In full transparency we were originally going to another diner. The wait there was very long so we left and by happenstance stumbled upon this gem. Best accident ever! The food? delicious! Stuffed French toast & 2 eggs over easy with home fries and Jamaican Toast. The service? Personable and attentive. We will absolutely be back. I almost don't want anyone else to know how good the food is because I don't want to have to walk into a "wait" but they deserve the praise. 100! read more

Just finished a fabulous lunch at the Five Mile Cafe. The food was delicious! Their 8 ounce handmade burger was perfectly cooked, juicy and tender and served with hot crispy fries and even a sweet pickle garnish. We also had a delectable tuna melt , grilled on rye with tomatoes and sharp cheddar cheese. I opted for the traditional macaroni salad and it too was a great side with the addition of grated carrots and red onion in a very creamy and tangy mayonnaise dressing. Their menu is extensive for breakfast and lunch entrees! Service and ambiance is a definite 5 star! Do yourself a favor and enjoy a meal at this quaint, spotless and so inviting cafe! read more

Food was good, however the waiter acted like he was upset that there were patrons there. Did not say a word. There were 3 tables with 2 people at each table. Could not even say welcome or anything! When we left he could not even say thank you! Will not be back as the atmosphere was NOT what I expected at all. read more

Best breakfast around!!! Fresh flavors and great portions. My husband had the Jamaican bowl and I had the crab cake benny, both slapped! the jerk pork was mouthwateringly good. I left a review 7 years ago and this place has stood the test of time, still five stars. read more

What a treasure this place is. They were very busy when we got there but Chelsea made us feel welcome. We had a 2y/o with us, she brought crayons and coloring books followed by pancakes and sausage. My companion had the stuffed French toast. I would have taken a pic but she dug right in. I had a turkey melt, yum. This place is cozy and homey. We will be back!!! read more

Andre and Chelsea, great hosts....food top notch..it was worth the side trip. I recommend the home made cornbread hash! read more

What a fun find! Great tasting food. The crab cake Benedict was generous with the crab, and the eggs were perfectly cooked. My daughter got the Reuben, and it also was generous on the meat side. The restaurant was clean and the wait staff was very friendly! Positive sayings and little books on the table reflect hope-nice theme! Found out that Jamaican toast is a dense bread that is slightly sweet. Very nice! Open for breakfast and lunch with breakfast served all day. Highly recommend. I saw tables outside for warmer weather! read more

The Five Mile Cafe - Cafes Near Me - Penfield, New York

See all

Cozy cafe and fabulous breakfast spot. We had the spinach and artichoke quiche special and made to-order-mushroom, Swiss omelette. Everthing was delicious and service was exceptional. Will definitely return! read more

It was the most beautiful cafe I've been to.10/10 would recommend. The food was amazing.I had a 5 mile burger Jr.it was the best burger I've ever had .i hope will enjoy the cafe too.the service was amazing and the staff were so nice and friendly. read more

See all

Passed my this place many times, so glad we finally went in to eat breakfast. We got a veggie frittata with a blueberry muffin, a chocolate chip pancake and crab cake eggs benny with home fries. Tried everything and it was incredibly fresh tasting and delicious. The service was very warm and friendly as well and the coffee was really good (and Im pretty picky about my coffee). Definitely coming back ASAP! read more

Second and certainly not my last visit. Cozy family run restaurant with excellent service and food. My lox and bagel came out like a work of art. read more

The Five Mile Cafe - Cafes Near Me - Penfield, New York

my wife and I were seated right away. we only had 1 menu. had to get up and take one from another table. food took a long time coming even though there were only 5 other diners in the restaurant. the food was very good. the service was terrible. it felt like the regular waiter was out and the bartender took their place. we got one word greetings, replies. or none at all. waiter bordered on very rude! we were not happy with the place at all! read more

As soon as we arrived, the hostess told us there would be about a 10-minute wait, despite several empty tables that were clearly ready to go. Our waiter was friendly but very slow--it felt like it might've been his first day on the job. My mom ordered her bacon well done, and I asked for mine lightly done. When the food arrived, mine was nearly twice as cooked as hers. The food itself was decent--not great, but not terrible either. However, the service left a lot to be desired. While my mom was mid-bite, the server dropped off the check. Then, just two minutes later, she came back looking for the payment and wanted to box my mom's food up. she offered this while my mom was trying to finish her meal. my mom dropped her fork, passed the server some cash to cover the bill and tip. the woman walked away without even a simple "thank you" While the food might be worth three stars on its own, the poor service and pricing drag the overall experience down. I wouldn't recommend the 5 Mile Café unless you're okay with inattentive, borderline rude service. read more

Its one of my favorite new breakfast place. I had the veggie frittata with biscuit and it was delicious. This has now been my weekly weekend place. The place is quaint, clean and staff very friendly. read more

Bigger than it looks from the outside. Small family owned business, my favorite. We got a wrap, the stuffed French toast and a tuna melt for our brunch-ish meeting. The tuna melt was perfect, coming with a tomato without asking. The stuffed French Toast was fruity, creamy and sweet. Exactly as described. The wrap was light but filling. It was a special, there were many, and I'm not sure which it was. But we all left extremely full and happy with both the food and the service. read more

The Five Mile Cafe - Tuna Melt - Cafes Near Me - Penfield, New York

See all

4.5 stars My wife and I had a good lunch experience here yesterday. The service was friendly and the atmosphere was friendly. Most importantly, the food was good. We were both craving club sandwiches and The FIve Mile Cafe served a pretty good one. Perfectly crunchy toast, thinly sliced in-house baked turkey with crisp lettuce and tomatoes. It hit the spot. Definitely will be back again for brunch. read more

The Five Mile Cafe - Turkey Club Sandwich - Cafes Near Me - Penfield, New York

See all

We ordered pick up from here for breakfast.  My husband went and picked it up, and it took longer than they said to be ready.  I had stuffed French toast. It was pretty good.  The filling in it was really good. My husband got a frittata that was also good.  I wish they had longer hours because my husband and I aren't morning people, so there's not many times we can get here.  I did see they're on Doordash or one of those, so we may try delivery sometime. I would definitely order from them again. read more

Quaint little breakfast nook! All three of us enjoyed our breakfast, as well as the atmosphere.

The establishment has limited seating. It is small and cozy and it appears to be a house that the owners turned into a local breakfast spot. The staff was very polite and they made every accommodation to seat our family of four. Andre was a wonderful server and gave us recommendations for the area. Mom-view-Family friendly breakfast without an overly complex menu. The portions are a good size for children. My girls enjoyed the teddy bear pancake. They keep the food simple just like you would get at home. I enjoyed my quiche and my husband ordered the Benedict. I was tempted to try some of their Jamaican options but opted for the quiche because it is my favorite! read more

See all

Fantastic. Cozy place off of five mile line rd. Good sized parking lot in the back. We had the stuffed French toast(delicious) and the weekend special jerk chicken breakfast bowl(also delicious). They used a sturdy bread for the French toast so it still had some structure when biting into it. The jerk breakfast bowl came with potatoes, peppers and onions, 2 eggs any way, chicken and jerk sauce. It was so flavorful and great sized portion. The staff was very friendly and personable. Especially Andre. We will definitely be back! read more

One of my favorites for brunch, the food is outstanding! The environment is friendly and cozy, and the staff is always welcoming. You won't be disappointed, and will return often! read more

Great little spot is a heart of Penfield... Family owned super friendly! We had a delicious breakfast here and sat on the outside patio. Who made biscuits and poultry sausage gravy with eggs and beautifully hand sliced thin home fries. The veggie frittata was loaded with veggies and the Apple & mint garnish was delicious. We had a lovely time with the owner and chef who gave us a full tour of the space. If you're thinking of a private event they do those in the evenings and the entire building is available. Open for regular lunch and breakfast service read more

See all

I can't fathom why this place isn't busier. We've been here for breakfast/brunch a number of times now and it's always good. The owner (Andre?) is always there working, super nice. My better half got the crab Benedict and it was fantastic, perfectly poached eggs and the crab cake was delicious. I got the special, which was a Jamaican spiced mix of sausage, potatoes, veg and eggs. It was great. We need to come back here for lunch. Seating is nice indoors but outside on the front porch is perfect this time of year. Go to this place! read more

Out-of -towners recommend The Five Mile Cafe! The house was cute, the food was delicious, and the manager won our hearts with his American dream story of owning a small restaurant! Here's to hard work and great food! read more

Beautiful place great food great service! We will be back for sure! Had stuffed French toast and Eggs Benedict. Did not get a pic of those but this we split. Very good. read more

The Five Mile Cafe - Stuffed French Toast - Cafes Near Me - Penfield, New York

I had lunch here for the first time with a dozen friends for a baby shower ordering from their quite extensive menu including gluten free. The food was very very good and modestly priced. Portions were generous. The service was quick even for a large group and other customers. The service was attentive throughout the meal. Everything was quite clean and well decorated. This restaurant is not in my neighborhood but I plan to frequent it in the future. I recommend you come and bring your friends. read more

This place has the best bacon egg and cheese breakfast wrap around. Frequent this place often via grubhub and I'm never disappointed. Why don't my breakfast wraps ever taste this delicious? read more

The Five Mile Cafe - Breakfast Wrap with a lil ketchup - Cafes Near Me - Penfield, New York

My favorite meal is breakfast. And, The Five Mile Cafe was a great choice for breakfast. I enjoyed the eggs benedict which I customized to substitute a bed of spinach for the english muffin. My husband enjoyed the corned beef hash and eggs. Another great breakfast restaurant to add into our rotation! Service & food was perfect. We are looking forward to returning for lunch on a nice day so we can dine on their quaint outside patio. read more

See all

We had our second great experience at the five mile line cafe today. The food was delicious and fresh. The service was again outstanding. The location is cozy and comfortable with plenty of parking and easy access. We definitely recommend the five mile line cafe for a great breakfast or lunch experience! read more

It's so cute! I loved that it was just in a house. The atmosphere is perfect. I was in the mood for a savory brunch, and we were able to get a table for 2 immediately (even called and asked over the phone). This place really hit the spot! read more

The Five Mile Cafe - Corn beef hash with toast and poached egg - Cafes Near Me - Penfield, New York

It's Mother's Day (always busy) but they did well taking it all in stride! (And they do take reservations.) Quiche was great! Stuffed French toast was excellent, had it with the fresh (not canned) peaches--nice! (They also offer maple syrup for a little extra.) We'd definitely go back! The only thing is I wish they had chairs with more of a back, that would be more supportive for older folks. Great little neighborhood place. So nice to patronize a family run business and not a chain! read more

First time eating here. Excellent food, beautiful setting and great service. Small inside but nice porch in front and patio in rear with 10-12 tables. Had breakfast this morning, wife had a Veggie Benedict over Jamaican toast and I had an Italian sausage hash omelette. Both were excellent but the best were their home fries. Not sure what's in it but simply delicious. Lunch menu looks awesome also, they have a Jamaican heritage but most of the menu is American fare. They did feature some jerk chicken specials. Not cheap but what is today. I will definitely be back. read more

The Five Mile Cafe - Rear patio - Cafes Near Me - Penfield, New York

See all

Yum! I live close by and decided to try it out for my first time. Food was soooo good. Cute place with some outdoor seating. Everyone was nice and attentive. I came at 1pm and they close at 2 so not a lot of ppl, which was good. I'll definitely come back. One downside, no Mimosas. Haha read more

The Five Mile Cafe - Western Omelette - Cafes Near Me - Penfield, New York

What a wonderful place for lunch. We enjoyed a delicious sandwich and a frittata. Fresh food, fast service but did not feel rushed. Andre made everything so enjoyable. I'm glad Yelp suggested this spot! read more

We had lunch at the five cafe. I had the Corned Beef Reuben Sandwich and coleslaw and my wife had the tuna melt and macaroni salad. The total cost was $34. My wife enjoyed her lunch! My reuben was excellent and they made great coleslaw! The cost of the meal was $34 which was reasonable. We have also been here several times for breakfast and we were never disappointed. I had the french toast and cinnamon challah. Both dishes were excellent. The service is always good and I recommend eating here. They have indoor and outdoor dining. read more

The Five Mile Cafe - Corned Beef Reuben Sandwich - Cafes Near Me - Penfield, New York

Food was great! We had really good Eggs Benedict and Potato Latkes. Server was nice, plus they were open on Thanksgiving morning. Portions were the right size. read more

The Five Mile Cafe - a sign for the five mile cafe - Cafes Near Me - Penfield, New York

See all

This is a family run restaurant that provides customers with not just great food, but also a warm friendly environment. Indoor and outdoor seating (seasonal). There is parking in the rear. Open for breakfast and lunch. The service is fast and the flavor is satisfying. I came for breakfast. I had biscuits and gravy, scrambled eggs and hashbrowns. The default potato is home fries which are crisp and tasty. Next time I will do the home fries. They offer a choice of poultry or Italian sausage gravy. Try the poultry. You can create your own omelet or choose one off the menu. There are many other selections. read more

Love this little cafe. Plenty of seating inside and out at this repurposed house. Comfortable, charming ambiance. Delicious home cooked food. Friendly service. Great place to meet friends. read more

Great ambiance and service. The Cobb salad and stuffed pancakes were mediocre and uninspiring.

Had the ahi tuna for a third time with homemade potato chips and Jamaican frittata. Both excellent!