Delicious sandwiches, delightful setting, friendly staff in Palmyra on the Erie Canal. Can't wait…read moreto return.

The worker is not friendly at all. My potato chips was small crumbs. They must have just emptied…read morea bag on my order. Other people potato chips looked good. If you want a friendly place to eat go elsewhere The sandwich was poor quality. Byrn dairy sandwiches are so much better

One of my favorite diners. The staff is always friendly and has come to remember us from our…read morefrequent visits. The decor is a bit outdated but some of the original features; such as the brick wall bar seating area add a cozy charm to the overall ambiance. The main attraction here is the food. The portions are large and the quality is high. I have been to diners where they use deli meat and you can tell, it's just not as good. At Yellow Mills they serve carved roasted turkey. It's delicious! The sandwich and mashed potatoes come smothered with gravy; the ultimate comfort meal for me. My partner ordered the fish fry with fries. It typically comes with coleslaw but they let him upgrade to a salad at no additional cost. Prices are reasonable, less than $30 pretax for our pictured entrees.

A homestyle and local diner as they could come. A friend took us here during our visit to the area…read morefrom Pittsburgh and Yellow Mills Diner did not disappoint. Insanely affordable, delicious meals, solid portions, great service. Zero complaints and would love to be back.

Service was great! Friendly greeting and seated immediately. A brief wait for the food. We split a…read moreFish Fry dinner. Got onion rings instead of fries and side of slaw. The diner itself is cute. Oh! We got a giant cinnamon roll to go! Desert & breakfast later!

We were visiting from out of town to bring our daughter to the Strong museum, and we were looking…read morefor a place for breakfast. We walk in and wait at the front to be seated and no acknowledgment that the 3 of us were standing waiting to be seated- I get one glimpse from the cook standing in kitchen- Then the lady comes out a few minutes later and says she has one party of 12 so there will be a wait to assistance- She gave us this impression that we were an inconvenience and we were only a party of 2 adults and 1 child. The atmosphere was very uninviting and she was more relieved that we decided not to stay so we left- will never enter there again.

Great place off the beaten path. Thanks Yelpers for recommending this cute little café on the main…read morestreet. There is both indoor and outdoor seating and they do a very big take out business. In the rear of the restaurant, there is a very large outdoor patio one flight up, which includes an elevator from the parking lot. Menu is limited to a salad, wraps, and breakfast items. I ordered the chicken Caesar wrap, and it was perfectly prepared. In addition to the chicken, it included lettuce, mushrooms, and bacon and dressing that did not leak outside the wrap which is always my fear in ordering a wrap. There's a variety of so doesn't soft drinks inside of a chiller. Order at the counter and staff will happily bring your food pronto.

Amazing food and even better ambiance! The "pizza pancake" was perfectly golden brown and delicious.read more

Cute diner in the middle of village of Palmyra. Love the outside with all the flowers. Hometown…read morediner feel when you step inside of the diner .

Palmyra is a pretty small town, so we wanted to try a small local diner and get some simple food. I…read moreordered a really basic breakfast of 2 pancakes, 2 eggs and 2 sausage links (for some reason, the sausage links were extra, even though the name "2-2-2" implies it comes with them, like huh? ) and my husband got a breakfast muffin sandwich. Both of our orders were so bland and boring, I felt so ripped off. What is the point of going out to eat to a diner or a restaurant if they can't offer you something slightly above "just barely" okay? I can't find a reason to stop and eat here, at least for breakfast. If you can't do staples right, what makes you think I trust you to make something more complex and experimental taste good? Don't waste your time here, seriously.

We were passing through town and needed a non-diner breakfast with a good coffee selection and…read morefood. The busy bean cafe was that and more. My girlfriend got the Brown Sugar Shaken Espresso - which she thought was fantastic, and I got the cold brew (black) which was not too strong and was very tasty. The drinks even came in 20oz cups for caffeine lovers. To eat, we got a breakfast sandwich and a breakfast burrito which were both offered with a variety of add ons. The avocado was sliced, and the potatoes were in the burrito, not on the side. The service was friendly and kind. I would recommend this breakfast to everyone.

It was just ok. It was very busy and because you order at the counter and then sit down and wait…read morefor your food, it wasn't clear how long it would take for a take out order . We just ordered breakfast sandwiches (2) so we didn't think it would be long. As we waited, atleast 20 min, we barely saw any tables getting food so we inquired on how long it would be for the order and we were told they weren't sure?!!!! It came out right after luckily but not being able to say how long it would be was off putting and I wish they would've given a disclaimer before ordering. There is a whole separate section across a hallway with tables full of people also waiting for their food so it was very deceiving where you order to know how many people are ahead of you .

Typical diner food, good, large portions, fresh fruit is option, very nice. Facility is clean but…read moreold, basic, typical of older diner. Prices very reasonable.

What a diamond in the rough. Headed out on a rainy Sunday morning to find a good feel like home…read morebreakfast. This was just the place. Nestled in a plaza that you may not even take a second glance at but trust me, you should. If you want a diner with a hometown feel this is the place. Every person was so friendly! Smiling & kind. More of what we need in this world. Food came out hot, and tasted amazing. Portions are huge & prices are fair. Added bonus fish tank for the kids to look at & free WiFi if you are into those things. We will absolutely be coming back for breakfast & to try lunch.

I was camping at Keuka Lake State Park and needed some good breakfast and coffee. This place popped…read moreup with a lot of reviews and was about 20 minutes away! Lots of parking but it gets pretty busy. The restaurant is fairly small so seating can be limited. There is additional outside seating. They also have a general grocery store with some unique items. Coffee was good, my breakfast sandwich was awesome with bacon & ham and I should have bought more fry pies from the grocery store. I had a great visit! Looks like typical breakfast is in the $5-$10 range.

What a goldmine for breakfast, lunch & snacks! Service was so friendly. Lots of options for picky…read moreeaters

I ordered the chicken schnitzel and a ginger beer. The sandwich was delicious, perfectly cooked and…read morewell dressed with sauerkraut and Dijon mustard. The view of the lake was peaceful. The best part of this restaurant was their waitress. I didn't catch her name, but she was incredibly kind with a brown ponytail and sweet aura. She can tell I was traveling alone and gave me a list of all the places to check out in the area! I'm so lucky to have met her and plan to check out recommendations from her list

We spent a few days visiting Seneca Lake. After hiking Watkins Glen, we wanted a place to grab a…read morequick bite to eat. We found the Elf in the Oak on Yelp and once we saw the menu, we knew we had to give it a try. The Elf in the Oak is nestled on Rt 414. If you're not actively using a GPS, you may pass it by. It's not a large place by any means, but there's more than enough seating indoors and out. We went on a Friday morning, so there wasn't a wait and we received our food quickly. We both wanted 'the Spicy' and I have to admit, it's one of the best egg sandwiches I've ever had, which is high praise coming from someone who once worked at a popular bagel joint on Long Island. If we lived locally, we'd definitely go back, but I hope if you're looking for a quick casual brunch place to grab a bite, you consider visiting the Elf In The Oak.

They're open Friday, Saturday & Sunday. If you're in town those days this is the place to enjoy a…read moregreat lunch. Our small group enjoyed the salt potatoes and brisket! Definitely worth your time if you're visiting the area!

I have to say, I'm very disappointed to report my recent experience with Black Hart did not hit the…read moremark as well as it did my previous one. Unfortunately, the brisket sandwich was cold and really fatty- nothing like the first time. This time I asked for the coleslaw on the side and they gave me a thimble size (totally not exaggerating!) that didn't even cover a 1/4 of the sandwich - I understand they don't want to give people "extras" but at least give them the standard amount you normally put on the sandwich (I only asked for it on the side so that the bread didn't get too soggy on my way home). Cornbread was dry and wasn't as delicious as I remembered. Mac and cheese, just ok. I will say, the front end staff member was so friendly and kind-pushed their food and catering a little more than needed, but totally understand and know she was only doing her job and help support the business. Overall, so disappointed