Delicious sandwiches, delightful setting, friendly staff in Palmyra on the Erie Canal. Can't wait to return.

The worker is not friendly at all. My potato chips was small crumbs. They must have just emptied a bag on my order. Other people potato chips looked good. If you want a friendly place to eat go elsewhere The sandwich was poor quality. Byrn dairy sandwiches are so much better read more

What a hidden gem. We were traveling through and found this little spot to eat at. It's like everything is homemade - it's so fresh, delicious, and definitely make sure to try whatever seasonal lemonade she has available. Great price, great food and GREAT people! Lunch was a 10/10. Hope I can come back when it's warm out to enjoy the view even more. read more

If you're basing your food plans on Muddy Waters, make a backup plan! We came by three times, but it wasn't open during its posted hours any of the times. While we were trying to figure out if the online hours were correct with the posted hours, there were other people trying to go to the café too. Super bummed because it looks cute. read more

The lady that took my order was not friendly. The sandwich I got I wished I got something else. The chips was from the bottom of bag. They were all broken small pieces. Won't spend my money there read more

Will NEVER go here again. Tried it 3x and the owner got our order wrong each time. Not the friendliest, or most efficient service.

Service wasn't the best, and we went during a hot day and there was no ac on in the dining room

Closed during posted hours. Don't bother going there. Saw a few comments mention this and gave it a chance... should not have.

The Sandwiches are so freaking good. They are very fresh, very good flavors but very slow service. If you come during the palmyra pageant expect an hour wait. read more

Muddy Waters Cafe - Hobbledasher - Cafes Near Me - Palmyra, New York

See all

The most rude staff/owner I've ever experienced. We were trying to look at the menu and figure out what our kids wanted because they didn't have the bread the kids wanted, then she yelled, "While you guys ARGUE about that, let's figure out the ADULT orders." Now I know it can be hard to wait while we figure out orders but she was not understanding at all, and lost her temper after 30 seconds of contemplation. We left because we no longer felt comfortable there and had never been treated like that at a restaurant before. I will say there was a lady with white hair at the cash register that was very nice so I will give them that. Overall bad experience. read more

So perfect! This little cafe is tucked into Palmyra down by the river. So delicious and so hospitable. Our family was treated like family. The food was fresh and yummy!! The owner chatted with us for quite awhile, getting to know us and our travels. She made great recommendations and made everything from scratch and served it all hot. We will definitely be back and definitely recommend to all! read more

The food was so good it was really hard to decide what to get! Definitely get a lemonade, they were delicious! I got the blue moon salad and it was so good. My sister got the Neffer sandwich and that was amazing too! Also get the chocolate chip and macadamia nut cookie. The lady was very nice and you can see that the food is all fresh. If you sit outside you get a great view of the Erie Canal. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone in Palmyra. read more

Donna, owner and Chef is a warm friendly lady who will fill your belly with good, homemade food! Clean, cute and a wonderful view! read more

See all

Large variety of tasty sandwiches, homemade bread. Peaceful outdoor seating and great service. Hidden gem in Palmyra. read more

Muddy Waters Cafe - Hoodledasher - Turkey Breast, Provolone, Roasted Red Peppers, Crispy Bacon, ​Roast Red Pepper Sauce - Cafes Near Me - Palmyra, New York

See all

Road our bikes from Buffalo to Rome - slept in Palmyra and had breakfast at Muddy Waters - Donna and Miss Sheila couldn't have been nicer - breakfast was delicious - picnic shelter nearby - right on the canal and very convenient - highly recommend read more

My partner, 12yo, and I rode our bikes from Syracuse to Lockport. We camped in Newark, but waited till our first stop in Palmyra to get our coffee and breakfast, because we heard about this cute little cafe right on the trail. I actually ate a salad for breakfast, because it just sounded so good on the menu, and it was! My son loved his sausage, egg, and cheese sandwich. Definitely take a little time to explore Main Street-a beautiful, historical little town! read more

Fabulous place. Delicious food. Just in town for a visit and thought we would check it out. Had the number 2 sandwich, and it was great. The owner was very kind and gave us advice about our trip. The place felt like home and I loved the decorations. I'd highly recommend! read more

See all

Great place to eat! Small little place that is super friendly and the food is very good. Probably not many out-of-towners go here since it's not on a Main Street, but the sandwiches were good, and everything was homemade. read more

Muddy Waters Cafe - #19 Freshet - Cafes Near Me - Palmyra, New York

Hadn't been there for years and decided to take a friend there for lunch. We both had delicious food and you can't beat the beautiful setting. Best lunch spot in this area! read more

I am from out of town and had someone online tell me about this restaurant. I am so happy we went. It was so good and had a very cute and quaint feel about it. The sandwich we got was a number two and it was delicious. I would definitely recommend it to a friend the atmosphere is great and their healthy lemonade was delicious. read more

Muddy Waters Cafe - Cafes Near Me - Palmyra, New York

I went pre-pandemic and the place was nice I had a sandwich and soft drink the food was excellent but the prices were so INSANE I won't go back. read more

We just happened to stumble on this cute little cafe while out for a walk on the Canalway Trail and it was the perfect place to stop for a sandwich and a beer. They make both hot and cold sandwiches and had maybe four kinds of beer on tap, including Fat Tire. My BLT was very good. They have more tables inside, but also have a small deck with four tables and a view of the canal. Great find. read more

Muddy Waters Cafe - Cafes Near Me - Palmyra, New York

This place is so good!!! My husband and I are vegan and we've found a good selection there. Before we became vegan we really liked the Spillway (vegetarian). Their flavored lemonades are really great too!!! You should definitely try their wood fired pizzas... so fresh and good!! read more

Delicious paninis that are very reasonably priced (~$8). Small place with cute decor and great location along the river. The woman there (guessing the owner) is a one stop shop taking orders at the counter, making sandwiches and ringing people up. We got there around 1:30 and they were sold out of cookies so call ahead if you want to try them! I liked the #2 sandwich (had good flavor) but I tried bites of a few others and they were all pretty good. Just wish they offered carrot sticks or salad as an option versus tortilla chips. read more

See all

This place was amazing. I had a turkey provolone sandwich with the chips and a flat tire beer on draft the staff was very welcoming made you feel like you were at home. Food was excellent warm fresh ingredients very tasty very cute quaint little place make sure you time it as I would imagine it fills up quickly at the peak hours Great scenery nice deck I would a hundred percent recommend this place read more

Muddy Waters Cafe - a bridge over a river - Cafes Near Me - Palmyra, New York

Amazing place to stop off the canal trail for a quick treat and coffee! We couldn't have found a better place! Donna will make you feel like a local. Wish I could give her more than 5 stars!!! read more

Get the Coconut Pecan Chocolate Chip Cookie. You won't regret it. So many Nom Nomsssssss

Get off the beaten path and stop by this gem of a lunch spot! Beautiful view over the Erie Canal, would recommend sandwich #2 and Açaí Lemonade! read more

Delightful and charming! Almost like eating from your mother's kitchen. We loved the Hoodledasher panini, Caesar salad, and the cranberry lemonade! The owners are so nice & accommodating. Such cute decorations and we just loved the food & hospitality read more

What a gem! Found it on Yelp and the reviews don't lie! This is a charming cafe, with fantastic food and the kindest and most helpful owner in the world. Take her suggestions! The #4 (grilled turkey provolone) was amazing! And if you get there in time, her cookies are a MUST!! read more

This little cafe off the main drag has delicious food. We all loved our lunch!! We were looking for somewhere for a late lunch on my birthday and this served its purpose very well. Friendly staff and fresh food. read more

Warm atmosphere and quality home made soups and sandwiches. We enjoyed chatting with the owner and chef. Delightful little place. Facing the canal and quaint. Summer would be ideal to sit outside on the patio. read more

Dine-in is available even though Google says it isn't. Wonderful little place and amazing food!

Such a cute little place, perfect for a little lunch spot with a nice back patio view! Delicious sandwich/panini options. Definitely recommend! read more

We were looking for something new other than the typical Main Street diner and we found this little gem. The setting is quaint and peaceful; right on the canal. They have a pleasant indoor dinning area with plenty of windows to enjoy the view or sit outside on the deck and listen to the birds while you enjoy the home cooked food. Everything we had was delicious, from the breakfast sandwich with grilled veggies, egg and cheese to the bagels. Coffee is fresh and self serve. The owner greater us with a smile and promptly waited on us. We plan on making this a regular stop when we are in town. If your looking fort something different than the dark and old interior of the local diner, give Muddy Waters a try! read more

What a fantastic find! Delicious sandwiches. Try the "Something New" for a fun bunch of flavors. The location is so quaint. Personal service. read more

Such a sweet, yummy place. We came in almost at closing and they were kind enough to stay open and help feed our large family (adjusting orders for kids too!). read more

Cute and quiet place! Beautiful scenery as well. Delicious food that is all made fresh. I had the hoodle and it was great!

Delightful and helpful service. Really handy from the dock if you're doing the Canal Boat rental thing. While you're in Palmyra, check out the museums. This is such a nice & friendly town and Muddy Waters is a great start to your tour. We were there in August,2018. read more

Charming little restaurant! And the food was amazing!!! We wend from Niagara Falls, Palmyra, New York City, Gettysburg and Philadelphia, and this was our favorite restaurant. The sandwiches are sooooo tasty! read more