Stopped here on a whim since it was in the way back from a lecture to the hotel. Loved their pizza. Reminded me of the pizza from a pizzeria from my hometown. Yum! Peeps were super nice. Great service all around. Energy upbeat. Cool wall of music albums (see pics) read more

See all

When I come to Columbus, I always just go to the North Market. This trip, I was branching out! Within walking distance of my hotel, of course. Mikeys popped up on yelp, and to my surprise, they are open LATE. Not like 10:00 late, like after the lights come on, late. I couldn't take myself back out after checking into my hotel at midnight, but I went to sleep thinking about Mikey's. First stop the next day, after I was caffeinated, was to get their special of the week. Das Taterhosen. If I am going to wake up and carbo load, it will be on mashed potato pizza. Garlic potatoes, to be precise. With caramelized onions, bacon, cheese, and spices. It is finished off with a drizzle of sour cream and chives. I believe there is no pizza blasphemy, in America, and I am down to try something ridiculous. (However I would never speak of such things in Italy) Inside, the space is awesome. Bar to the left, straight back for pizza at the counter. Sauce distribution just left of the counter. I asked about the unicorn sauce and was told it was chipotle ranchish. Cool. Tin tiles on the ceiling, fun art scattered on the walls, the place is comfortable and whimsy. I just ordered the one slice. I had things to do and places to eat that day. It was exactly what I expected, but better. It wasn't just stoggy and heavy. The dough was super thin and still have a nice crisp to it. The crust had flavor and still a nice chew. The toppings were spread thin, not to overpower and just sog the crust. Had to do with mashed potatoes. You could taste all the ingredients and somehow it was both pizza and pierogi. In the best way. This particular concoction was a limited recipe and I am glad I tried it. I really want to go back and try just a regular old pepperoni. I bet that takes it up to 5 stars. Next time Columbus, next time. read more

See all

Ok we LOVED this place! Pizza was good, they had their own sauce bar with lots of options (no extra cost). We had the garlic and unicorn sauce - highly recommend! Then we got 2 shots.... Because why not? Bartender was knowledge and friendly and the drinks were good. The service was a little slow with a long line but overall good and friendly. The ambiance is eclectic and fun with a touch of old school (pizza hut lamp) and we enjoyed it! The prices are a little high, but fair. The only negative experience was we saw the photo booth and were unbelievably excited about it but it was out of order. We are visiting from out of state and loved it! Lots of walkable options around in the area. read more

See all

Great place to stop in and grab a slice or a pizza to go. They have a bar as well. We ordered a slice of cheese and it was ready in just a few minutes. Piping hot and delicious. read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I finally got a taste of Mikey's during my visit to Oddfellows, their truck is conveniently located right next door to the bar. Ordering was easy and my slice of spicy pepperoni came out quickly. The slice was big and cheesy, easy to fold and start muching on once back inside. My friend warned me that it may be a little greasy, but I don't think it was greasier than any other pizza. A yummy addition to a night in the Short North! read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I tried their pizza inspired by a pierogi...potato garlic. This was really good. Maybe cause it was midnight? Not sure but I really enjoyed it. The bread sticks were just ok. Dipping sauce was cold. Would definitely come back if I was looking for a late night slice. read more

Been coming to Mikey's for over a decade and I have never been disappointed, on busy days, on rainy days they always serve the best! I love the Sauce bar, and all the fun weekly pizzas! The vibes are immaculate and I adore the staff. The place is its own, though it's a growing chain (yay more locations) I feel like its own little oasis, welcoming all! It's like your super cool older sibling made a pizza place! I love it here!!!! read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Whole Plain-Ass Pepperoni Whole Cheese w/Fresh Basil - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

The pizza box itself is amazing. I will feel bad for throwing it out, but it's not going to make the two hour trip home with us . We ordered online and walked a block from our hotel and brought it back to the room to eat. The interior of the place is cool and the people were nice. I don't generally like thin pizza, but this was really good. I'd say this is more of a 4.5...the thing keeping it from a 5 is the price. This thing cost me $32 plus a tip. It's worth a look if you're in town. read more

See all

Came in and ordered a slice of the spicy pepperoni. Slice came fast and was fresh. Flavors were good but pepperonicini was an odd flavor choice. Good but probably better places in the area. Nice that it's open til 230 am tho read more

This is a pizza place I always have to visit when I make my way to Columbus (from 3 hours away). I love the spicy pepperoni and the garlic sauce is so good. They sell the pizza by the very large slice or by the pie. The decor of the shop is so cool too! read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Pizza display case - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Update 12/2/25. After posting my review, Mikey's did everything to make it right. They refunded my order and sent me a gift card to use in the future. Therefore I'm updating my 1 star to 4. Will update again once I am back to use the gift card! read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Burnt pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Decent pizza. This is a good choice for a late night bite. The pizza is pretty good. Some good options. The place also has a full service bar. Atmosphere is pretty relaxed. We had a minor issue but was quickly addressed by the staff. read more

My husband has named this "the best pizza in the world." He gets the pepperoni and I get vegan. It is amazing vegan pizza and I love that they also have the dips available for me. He gets 3 pieces and KILLS them, but you could easily have one piece and be completely full. lol We live in Dayton so we stop in frequently when we come to town for CBJ games. The marketing is fantastic and the ambience is killer. We enjoy hanging out and crowd watching while we eat a slice (or 3 haha). The service is always great too. Extremely friendly and makes you feel like you belong there! Calling me queen?! Giving me special vegan ranch?!? Yes, please and thank you!! read more

See all

The people here are always really chill and nice. I love the fact that they have a vegan pizza as well. I love all of the cheesy designs they add in into the restaurants, making a fun environment. This location has booths you can sit at and a small walk up bar! read more

Was in the area looking for a slice of pizza and came across this gem! The pizza was good and service was quick and friendly. read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Spicy Slice of Plain-Ass Pepperoni* - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

If you go late, know that the line will be long. Stay in it though. It's well worth it for weary stomachs in need of late-night pizza. We had someone stake out our spot and hold a booth for us while in line. The decorations are quirky and there's always something to see while you're standing waiting. Chances are if you're staggering around after dark, you'll come to this place as it's basically the only spot in the area that is open so late. It was great! read more

See all

We were at origins game fair, and one of the companies got a bunch of us pizza to share while gaming. As a self proclaimed New York pizza snob I always like to see what's out there. This slice did not disappoint with really flavorful pizza. Crust was nice and crispy, and the pizza overall was not too greasy even with the pepperoni. I also found that the spice they use for some added flavor really works well with their cheese and sauce. Definitely more basil in the flavor, which to me is a great thing. Based on this and the experiences of other gamers, I met this is absolutely a great place to go for a wonderful slice. read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Whole Spicy-Ass Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This place is an absolute late night treasure and really hits in the wee hours. The service leaves a bit to be desired, but what can you expect? Recommended, if you're looking for a late night guilty grub spot, it does get crowded tho. That spicy unicorn sauce is DELICIOUS! read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Buffalo Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This place I would give an 11 out of 10 because as a native New Yorker, the vibe was immaculate, from the music and service staff who were patient, friendly and helpful. Now the food, let me preface by saying I'm a pizza snob and the pizza here was delicious very close to a NYC style pizza! When you're in Columbus, Ohio DEFINITELY go visit and get yourself a slice or pie! read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - BBQ Chicken slice & Crunchy Slice PoW Cheezus Crunch Supreme! We left no crumbs!!! - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Great pizza and efficient service. We stopped in after Dave Matthews at Nationwide. The line was a few people out of the door. Maybe a half hour. Great New York style pizza. I just had the spicy pepperoni and the wife had a vegan BBQ chicken imposter. Mine was what you would expect and hers had a great taste for a bunch of fake stuff trying to be cheese and chicken. read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Walking by before the show. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Listen, I've liked Mikey's since I found them in an alley years ago. Good food, cool staff, funny menu names, and more. I didn't even know this one was here. They've been gradually expanding, through the heart of Columbus. This is directly across from the convention center and right behind the North Market, so a very prime location. Parking can be tight but there is some on the street, and the Vine Street garage a few steps away. First time I came was a Friday at lunchtime, with a big event in the convention center. Huge line, I didn't wait around. Today, a Tuesday at around 1pm, it was fine, just a couple other customers. Bigger than it looks, with a lot of tables in back and a nice view of the North Market construction. Friendly service. I was really here for the Thanksgiving pizza, though I knew if they were out I'd still enjoy the other offerings. They had it: gravy, Ray Ray's smoked turkey, stuffing, and a side of cranberry sauce. Darn good. The sauce was too thick to dip in or pour, so grab a fork to get some out and spread it if you like. Strange combination of flavors for a pizza, but works well. Thin foldable crust, perfectly cooked. A little cheese holding things together. I could easily have eaten several. But one big piece and a drink (and tax) was about $10. Not bad for the area, and the quality and quantity. A quick tasty lunch. The building is old and the decor is funky. Comfy seats. Bathrooms downstairs. Rickroll on the way up. A fun experience all around. read more

Fun little spot. My friend wanted to have a fun night out with my wife and I, so we hit this place up first. Never ate here, but we'd always visit the bar downstairs. Good pizza! Extremely friendly staff who could tell it was our first time. He gave us a lot of sauce packets and talked a bit about all their pizzas. Fun time! read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

The pizza is New York pizza thin crust . I'm from Chicago so I'm use to the thicker crust pizza when it comes to Pub Style pizza or this type that they serve. I had the chicken Bbq and the Mushroom pizza both were delicious. The Crust had a nice crunch for being thin/thiner. The price was good for what you got 2 slices and a Pop or Soda for like 15 bucks. I'd definitely comeback. And the way they serve the pizza on paper plates gives you a home like style friends place. All in all get your hands on some pizza. read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Slice of Vegan BBQ Chicken* - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Perfect place to get a slice after a late night! We arrived after 11pm on a Thursday and had a bit of wait, but it was no problem. We ordered the "Date Night" option which included 2 slices, 2 drinks, breadsticks, and unicorn bar for $20! That was a super steal! We both got the hot ass pepperoni slice - just a little bit of spice in my opinion. Slices were warm and large. The breadsticks were so good with all the garlic! If we are in Columbus again, we'll definitely be back for a late night slice! read more

First off, the place was disgusting. The staff seemed empathetic. The pizza was alright, but nothing special. I had the mushroom garlic and spicy pepperoni. Both were mid. There were no kids on the drink area and many of the drink flavors were out. This was probably the worst restaurant I went to while in Columbus. 0/10. Would not recommend. read more

We were hungry and wanted quick food. This place ended up being perfect. I chose two slices (pepperoni and mushroom) while my teenage son picked cheese, and each wedge was under $6. They were put on basic paper plates that were soon soaked with oil. The slices were thin and large, and loaded with great flavor. Everything really hit the spot. Nothing fancy, but not low quality either. The restaurant itself was small and I feel like we were lucky to get a table. There was no air flow, so it was pretty warm and stale inside, and the music was loud. It wasn't my preferred ambiance, but we just needed to be there long enough to eat, so it served our needs nicely. read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - regular pepperoni, and mushroom in the background - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Mikey, please come to Columbia SC? This place is a perfect place for a late night bite. I might have visited 3 times in my 4 day trip. I may have also eaten pepperoni even though I don't eat red meat really ever. They had a spicy pepperoni and a vegan pepperoni. You go up order a slice or pizza. It's about 5-6/slices, but worth it. The pizza had a perfect mixture of crispy, but not hard crust and frankly is now my new fave pizza. A slice is a perfect meal. They also have a bar. The music is fantastic and the staff were very nice! They take Apple Pay also. HIGHLY recommend! read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Pizza for the clutch - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Delicious foldable slices with equally-yummy options for vegetarians, vegans, and meat eaters. The spicy unicorn sauce is a game changer.

Ran in to grab a quick slice prior to setting up in the convention center. The guy who helped me was great. The slices are huge and very good. Crispy crust and tender toppings. I had the pepperoni and it was delicious. It was not late night but they were still open. read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Plain Ass Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Despite having the reputation for being run by and run for stoners, Mikey's has the best pizza in town. Incredibly large and flavorful slices. My favorites are the classic cheese as well as the mushroom! read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Horrible customer service. Very dirty restaurant and prep area. Average pizza especially for the price. I work in the neighborhood and today popped in for a slice. was charged $6.08 for a SINGLE SLICE of pepperoni with banana peppers. Gave the kid a Ten and he handed me back $3.75. I said "Excuse me, the change is a little short". very politely I might add. He responded "The company only stocks quarters". then turned his back on me. So i ask the manager lady "If you guys are rounding to the nearest $.25 shouldn't YOU make up the $.08 on your end? Especially on a $6 slice of pizza?" She returned with "It's not my policy, the company makes those calls" and proceeds to ignore me. If the business model is alienating locals and fleecing late night party goers and conventioneers with expense accounts, Mikey's gets 5 stars. I recommend that you avoid this local chain. Bottom of my lifetime dining experiences. read more

Great place to get a slice or whole pizza. It's located across the street from the convention center. It's a small pizza place, but easy to order pizza and take a seat in the front of the restaurant or back. There's also a bar (where I got delicious Jell-O shots). Even with a long line, service was nice and didn't take extremely long. I enjoyed my cheese basil pizza, but wished it was a little less blackened on the bottom. Others in my party greatly appreciated the crunch of the crust. I like the option of buying a dipping sauce, such as garlic butter or unicorn dip (zesty or spicy ranch). read more

As a NYer (you know how we are about our pizza)... I actually liked these slices. I'm pretty picky, I think these had great ratios (cheese to sauce to crust..? You know what I mean??) Seasoning is interesting... actually reminds me of sausage..? But there was no sausage on my cheese slice. The atmosphere of the place really did it for me, loved the styling. The person behind the counter was very sweet as well. Good vibes all around and good food read more

Stopped in here ironically for a late night slice of pizza on the way home from Cleveland to Louisville. The indoor decors and setup was very lively, funny and entertaining. Had a small wait when I arrived but they went through it pretty quickly. So can't complain about the service. I got two slices of cheeses pizza and my buddy got two slices of pepperoni. Too tall was 18 bucks. So 4.50 a slice. They are larger New York style pizzas but that is still pretty steep. In New York pizza by the slice was actually cheaper when we visited the Manhattan area last year. The pizza itself was just ok. Had good taste but it was outweighed by strong tastes and douses of garlic. The garlic was very overbearing at different parts of the slice. Which was disappointing. As mentioned the pizza slices have a good size and are extremely greasy. Overall the inside atmosphere and setup to me is the catch for this place. Cool place. The pizza itself needs work though. Lay off the garlic some for sure. read more

See all

My husband and I were staying at the hotel across the street and were a bit hungry after dinner, so we found ourselves here. I was just expecting a quick slice of pizza, but ended up being very impressed. This is the best pizza I've had in a long time. The pepperoni was my favorite of the ones we tried. They also have fruity pebble treats that are very good. If you find yourself nearby, stop by and grab a slice. You won't regret it! read more

I love the atmosphere of this location - it's fun and clean! It's located on High Street so the only downside is trying to find parking. There is metered parking all around if you can find one. I came in and was taken care of right away. I got a slice of the mushroom and garlic to go. It was heated to perfection. That CRUST! Oh my gosh, I wish I could've gotten a video of the crunch every time I took a bite. I even got a little cheese pull here and there. Should've done a mukbang for the world to see and hear, lol. The employees were extremely nice! read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - a slice of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Tiny space but incredible food, friendly service, and fun atmosphere. Vegan options for the win! read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Don't mind the creepy basement but definitely don't go down there! - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

On July 5, 2025 I visited with my sister and her fiancé. I am from Georgia and was in town for the holiday. I ordered a couple slices from the restaurant and I also ordered a round of drinks from the bar. I asked the bartender if she could make a strawberry margarita and she told me that she did not want to. Thinking I misheard her I chuckled and said, can you please make me a strawberry margarita to which she replied bluntly I can but I don't want to make that. I have never been to an establishment where the bartender literally tells you they're not going to make a drink because they don't want to... the pizza was good. The female bartender ruined the experience though. read more

My wife and I are visiting from Indiana. After a couple of breweries, we ended up here late last night. It was exactly what we wanted. We both had a slice of the "Spicy Ass Pepperoni" and an order of breadsticks. They did not disappoint. And the "Spicy Unicorn Sauce" (on both the pizza and breadsticks) took it to another level. This is the perfect late-night pizza place. read more

Ordered over the phone and was delivered to the hotel in 35 minutes amazing quick service considering the time of night really fast pizza was cooked perfection just enough toppings, and cheese, crunchy crust everything we liked about a pizza read more