I've lived here for about two years now, and I still haven't found a place I enjoy more than Murphy's. I try something new almost every time I go, and somehow I'm impressed every single time. The food is always amazing, and the drinks and atmosphere are easily 5 stars too. Whether it's a weeknight dinner or a night out on the weekend, Murphy's is always a great choice. Definitely one of my favorite spots in the area and a place I'll keep coming back to. Thomas R. -- The Review Guy read more

We decided to stick it out through a pretty disorganized host stand arrival because we really loved the visit we had at the Geist location, and overall, the meal had plenty of bright spots despite a few minor hiccups. ​The menu offers a great assortment of choices, though the prices run a bit high. The kitchen and service staff were wonderfully accommodating with custom requests--my husband ordered a double patty burger topped with an egg and no bun, and they executed it perfectly. ​I ordered a salad and the chicken stir-fry. The salad was generous with plenty of fresh cucumbers and cold tomatoes, though it was made with iceberg lettuce, which really isn't my preference, so I left most of it behind. However, the chicken stir-fry completely made up for it. It was incredibly well-balanced, loaded with great broccoli, and definitely a dish I would order again. I wish we had known there was a filet special the night we went. Our server was slow and seemed confused. read more

This place used to be amazing for grabbing drinks and dinner, and it's honestly disappointing to see how much it has declined. It seems most of the amazing bartenders who made this place special have moved on. Nick appears to be carrying the majority of the workload, while some of the other bartenders seem more interested in socializing with each other than taking care of customers. Unfortunately, the food has declined just as much. The filet tasted like something you'd get at Denny's, the Black-n-Blue salad has lost what made it so good and now tastes like it's made with cheap steak, and the wings tasted like they had been baked for three days. We've given this place several chances, hoping maybe it was an off night, a different cook, or that some of the bartenders were simply on vacation. But at this point, it seems the changes are here to stay. There are a couple of newer bartenders who show real promise, and I hope they get the opportunity to succeed. But great service and good food are what keep customers coming back, and right now both are falling short. It's hard not to notice how empty the restaurant has become, whether we've visited during the week or on the weekend. There was a time when you couldn't find an open seat in this place. I've been a loyal Murphy's customer for years, visiting both the south-side and north-side locations. It's sad to see what this place has become, and I'm extremely disappointed in the direction things have taken under the new ownership. I hope the new owner takes these comments seriously because this place has so much potential, but longtime customers are going to stop coming back if things don't change read more

I like to visit Murphys around St Patrick's day. They typically have something special going on. Sunday was a bit more tame than Saturday. In the speakeasy, They had a tattoo artist doing shamrocks for people They had their special Irish menu this weekend. The dishes people had around me looked amazing. Strong recommendation on Irish burger from person next to me. While I looked at the menu, I had my first green beer! Monica and Nick were bartending, both are exceptional. I finally went with the corned beef and Swiss on rye. It had an huge helping of corned beef, I could only eat half the sandwich. The corned beef was moist, no condiments needed. Perfect meal. read more

See all

Stopped in for lunch after bringing a family friend back to town. The place was clean and had a great setup with booths and TV's. I server was very nice and polite! I ordered the half sandwich and soup and so did my Dad. The Velvet Chicken soup was really good and the sandwich was fresh and tasty! Our friend got the Reuben and Fries and said it was really good! Next time I am in town I will be sure to stop by! read more

Murphy's PubHouse - Half sandwich and soup - Pubs Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Our server was very friendly and on top of refills. I got the filet mignon with twice baked potato off the lunch special menu. I asked for my steak to be medium rare and I was not disappointed. Steak was perfect. Juicy and tender. Twice baked potato was seasoned well. All the lunch specials seemed really good. The only complaint was the booth we sat in wasn't cleaned well, small crumbs/grains of salt all over the seat and table. I could feel it as I slid into the booth and put my arms on the table, kinda gross. read more

Murphy's PubHouse - Filet mignon with twice baked potato off the lunch special menu - Pubs Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

We eat at Murphy's for lunch regularly. Tonight we got carry out for dinner, including a taco salad. It was supposed to have ground beef, but there were chunks of something that can't possibly be ground beef. I've had the same salad at lunch and the beef crumbles are often dry but otherwise as expected. This stretchy rubber band meat is really unsettling and kinda ruined my meal. read more

The newly opened Barstoner Lounge inside Murphys is a beautiful Speak Easy experience that was decorated gorgeous with every detail of seating, tables and the gorgeous walls designed with very eccentric fabrics. The bathroom blew me away by the decor and the photo of Marilyn to love she's an absolute knockout! We enjoyed the service as we were politely asked how our experience was going. This is a relaxing atmosphere as I met up with a friend and had no distractions with the comfort and sounds of this lounge! Congrats on all of your success Ryan and offering a community an upscale lounge in the suburbs!! We didn't order food this was a fun night with casual drinks and be back for the Big Ten experience and menu this weekend!! read more

Murphy's PubHouse - Feel Good atmosphere 100% - Pubs Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

If I could provide negative stars I would. We typically enjoy local food and never have had issues with ordering carry out locally until we came across both Murphy's pub house and craft house. There have been multiple times over the course of the last several months that we've had ordering issues with both for carry out, as well as a horrible experience at the craft house. Most recently, we've tried ordering carry out from the pub house and have not been successful any time. We understand the kitchen closes an hour before the restaurant closes and have ordered well before this time frame. It seems like the online ordering may shut down 3 hours before the kitchen closes, which is what we experienced tonight. The cherry on top was calling in to place our carry out order at 915pm (kitchen closes at 11pm tonight) - someone answered (and we were like "yay!") but then were put on hold, waited for 15 min and tried to call back for the next hour and 15 min and no one answered no matter what option we selected. So what I've been able to deduce from these multiple experiences is Murphy's doesn't like carry out traffic and isn't willing to take money from local fans. It's one thing if your website says "ordering stops at 7pm" - we'd order prior to 7pm. But when it says "kitchen closes 1 hour before closing" and nothing else about carry out, no warning while preparing our order that we wouldn't be able to place the order (like other local establishments provide) or employees who could answer the phone and easily say what the actual rules are - like "I know it says online the kitchen closes 1 hour before closing but we actually stop taking carryout orders 3 hours before the kitchen closes" - then we'd be informed and be able to operate in a manner where we understand what the boundaries are. I've had business dealings with this business and it's not surprising they are as or more disorganized on the customer side as they are on the actual business side. I reached out to the owner tonight and received no response. I hope this review helps take business away from Murphy's pub house. Since we aren't allowed to give them our business, maybe no one should. read more

Great atmosphere, great service and the food was delicious! Had the wings (fireball whiskey bbq- amazing) and the filet sliders!

I recently moved to the area and was looking forward to trying this establishment. Went there yesterday with a friend who helped me move my stuff from NJ to Indiana. We specifically asked to be seated in the dining area. The hostess told us they had a 20 minute wait but encouraged us to go to the lounge. We waited there for 15 minutes for someone to acknowledge us. After we left one of the bartenders came after us and tried explaining that they didn't serve food in the lounge except the bar. Would have been nice to know before. But really, at 6 pm on a Friday afternoon - after a long day's work, I was not in the mood. I am not going back. Would have given my experience zero stars if I could. read more

Updating my review to say that Luke is the greatest server at Murphy's, possibly the greatest server in the world! We always try to sit in his section because he is so friendly and personable, he always makes us feel welcome. We had a little issue with our appetizer today, but Luke fixed it and made everything better! I really appreciate Luke and everything that he does. I hope he receives the recognition he deserves!! read more

See all

I like Murphy's PubHouse and usually drop in every couple of months with friends for a cocktail and televised sports event. Great steaks, friendly bar staff, and an excellent thin crust pizza. Today I ordered a small sausage and mushroom pizza for take out. As always, the pizza was tasty and cooked just right. With just the right amount of toppings and cheese. Murphy's PubHouse has a wonderful local / neighborhood feel. The staff is "top notch" friendly and work well together. Good food, good service. I'm a happy customer. read more

Murphy's PubHouse - I love sitting at the bar. Great place to watch a sporting event. - Pubs Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

me and my husband went in on Sunday. it wasn't busy this was our first time going. We thought we try something new. My husband order ribeye and I order the chicken alfredo. His steak wasn't season at all he asked for medium he got rare. my chicken alfredo had 3 different noodles it was the worst chicken alfredo I ever had. We will never go back to this place worst food ever. We left hungry and had to order late wings stop. read more

Great local family friendly pub with a good variety of food and drink options. The service is always consistently great and everyone is friendly. read more

Here for lunch. Service was very friendly and efficient as we sat at the bar. My wife just had a soup of the ay which was a chicken velvet, or something like that. Anyway, it was very very very salty, so most was left behind. I had a cup of chili, which was good, but not great. We also shared a big soft pretzel which was the highlight. When it came to ordering a beer, virtually all choices on tap were ordinary national light beer brands or a few local IPAs. I wanted an Ale of any kind that wasn't an IPA and the bartender looked at me like I was speaking another language. I said, anything red or amber or brown of any kind. Nothing. I ended up with a very dark porter as the only choice. Come on, a pub house that has no red or amber ale at all? Not acceptable. read more

First time there and will definitely be back. Food was great and the bartenders have heavy pours !!! read more

Murphy's PubHouse - Purdue Fans !!! - Pubs Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

My wife and I have been there twice and both times we waited and waited for someone to acknowledge us and wait on us and we ended up walking out so we will no longer try this restaurant again. It has a great location, but it is very disappointing. read more

Murphy's pub House is excellent. The service from the servers is excellent all as well. They have a wide variety of food and it is always good. I would recommend this place to anyone who loves food. The atmosphere is excellent as well. read more

Food was excellent! Service was top notch! Highly recommend, and they take reservations! They offer brunch on Sundays from 11-2 with ample items to choose from. Started with the pub pretzels for $8 or $10 if u get both cheese and mustard. Got a delicious burger with crispy bacon and homemade crispy chips!!! The waitress stayed on top of our drinks and was very friendly. read more

See all

Decent spot for typical pub/bar food. Nothing terrible nor anything great. Service was decent and food was good. Not much to set this apart from the crowd in the local watering hole spectrum of establishments. read more

What a great spot! Had great food in the cool new lounge side. Also had the best service with Kendra. I would definitely recommend if you are close by! read more

This place has become one out favorites for evening meals and lunch during the week. Their burgers are excellent but my favorite is their fish 'n chips with a side wedge salad! In fact my wife and I split a meal and never walk away hungry. Their soup of the day is great as well, whatever they make that day. I will say we were quite disappointed I. Their Easter brunch. Everything was cold and nothing was special and it cost $29 per head. Not a good experience, but all their regular meals are great and I couldn't recommend them more highly read more

Great craft foods and atmosphere. Awesome new speakeasy bourbon bar just added too. The drinks are always amazing and service is stellar.

We came here for the first time today & we loved it! The atmosphere is great. The food is excellent. And the service was the best! We had a great server, and Amy was so kind and chatted with us & our son. We had some drinks and food and loved it all. Highly recommend the pretzel & pizza. We will definitely be back! This will be our new spot! read more

Murphy's PubHouse - Meat Murphys Pizza - Pubs Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

I dined here with an EXTREMELY large party of adults and children this past Sunday. What an AWESOME experience! When I say "large" party, we had at least 16 adults AND children with us. MAJOR kudos and props to our servers who put up with us. The food was good. Nothing really to write home about, a little greasy for a sandwich (I had the Turkey Gouda), but it was edible. I was thrilled that they have Angry Orchard on draft! It's not often I see that. My son enjoyed his grilled cheese very much (it's basically been his only meal at every restaurant lately, so he's a Grilled Cheese connoisseur). The one thing that made EVERYONE happy was a visit from Santa AND the Grinch! The Grinch was definitely a fan favorite and made us smile a lot! read more

See all

The server was nice and my wife loved the salmon but I had somebody's leather shoe! Worst steak I think I have ever had. It truly was tough as shoe leather. I ordered it medium well and it came out just shy of rare. No blood so I did my best. It had more gristle than any meat I ever had. One star for me! read more

The food was very flavorful and not too expensive at all. The service was very nice, everyone there is super friendly. Lots of tv's and the music was also spot on, overall a great experience. 10/10 would go again! read more

Great local institution! Great staff and food and drink! Try the Apple salad! Off the chart in flavor. Good Irish drink on draft! Been a local go to for our family for many years! Thumbs up! read more

Murphy's pub house is off of Olio road. They serve lunch and dinner and of course have a bar. I took my mom and sister to lunch there because they have good food and its not too crowded during lunch time. However today the place was pretty packed. Granted that it was fathers day, so of course theres going to be more people around lunch. We walked in and they looked pretty understaffed. The poor hostess was doing everything she could to clear a table for us. It took us about 15 minutes for us to get a seat, which was okay because my mom and I were catching up so we didn't mind the wait. Eventually we were seated and we were spaced out following COVID social distancing guidelines. I ordered a bBoody Mary and for lunch I got some wings. My mom got a mimosa and the ham and cheese pretzel panini. It took a while for our food and drinks to come out but once again they looked understaff on top of it being Fathers day, so I understood the delay. Overall everything tasted good, the wings were meaty and baked (not slimy). I had recommended the pretzel panini to my mom and sister because i used to get that and it has been a favorite of mine since i first had Murphys. I can definitely say that my lil sister and mom enjoyed that panini. Will definitely be back, but maybe when its not a holiday. Overall great staff and decently priced food! read more

See all

What an absolutely fantastic place to grab a bite. It has a lot of regulars you can tell, but as soon as you walk in you feel like you're one of them. The bartender calls you hon but it's not annoying. The menu is way better and way more diverse than what I expected for pub food. I actually saw a couple of ribeyes go out that looked fantastic. I had the Pubhouse Hoagie and Jill had the Turkey Guada Pretzel and both were good but hers was the best. We passed on dessert but the brownie skillet looked amazing. read more

Murphy's PubHouse - a beer and menu - Pubs Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Food was very good service was fast and friendly it was just a bit dark inside. We would definitely go back

I haven't had anything that wasn't excellent! Tries their Chili today for first time. I will be back for a LARGE bowl next time. But this sandwich is fantastic too! Wife had Loaded Potato Soup and cleaned the small one up. She must have loved it! Great service! read more

See all

Good price and quick. Can dry and vacuum as needed or just drive off. Like the towels

Foods are so good! We have a philly steak, cod fish, teriyaki burger and wings. All are delicious! Love our hospitality waitress named Amy. She's best! Definitely will comes back! read more

Murphy's PubHouse - Pubs Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

As we pulled into the parking lot of Murphy's Pubhouse there was plenty of parking with disabled parking available. After entering the establishment, It was clean and had a pleasant sent of yummy steak. The staff greeted us with a warm welcome and smile. There was plenty of seating in booths, tables, and seating at the bar. We had a reservation we were seated immediately. Our server was Shannon. She came right over to our table and gave us water. We ordered our drinks and they came out fast! Shannon was very attentive to all our needs, especially when we ordered our meals. We were told the portions were large, the dishes were indeed large!! There was no room for dessert as we all had to go boxes. I highly suggest Murphy's Pubhouse. If possible, request or Shannon to be your server! They definitely earned their five star review! read more

While I've been off on a short stay-cation this week, I've committed myself to snagging at least one Yelp review daily. That is a legit way to spend your stay-cation, right? You're right. I probably need to get out more. But hey, until then Yelp reviews it is! Murphy's Pubhouse is the latest Stonebraker family establishment that includes Murphys at Flynn's at 52nd & Allisonville Road, Murphy's Pubhouse South, and Murphy's Crafthouse in Geist along with Stoney's Liquor. As a fun fact, the family, via a grandparent, also used to own the old Huddles Restaurants. While I'm a semi-regular at Murphy's at Flynn's, I'd actually never been to this spot before I set out today in search of a new place to review. Murphy's Pubhouse is located in a strip center that, while visible from the street, actually takes some intentional looking to really see. Accessibility is decent - there's a handful of accessible spots in the middle of the building, though Murphy's is probably 2-3 storefronts down. Curb cuts are fine. As you enter through the double-sided doorway, just a tad heavy, you wind your way into an area that on this visit said "seat yourself." They have a bar area, some outdoor dining, and a side toward the left that appears to have both a small stage and tables/booths. Unless I'm guessing poorly, I think Dave Matthews has been there as they carry his wine (Dream Tree) and there's a couple signed guitars and a huge poster. There were no ants marching, so that's good. I sat at a four-top, moved the chair myself. My server was over fairly quickly and I ordered my usual unsweetened iced tea while checking out the menu. The menu has the usual pub fair - steaks, sandwiches, entrees, pizza, wings, and a full bar. I contemplated the tenderloin, but actually just wanted a really good burger. So, hey. I ordered that with fries. Yes, I know it's weird to go out to a nice joint for a burger and fries. But, most of you reading this have met me. I'm kinda weird. Let's be honest. The atmosphere was, well, a bar. It was average in terms of sound and there were televisions playing sports. The crowd seemed to be mostly older folks, though the pub is family friendly. If there was one issue with the atmosphere, it was that I just thought it was a tad chilly inside. The burger? Very nice size and thickness, served medium well as ordered. If I'm going to pay ten bucks for a burger, I prefer that it actually last me more than a couple bites. This one did. The fries were also quite good - seasoned nicely. The service was fine throughout. I actually ended up with a couple refills of my iced tea. She was attentive. I will confess maybe a little too attentive - I was actively reading during my meal and at least once was truly interrupted. However, it wasn't jarring and overall I think the service was quite good but not quite to the "I'm dying to go back" point. I was able to linger long enough to do some decent reading - I always like that, especially on a day off when I truly have time to relax. This experience was a solid 4-star experience. It wasn't what I'd call flawless, but I'd easily go back and definitely thought the meal, at right around $13, was a solid value. The service was good to very good, while the atmosphere, even with a bit of a chill, was warm and comfy. If you're in for a pub type experience, this is a solid choice for this area but not quite what I'd call a destination spot. They do also feature live music. You can get more details on their website! read more

My wife and I had an excellent visit to Murphy's. We have been to the south side location before, but now that we live up north, we wanted to try to fishers location. It was a great visit. The service was very quick and responsive. They had some great nightly food and drink specials. They have live music on saturdays. I ordered the tenderloin. It is always my go to at new restaurants. It was probably not the best I've ever had, but it was very good. The fries were great and had a good crispness to them, while not being overcooked. My wife ordered the wings, and thought they were good as well. They had some great dessert options, but neither of us left room to try them. There was plenty parking and we got in early on Saturday evening and were sat right away. We will be back. read more

Murphy's PubHouse - Pubs Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Murphy's pub house is a hidden gem in Fishers! My husband and I just moved north and we have been looking for a great spot to eat close to home. We had heard about Murphy's PubHouse online but one day we got to meet the owner of the restaurant as he had purchased furniture off of us. He was very kind and encouraged us to visit the restaurant and today, we finally did. Wow... just wow. The food is amazingly delicious and the service was wonderful! We ordered the potato skins along with apple butter biscuits and cleaned our plates because they were so tasty. We didn't think we would have room for our entrées but once they came out we made room very quickly. Both my husband and I ordered the 12 ounce New York strip steak, he had french fries and I had mashed potatoes. So so good!! Both steaks were perfectly prepared and juicy! The sides were yum as well. We just left and we are so full and so satisfied. If you're in the area, please make sure to visit this place because it won't disappoint! We will be back again without a doubt. read more

Murphy's PubHouse - 12 oz New York Strip steak - Pubs Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Great food and staff!! We love this place and they have the BEST ribs. Highly recommend