An absolutely perfect dining experience for our group of 8 on a Sunday evening. We had a reservation for 5:30 but our plans changed slightly and we arrived 30 minutes early. We planned to wait until 5:30 but we were told it was fine and we were seated immediately. The service throughout our meal was outstanding. Our server was knowledgeable and answered our questions about menu items. She was extremely friendly and personable. We ordered several appetizers including my favorite, Saganaki. The hummus was garlicky and wonderful. We all ordered different entrées. My choice was the vegetarian pastichio. Our entrées and all the sides were excellent. Unfortunately we had no room for dessert so we will try again next time. The ambiance was wonderful, the food and service could not have been better. We all agreed that we will be returning soon. read more

See all

Service: Amazing! I felt so taken care of and attended to! Customer service was on point. Ambiance: I sat outside. It happened to be the first warm day, and so I could tell I was probably the first customer to sit outside for the season. Even so, the tables and outdoor space were clean. Food: I got the meatballs and they were good! I enjoyed the feta on the inside. I felt they were a little dry and could have been more tender. The pita that accompanied was perfection! The french fries were also very yummy. The feta, oil, and seasoning were delicious. While the food was good, I'm not sure $30 for these two is reasonable. read more

Athens on 86th - Feta Fries - Greek Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Food was excellent, including cobia prepared with lemon, dill, carrots and artichoke hearts. Gyro meat was tender and authentically spiced. Service by Ameer was friendly, helpful without being overly familiar. Ambiance from the photos, decor and music was like being in Greece. read more

See all

We live Athens on 86th. I asked today how long they've been open. Since 2004. I imagine we been eating here for 21 years. Food is always great. Service is super. It's nice that most of the servers know our order since we don't chance much. Always nice seeing the owner waking around and taking to people. Such a wonderful place. read more

See all

Craving Greek/Mediterranean food, my wife and I decided to try out this place. We'd seen it once when going to a nearby Mexican restaurant. We were immediately seated at a nearby table closest to the front windows. The table was nice and clean, so was the rest of the restaurant, but the chairs were a little hard to sit on. They were straight-back wooden chairs with no cushions. There were other tables with chairs that had cushions. We opted not to move because we were otherwise comfortable and liked the view out the window. I noticed they had outdoor seating that looked nice and comfortable, it was just not quite warm enough for us to sit out there. There was what seemed to be authentic Greek style Mediterranean music playing and a lot of similar Greek style decoration/architecture around the restaurant. It felt like we were transported to Greece. We were greeted by our server, Alexa, within a few minutes. She was very knowledgeable, friendly, and helpful with our questions and selections. We both decided to stick with water to drink. For our appetizer, we started with saganaki (flaming cheese). It's Greek Kasseri cheese, flamed at the table with vodka and topped with fresh squeezed lemon and served with nice, warm, sliced pita bread. It was served like a show, Opa! It had a nice savory tangy taste that went well on top of the sliced pita. I'm a big cheese lover, so I would definitely get this again, it was really good! For my entree, I got the Athens Specialty Chicken Gyro which is lots of warm and thinly sliced tender and juicy chicken served open-faced on a 7" pita topped with hand-shredded lettuce, juicy tomatoes, fresh red onions, soft crumbled feta cheese, and lots of tangy tzatziki sauce. It normally has pepperoncinis, but since I don't like them, I had those left off of it. It was a deliciously, delightful, mouthful of blended, lightly spiced, Mediterranean flavors. Pretty messy to eat by holding it, but that was my choice and I enjoyed it all the same. My wife had pork souvlakia that consisted of two kebab sticks of pork that was marinated and charred-grilled with Greek herbs and spices. She had a side of savory Greek style green beans, some rice pilaf, a Greek style oven roasted potato and a small Greek salad with two pieces of garlic toast. She enjoyed the delicate blend of Mediterranean spices on the tender and juicy pork souvlakia. The salad had a nice light crunch to it and the garlic toast was a good complement for it. She liked the green beans, potato, and rice as well. She ended up needing to take some food home because she was getting full, but I managed to finish my gyro. Alexa was a good server and checked on us often, making sure our water glass stayed filled. After I finished dinner, I used their restroom. It was very nicely decorated with Greek/Mediterranean pictures and the dark, maroon red paint on the walls I thought was a nice touch. The restroom was very clean. Next up, dessert! We decided to partake in some genuine authentic baklava. Crispy phyllo dough pastry layered with finely chopped walnuts and honey. I'm not a big walnut fan, but I've enjoyed baklava in the past regardless and had been looking forward to this after dinner. It was not as light and flaky as I had imagined it would be, it was more thickly sweet than I remembered it being as well. It was difficult to cut with the fork no matter how I went about trying to do it. It sat kind of heavy on my stomach also. We do plan on returning sometime in the future, but I'm not sure I'll get the baklava next time because it was too rich and heavy a dessert for me. All in all, it was still a positive experience. read more

See all

A first time visit and we were SO DELIGHTED! A very nicely decorated dining room, clean bathrooms and friendly, knowledgeable staff! From our appetizer to our dinner salads, fresh garlic bread and AMAZING Entrees! Everything was PERFECT! Seasoning, fresh, hot and filling Greek taste! Our dessert was First Place all it's own! My boyfriend said it best, "It tastes like Christmas!" We had the delightful Effie's Galactobouriko! Also the Baklava! Please give this place a try, we know we're coming back! YUM read more

Athens on 86th - Greek Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I was invited to Athens on 86th for a company Christmas party and while I absolutely love gyros I really did not know what to expect in a family style meal. I was very quickly surprised by the delicious sampler style courses. I really don't think there's anything I didn't enjoy and the style and art is very fitting to the experience... With all that said I also extend my thanks to the staff for being kind to the children with our party and for being good sports with the funny after dinner squat challenge it's truly an experience I will remember and I plan to come again! read more

Food was good and plentiful. Service was a bit slow that night but worth the wait once served.

The Greek food does not hold a candle to true authentic Greek food. Super disappointing experience. When you go to a restaurant expecting authentic greek food you might not get the flavors one desires. The "authentic flavors of Greece Cuisine"! This dining experience did not bring me home to Athens. The lamb was horrible. Did not taste good at all. If you choose to order a special make sure you ask the server as the specials do have the same price point of anything on the menu. Sadly we will never return to this establisment. read more

Amazing Greek restaurant! They were able to seat a large group and were kind. As an appetizer we enjoyed the Saganaki- fried cheese flamed at your table and served with the best pita. The speciality gyro was filling. I would recommend sharing an order of fries if you order a sandwich and appetizer. I was pleased by the overall experience. read more

See all

Two of us split the taste of Athens sampler and a galaktoboureko dessert. Not to brag, but it was a perfect order. The sampler had plenty of gyro meat, pastitsio, moussaka, dolmades, tiropita, spanakopita, potatoes, and rice to share. Of them, all were good, but the one that was the most "above average" was the dolmades. If done well, they are leafy and lame. This one was great: tender, moist, flavorful. The show-stealer, though, was the galaktoboureko. It can sometimes be too heavy and honeyed. This one was light and sweet to right where you'd want it to be. Add to all of it a great wait staff lovingly making fun of each other in Greek, and this place is not to be missed! read more

Athens on 86th - Galaktoboureko -- do not miss! - Greek Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The food! Sooo good. I wish I lived in state so I could visit on the regular. Yum. I got the Athens fries and the grouper. I'm salivating just thinking of it. read more

Had lunch here with a large group of friends, and we got excellent service from our dedicated server. It was not very busy on a weekday, which was wonderful for us because we were able to talk easily and not feel like we were disturbing anyone else. Food was good quality. if you are on a budget, this may not be the place for you. Prices were higher than some other places of the same type. read more

The food is fabulous. Kind servers and The night we were there a large Greek family was celebrating which was entertaining! I will return again and again! read more

We had our own little Greek Fest at Athens on 86th. Our party of 5 had a pick of tables when we arrived early in a Friday night (5:30). But the restaurant filled quickly after. They have a few tables outside as well. Drink and dinner specials are listed outside, but no prices. I tried the Pomegranate Martini which was a little too sweet for me but still tasty. The Martini was $15. We shared a plate of the Greek Mestballs, which are stuffed with feta. The meatballs are large, moist and sharable. I had one of the dinner specials, langostino Pasta. The meal came with a small Greek side salad which was composed of very fresh greens and delicious. The pasta was covered in a spicy creamy sauce that was very good with bits of crab, shrimp and langostinos. The meal was very filling and good, but a little pricy at $35. The restaurant is decorated with a Greek ambiance. It was nice and comfortable. The small bar looks fun. The service was great. Angela was attentive and friendly. The staff kept water glasses filled. Food came out quickly. There's plenty of parking in the strip mall. All in all, a great experience and I will be back. read more

See all

Went in for a quick carry out order and asked for the chicken gyro. When I got my food it didn't have all the fixing I was used to. Upon looking at the menu there are 2 options for gyro (classic and speciality). I honestly don't know which one I got because I only had chicken and pita. No tzatziki or anything. Next time I will check my food before leaving or opt for dine in service. read more

I stopped by for lunch and the restaurant wasn't busy. I ordered my Greek favorite, spanakopita, and had the appetizer as my meal. Yum. It was an ideal size for a light meal, and so tasty that I ordered a spanakopita and a baklava to go for tomorrow's meal. It has a nice, quiet atmosphere inside plus an outdoor seating area which would be nice on a warm, sunny day, and has music playing through speakers. The restaurant and dining area is wheelchair accessible. Athens on 86th is at an easy location to find, behind MCL Cafeteria and a few doors down from FreshThyme Grocery. A short drive to St. Vincent's Hospital and Peyton Manning Children's Hospital. Stop by (get it to go or delivery) and Opa! But, please, don't smash the dining ware. read more

Quality Greek food. As a former resident of Astoria (Queens), I'm always looking for good Greek around Indy. Athens has good food and a nice Grecian themed dinning room. The staff are a little harried, but doing their best. Not bad if that's what you're in the mood for and you're in the area. read more

See all

We ended up here after our first restaurant pick had an 1-1/2 hour wait and they don't take reservations. This was our first time here and Athens did not disappoint! It was lively and had a great ambiance. Our waitress was very friendly and attentive. The food came out quickly and delicious. This is definitely a place to try if you like Greek food. You can tell the family truly cares and wants to ensure you enjoy the food and experience. We started with the dolmades which were amazing! Our main courses were the Lamb kabob special and the Santorini special. Both were full of flavor. My only comment not a complaint, we felt the lamb special was a bit pricey for what it was. However, this will not stop us from returning. Look forward to returning to try some new dishes from the menu. read more

See all

Nice cozy little setting, very atmospheric. The staff was prompt and attentive, and the lamb shanks were delicious, tender and falling off the bone. Give this one a try, you'll be glad you did. read more

Unfortunately our small group didn't have a good experience here at all, despite the great reviews. Visited one Sunday early afternoon and the place was quite busy, it seemed as though this was a usual crowd as many of the patrons mingled with each other. No problem, I'm glad to see a local biz doing well! We asked about a wait but told we could be seated promptly. We were then led up to a raised dining area where one of our guests tripped on a step up and fell. It was strange bc the carpet on the step was all the same dark color, even the transition strip was dark. I also don't recall seeing any sign as a warning that a step was there? Our guest seemed to be fine afterward; the waitress was kind enough about it and that was that. One party member inquired about an appetizer, and the waitress informed us we should order all our food now or there could be a long wait. We ordered an appetizer size hummus and our meals (a lamb burger, two side salads and two cups of soup). The guest who ordered the lamb sandwich asked to sub out green beans for the potatoes. The waitress said no, likely not and the remarked, "since they probably won't, will you eat the potatoes?" Umm, ok? Our hummus was delivered timely. See the pic, it was served with maybe one full piece of pita bread cut into triangles and toasted with garlic seasoning ($10.99). We asked if we could have a bit more pita, given the amount of hummus served. Sure, for an extra $1.99 up charge?! At this point we were all becoming uncomfortable. I certainly didn't expect anything for free, but after the minor accident you'd think they'd have been a bit more accommodating? Our food arrived and was good (hence the 2nd star), the lamb sandwich predictably came with potatoes and not the green beans. The other two guests at the table ordered a side salad and cup of soup each. The portion sizes were quite small compared to the prices. We received some Italian-like bread with the salads which was saturated in butter and not at all appetizing. I'd happily have traded it for more pita! The final bill for the late lunch meal: $72 for three (did not include tip and we all had water to drink). Final note: at the end of our meal, we noticed a woman visiting with some of the guests and clearing tables. I presume this was the manager/owner? I was really surprised that she did not acknowledge us at all, nor even apologized for the fall. Again we were not expecting, nor wanted any preferential treatment, but just a friendly greeting and/or an apology would've gong a long way in this situation. We didn't feel welcome here at all. Given all these factors, I'm sorry to say I can't recommend this restaurant. read more

See all

food was great. service was a bit slow but that happens. we had the hummus to start and they offer cucumber with the hummus if you are gluten free. got the lentil soup and it was very warm and comforting. also got the greek salad with chicken gyro and it hit the spot! read more

See all

Everything was perfect. The service was fantastic. The pork chop was the best I have EVER had!

Great family owned Greek restaurant. Stopped for lunch today and I always enjoy this restaurant. It had gone thru a recent refurb and it's lovely little restaurant. We started with the saganaki appetizer which is always tasty and fun. I had the Greek salad, good sized, very fresh, lots of veggies and a side of garlic bread. Yummy! My friend ordered the gyro piato that came with potatoes, green beans and salad. Loved it and plenty for leftovers. Service was very good. Will definitely go back. read more

See all

This was my second visit, but it was the first time actually dining in. We went to celebrate my birthday. They have falafel, but it's not on the menu. I ordered a falafel gyro with fries. The sandwich by itself was $16.99, and fries were $5.99. I wish the fries came with the sandwich. It was pricey, which is my only complaint. Our waiter was super sweet. They had live entertainment as well. I loved the restaurant decor/vibe. It felt like we were no longer in Indianapolis. You have to go and experience it for yourself. Everyone was super nice and helpful. I was even blessed with a birthday baklava and song. Even though it was pricey, I had a great experience and will be back. read more

See all

My pastichio was delicious as were the dolmades. Side dishes savory and sumptuous. Very traditional Greek food. I will get at least two or three meals out of my carry out order! Healthy but generous servings. I will be back! Oh, and the service was very friendly and relaxed. read more

Food, service, ambience were all top notch! We had a great time celebrating my Mom's birthday with family! Opa!

We brought a group of 12 here and most had never had Greek food. Our entire group was thoroughly impressed with the food, service, and ambiance on a Friday night for dinner. Our waiter was wonderful and there was even a dancer during dinner going around the room. Several times our friends said "I'm so happy you recommended this place." My personal favorite thing we got was the Spicy Feta cheese. It would be worth coming back for on it's own. read more

Athens on 86th - Loukoumades with chocolate syrup - Greek Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Atmosphere, great! Very authentic in Greek decor and Greek music playing in the background.... Food, excellent! Just like our parents home cooked meals from Greece! Each item we chose were made with the best of ingredients in Greek cooking! Service was wonderful! One of the family owners, "Vasili", took good care of us and was exceptional in his service and made us feel welcome and at home.... No doubt, when we come back to town, we'll make sure to bring other family members! read more

Athens on 86th - Mother & Daughter Day in Tarpon Springs! - Greek Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Service is great. Food is too. This is our go to for authentic Greek food. Dining room is attractive and the staff is very friendly.

We've always enjoyed Grecian cuisine, so we're not strangers to it. We've had it all. Especially when we visited and explored Greece. Having said that, Athens blew us away. From the beginning of the meal and the welcoming introduction by our server Erika, to the end of the meal, nothing failed to impress. Our visit was during lunch. Hopefully one of many more to come. We started off with an app of falafel and a special app of the day that is very similar to spanikopita. All I can say is you'll love everything about this place. read more

Came again for mom's bday. Good but nothing special. Mom n dad like to.split the Athens special. They did give a baklava for her dessert. The spaghetti I tried for the first time was a little dry. Didn't take any pics since we were pit celebrating. Good. But not worth the price read more

The atmosphere is rather romantic with low lighting & "candle light" on the tables. Servers were all polite and prompt, and all worked together to keep things cleared and drinks refilled. The food was great. read more

See all

Excellent Greek and Mediterranean Restaurant. The food was excellent and the ambiance casual but not too noisy. The staff is outstanding, friendly greetings, no rushing the diners, sort of has a home feel. Portions are large, but not overwhelming. It is not a large restaurant, but as far as I know it is a local restaurant (not a chain). One of our favorite places to dine. Their menu prices are not overly priced, with drinks,appetizer and entrees our bill for two was $100 plus tax and then added gratuity. We highly recommend Athens on 86th if you like excellent Greek and Mediterranean food and excellent service. read more

Dined here last week with a group of friends and the experience was wonderful. Our group of 8 was treated to excellent Greek food, outstanding service, and a comfortable atmosphere that lent itself to great conversation, as we were catching up with friends from Italy. I highly recommend this restaurant and will definitely return. read more

Food and service was great! I've moved from Michigan to Indy and accustomed to Lebanese food. Indy is difficult locating ethnic foods that are quality and delicious. Finding this Greek restaurant will become a game changer for me and I have found that Greek food isn't that far off and very similar to taste. I'll definitely be back! read more

Athens on 86th - Lamb kabob and my boyfriend had the chicken kabob meal with appetizers Spicy Feta Cheese and spinach pie - Greek Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Just had lunch for the first time here. Beautiful decor and food was amazing. I chose the Avgolemono soup and my friend had the gyro plate. Great portions and the soup hit the spot for such a cold, snowy day! Great service from everyone at the restaurant and we will be back so I can try more! Also, I grabbed some baklava to go for my husband which he said was awesome! Sorry, no food pics because I was hungry and forgot! Go here for authentic Greek food and you will be happy! read more

First time here and it definitely won't be the last. Amazing service and atmosphere. I am pretty sure our server was the owner! She was amazing and extremely friendly. The food!!! We ordered Saganaki, Hummus and the Athens Pikilia appetizer platter. BEST pita bread we have ever had. It was warm and crispy on the outside...YUM!! Hummus was very good but we will ask for an Olive Oil sprinkle next time. Saganaki was hands down the best we have ever had! Crispy edges and a ton of lemon flavor. When it was gone we ate the pan drippings with pita bread. The sampler was delicious and a great way to try a lot of different things. The feta cheese was a game changer for us, never had anything close to how good this was. We are already planning our next visit! I want to try the smelt! I am from Chicago and have not had it for probably 30 years. So excited to find this place!! read more

We've always had good food & great service. Love all the Greek entrees. The Saganaki is very good. They even have Smelts, which you can't find in other restaurants. The staff are always good & attentive. Love going there. read more

Love this smaller family run Greek restaurant! Every time we've visited it's been packed. Even on a weekday right when they opened it didn't take long to have a good amount of tables filled. Friday nights they have a belly dancer perform that is great at getting kids or anyone that wants to join in the fun. Their hummus sampler is delicious and one of our favorite appetizers. They are very generous with the hummus so we usually have to ask for more warm pita bread and still take home half. The menu has a wide variety of options from fish, chicken, and lamb entrees to gyros, delicious salads and more! We always leave very pleased and with a few boxes of leftovers. Definitely our favorite Greek restaurant in Indy, but on the pricey side compared to others. Recommend trying on a night they have belly dancers but see about a reservation or getting there early as they are slammed those nights! read more

See all