suggest an anomaly, but we won't be ordering from here again. read more

This pizza made it into my top ten list!! Great crust and sauce and cheese. Try it, does not disappoint and I am Italian so very hard to please! read more

After moving to the South Shore a few years ago I have on occasion tried to find a palatable pizza. A lot of the places around here seem to use a Greek style pizza dough that can only be described as crispy and greasy .it almost seems as if the bottom half of the pizza is cooked in a fryer . Thankfully someone recommended Blue Moon to me. Whenever I want to have pizza I will go out of my way and drive extra 30 min. so that I can have a decent tasting pizza The cheese on the pizza actually tastes fresh as if it was shredded in-house. R dont The sauce on the pizza had a nice clean flavor profile. The tomatoes ,garlic and spices blended together quite well without any overpowering flavors . The pizza dough is usually perfect, the crust is slightly chewy with a nice warm bread like center that is never oily or overly greasy. Only once during my many visits did I ever have a problem. The dough under the sauce and toppings was slightly burnt on the bottom. I told the man working behind the counter and within about 10 to 15 min. I had a perfectly cooked pizza once again. read more

Two words: Margarita Pizza. Two more: THE BEST! Eh, screw it. I won't order this pizza like, anywhere else. Yum! read more

First time ordering from blue moon. I've been waiting an hour an half for my deliver and every time I call the phone keeps on ringing or it's busy. Girl on the phone told me 50mins-1 hr. Never ordering from here again. read more

Quality, quality, quality. The freshest ingredients and people who care about the food they create. They even grow their own herbs. After 5 visits there (all take out) we have not been disappointed once. The food is amazing. Great mix of ingredients and brilliant combos of toppings. Fell in love with Gorgonzola and Onion! Also a fan of the Spicy Hawaiian and BBQ Chicken with Pepper Jack cheese too. Really small seating area inside, but they do have a patio. read more