This could be one of the most confusing groups of reviews I've read on a restaurant. Either people love it or hate it. I went with a friend for lunch yesterday (Thursday), and after trying pretty much all of the major restaurants in the Hingham/JNorwell/Cohasset area, this restaurant was clearly at the top of my list. We were served the Wagyu Beef Sliders and the Bacon & Carmelized Onion Arancini for appetizers, and the Pulitzer Short Rib Burger and Norwell Hot Chicken Sandwich for entrees. I say that we were "served" those things because we actually ordered the Bavarian Pretzels and not the Wagyu Beef Sliders, but because the sliders were so delicious, we figured that we'll try the pretzels on the next go around. All four of our dishes were absolutely fantastic. The sliders and arancini were absolutely top-notch. I've had so many average arancini that I forgot what it's like when cooked at a high-level. It's as good as any I've had anywhere. And the Pulitzer Burger is now my favorite burger ever. Just the right amount of char on the outside with the inside a perfect medium. The chicken was moist with fantastic seasoning. The unexpected surprise were the fries. The fries here are outstanding. And they achieve something that I've never seen anywhere else: their fries are "pillowy". They are crispy on the outside, but the inside is remarkably moist and fluffy. I'd have to categorize these as steak fries, but steak fries are usually a bit denser. Service was terrific, and the decor of the place is not "dated", as another reviewer commented. The place was clearly built to give off a classic and intimate vibe. I didn't try any of the fish offerings this time, but I plan on returning and checking them out. It blows my mind that I never heard of this place until a few days ago. read more

I had brunch here for the first time last Sunday. While the atmosphere was pleasant enough, the overall decor felt a bit dated. Unfortunately, the service felt rushed and somewhat impersonal. Our waitress was responsive when she was at the table, but she tended to disappear for long periods of time. As for the food, it was honestly just average. I ordered the Eggs Benedict, and I'm sad to report it was a disappointment. The hollandaise was cold, the eggs were over-poached, the English muffin only was toasted on one side and the hash browns lacked flavor. Even the coffee I ordered with my meal arrived lukewarm. Surprisingly, the best part of the experience was the Bloody Mary I had at the start of the meal. Maybe the the food would be better during lunch or dinner service. I might give them another try in the future and hope for a better experience. read more

Cheever Tavern - Eggs benedict long fries. - New American Near Me - Norwell, Massachusetts

Had brunch at Cheever tavern and it was good. They had a nice seasonal drink and food me menu with plenty to choose from. We had the breakfast bowl and basic breakfast and tried the French toast. The food was solid and service was good. Nice local spot to try. read more

Cheever Tavern - New American Near Me - Norwell, Massachusetts

We had friends visiting from New Jersey and on their last night with us we decided to go to Cheever Tavern. As we pulled into the parking lot it looked lovely with many guests dining on the pretty outside patio. We hadn't made reservations but were able to be seated indoors right away. The wait for an outside table was estimated to be 25-30 minutes. As it was muggy out we were better off indoors. Our waiter was very nice and ultimately quite efficient. However another waitperson had apparently called out sick and our poor waiter was extremely busy resulting in a bit of delay in service. But it was fine. The menu had lots of options with I'd say something for everyone. I appreciated that the beverage list included mocktails and non-alcohol wines. I opted for a non-alcohol wine and it was quite good. My husband had ice water and our friends had two different kinds of wines. We skipped the appetizers. I ordered the French dip sandwich Tom had the spicy fried chicken sandwich. One of our friends had chicken piccata and the other had a salad with halloumi and peaches. My sandwich was tasty enough but the steak although thinly sliced had gristle. The fries which were interestingly cut like potato chips were dry and bland and in need of salt. I would not order this dish again. Disappointing. Everyone else seemed to thoroughly enjoy their meals. We were seated at a high top table which was fine, but I would have preferred a regular table. All and all a good first visit. I would return, and in fact would like to while it is still good weather so we can sit outside. The outside dining seating options are compelling. This was a 3 star experience for me based on my gristly meat but a 4 star it seems for everyone else. read more

We enjoyed dinner outside. Our waitress was great - very attentive and helpful. We started with the Buffalo cauliflower - full with flavor. It was even better when we asked for a side of ranch. For entrees we had the burger and the chipotle lobster roll. The fries were so good! Both meals were delicious! We'll be back! read more

See all

This is not our first time here, but we are always more impressed each time. Zak always recognizes us and treats us like regulars! Travis is always so welcoming as well. We will be back! read more

Finally got the chance to try Cheever tavern and it was wonderful! We sat inside just due to the heat, but the outdoor space is lovely and I think it would be so nice in late August-September. The indoor space is cozy and there are both tables and bar seating! The Brussel sprout app was so yummy and definitely could feed 2-4 people. The ribs were delicious and perfectly cooked. I love how they make their own sauces, I really think it makes their dishes more unique! I didn't get any of their drinks but the ones at tables around looked good! Definitely a new go to spot on the south shore! read more

Cheever Tavern - Apple butter BBQ ribs - New American Near Me - Norwell, Massachusetts

See all

First time having lunch here great service as we always The food was delicious but limited since it's lunch

Great spot. Small inside so you'll want to get a reservation if you're trying to visit on a Friday or Saturday night. Food was great, got a burger and bolognese, both were delicious. Looking forward to coming back to sit outside when the weather gets nice! read more

28 dollars for a pumpkin tortellini with only 8 pieces of pasta is kind of absurd.... Skip this read more

Cheever Tavern - Pumpkin tortellini - New American Near Me - Norwell, Massachusetts

Brunch last Sunday. We were one of the first parties in the restaurant and waited a long time for 4 drinks. The chicken and waffles was cold when it arrived. Asked for butter and it came 15 minutes later. The whole experience was average at best. read more

Date night! Sat at the bar to watch the game, grabbing the last 2 seats just before 5 pm on a Sat night. Great drinks, loved the Maine beer flight they offered, and the food was very good this time (burger sliders, buffalo dip, calamari, and Caesar salad). Friendly and attentive bartenders. Will definitely be back to sit at the bar as it was a great experience. read more

***DO NOT TRUST GLUTEN FREE OPTIONS*** I went to Cheever Tavern with my husband because their menu online showed a lot of gluten free options and I have celiac. When I ordered, my server assured me it would be gluten-free and that she would even let the kitchen know. Half hour after I left I knew I had been given gluten. The rest of the night was a horrorshow. Upon contacting the restaurant and asking a manager to call me, I have still not heard anything. A total disgrace. If I could leave 0 stars out of 5, I would. read more

We found this place on Yelp As we always do. Nice clean restaurant in a residential neighborhood. Very friendly staff. Indoor n outdoor seating. We ordered the crab cakes, fried calamari n maple roasted Brussels. Both Crab cakes were good size n good n the Brussels sprouts were crisp n tasty. The fried calamari was good too. Generous portions. For entrees we had the Pulitzer burgher, bourbon steak tips, scallops w seafood risotto n beet salad. The scallops were yummy n moist perfectly cooked. Seafood risotto tasted good. Beet salad was very good w toasted caramel iced walnuts n goat cheese. We topped our meal with tiramisu, chocolate lava cake n crème brûlée. The molten lava cake was heavenly. The tiramisu n crème brûlée were good. Tx 4 a Great meal Cheever tavern. Will be back again next time we r in the area. read more

See all

Well looks like it's over for us at Cheever.I tried to give it another try!So dissatisfied!!I ordered the seared scallops with glazed carrots and some sort of purée!Just awful!!Scallops were raw and not sure they were real as I never saw scallops that looked like quarters(coin)the carrots were barely cooked and couldn't eat them!The dish just didn't go together well!Not sure what's happening at Cheever but after 3 bad experiences in a row I'm done!!To bad as it's so difficult to find decent food on the south shore!! read more

I've been to Cheever Tavern multiple times and honestly have never been disappointed. The rotating menu and drink specials always keep it fresh and the staff are always spot on. I will definitely be going back read more

Sat inside in the dining room, when we arrived only one other table was taken and we were surprised that we were led the the table right next to the occupied one. I asked for a different table (party of 4) and was told that I could not have the one I was next to but could have the table in the corner (which was perfect as it had two windows). When we left the three tables which I was told were not available had not been occupied. (what a surprise....) Second issue - when we went to order a flight of margaritas listed as $18.00 on the menu we were told that the flight costs $25.00. How about manually updating the menus??? Food mediocre - I had the peach and halloumi salad but the dressing was too sweet. Also confused as to why they list 'Aperitifs' on the dessert menu - an aperitif is taken before eating to stimulate the appetite...??? read more

Have been here 3x. 2x for dinner and once for lunch. Very nice ambience and the food is very good. The service could use some improvement, once they take your order you are left alone. Need to flag down someone for water or whatever you may need. Dishes were whipped up without any question of asking if we were done or would it be ok to take our dishes. Last time we were there ( about 6 mos previous) for dinner, they added on a charge for kitchen staff and taxed the whole bill. Did not see this charge at lunchtime. Maybe they did away with it? will definitely go back. read more

Our first visit to Cheevers, excellent experience. I had French dip ( called something else) but it was a 4.2 excellent and the Fries, 4.9-5.0 different, nice. Wife had Cod dinner, light , big, fluffy, 4.0 Daughter- the Thai - she loved it- 3.9 Son-in-law- Risotto 4.5 Cauliflower 5.0 Calamari 4.7 Bottom line, impressed and Sam our waitress did a great job Going back read more

How cozy is this place?? I loved the vibes the minute I drove into the parking lot and saw the beautiful cemetery (I love cemeteries!) next to the restaurant. My husband and I came here for lunch and sat outside on the deck overlooking the cemetery. It was so calming, peaceful and relaxing. My husband ordered the Norwell chicken sandwich and I got the fish & chips. The chicken sandwich looked amazing; a giant piece of fried chicken topped with a very appealing-looking sauce. My husband inhaled the sandwich before I could ask to try a bite! My fish was fried in a very unique and very thick batter. I wasn't sure what to make of it - I didn't love it but I didn't hate it either. But what I did love were those fries!! They were like thin steak fries with a slight curl to them, perfect for dipping! I'd definitely come back here to try other things off the menu. read more

See all

Susan and I had a delicious late brunch at Cheever today -- mine was the West & River sandwich, Susan had the Basil Pad Thai with chicken, and we split the Caesar salad. All were perfect, and generously portioned. Teddy, who took care of us, was attentive without being intrusive, and just a delight to talk with. We don't get out much, but will be back to Cheever soon, and ask for Teddy again. Thanks for a great time! read more

This is our second time. We love the ambiance, sitting outside. (The partner really loves that it is next to a cemetery.). The bartender was helpful with the drinks, but the food was a bit hit and miss this time. The Brussel sprouts had wonderful spice and flavor but they looked like an unappetizing darkened mess. The Mediterranean pizza was really a flatbread, tasteless, and light on toppings. The cauliflower however with sweet chili and ranch dressing was excellent. The warm chocolate cake was really more of a brownie. read more

Cheever Tavern - Warm chocolate cake (but it really is more of a brownie) - New American Near Me - Norwell, Massachusetts

Sevice was slow and food was average. We were expecting better from the reviews we read on line. I would not go out of my way to dine here.

Food: bland as all get out. Service: very poor, waitstaff rude/useless Ambiance: Honeypot - it looks really nice (and on the surface it is) but holy fartballs for what they are charging (with zero shame) either go over to the Tinker's Son or somewhere else. End: Scarlet Oak wannabe - at least at the SO you get what you pay for. Avoid. read more

Stopped in here Saturday after hearing about it from a coworker. We arrived on the earlier aside, (about 4:30) and the place was busier than I'd expected but we found two seats at the bar without issue and there looked to be a good amount of open tables in the dinner room and outside seating. Servers at the bar were friendly and attentive. Food was good, prices on par with most restaurants of its type. Ordered the maple chili Brussel sprouts app which was fine but not particularly sweet or spicy, so slightly underwhelming. My wife ordered the orange salmon and when they dropped it, which was probably one of the largest portion I've ever seen out, easily 6-8oz. That being said, it was very good. Sometimes you see portions like that, especially on something like salmon and it's a red flag that it's not going to be good or fresh, that wasn't the case. I got a salad with blackened chicken which was good, pretty standard. For me, the lemon blueberry cake was the highlight of the evening, whipped lemon cream cheese frosting , need I say more? I'd definitely go back on a warmer night and sit outside, not that inside was bad, it's a lovely building but the fire pit and patio look like a must try. read more

This is a 4.5 star review. A few weeks ago, I dropped by this place for lunch. I had a bit of trouble in finding the restaurant but finally I was able to locate it. The restaurant was situated right next to the cemetery which kind of gave a weird vibe. Fortunately, it was during the daytime. The outdoor seating was very nice and there were heated lamps and a fire pit as well. I got the smoked brisket tacos as an appetizer and the Italian pork sandwich for my entree. The tacos had smoked brisket with an apple cranberry almond slaw and barbecue sauce in a corn tortilla. It tasted really good but I preferred that the tortilla was warm. The pork sandwich was phenomenal! It had roast pork loin with broccolini, provolone cheese and roasted red peppers on a brioche bun. It was delicious and the au jus wasn't really needed. The side of truffle fries was awesome as well. The potatoes were sliced thin and were crispy on the outside and fluffy inside. For dessert, I got the chocolate fudge cake which came with whipped cream, salted caramel sauce and a side of almond joy ice cream. The cake was surprisingly good and wasn't too sweet. Service was prompt and friendly and the food was surprisingly great! The only thing that bothered me were the number of bees and flies flying around the outdoor patio. Other than that, it was an enjoyable experience. read more

See all

Awful! Rude staff, cold food, just a totally awful experience food service was awful!!!!

This was a nice find. We were in the area and popped in. Clean, welcoming atmosphere with lovely artwork. The food was very good. It was very slow in there, so it was a bit perplexing as to why the service was also very slow. I would definitely go back as everyone was kind and friendly. read more

See all

Zak is the best! Cheever brunch is delicious, the vibes are impeccable and the service is even better. You won't regret it. We come back every weekend just because the service is so good! read more

First time here with some friends and it was lovely! We sat on their couches outside on their gorgeous patio. Food was great! We shared Brussels sprouts, Mac and cheese, and their GF pizza. Service was a bit slow but the Manager was extremely helpful. A must visit especially on a beautiful warm day to sit on the patio. read more

Cheever Tavern - Nice night for a fire - New American Near Me - Norwell, Massachusetts

See all

This past Sunday, I dined at Cheever Tavern for the second time. We met another couple there for brunch, and it was such a pleasant time. We dined indoors, and I honestly can't remember what my dining companions ordered, but the chicken and waffles that I got was out of this world! Service was attentive and professional, the environment is very inviting and soothing, and I wouldn't hesitate to recommend Cheever Tavern to anyone who is looking for a lovely South Shore brunch spot. read more

Ambiance is excellent. They try to make you order fasts. The meals are OK like the steak was good but tiny portion for the price and the scallops are yummy but the risotto was nasty mush. I hate complaining but risotto should at least be edible but they did not care. $$$ for a neighborhood place read more

Just plain good! The signature chips are house made and far better than regular french fries. Fish and chips ? excellent! Atmosphere fun, relaxing and a bit historic. Beer on draft; servers are very friendly and add to the experience. Go for it! read more

Highly recommend. Quaint and cozy. Nice outdoor seating but we chose to stay inside. Service was excellent. Our waitress Kylie was attentive, friendly, professional, courteous and polite. As well as the hostess and food servers. We ordered the mussels scampi for appetizer. The fish & chips and seafood fra Diavlo special for our entrees. Plenty seafood especially lobster which was awesome. All the food were cooked to perfection, absolutely delicious and worth the price. Definitely going back to try the other items on the menu. read more

See all

Cheever has made me a believer. Quiet, scenic outdoor patio, and a menu that'll have you down with a case of FOMO: fear of misordering. Nashville hot chicken, short rib burgers (free if you've won a Pulitzer), grilled octopus, pappardelle bolognese, street corn, fish & chips, mojo steak tacos, tips, tomahawk pork chops, chowders and chicken l'orange... you'll be planning your next trip while finalizing your choice. I went togarashi crusted ahi tuna, served over cukes, watermelon radish and pickled ginger, and drizzled with a soy-lime vinaigrette. Sided by seaweed salad and cold soba noodles - it's an excellent dish that won't sit heavy when you lick clean your plate. I have had a few missteps, but they were rectified when addressed, and overall the execution is really fantastic. Kids dishes are $6-7 and right portioned. Not sure why so many spots charge $12 and serve 2lb of buttery pasta to a toddler, but Cheever's got the formula down. The true find? Five Maine Beer Company offerings on tap, including their ultra-rare Dinner DIPA! read more

See all

sooo pricey and not really worth it, i'll admit the food is good but definitely not worth the price , service is okay at best, dessert isn't exactly worth it, okay on occasion if your willing to spend for little read more

Great service! Food and drinks were delicious. We only had a couple of appetizers, but will be back for a full meal soon! read more

Cheever Tavern - Delicious cocktail Ghost tequila paloma (by request) made by Matt - New American Near Me - Norwell, Massachusetts

See all

This was a cute place that we found from yelp. In the area for a tournament. The place has a country style feel to it. Staff was helpful and service was amazing. They started us off with the sweet bread which was tasty . We got the steak Frites, crab fried rice and chocolate lava cake. Steak fries was on point. It was perfectly cooked. The fried were super crispy. The fried rice was okay. It could of use more crab meat. The chocolate lava cake was so rich and sweet. Needed another scoop of ice cream for the sweet cake. Overall, a great time. Would come back read more

See all

They turn people away for no reason - they don't want customers It was midday Sunday, October 16. My wife, our daughter and I wanted to try Cheever Tavern for lunch. It was a beautiful day and we wanted to sit outside on the patio. There were plenty of empty tables outside. We went to the hostess stand and asked to sit outside. The hostess told us they don't have anything available outside, even though we just saw that wasn't true. We asked to sit inside, which was mostly empty. She smugly told us "We're not accepting walk-ins at this time." She was literally standing in front of a room full of empty tables. I asked "All these empty tables behind you are reserved?" And she repeated, "We're not accepting walk-ins at this time." Dumbfounded, we left. On the way out we ran into another family that had been turned away just before us - a husband, a pregnant wife and a young child. She'd told them the same thing. Was it because we had children? There were plenty of kids running around the patio, so they'd been allowed. There was no staff shortage and the place wasn't even half full. Our kids were well behaved, so why weren't we allowed? There was no conceivable reason for the snooty hostess to turn us away. I even check Cheever's online reservations and there were plenty of tables available to reserve, so why the hell were we not allowed? We couldn't even get a reason from them. It was embarrassing and insulting. What a stupid, trashy place. Instead, we went to The Blacksmith Tavern in Pembroke, a much better establishment. They were friendly, accommodating and professional. The food was fantastic, the service was quick and the price was reasonable. It was everything Cheever Tavern was not. We live in the area and we like to dine out. We tip well too. I'm going to tell everyone I know to avoid Cheever Tavern. If you're thinking of visiting Cheever Tavern, don't waste your time. Go to The Blacksmith Tavern in Pembroke instead, you'll have a much better time. read more

I cannot believe I've not been here sooner. First off, classy place. Well built and organized. Like something you'd expect on MV or Nantucket. Most importantly, the food. We had: Brussels Sprouts & Meatball Slider apps. Wow. Delicious! Then kids MacNCheese, probably the best tasting Mac N Cheese, ever.... Wife had the Cheever Hot Chicken Sandwich & and I had the Haddock Entree. I cannot remember the last time EVERYTHING I ate was unbelievably tasty. Service was great. You can easily spend 2x in the city, for half the value and service. This is a south shore MUST go to. Will back, soon! read more