I was camping at Keuka Lake State Park and needed some good breakfast and coffee. This place popped up with a lot of reviews and was about 20 minutes away! Lots of parking but it gets pretty busy. The restaurant is fairly small so seating can be limited. There is additional outside seating. They also have a general grocery store with some unique items. Coffee was good, my breakfast sandwich was awesome with bacon & ham and I should have bought more fry pies from the grocery store. I had a great visit! Looks like typical breakfast is in the $5-$10 range. read more

See all

The food is amazing! We got the Skipper paninis, breakfast panini, macaroni salad, ice chia and grape juice. Definitely be coming back here again! read more

See all

Great place to stop while you shop for any bulk food items at Oak Hill. Menu and ordering has come a long way - great breakfast and lunches. They e redone the inside over the past few years. The latest addition are booth type seats. Be sure to be very specific on items you want on or off your choices - they're very literal which is great but just know that ahead of time! read more

Oak Leaf Cafe - Large coffee - worth the extra couple of quarters to get the larger size with the big mug! - Cafes Near Me - Penn Yan, New York

See all

I accidentally discovered this place while visiting from out of town! This cute little Cafe, combined with fresh ice cream next store and the Oak Hill Bulk Foods is an absolute gem! The one thing I order for sure each time I visit is a smoothie - each one I've tried is amazing but the peach one is my favorite, especially in the summer! I've also enjoyed a number of their seasonal sandwich/panini specials. I like this place enough that about once per year, we make a special trip there from Rochester to grab a bite to eat and stock up on our favorites from the store! read more

A beautiful place, comfortable, homey feel. The food was so plentiful, beautifully served. I had a coffee (served in a huge ceramic mug, and a breakfast panini. It was garnished with oranges that were so delicious. A really great start to the day!! Highly recommend! read more

As someone from California exposed to an abundance of good coffee shops , I can say that the latte here is one of the best I've tried. Properly extracted shot so it was smooth and delicious. I also got some yogurt next door , and milk. High quality and delicious . Everyone was also friendly , I would definitely come back to this casual but delicious cafe. read more

Food is good, especially their soup. Love their chai, but unfortunately we do not go there often anymore as they now close the cafe at 3:00. We used to go often, just before 4:00 and get take out for supper. The new closing time is too early to do this any more. Never understood the time change as closing was at 4:00 for a long, long time. For some reason they catered to whatever convenience the time change was for them rather than accommodating customers. read more

Paninis and cookies were delicious but the biggest surprise to me was the Mac n cheese.

Yummmmmmm! What a hidden gem!!! So happy I gave this place a try. They have wonderful groceries and homemade items. Really good praise. And if you like pretzels, they have about 20 diff kinds to choose from! I got my boyfriend three diff kinds and all were yummy, especially the tiny pretzel bits. I can't recommend enough and really worth driving out of your way for. A local encouraged me to go and I had some work to do and sat outside comfortably the whole time while eating delicious food. I went back in for more to bring home too. Definitely worth a stop read more

See all

This counter-service cafe is a welcome cheap eats spot in an area whose options are sparse, especially in the off-season. The fact that it's a draw for an adorable bulk-foods grocery doesn't hurt, neither does the quality of their sandwiches. They seem to do paninis perfectly - crisp, tender toast, perfectly melted cheese, good ingredients. The seating area is relaxed and features a fireplace. It's clear the locals like it. I'd give it 5 stars but a couple things knock it down a notch for me. First, their selection of foods is not particularly exciting. Their focus is definitely on execution rather than innovation. Second, we got there 5 minutes after 11 and were told they stopped serving breakfast. I am sympathetic to the need to have some standard practices, but it's hard to believe in the Mennonite lunch counter that behaves like McDonald's. Nonetheless - try the mac salad, and the fry pies in the store. read more

Oak Leaf Cafe - Part of the order counter and the beverage case - Cafes Near Me - Penn Yan, New York

See all

Great cafe in this out of the way place. Very charming. We had read about their fry pies before coming here. So that's what we went for, after the coffees. They're kind of a cross between an empanada and a donut. They're fried pastry stuffed with cream, various fruits, etc. We took 4 different kinds back to our B and B. Delicious after heating a few seconds in the microwave. Probably better toasted in an oven. And then we went back the next day to get another bunch to bring back home to NYC. The place was very clean. The girls behind the counter were busy cleaning. And we got service with a warm smile. Great place! read more

Unusually affordable. Tuna salad tastes sweet and sour; I'm guessing they add a lot of sweet chopped dill pickle. Tastes great on multigrain bread with vegetable chips. Veggie chips remind me of "Bugles," a ground corn salty snack my kids used to like. Side salads use very fresh crisp high quality ingredients. They let you build your own salad and the price is ridiculously low for what they give you. Service is usually quick. They give you a buzzer that buzzes when your order is ready. I've only done take-out but there are many people who dine in and the cafe is very attractive. read more

This is the cafe attached to Oak Hill Bulk foods, serving up breakfast, pastries, and drinks crafted by the Amish community. Stop by here for a mind-blowing meal to remember. I'm shocked that the food here is so amazing given the extremely cheap prices. I ordered a breakfast sandwich filled with a fluffy egg omelette, ham, swiss, and a light mayo dressing. It sounds like such an ordinary sandwich, but it tasted absolutely phenomenal! The sandwich was stuffed with fresh ingredients, and even the bread tasted better than I expected. It was somehow as fluffy as the omelette. My boyfriend ordered a chai latte and the biscuits and gravy. The latte was so smooth, creamy, and delicious. Every sip delivers a creamy blend of spices. The biscuits were soft, buttery, and paired well with the gravy. This is definitely going to be a breakfast for the books if you stop by. read more

Oak Leaf Cafe - Egg Sandwich, Biscuits and Gravy (comes with potato salad), Chai Latte - Cafes Near Me - Penn Yan, New York

See all

Smallittle Amish Cafe thats part of a Amish store. The food is very good. Especially the smoothies. The peach smoothie with yogurt was amazing. Not like your local wawa peach smoothies. Very clean and friendly service. read more

Oak Leaf Cafe - Baked Oatmeal - Cafes Near Me - Penn Yan, New York

We love Oak Leaf Cafe! The atmosphere is friendly and the food is good. We order the sandwiches and salads quite often. The coffee drinks, smoothies and baked goods are wonderful too! We've been going to Oak Leaf for breakfast a lot lately! It's quick it's clean tasty and friendly. read more

See all

Yummy soup and chicken sandwich. Store next door was great, and the toddler enjoyed the playground

Delicious coffee and yummy breakfast. Quiche and breakfast panini. Absolutely must go back! read more

Oak Leaf Cafe - Simply delicious coffee - Cafes Near Me - Penn Yan, New York

See all

Absolutely beautiful store and Cafe. So clean. The food was excellent. Beautiful hand made goods. Wonderful Christian music playing softly in the background. Felt like I was in heaven! read more

This was my second time here and it never disappoints. The café and the shop are absolutely amazing. You can find anything you could ever possibly need to cook or bake with right here. The only reason I'm giving this place a four stars is because they were not cleaning tables in between customers. It is important to me that we use good hygiene when out and about in public. I'm hoping they improve their practice to create a safer environment for their customers. read more

See all

I don't know if it is the Covid or normally this disjointed. The service is weird. If you ordered soup and a drink and a sandwich all three things came at different times. At first I was impressed by how one of the wait staff cleaned tables down. After that one cleaning nothing more happened. The menu was so uninformative that if you didn't bring it up on YELP to get detail you wouldn't know what your ordering. I'm not a fan and won't go back. read more

I wrote up the bulk food and I thought it was the same but This is also a 5 stars, from their pastries to their yogurt parfait. They use top notch local yogurt, frozen fruit and their homemade granola. Their muffins are delish Their cappuccino is AMAZING. Didn't love the coffee as much. Very kind people working here. All of their homemade pastries are so so yummy. Love this place. Also breakfast burrito is good!!!! read more

Oak Leaf Cafe is definitely a must try place! They are so attentive, clean, and super kind. My Ma and I both wanted to get breakfast, but we just missed the mark at 11:10 am and it was 11:12 am when we tried to order. They don't serve breakfast after that time we were told unfortunately. My Ma and I ordered the cheesesteak sandwich and it was slamming. Although, it was a bit dry through some parts and we asked a waitress that happened to pass us by after cleaning a table with a sanitizing agent(which is awesome to see) if we could get some extra mayonnaise. Without any problem or extra fee she delivered to us extra mayonnaise to us within that minute. It gets quite busy during Lunch time, but the long lines become pretty short in no time because the workers here get their work done (imagine that huh haha). The layout of the Cafe is very spacious, so it doesn't feel like you're crammed near people. It displays lots of nature paintings, which gives the Cafe a tranquil and airy feeling. I would definitely stop by again whenever I'm in the area and hopefully next time I make it for breakfast! read more

See all

This place was phenomenal! My absolute favorite breakfast/cafe place I have EVER been to! It's cheap, it has amazing food, amazing drinks/lattes, the staff is wonderful, the place is so cozy inside. I loved it and definitely plan on going back when I'm back in town. They have a cute little fireplace inside, and connected to the cafe is a market deli place and a little spot that has cute Christmas and fall decor. They have a neat little doorbell sound when you enter the place, and it just feels so cozy inside. Highly recommend this place - it's wonderful!! read more

See all

You have to start kicking it up a notch! The service is getting slower and slower. Very few customers waiting for food. We waited 15 minutes for 2/2 sandwich with cup of soup. Needs a Cafe manager soon! read more

All I have to say is PLEASE get the baked oatmeal! OMG, delicious I have never heard of or tried baked oatmeal in my life and this was out of this world good!!! You can get it with milk or yogurt and with or without powdered sugar & whipped cream. I chose yogurt without the powdered sugar & whipped cream. It comes out piping hot surrounded by fresh cut peaches. I enjoyed every bite! The yogurt was so delish too!! I accompanied it with a hot chocolate that was so creamy and heavenly for the taste buds. My Aunt raved about how incredible the coffee was too! read more

Between the excellent food, generous portions and reasonable prices, I was really blown away both by the cafe and the store. The store had all sorts of unique and delicious looking products, at fair prices. The fact that it is an Amish run business, I thought, added a nice touch But in general, I was just really impressed by the overall attention to detail that you don't find in most businesses. For example, in the cafe, there were electric outlets underneath the benches . Would highly recommend to anyone passing through the area read more

For the second time in six months I have been very disappointed in the breakfast selections that were offered at this establishment. The first time this happened I thought this was COVID related. However, this time at 9:30 in the morning on a holiday weekend they were almost out of all breakfast items on the menu which now makes me think it's a lack of planning that is causing me to give this poor review. The staff is incredibly friendly and the setting here is very nice, but I find it very frustrating to go out for breakfast and be offered either a very limited menu or actually lunch as it was proposed to me by one of the staff members. Not good! read more

Great food! Friendly staff. Variety of items to see and shop for and taste. Popular for all ages. Great place to shop for birthdays and holidays. More baking items to shop for baking. Back to basics. read more

Great lunch or breakfast home cooking and specialty store Sunrise Sandwich Oak Leaf's Panini read more

What can I say this I love this place it is very unique! First they have an amazing cafe that has everything from great latte's to great baked goods such as pastries, donuts and bread. All made right there on side with simple yet great ingredients!The cafe is like Panera on steroids! I have had so many items such as the breakfast sandwiches, turkey presto paninis and many other things on the menu. Then the other side is a bulk food store. They again have soooo many great things from the deli to Stolfuz Yoguart which is a farm in upstate that makes the best I have ever had! They even have chocolate bars the side of my torso!! Bonus On Saturdays they do a great Chicken BBQ! read more

See all

I loved this charming little cafe inside the store, and I appreciated the unique flavors. I chose a sandwich special that had apples and sharp cheese with turkey breast but I cannot remember what exactly it was called. I do remember exactly what it tasted like though! It was awesome. Warm gooey sharp cheddar and the crunch of the apple slices was the perfect contrast. I would absolutely revisit and try something new. read more

Oak Leaf Cafe - Turkey cheese and apple sandwich with chips on the side! - Cafes Near Me - Penn Yan, New York

This place is amazing. We just stumbled upon it in the country. Wow! I absolutely loved my BLT wrap. It was huge and so yummy and only $6. The people were so nice! I highly recommend it. You won't be sorry. read more

Oak Leaf Cafe - Cafes Near Me - Penn Yan, New York

See all

Best turkey sub! My husband and I split a 12". We couldn't finish it. Great homemade roll and some macaroni salad. Friendly folks. The bakery treats looked wonderful. Busy place. Seems out in the middle of nowhere. read more

Food is great, prices are great, employees are kind and cafè is very clean. I regularly purchase the monthly specials and enjoy the ice coffee. The peach milkshake is also fantastic if you come when they have it! read more

Delicious oatmeal. Great food and quaint atmosphere. Love coming here when we are in town.

This is a great stop for breakfast or lunch. Cute dining area to dine in or call ahead and get your order to-go! Either way the food is delicious and the service is exceptional and there is never too long of a wait time for your food. Food is reasonably priced and comes with a side of chips or veggie chips. Their coffee is also very good and cheaper than dunkin! My personal favorite for lunch is the pepperjack panini, and I can never leave without some sort of fruit & cream cheese fry pie. So delicious! read more

The food is great from wraps and smoothies to bulk food off to side. If my kids are happy eating somewhere. I'm happy too. Good family atmosphere. read more

This place is a gem. Nice friendly staff. Clean restrooms. You can count on good food, good service and a great price. If your interested in a good basic sandwich or salad, this is your place. We have been there four or five times and the product and service as been consistently good. Don't expect a place with beer on tap, wine or beer. Good spot for a family to enjoy a good reasonable place to have lunch. After lunch, take a leisurely walk through the bulk foods side of the business. read more

Delish locally sourced food - sandwiches, coffees, smoothies, paninis, salads, baked good. Yum Yum Yum. Definitely getting your monies worth! read more

Oak Leaf Cafe - Cafes Near Me - Penn Yan, New York

So finding good food in and around Keuka Lake takes some time. There are a ton of greasy spoons or places that are chains. Oak Leaf is a true gem. They offer fresh baked cookies, pies, sandwhiches and so much more. If your party has Gluten Allergies, they also offer Gluten Free Bread as an option. Their breakfasts are awesome. Coffee is the best in town. Great Lattes. If you are in the area, make sure you swing by and try it out! read more