Love this place great food & great service! My husband and I have been coming here for years & will keep coming back! Thanks Murphy's Pubhouse for always treating us right when we come to visit! Keep up the great work during these hard times!! read more

Dinner was amazing! Came back for dessert 3 hours later and the bartender was the only one on 2 hours before close and was extremely rude! Gave off a bibe if we were a bother to him and the split our check with the other couple when we told him several times we were paying for ours and they were paying for theirs. So will never be waited on by male bartender with long beard. Kinda ruined our impression and enjoyment for this place. Would love to return but will refuse to be waited on by him again! Panini Sandwiches read more

Murphy's PubHouse - Desserts - Pubs Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Was given a certain time to pick up an order. Order wasn't started until I walked in. No sense of urgency. No apologies, except "kitchen is backed up." Ended up waiting 30+ minutes for an order that should have been ready when I walked in. read more

We go here all the time & love it. The staff, the atmosphere, & the food are all always great. 5 stars!! However this past Monday evening we sat at the bar while waiting for our family to have dinner. When they arrived my husband cleared our tab, $22 paid in cash with a $5 tip. After dinner, our very wonderful server gave us our bill & stated that our bar tab was added. My husband went to the bar with her & cleared if up. What happened. 2 bartenders waited on us with one tab that apparently was NOT cleared out. 2stars!! We felt it was an attempt to dupe us. IF we go back we will certainly pay close attention. read more

What good can come out of confusion over a party (group) size at a restaurant? Amazing food, endless laughs and impeccable service, that's what! This was the suggested dinner spot after attending an afternoon dance recital and it was a perfect end to the day. Murphy's reminded me a little bit of Logan's Roadhouse or City Barbecue in the layout and decor. As you enter the door you come to the hostess stand along with a couple padded benches and chairs in case of a wait. In our case, we had called ahead and put our name and group size on the list, but unbeknownst to us they had mixed up the seating list and put our name on last night's list so when we all arrived they did not have a table ready for us! No problem, though; we weren't in a hurry so we waited the 10 minutes they told us it would be before a table was ready, and then promptly were seated. Our server, Amy, came right away to take drink orders and oh my goodness, was she hilarious! She was full of energy, friendly and so attentive. She is one of those people who loves her job (according to her) and sets out to make people smile and give them a good experience. You just can't be having a bad day when you are around her. She brought our drinks out and took our dinner orders. While we waited for our meals we munched on appetizers of Pubhouse pretzels--soft baked pretzels with warm queso cheese and house mustard sauce, and shrimp cocktail--jumbo shrimp with tangy cocktail sauce. Both were delicious! They have sandwiches, burgers, soups/meaty chili, salads, appetizers including onion rings, fried mushrooms, shrimp cocktail and mozzarella sticks, desserts, an extensive chidren's menu, entrees, steak, seafood--just about everything. I ordered the breaded fish sandwich, a whitefish served on a crisp bun with lettuce, tomato, pickles and onions on the side, a choice of chips or fries (I had the fries), and tartar sauce on the side. The fries were seasoned perfectly and the fish was cooked to a beautiful golden brown. All of it was SO good. The fish was just about as big as many restaurant tenderloins and I don't think anyone expected me to finish it, but I did! Oh by the way, you have the option of adding a slice of cheese to the sandwich...do it!! Amy asked me if I wanted some, which I wouldn't have even thought of for a fish sandwich. But I love adventure and trying new things so I said go for it! Yummm. It added such a good, rich flavor and just completed the sandwich for me. I told Amy I was going to try to get other restaurants to make the addition. :-) The restaurant itself has a sports pub feel to it, with big screen TVs and a bar area, as well as both tall and short tables, and booths. It can get loud, I'm guessing more during big sporting events and races, but it is a fun atmosphere and not so loud and busy that you can't have normal conversation. This is just a great, family-friendly place with delicious food and the promise of amazing service and a wonderful time. When you go, remember: 1. ask for Amy 2. order cheese on your fish sandwich read more

Best bar food around. You are guaranteed perfect service if you get Amy as your waitress. The wings are crisp, the nachos are loaded, the pretzels are divine, and the onion rings are by far the best ever. Don't forget the raspberry cheesecake!! Murphy's is the best pub around. read more

Murphy's PubHouse - Raspberry cheesecake - Pubs Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

My wife was looking for a place we could have dinner after hitting a few buckets of golf balls at Grey Eagle. Murphy's just happened to be the find, and a great one it is. Family friendly atmosphere, great selection of really, really good food, and very friendly and professional staff. It's our new go-to restaurant. Great place! We love the layout and atmosphere. Highly recommend you give it try, you'll be glad you did! read more

Murphy's PubHouse - Pubs Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Got tenderloin but it was a bit overdone as well my spouse got over fried fish& chips. So Food was OK but not Great. Service was ok in the beginning but really died off after our food came. Waited & waited for a refill on tea & drinks. Place was not even that crowded? So not sure why our service was poor? read more

Oh my goodness. I'd heard about this place for a couple of years but hadn't wanted to drive the 20 minutes to get there, but boy am I glad we did! If you've been around Indy as long as I have you've probably heard of, driven past, or eaten at the old Murphys Steak House that was on Keystone between 38th St and Fall Creek. Well, this is the same family who runs it and the steak is fabulous! I had the 8oz New York strip at the recommendation of our wonderful waitress, Amy and it was terrific. I'd put it up against Capital Grille or Harry and Izzy any day -- and a LOT less expensive, too! Amy also recommended their homemade clam chowder and I've got to tell you, it was one of the best I've ever eaten. They also have pizza and sandwiches and salads, all of wihich are very reasonably priced. Now I can't wait to go back! read more

Murphy's is great! Good atmosphere and good food. We've tried their sweet chili calamari (delicious), fried biscuits and apple butter (I mean, can you go wrong?), fried mushrooms (a must!), but my favorites are their pizza (a delightful incredibly crisp thin crust), their fireball whiskey ribs, and their boneless wings which have a very unique panko breading. Their crab cakes were not my favorite. Service has been good a majority of times we've been there. We've also been several times for brunch which I'm not sure if they are doing anymore but it is fantastic! Love their half portion options. I usually get chicken and waffles and hash brown casserole. It's a great place to take our toddler daughter since it's louder, casual atmosphere, and the servers have always been great with her (brought out a plate of fries immediately for her one time so she didn't have to wait- we didn't even ask!). We've had some off service a couple times, and once I ordered something on the menu that I had before and it came out completely different than it had been in the past (this was before the supply chain shortages), and the waitress treated me like I was making it up. It didn't even match the description on the menu (specifically it was the brioche french toast with maple cream sauce), it came out as regular french toast made with normal bread and normal maple syrup... was just weird the way they handled it. That and a few other long waits are the reason I bumped it down a star but overall I love Murphys! read more

An enjoyable place to have drinks and lunch! Venue: The restaurant and bar area are moderately dated, but the atmosphere is very open and friendly. Restroom facilities were clean and plentiful. Service: Our waitress was phenomenal! She was very personable and the entire staff appeared to be this way. Constantly checking in with us and making the dining out experience as pleasant as possible! Home run to the staff on this. Price: The price point here decent. Each person with a drink should expect to spend $15-20 each. Food: This is your pretty standard pub food menu. I would put it on the higher end of the spectrum in terms of food quality. read more

So glad that this place has stayed opened during COVID my hubby and I LOVE the French onion soup

As always, great service, great staff and great to have NCAA basketball n the TVs and the sound on!! Always enjoy coming here and you should too! read more

Terrible service, the bar tender was washing dishes and blatantly ignored us. If I could give this place zero stars I would. The hostess said we could sit outside originally but just have drinks and apps and we said ok then she said nvm sit at the bar so we did and then were ignored. I will definitely be telling everyone I know to steer clear of this place forever. read more

After asking for restaurant recommendations from my sister and brother in law we decided on Murphys. There are countless restaurants around this area and they highly recommend Murphys. I was hesitant on going to a "pub" for dinner as it is typical bar food. Murphys was an exception. From the time we walked in we had AWESOME customer service. The food choices were great and the food itself was wonderful. It was quite full and the employees were working constantly. Not once did I see an employee just casually sitting around not interacting with a customer. Even the busboy was on top of things. As busy as they the wait staff interacted with customers and gave them attention. Very cozy with live music in the evenings. We will definitely be back!!! read more

The meat was over cooked a little. The service was good. The environment is busy but not loud. If you want a classy dinner in a pub style joint this is the place to go. read more

I've been multiple times and had great food and great service. However tonight I went in with a group of friends (all servers). One of my friends never received their food and when we were all done waiting for our checks Amanda didn't even offer to compensate my friend for not ever getting food after waiting an hour for our food to even get to our table. She was very clueless and very rude. I love Murphy's usually but I would not recommend Amanda her customer service skills are 0/10. read more

Our food was fine, however, our drinks took over 20 minutes to arrive. We were ignored & when we told the waitress it had been so long, she became nasty with us. It was my first, and last, time at this restaurant. read more

After waiting 20 minutes the manager refused to seat us when they had several open tables. We asked to be split into two groups rather than waiting 30 minutes or longer for the one table with 6 seats to open. They had two booths back to back and the reasoning we were given was the booths were covered by two different servers. We left. read more

T-Bone is the best cut on the menu. Ask for Amy the best at Murphy's. Great prices, Great food, Great Fun.

Went to this restaurant for lunch because we loved the old Murphy's on Keystone from years ago We were extremely disappointed. The food and the service was really, really bad. There are many great restaurants in Hamilton County to choose from so don't waste your money here. read more

I would seldom rate a 5 but since there isn't a 4.5 I have to run it to a 4. It's a really neat looking place on the inside and very clean. We were seated immediately at a comfortable booth. Our server, Amanda did a great job taking care of us. She was very friendly and helpful. Drink order in, we ordered the chips and salsa as an appetizer. The chips were fresh and warm and the salsa tasted home made. Could have used more cilantro but that is a personal preference. Not everyone likes a bunch of cilantro. I ordered a strip steak, baked potato and clam chowder. My beautiful date also known as my wife, ordered crab cakes and the chili. All the food was good. I had to send my steak back for doneness but that may have been on me. It came back more done than I wished but it was probably right in the first place. Anyway, it was still very good. My wife liked the crab cakes and she told me they had plenty of crab. The meals were good overall but.. The stars of this meal... The soups. The clam chowder had an abundance of very tender clams carrots and celery was creamy and buttery and rich. We both agreed, very very good. The chili.. My goodness. It was hearty, not soupy, just the right amount of beans, tender and well ground beef. No fat or gristle to be found. Very nice broth. Not too spicy but had a little kick. Just really outstanding. We randomly visited here from out of town, looks like a revisit will be in order next time we are near. read more

We've been coming here on Friday nights for several months and have tried something new every week. The food is great, atmosphere is fun and comfortable. Most of all, we love Amy! She makes everyone feel like family and always gives the best recommendations. We look forward to seeing her every week! read more

A solid choice for pub fare. We met some friends for dinner and I had a cheeseburger with fries. The burger was nice and juicy with good flavor. This is a good place to meet for a casual meal. read more

I went here for the first time last night - I'd driven past the strip mall at 116th/Olio many times and sort of never noticed it. The bartender, Dennis, was hilarious and very generous with his wine pours. We had the soft pretzel appetizer---I was thinking it would be a sort of dry soft pretzel with the unnaturally yellow cheese. I was so wrong. The pretzels were huge, soft, buttery, and maybe a little slightly sweet (but not overpoweringly so), and the white queso that came with it was seriously amazing. Several regulars suggested the pizza, which I'll definitely try the next time I go back. This seems like the kind of cozy place where people will know your name and favorite drink after you've been there a couple of times. Definitely worth checking out if you're tired of the Hamilton Towne Center chain restaurant/bars! read more

Ordered a pizza on August 18, on line at 5:50 the on line order indicated it would be ready at 7:15. I got there at 6:40 in a pickup parking space and as instructed, I texted them I was there. I waited 10 minutes, then went inside, to see the pizza setting on the counter for who knows how long. I told the host that I texted 10 minutes ago. She indicated they were short staffed and not going outside. Why didn't they text me back to come inside? As a result we got a lukewarm pizza. I think I'll try another place for a carry out pizza. read more

We are regulars. Amy our server makes it a pleasure to dine here. The cocktails are always perfect and the steaks are delicious.

Was sat immediately by very friendly staff. Looks very clean inside, not a dingy bar atmosphere at all. Great music selection and general ambiance. Had the pepper steak sandwich, my girlfriend had the fish and chips. Both were well beyond expectations! I always consider Ale Emporium as the front-runner in Indy pub food, but this is certainly among the competition. Overall would certainly come back again. I don't know how this place doesn't have more attention. read more

We went here for drinks and apps, and for a pub in a strip mall next to Kroger, I was pretty impressed. The service was wonderful. I'm so sad, I can't remember our waitress' name as it's been a few weeks...Amy, maybe? Anyway, she was so attentive, bubbly and straight-forward about the dos and don'ts of the menu. Our apps were pretty standard, but all well executed. I saw some giant tenderloins and steaks floating by, and I thought this would be a great place to take our parents. They're not much for the new food wave that we love from gastropubs and various fusions, but this straight-forward cuisine would suit them just fine. 'Merica! read more

4 1/2 stars actually! We went here last night and were all thrilled that the food was delicious! We had five in our party and we ordered sandwhiches, a large pizza, wings and some ice cold beers! Great atmosphere, yummy food and it is smoke free!!! We can't wait to go back to try their steak and salmon as they looked great too! read more

Wow. Extremely pleased in every respect. The food, beer and service were top notch. The burgers were phenomenal and the onion soup was amazing. The interior was small, a bit crowded and a little loud but overall it was a great experience. Thank you! read more

Honestly, the worst restaurant and the waitress didn't even care or greeted and she was extremely rudeI made eye contact with her and continued cleaning the table didn't even say I'll be with when I'm done. read more

Preface: We have had horrible service in past so do not frequent Murphy's much at all. Hubby wanted to watch football last night so we decided to go out. Murphy's was not on the list of our top 2 choices to go to but after hearing wait times at other establishments, we decided on Murphy's hoping it was better than the last time we were there which was over 6 months ago. Boy were we wrong. We found a place at the bar so sit.. There were two glasses there which didn't bother us. After 15 minutes, the bartender asked us how everything was thinking those were our drinks. We asked if we could have a drink and she apologized saying she thought those were our drinks. It took a while to get our drinks. While sitting there, the couple beside us had to get her attention to ask how much longer it would be before salad and soup came. She apologized and continued scrambling. Rest of visit- dinner came out just as wings were brought out. We had to flag someone down to get plates and silverware for wings. Dinner- had to grab the food delivery boy to get a steak knife. Green beans were missing so had to find someone for those. I asked to speak to manager and bartender asked what problem was. We told her and she apologized- never got manager. I am not sure what is going on there. The food is great and love the atmosphere but the service is on decline. This coming from customer who goes there infrequently knowing the service is lacking. It sure did disappoint. read more

We eat out once or twice each week and Murphy's is our favorite restaurant. Everything on the menu is delicious whether you order a steak or burger. The restaurant is always clean including the dishes. The staff is always nice and efficient. I have to say Amy is our favorite server! read more

Murphy's PubHouse - Pubs Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Went here for Father's Day brunch. The menu options were delicious! That hash brown casserole is so good! The cinnamon roll waffles were a hit with my son, didn't even get the chance for a bite. Good and spicy Bloody Mary's. Love that you can order off the lunch menu too. read more

Love visiting Murphy's for a girls night out. A great place to get cheaper drinks and dessert. They have a good variety of menu items- like a pretzel ham and cheese sandwich which is delicious. Staff is always friendly and they have a laid back but fun upbeat atmosphere. They provide live music often, and outdoor seating. read more

Accepted online order on Sunday night at 7 pm and confirmed it would be ready at 8 pm and charged my card. Went to pick it up and the restaurant was unexpectedly closed. read more

The steak was good the rest was ok. Crab cake was horrible. Kids chicken fingers were awesome. The wait for the food was horrible. It took about 45 min. The waitress was always checking on us. The place was packed and expensive for what it was. Won't be returning. read more

Excellent customer service and food! The food options are endless. I love the selections on the jukebox.

We've eaten here 4 times now - all quite good and its quickly becoming my go to place. I'm not sure what the lower ratings are about. But if you read them its about odd things, soda machine trouble or didn't have a certain beer. Pizza good. Wings - really good. Burgers - really good. By far the best kids hamburger around. It's a real pub burger, just smaller. I find that I hope the kids can't eat it all. Every time I eat somewhere else I wish I was at Murph's. read more