Incredible fish fry. Great craft beer selection. Definitely recommend ... and bring your appetite or you'll be bringing home a to-go box.

We finally stopped at Mill Creek one night after seeing it was back open. The service was excellent, drinks were good but the food was just okay. It was also pretty loud in there for the amount of peiple in the place, we couldn't hear each other without shouting. The vrie sandwich could've been grilled longer so the cheese melted , the bread was a bit soggy but the flavor was pretty good. My partner got the chicken parm sandwich and it was just too much bread, he didn't finish it. We spent 58$ with the tip and that's too much for just okay food. We wish them luck but I'm not sure we will be back. read more

Just wish they had more interesting healthy options. I had a large house salad with chicken. Unfortunately, there was literally about 2 ounces of chicken on the salad. Coffee they do Keurig cups?!! So ... you get one cup of coffee, which for the price is ridiculous imo. If are eating a meal there, you should be able to get a second complimentary cup of coffee . The atmosphere is nice and casual. My companions had delicious looking burgers, sandwiches and homemade chips. I would go back again, and order the less healthy options. read more

First time visiting and would certainly come again. Myself and two friends came for breakfast and left fully satisfied. The portions were just the right size. One friend commented their eggs and bacon were cooked perfectly. And the other marveled the blueberry topping they added to their French toast had whole blueberries and not just filling. The avocado toast was on such thick rye bread and the flavors were spot on. Truly delicious! This is a bit of a small place but the servers were very attentive and orders were placed and received in a timely manner. I can certainly see if you plan to dine in you may need to have a bit of patience because if you don't happen to stop in at the right time tables may be full and you have to wait a bit. There is outdoor seating but I'm not sure if that is only to service their walk up ice cream orders or also for dinner and lunch orders. They do seem to have take out as well but I'm uncertain if it's coffee and breakfast sandwiches only or if you could get a full meal to go. The decor was tastefully minimal and featured semi rustic wood with bird and lake motifs. Being mostly wood and the indoor area mostly full at the time of visiting was a bit noisy. Not a deterrent but something to keep in mind. Definitely check hours before you go as of the time of writing this the times they offer full breakfast or lunch or just to go breakfast varies. But a great breakfast spot and possibly a great ice cream option too! read more

Mill Creek Cafe - Avocado toast: Rye bread topped with avocado spread, pico de gallo and everything bagel seasoning - Diners Near Me - Honeoye, New York

Food was fantastic and portions were large. I got the breakfast wrap it had plenty of egg, meat, and cheese. Service was great and responsive. The place is smaller but leaves a hometown feel. Coffee was also fantastic. read more

Great food and service! Glad to have a great place like this in our town! I often stop while out riding my motorcycle and enjoy the conversations with the waitress and owner! read more

I had the breakfast sandwhich which was delicious, I don't remember her name but adorable waitress couldn't have been sweeter. Will definitely be back next year for breakfast on my way to Watkins Glen! read more

They closed for good, up for sale, I was so bummed. Had really good ice cream and I wanted to get a meal to go. Oh well, hopefully someone will buy it! read more

This place was the perfect place we were looking for to stop on our way to my husband's brothers house in Rochester. My husband and I ended up both ordering the "Jackie B" wrap and it was delicious! A group next to us had ordered a rice bowl and that also looked amazing! Whats really nice is they have a cute outdoor patio to sit and you can bring your pup - which was super convenient for us. The service was wonderful and our waiter was super friendly. I highly recommend getting their sweet potato fries and ask for honey to dip it in- they are AMAZING. I definitely plan on coming back when we go out to visit his brother another time! read more

See all

On a recent vacation my boyfriend and I stopped here for a snack. We had the shrimp quesadilla and it was delicious.They didn't skimp on the shrimp at all, and all the ingredients combined really well. All the prices were very reasonable too. The atmosphere in the place is perfect for a date night or for a girls night out. Our server didn't seem to mind that we were just sharing something and was really friendly. if I lived in the area I would come back again. . read more

Such a great place The blackened steak sandwich and Philly the love So good The flatbreads. Def gotta get the chicken pesto The beer was a great finisher. Everyone there was super friendly Will definitely be back when we visit next year read more

Arrived with reservations for 5 and were glad to have made them. Space is limited.... So ouch up the phone. They have a lot of GF options to try! I opted for a bunless burger with fries.... But they also have burrito bowls and Gf flatbread pizzas available. Fantastic service, delicious meal, and cute rustic yet quirky nautical themed dining room with a fireplace.... all five in our party enjoyed their meals... If ever I'm in the area again I will definitely make a stop. read more

Really nice cafe, food was really and the chef and own were really nice. Definitely would come here again. Friendly service and great atmosphere. Nice small town place to go read more

Really small. Everyone was friendly. I had the burger. Was pretty good. Hubby had the poutine. The fries were good but too much gravy. But was a nice evening read more

Recommend this place if you're in the area and not looking for anything too fancy. There's not much out in Honeoye so we weren't really sure what to expect. After a day of canoeing on Canadice we were hungry and looking for someplace close. Really pleasantly surprised at this place. The food was good and the waitstaff were friendly and attentive. Had a couple local beers on tap that were good. Really an enjoyable meal. Menu is pretty "lunchy" lots of sandwiches, paninis, that sort of stuff. Wife got the 1/3 lb bacon cheeseburger and it was tasty (cooked med rare and it really was med rare) and I got a taco special that was really good. read more

I was really pleased with how spaced out the tables were in the outdoor seating area. It made me feel comfortable enjoying a meal out during this craziness. Our waiter (also the owner) was incredibly friendly, engaging, and funny. He was super nice and attentive! I was also so pleased to see the wide variety of food options that accommodate many dietary needs. Sometimes small town restaurants are limited in what they offer, but not here! read more

Atmosphere, food and service are all 10s! Had tilapia tacos and steak tostados. Food was high quality and fresh. Sorry I forgot to take photos before we dug in. More of a bistro menu. Hoping to go back for dinner sometime. read more

Mill Creek Cafe - Diners Near Me - Honeoye, New York

Honeoye is such a small town and we visit here with family- there are few options for restaurants. This is a hidden gem and does not disappoint. My fiancé and I were SO impressed with the quality of employees and food. I got the chicken burrito and it was to die for!!! The tortilla chips on the side hit the spot too. 10/10- we can't wait to come back and support this local family business. read more

Mill Creek Cafe - Chicken quesadilla - Diners Near Me - Honeoye, New York

Cheap beer, buffalo cauliflower was amazing. Breakfast was awful. Small and really underwhelming. The onions and peppers in my omelette was hardly cooked. Everyone else I ate with didn't have anything good to say. The owner is kinda really rude as well. There was music in the back, we tried to get some chairs that weren't being used and he rudely came up to us and told us not to touch the chairs. He was pretty rude the entire night. That alone was enough to not come back, but the food also sucked. read more

We've been here a couple of times and love it! The last time was my birthday request. My daughters, wife and I each enjoyed a variety of options from the menu. Breakfast and dinner was great! read more

What a fantastic find!! After spending the day kayaking on Honeoye Lake, we were ready for a break. The Mill Creek Cafe exceeded our expectations!!! Caleb and staff treated us like regulars! We happened to visit on taco Tuesday and had an exceptional fish taco with delicious beans and rice. Do yourself a favor and visit here if you have a chance - they will not disappoint!! read more

Mill Creek Cafe - Diners Near Me - Honeoye, New York

An absolute small-town gem of an eatery! Great food, service, and atmosphere. Indoor and outdoor seating. Everything is delicious and they have an ice cream shop (seasonal)! This is a must-visit when you're anyway in the area! read more

I've been here a couple of times. The most recent was Mother's Day for brunch. They had a nice special for the day and as always, the staff was attentive, especially considering the size of our party and the amount of other people in the restaurant. The food was delish - I always look forward to eating here when I'm nearby. read more

Mill Creek Cafe - Mother's Day brunch :) - Diners Near Me - Honeoye, New York

Great food. Unique menu. Spectacular service. I definitely recommend. My favorite is the millcreek quesadilla

Mill Creek Cafe is an awesome place to eat at. I've been there a few times and if Dr had nothing short of A1 service and food. The food comes the way its ordered and the service is always made with a smile and a kind word. The menu changes so expect to try something different each time you go. It's really neat to see a different selection each time you go. The food is very good too. If you are ever in the Finger Lakes stop in its right on Main St. Honeoye. read more

I usually steer away from places with the word "cafe" in their name, however, they proved my theory wrong of "anything named cafe has a small, boring limited menu and small portions." The menu wasn't huge, but it had everything you might want for breakfast coupled with awesome service. I actually had their special breakfast bowl which i highly recommend if they have it. Home fries, bacon, fried green tomatoes, 2 eggs sprinkled with a bit of cheese and voila. I'm a cheese addict, but was happy to have a breakfast that wasn't dripping in cheese. I also judge breakfast based on the home fries and they get 2 thumbs up for perfectly seasoning them, which many places fail to do. I want it again. Now. read more

Absolutely great place. Friendly fast and really good. Awesome burgers and salads, good beer selection too. Service was second to none. I ate here three time in three days liked it so much read more

Fresh food that doesn't weigh you down! I got the Greek wrap with their homemade dressing with sweet potato fries and it was excellent. The menu is smaller, but creative, so there is something for everyone. Our server was charismatic and funny, and the outdoor seating was cozy and inviting. I will be back again! read more

I have no idea what the food is like here, but last Tuesday, I really wanted to find out because the web site pictures made me think this place was a refreshing antidote to the usual small town slop. Too bad, though: The web site said they were open for dinner on Tuesday, but they were only serving ice cream. We drove 30 minutes to get there. PAY ATTENTION TO YOUR WEB SITE, OWNER(S)!!! read more

Better than expected! We spent the morning paddle boarding on a nearby lake and were looking for anything for lunch. We expected this place to be a diner, but it was amazing. We shared the Buffalo Cauliflower Wings which were great. We each had a wrap, mine the Flying Pig and hers the Black and Blue. They exceeded expectations, and we had half left to bring home. We'd go out of our way to come here again. Good selection of craft beers as well. read more

Such delicious food. My husband got an incredible sandwich and I got an unforgettable salad. We got a couple of delicious beers to go along with it. Highly recommended! read more

We stop here after a walk at Mendon Pond Park. We both chose the black and blue salad which was the perfect mix of spicy shrimp, steak and bacon. Topped with a creamy blue cheese- totally yummy. read more

Four of us stopped yesterday and were so so happy with our meals. We've been here before but yesterday's meals were just over the top. We ate outside and felt totally safe. Food came out quickly and server provided great tips. The Spanish rice bowl was maybe the best thing I've ever ordered.., fresh, all home made including the tortilla chips, salsa and guac. read more

Great meal, very good food, amazing staff, helpful, collaborative, and very reasonably priced. Definately the place to eat at if you're in the area! They were very accommodating, understanding and flexible on a gluten allergy as well. The restroom had a changing table which is not always something you can take for granted in this area! Oh, and the built-in ice cream shop is a great bonus! Tasty ice cream and always a dairy free option. read more

We were staying nearby and in search of a good breakfast spot. Our hostess recommended Mill Creek Café and we were really pleased when we tried it out. We stopped by on a recent Saturday morning and enjoyed the local atmosphere and friendly service. The breakfast menu presented an interesting assortment of options including most classic breakfast dishes. I went for The Atticus which is a delicious breakfast wrap filled with eggs, spinach, bacon, cheese and a delicious local spicy sauce called Woodstead Sauce. Served with crispy, well-seasoned home fries, it was a great choice. My friends and I also shared an order of their banana pancakes served with real NY state maple syrup, and those were outrageously good. The pancakes were fluffy and buttery and worth getting just on their own. Service was friendly and patient, and our coffee was regularly refilled (necessary!). This is a worthwhile choice for a laid back meal if you're in the area. You can also buy some neat local specialty foods like the aforementioned Woodstead Sauce and Seneca Lake Culinary Salts at the counter which we loved. read more

Wow! What a place. Nothing bad to say here. We brought our kids and the server brought out candy land to keep them busy prior to lunch. Beer selection is small but great. Food is amazing. We had a salmon burgers that was on special. It was freshly made that morning and tasted great. Homemade fries were worth the upcharge. My kids shared a rice bowl that they raved about. Server was great. We will definitely be talking about this for a while. Great outdoor seating on a nice day. read more

Mill Creek is one of my family's favorite restaurants. The service is consistently top notch. Today my husband had the fish fry. Very fresh and cooked well. The home made chips are delicious. I had the chicken rice bowl. I really enjoy the black beans that are Seasoned with honey and chipotle pepper. Served with fresh tortilla chips. Mill Creek serves local, high quality food. I highly recommend. read more

My fiancé and I stopped here on our way to hike some nearby trails. Wow was the food amazing! She got a salmon burger, one of the specials, and I got the milk creek quesadilla. Also very good service. Waiter was attentive and food came out quickly. read more

Out for a motorcycle ride and stopped for lunch. Nice little place with outdoor dinning. Very good food. Had the Cajun Salmon sandwich was a special for the day. Very good. Service was Very good. I would stop here again if in the area again. read more

Mill Creek Cafe - Cajun Salmon sandwich - Diners Near Me - Honeoye, New York

The food and service is exceptional. They are very friendly and accommodating. Much better than I anticipated for a small town restaurant.