Listen, this building has been around for decades... it's ran down and the drive thru menu is all handwritten but they have some darn good food! It gives bodega eats but on 38th street Indy Terrible terrible service though, extremely rude lady at the drive thru window today - it almost made me want to snatch the bag when she handed it outside but I refrained. New year, new us! I would ask her a question and she'd audibly sigh and in the middle of me simply asking what soda's they had today , SHE CLOSED THE WINDOW!!!!!!!!! I don't know, writing this out makes me want to go tomorrow and ask for the owner or a manager or something. Anyways; if you want good lamb over rice with a lil salad on the side and can soda for $14.98 (cash) or $16.99 if paying with card, this is your place. Hole in the walls always have the best food, I'm telling you! read more

Mr Gyro's - 49) Lamb W/Rice W/Pita Bread - Greek Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Gyro was blahhhh - it came cold, meat onions and sauce. No lettuce, no feta, no tomatoes, just boring and the chicken wings had no seasoning. Ordered via Uber Eats and was very disappointed. Oh well. read more

Mr Gyro's - Greek Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Every time that I come for my weekly Mr. Gyro run they are treating me like family. The service is top tier they know my order and make accommodations for me which is perfect. The inside is very nice and clean. I enjoy talking to staff when I come inside. Chicken over rice is sooo good. Got to get extra sauce and extra chicken. Hot and fresh ingredients is key to their success. read more

This was out first time there. I ordered the Philly Cheesesteak and the sandwich was all bread had barely any meat on it. Super disappointed. To be fair, my husband ordered the Gyro and he said it was "okay". You get a good amount of fries with each meal. But overall, we were not impressed - especially for the price! read more

If you know you know! This is a west side Indy staple. If you're looking for a good gyro at a good price definitely come in and check out Mr Gyro's out west 38th street. They're a great late night option on the weekends. read more

I ordered a 2 pc catfish and fries. Got home and they cut 1 pc into 2 pcs. I called and they said "that's how it comes brother". Then I told them I'm leaving a review and he said ok we'll make it right when you come back smh read more

Mr Gyro's - I ordered catfish fillets, but received strips - Greek Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I was in the mood for some state fair food and went to Mr Gyro's for an Italian Sausage sandwich. I opted to get my sandwich with grilled onions, marinara sauce and hot giardiniera peppers. It was a delicious hearty meal. They offer a wide variety of sandwiches including gyros which they are known for. They also offer a drive thru option for carry out. read more

Mr Gyro's - Greek Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Love this place!! Wanted to give an updated review as their quality and quantity are the same!! They haven't succumbed to reduced quality since covid like many other restaurants. Their prices are fair and have only slightly gone up over the years. This is a West side staple. If you're looking for yummy gyros, this is the place. Always a hefty serving esp compared to others. There is a drive thru but I would recommend calling ahead because it takes time as it is made to order. I didn't take any pics this time because I was too hungry and dove right in. I got the gyro salad this time as previously pictured. However I recommend the gyro or gyro platter if your really hungry (tons of fries). Also I enjoy their Italian beef w/hot peppers from time to time . read more

There is absolutely no way they charged me $30 and then cooked this up and thought it was acceptable . The fish is so overcooked it's unrecognizable. It was sooo dry and flavorless. Inedible. The fries were extremely soggy with grease. There is just no way they thought this was okay. If you accidentally overcook the food, you recook it, not package it up and sell it. read more

Mr Gyro's - Family meal fish, chicken, and fries - Greek Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Baked chicken rice is definitely on point. The rice was cooked to perfection and the chicken was juicy and well seasoned, not salty at all.

Got a 4 piece chicken tender, the chickens very small and over cooked so it was hard asked for buffalo sauce it was basically dry rubbed wouldn't recommend I threw ts out the window.FIRST AND LAST DAY TRYING TS. read more

This place can be a hit or miss. Today I would say was a hit! The food was fresh and my children were pleased. There weren't many people inside, so we received our food rather quickly. read more

Mr Gyro's - 10 piece chicken and fry (half lemon pepper and half Buffalo) - Greek Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I really have been trying to find a Gyro that compares to home, now I think we have a winner. Mr. Gyro is very affordable and gives you a perfect amount of food for your money I didn't have to ask for an extra pita bread and I had enough Gyro meat to make another for dinner. They've got a good thing going. read more

Mr Gyro's - a sandwich and french fries - Greek Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Quick service even when it's a line in the drive thru. Usually don't go in but there is plenty of seating inside the building. Saw some reviews but i haven't had a bad experience here yet. Always enjoy the food from here. A go to for gyro and Italian beef sandwiches read more

They just need better fries. They are very dry. . The gyros are the best. Service is pretty good.

This is a local hidden gem!! Great place for gyros with great prices that have never changed over the years! The quality and taste has always been on point each time I've gone ... I don't think I've ever had a bad experience here. The owners are very nice and friendly as well! read more

Mr Gyro's - Greek Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Mr Gyro's lives up to their name!!!! Unlike another local merchant who serves gyro meat in a pita pocket with only a choice of his custom sauces, you get the REAL GYRO experience here; a REAL gyro pita with all the trimmings, lots of onion, tomato and tzatziki sauce as an AUTHENTIC GYRO SHOULD COME WITH!!!! Food was hot and fresh and the Greek salad was complete with feta!!!! When in Indy I know where to go for authentic gyros; and so should everyone!!!! read more

Mr Gyro's - Gyro 3. Gyros Plate Combo - Greek Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Their food is extremely hard to beat, but their on-line menu is very misleading. I was told to ignore the menu on the internet. They only have what's listed in the store. Please fix your internet menu to match what you actually sell. read more

I went here for lunch the other day due to slightly higher reviews & lower prices. I got the gyro combo for $7.99. The gyro was good, but not the best that I've had. The fried were bland & not crisp. Some may like them that way (salt helped) but I like crispy fries. All in all, it was ok. I'll possibly be back as there is a large menu & I'm sure I can find something. And the prices aren't too bad. read more

Outstanding gyros . Whether you get the number1,9, Gyro dinner, or their daily specials you can never go wrong! $9.99 for a LARGE 14 oz Gyro and fries This has been around forever! I LOVE their last FB post! They are here for the people BY the people. The prices CANT be beat. The quality is just as good as the Gyros served at the GREAT #GreekFestival last weekend. Mr. GYRO HIMSELF is taking a much needed break in Greece for a month from what his staff informed me today. He left the place in good hands but he IS missed. DONT SKIP THIS PLACE!!! read more

Mr Gyro's - Inside of Mr. Gyros - Greek Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

the best gyros on the planet!!! I always get the number 1 with a Pepsi!!! My favorite restaurant when I come to town !!

This has been me and Daddy's spot for my whole life. now it's mine and my husband's. This is where I come for some serious comfort food. I have never had a bad experience. Drive-thru or dine in, everything is made to order. Family owned. They're actually from Greece, regardless of who is in the kitchen. Homemade tea and lemonade. They have the meats! $.40 for extra tazikii. They do have TVs. Pepsi soda machine. 23 years in the neighborhood and they aren't going anywhere anytime soon. read more

See all

Mr. Gyro's restaurant is a gem to W. 38th Street location that has been serving delicious food since 1996. I've 1st came out to the restaurant back in 2014 where I had hot, fresh, and very delicious catfish. Over, the few years I had catfish, rib tips, and chicken wings. Last time I had food from Mr. Gyro's was back in 2018. Today Saturday Oct. 2nd 2021 my mom wanted lunch there. We, both wanted catfish unfortunately they didn't have any catfish that day. I had large rib tips, and fries. The ribs tips were fixed in the oven, very tender, sauce wasn't spicy. I had about 10 rib tips that were very large. My mom had the Alaskan whiting fish fried hard. Mr. Gyro's does have a drive-thru, you can order their food from Door Dash, Grub Hub, carryout, and you can dine in to eat. The restaurant is small, women's restroom was clean, there aren't stairs in the restaurant so accessible to everyone. Mr. Gyro's restaurant is known for the delicious gyros, Italian beef dogs, Chicago hot dogs, polish dogs, and cheeseburgers. Etc. If, you're in the area make sure you checkout this gem on the West side. It's a small yellow building that you can't miss. read more

Mr Gyro's - Alaskan whiting fish - Greek Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I have learned that this place is hit or miss. I don't know if they have different cooks or what the issue is but one day, the chicken teriyaki is delicious, and the next visit it tastes horrible! So I don't go anymore because I don't have money to waste. read more

Here's the thing - Mr. Gyro's is exactly what you'd find in Chicago. Their gyros are terrific, they have Italian Beefs (yes, actually quality Chicago-style), Chicago dogs and pizza puffs. Seriously if you're a Chicago transplant or someone who even lived there for a few years, you know why it's so exciting that this spot exists. The employees are also super duper nice. Go here, and thank me later! read more

The food is affordable, good, and you won't have to wait too long. This place is off west 38th near moller road. They have a drive thru and you can go inside to order. The menu is pretty big as well. I read a review stating the people prefer for you to give the menu item number when ordering. I made sure I looked at the menu ahead of time before I went. Who wants to be the person holding up line because they don't know what they want? Not me lol. I ordered a number 64 which is lemon pepper wings and fries. You have the choice of ordering a 6 piece or 10 piece. I ordered the 6 piece with ranch and also a cup of hot peppers. I also ordered a strawberry milkshake. My total was about $15 or less I don't remember the exact total. They stay open pretty late on the weekends as well. Great place to grab something quick to eat! read more

Mr Gyro's - 64. Fried Chicken Wings with Lemon Pepper - Greek Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I have been a customer for 24 years and today was the worst food I have ever had , I know the owner and her husband and their kids from being a customer , and I am a chef , every condiment I ordered was temps at 50/55 degrees ( temperature danger zone ) I used my own dressing , didn't eat the feta in fear of becoming sick and the hummus they attempted to serve me in carry out went to the trash after taking pics of it , I am mortified and I hope they aren't selling their place that I loved so much to the two guys in drive threw who also gave me uncooked fries that I couldn't eat , all n all , unless the owner can give me a reason for this I am never going back and he charged 28 dollars for hummus Greek salad with gyro ( 10.99 ) on the menu board and a side of fries , all bad .. the gyro meat wasn't up to proper temp .. Won't be back and I am very sad about it . read more

Meat was dry, pita was hard and the sauce was watery. Very disappointing! I read a review that said it was hit or miss and it was definitely a MISS! The fries were hot but tasted old and had NO seasoning on them! Total waste of money! read more

All the love to Mr. Gyros! Drive-thru is easy, service is good, always a smile. They've made their mistakes right, portions are large and affordable. We usually get a pizza puff, combo 3 gyro plate with fries, and the chili is on point. read more

This is the best place in Indy for gyros. I get dinner from here at least twice a month.

Love this place! Always servicing with a smile. They're very friendly and polite. Their food is always delicious and well served. Never have any issues with them. The Restaurant is very well taken care of, wonderful staff, peaceful environment never encountered a bad experience at this restaurant. My mom always went here for her food over the last 8 years which is how I've discovered them. Have and will continue to recommend them to everyone. Even better than Jordan's chicken and all of the other chicken places. lol read more

This is a little gem of great food on the westside of Indianapolis. Not only is the food good but the staff is friendly and welcoming. We have eaten in the dinning area before but ordered "take-out" this time due to the pandemic. I ordered the Gyros Plate with Greek Salad ($8,25) while my wife ordered the Vienna Chicago Hot Dog ($2.25) and an order of Cheese Fries ($2.49). Pick-up time "about 15 minutes". I arrived on time and everything was packaged and ready to go. While their English is much better than my Greek, it still took me a minute to explain that I didn't want the soft drinks that come with each meal at no extra charge. Arriving home, we un-packaged the meals and prepared to enjoy them. The Gyros Plate was loaded with meat, almost more than I could eat...but I did. It was excellent as was the Greek Salad. My wife is a Chicago native and wanted to see if the Vienna Chicago Hot Dog was as good as "the real thing". She declared it to be so saying it was "as good as Portillo's". A high complement from a Chicagoan. The Cheese Fries (no idea why she ordered them and neither did she) were declared good as well. While my meal was fine, her only complaint was that the dog & fries were a little cold. This was probably due to the travel from the restaurant to home and dismissed. All in all, I highly recommend this restaurant for all the reasons above. I should also note that they have an extensive menu selection. Way more that would be expected of a small, family-owned location. We already have plans for our next meal there. read more

Food was pretty pretty pretty good. I'd go back there some day soon. Good value for the money spent.

Love this place is one of the best gyro spots in city Hands down I recommend you try to Philly Cheese steak and their Italian beef sandwich and don't forget the Gyro And I recently just haf there whiting fish and ribs read more

See all

It doesn't look like much from the outside with it's bright yellow exterior and drive-up window. Even on the inside, you place your order at the counter where there is a huge list of available items like a fast food restaurant. Not only gyro's, but hot dogs, burgers, french fries, and Philly sandwiches are available too! So, even though the menu is filled with choices, a white board with the daily special for about $8 caught my eye: Gyro dinner with my choice of fries or Greek salad and a beverage. I went with the salad and helped myself to the self-serve soda dispenser. I selected one of the booths on the side of the dining area (a number of 2-tops were available and some where grouped as 4's and 6's). Within a few minutes, they called my number and I was ready to dig in. (Note that they have plastic ware and napkins near the soda dispenser). I started with the side Greek Salad that had fresh iceberg lettuce cut to bite-sized pieces and topped with feta cheese, tomato, white onion, and dressing. Olives and a pepper where also included (both had seeds inside). Really nice taste and just enough dressing to coat the salad with flavor without being too much. The gyro was served on a styrofoam plate with an 8" pita as a base. The seasoned beef and lamb gyro meat was tasty on its own without being dry. The gyro came with a house sauce and was also topped with more tomato slices and white onion. Excellent! I'm not an oficianado when it comes to Greek and Mediterranean food, but this tasted great and I would gladly order it again. So tasty that I made a point of telling the manager how much I enjoyed it. So, I'm not sure why they offer so many other items when they make such a great gyro. They obviously know that they are good since they put Gyro in the restaurant name. My advice would be to drop some of the clutter from the menu and make sure the gyro's are prominently featured on the menu. Review #489 read more

Mr Gyro's - Greek side salad - Greek Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Great Gyros! I've been going there for years and haven't found a gyro to compare. The salad is always fresh, and the onions are sliced thin. The pita bread is fresh and soft. And my take outbis enough for 2. read more

Was in the area around lunch time so decided to stop by this place, as I was craving a gyro. The outside has a run down appearance, and the inside is much the same. But they do have some cool antique decor that give it an old time diner feel. The menu is huge, ranging from gyros to hot dogs to fried catfish and everything in between. There is surely something to satisfy even the pickiest of eaters. I ordered a gyro and greek salad. The greek salad was really good and worth coming back for, but I was a little disappointed with the gyro for a restaurant that has the namesake. The meat was a bit dry and seemed like it had been sitting out for a while. Would be interested to try some other things on the menu. Prices are all pretty affordable which is definitely a plus. read more

Gyro was great and packed full of meat! Staff offered to buy me baklava following a delay in drive through service due to inventory delivery. I will definitely return when in this part of town. read more

Gyro sandwich, Gyro plate/salad, BBQ Chicken Wings, Italian Beef, Cheeseburgers, are all good! Affordable, good service, and drive thru accessible. You can't beat it! read more

I absolutely love coming here! They are always so friendly and welcoming! We ordered the gyro dinners to go. The place is quaint and cozy and always clean. The food is always abundant and tasty! read more