I don't recommend this place due to a complete lack of accountability and poor customer service. I placed an order through their website using the Slice app and received a confirmation text saying it would be ready at 6:08 PM. Since the location was only about 6 minutes away, I left at 6:00. I initially went to the Brockton location, but they didn't have my order. I immediately called the Whitman location (the correct one linked in my confirmation), and the owner/manager told me they didn't have my order either and suggested it might be at the Brockton location--which I had already confirmed wasn't the case. After checking again, I called back, and he said they would "look into the Slice app" since they hadn't received the order and would start making it, with a 30-minute wait. By then, I had already been waiting about an hour. When I arrived, I was told they hadn't even started cooking my food. The manager said it would be another 20 minutes and made a dismissive comment about possibly making my order sooner if they finished someone else's first. There was no apology, no accountability--just attitude. After waiting even longer, I finally got my food, only to have the owner try to blame me for going to the wrong location, even though I had contacted the correct one right away and was told the order wasn't there. He then claimed the Slice app "doesn't work properly" and that I should call instead. I later contacted Slice, and they told me the owner reported that I went to the wrong location and they couldn't accommodate me--which is not true. If the Slice app doesn't work, why use it at all? This experience was frustrating, time-consuming, and handled very unprofessionally. I won't be returning or recommending this place. read more

Supreme is the best GREEK pizza in Whitman. They also have really good salads here. We love the gold fever chicken salad. Kids love their pizza as well ! read more

Not sure how you can charge over $12 for a pizza that is smaller than a "bar pie"? Overcooked and very few toppings (felt like they dropped a few just to charge) better pizza around, place has gone down. read more

Never had a bad meal here ! The honey hot chicken tender pizza is AWESOME! They do delivery, takeout or eat in. Cute little spot with great food - lots of parking right out front. read more

THE GOOD: Food is always delicious. THE BAD: Customer service is atrocious. I mean it. I have lived nearby my entire life and there are zero standards to work here. Mainly younger folk that have zero managerial guidance. The food is also extremely overpriced. The owners / managers are way too friendly with customers and don't focus enough on the final product being consumed. This place is on its way out if things don't change which is a shame because it holds memories from my childhood that will be lost. I hope they can turn it around. read more

I just paid $17 for this salad that used to be bigger but now it's smaller has less food and is still the same price read more

Supreme Pizza - Steak Tip Cobb Salad - Pizza Near Me - Whitman, Massachusetts

The calzone was really good, the tenders was really fried, the only thing I would want more of is cheese on the top. Other than that this calzone is a MUST. read more

Supreme Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Whitman, Massachusetts

Alright, so, I ordered a chicken parmasean calzone... But what came out was not a calzone by any definition of the word, it was a fluffy dough base COVERED in delicious pizza goop and then layered with a thiccc blanket of stringy cheese. This wasnt a calzone, it came out lookin like a delectable deflated football of cheese bread, but the cheese hid the giant chunks of chicken and diced innerds awaiting us. I destroyed this "calzone" with my girlfriend. One tip tho, I sprinkled garlic salt on top of the cheese. The layer of cheese was so thicc it needed its own seasoning. Trust me, it slapped. read more

Supreme Pizza - Chicken parm "calzone" (it's not a calzone) - Pizza Near Me - Whitman, Massachusetts

See all

Damn , I got a reg cheese, a Texas barbecue chicken and a supreme, The cheese was for my 2 young boys who are cheese pizza critics, it passed with flying colors. They loved it. The red onion on the Texas barbecue chicken pizza was very fresh and flavorful. The supreme pizza I devoured, to be honest I barely chewed it , I'm a savage, it tasted so good. I would recommend it to anyone nearby or from out of town to travel the extra distance if you have to because it's really really good stuff. I live a couple towns over and won't hesitate to go again. read more

I ordered here by mistake. Meant to order from a different supreme pizza. But I thought maybe it was a good mistake let's find out. Ordered a large steak, supreme sub, and a large chicken stirfry sub. Both tasted decent, but we're very dry. Also, both subs are supposed to have cheese on them and neither had cheese. I do know you can always call but what's the point after being home and ready to eat? To call and drive 25 min round trip again? So if I could I guess 2 1/2 stars but it doesn't let you do halves and it's definitely not three stars because two separate items on the menu weren't made with the advertised ingredients and then what was made wasn't all that great. I would recommend Billy's house of pizza in Abington read more

Supreme Pizza - Example of prices - Pizza Near Me - Whitman, Massachusetts

Supreme Pizza is the best at everything!! From Greek& Caesar salads, to classic Italian subs and all kinds of pizza it's always fresh, and made to perfection. Love this family run business and happy to support them on a regular basis!!! read more

Supreme Pizza - Meat lovers plain Greek - Pizza Near Me - Whitman, Massachusetts

Always amazing, we've never been disappointed. Every time we order from supreme it's always delicious, our go to is usually the cheeseburger sub, Italian sup or one of their pizzas with a side of curly fries. But in all honesty, every item we have gotten there has been awesome! When we do pick up the owners are always there, and you always feel like family. We've been going to Supreme for 8 years and we will continue to go. read more

Minus 5 stars. Lame subs at a rip u off price. Hospital food kicks this places ass. How it is still in business is a mystery. If you like bread sandwiches, this is the place for you. read more

The owner Yanni was extremely rude and stole our money. Granted the quality of the food is great, everyone working there is disrespectful.

Yummy. I purchased 3 subs 2 steak and cheese and an Italian sub. To go to Florida. I couldn't have my favorite meal not available. Both subs cooked with salt and pepper steak and cheese extra cheese extra mayo and extra cooked onions we ate one at the airport and the other half was eaten by my nephew soon soon as he knew where I got the subs from my son had the Italian sub which was made perfectly it was playing with extra mayo he loved it thank you so much Supreme Pizza for making the best. read more

$70 for a pizza and two salads and mozzarella sticks?? The salads were child portions. We ordered grilled and buffalo chicken on the salads, one had no chicken and the other had the wrong chicken. And it took over an hour to be done? Never getting my money again. read more

Excellent curly fries; steak and cheese was definitely the best locally. Friendly service. Ordered takeout, food was prepared timely and delicious when I got home. read more

Supreme Pizza - a sandwich and onion rings - Pizza Near Me - Whitman, Massachusetts

This place continues to have great pizza and service! I come fairly regularly and they know my order and my name. One of the managers (I think?) always says hello and is friendly. It's clean and lots of seating. They had issues with condensation on a pipe in the bathroom, so be careful! They had a caution sign up. read more

food is okay but they take way too damn long. the place looks fine aesthetically but they take too much time. i have been waiting here for 1 hour and 30 minutes.most of the workers are okay and very nice though. read more

Best Greek salad pocket I have ever had. It's basic but it's delicious. They are very friendly. I also recommend the Buffalo cheese fries. My only complaint is that I don't live closer! read more

These guys make some decent pizza. Good customer service. ...................................................................................... read more

The food at Supreme is always great and fresh. Easily the best pizza/sub spot in Whitman. Nice clean dining room and friendly staff if you choose to pickup or dine-in. I have ordered basically everything off of the menu at supreme and it is always very very good. They have been consistently good for years and years. Great family run business. read more

I've been going here for 19 years now and is always my favorite. Today I just needed it and got three small pizzas all of a different creation. My road was closed down and not only the girl on the phone was super nice and helpful but the delivery man had to park elsewhere and walk to my house in the heat. I met him in the parking lot and apologized for the construction and he was so nice and understanding. Not only great pizza but great customer service. Definitely the best around. read more

Supreme Pizza - four different pizzas in boxes - Pizza Near Me - Whitman, Massachusetts

The food is absolutely amazing always has been and I know always will be in the future love this place been going here since I was 12 years old. I am now 62. read more

This was a great go to for quick lunch or dinner. But over the last year the quality of the food has gone down hill. The last time we ordered from here we were told it was going to be an hour wait. An hour for a sub and a pizza. Then when we got the food the pizza was cold. This time we ordered and it will be our last. Place wasn't crowded. Full kitchen staff. Subs should be perfect. They weren't. Weren't really what we ordered either. There are enough pizza sub shops in the area not to bother with this place again. read more

Called the restaurant the girl on the phone checked we were in the delivery radius and took my order for two small pizzas and an order of fries. I called back after an hour and twenty minutes and was assured my order was out with the driver. It took another 30+ minutes for my food to arrive. My food was cold and bordering on inedible. The delivery driver insisted we weren't in the 10 minute delivery radius I just checked on my phone it's 8 minutes. The food is so cold I can't judge if it's good. read more

Been going here as far back I could remember don't live in Whitman anymore an still love this place ! One of the most consistent places u could imagine read more

Really enjoyed our meal here tonight! The mozzarella sticks were great. The pizza was delicious, I just wish there was more chicken on our pizza. We will be trying more items on the menu soon! read more

Best Buffalo Chicken Calzone out there, great mozzarella sticks and pizza too. Will definitely eat here again.

Haven't ordered from here in a few months, I somehow forget this little gem exists when I go to order food. Nonetheless, I have never had a bad experience here. Food is great, huge portions, and reasonably priced. My only complaint is that it's always BUUUUSYYYYY so pick up and delivery is usually a long wait, but it's worth it. read more

This is a great pizza and sub shop in Whitman's town center. I've done pick-up and delivery, and I've eaten here with my kids, and I've always been happy with the service. It's nice inside with high ceilings and exposed brick, and the food is really good. My most recent favorites are their Italian sub and buffalo chicken calzone. read more

The food was delicious. The staff was friendly. I had the plain cheese pizza, steak and cheese sub , fries and onion rings and meatball sub. My only complaint is that it is way too pricey for the portion size. Worth a try though if u havent been yet. read more

Tried to order a chicken parm sub and was informed Supreme just flat out doesn't carry mozzarella?? I don't understand how that's possible at a pizza place. The employee said they only have provolone, cheddar, and American. It's unfortunate because I've heard *great* things about their chicken parm, but the only cheese I like on it is mozzarella. I ended up leaving and getting lunch elsewhere. :/ read more

I love this place, best pizza and crunchy fries around! Also a really good price for most of their menu options. Have to say that almost everytime I call I usually hear "sorry this number is busy" after I call 3 times and when they do answer just try to rush you off the phone and get your order asap (do you guys share one company phone for all your call in orders??) I can understand being busy and frustrated but not to the point of almost yelling at customers to hurry up with their order. read more

EVERYTHING IS GREAT! I've had half the menu and couldn't complain about one thing ! Excellent pizza and subs!

I have held off from this but now it's a common occurrence. The food here is great ...never a problem with food ......the problem lies in the staff.. here is a simple break down Called in order for 1 pizza and mozzarella sticks was told 30 minutes. I told them I'll be in in 45 minutes they said great.... I get there to pick up my order an hour later and was told to wait 15 more minutes. At this point I'm irate bc I gave them am extra 30 minutes from when they told me it would be ready ......then I saw a pizza get put in the oven that looked like what I ordered so naturally I ask is that my pizza just getting put in the oven and then they got the manager just to find out it was my pizza getting put in the oven an hour after I have ordered...... Now the reason I am extremely upset is because after the manager tells me that it is my pizza that just got put in the oven he then proceeded to tell me that they have no mozzarella sticks now had my food been done on time I still would have had no mozzarella sticks and they didn't even bother to call me back which I am a regular there and let me know so i would have been waiting for another appetizer At this point I wanted to just walk away and go somewhere else but was so hungry that we still just took the pizza now the manager did not offer any sort of discount or any sort of free appetizer for all of this trouble he just said sorry we were busy sorry we were busy and told me all he could do was deliver my pizza to my address when it came out the oven for free....... Now if I ever made that much of a mistake forgot somebody's order and forget to tell them that something they ordered we ran out of I would have done a little more to help keep a customer considering I am a regular and their food is good now here is the reason I am writing this review I know everybody has a bad day but this is the third time this has happened on the same exact order so unfortunately I will not be returning to supreme pizza ever again I hope this helps and I really hope they can do better with timely management of the orders read more

Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Whitman, Massachusetts

This is the second time I've been there in the past month and a half. for $21 I found a large cheese pizza to be small, greasy and lacking in flavor. A garden salad which looked half-size for something that cost $6.80. It was enough to feed a five-year-old. I got home annoyed and frustrated. The only thing I can say is the people working at the counter and or the staff are fairly pleasant and the new interior is quite pleasing. Other than that there are many other places to get pizza and sandwiches for a better value and better food. I'm a fat kid who likes to spend money on food. Writing this complaint does not bring me great pleasure. I hope this helps. read more

Staff: Fast and friendly. I get the feeling that everyone cares and likes their jobs here. Food: Everything I have ever had here has been very good. In particular I highly recommend the buffalo chicken calzone, chicken fingers and the chicken salad. Cost: Average for a pizza place. read more

Just started coming here a few months ago and I wish I had found it sooner. Haven't tried the pizza yet, but the sandwiches and calzones (BBQ chicken and chicken parm in particular) are superb! Ratio of dough-to-filling is perfect. LOVE the crispy onion rings and the curly fries are a good touch. Can't remember the last sub shop I went to that had curly fries. Service is outstanding as well. Very friendly and there's always someone there making sure you've been taken care of. Don't miss this place when you're in town. read more

I'm not from the area whatsoever; but my girlfriend & I (she lives in the town over from Whitman) found this place right here & let me tell you... You don't wanna miss out. The people are super nice, the food is made with actual care & effort, they got great selection of foods & pizza with a great atmosphere. It's honestly my go-to for this whole area now to be honest. I leave always wanting to come back 5 stars read more