Not Mexican! A poor excuse to even think this place is Mexican. The local fast food, Mexican place does a better job than this wannabe Mexican restaurant unless you live in this town. This is all you've got unless you drive out of town to visit places near the southern parts of United States. What else would you know? read more

Server took 15 minutes getting to us, but it was a friday night so it was a bit busy. Ordered Burrito Verdes with beef and Steak Fajitas. The beef on the burrito was pretty grainy, almost sand paperish, very lightly seasoned. The steak was also very lightly seasoned, almost like it was next to the spices and deemed good enough. The vibe in the store was good, I did appreciate that. I've been here several times, I feel like almost things have gone down in quality since it has opened. I hope one day it will be better again, it is one of the only mexican places in town. Perhaps I will continue to dream if I experience this again. read more

LOVE SO GOOD very unexpected but i love everything drinks are great queso was good and our sever was over the top read more

Mi Tequila - 100/10 so was not expecting it best mexican ever - Mexican Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan

It was our first time here, and it was good. Margarita seemed watered down, but not bad. Cheese dip was superb. Both of our meals were hot, and tasted great. ( I forgot the names of our meals) Service all around was exceptionally good. read more

Food is pretty delicious and inside is clean and spacious. However our waitress messed up the order twice and never brought me my margarita.., like completely forgot about it. read more

Mi Tequila - Inside - Mexican Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan

See all

Food was adequate, service was adequate, but they charge for chips and salsa and that is a scummy enough practice alone to leave 2 stars.

Very hot inside! Food was good, service did best they could on a busy week. Margs were weak and mostly mix. Will be back.

Staff members were super friendly and welcoming. So nice! Service was very fast! Food was very good. Prices good. They had some specials, which was a pleasant surprise. We will definitely be back! (Sidenote: anyone complaining about having to pay $1.50 for chips and salsa shouldn't be going out to eat.) read more

My family was tired from spending the day on Mackinac island all day. Since we are from Texas we really needed some Mexican food and this place really hit the spot. I had the burritos texano with beef, chicken, shrimp, bell peppers and onions. I also asked for the mango sauce to go on top. It was verrrrry good. My daughter had the chimichanga del La casa. She could not finish it and was raving about it being so good. My future son in law had the verde spicy enchiladas and really enjoyed the burn and sweat on his brow. All and all it was a very good stop. I would highly recommend. read more

Best Mexican food in awhile. We were so surprised to have found this Gem in our new town. Everything was seasoned well and cooked to perfection. read more

Food & service is great. Atmosphere is really nice. This has been the same each & every time we have been there. Becoming our favorite. read more

Mi Tequila - a plate of food on a table - Mexican Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan

See all

Great food and service. We had the Carne de casa and fajitas nachos. Our waiter was great ! no complaints here we will be going back !

Some fake Hispanic food lol went a year ago but forgot to leave a review. DO NOT SAY YES TO CHIPS AND SALSA. They ask you if you want them but they will charge you after. Such scum business lol read more

Very good food! Marvelous jalapeño maharaja! Service was excellent ! Everyone was thrilled with their meal!!

The food is always pretty decent, and the staff is nice. Getting your food after ordering is typically pretty quick. I have noticed that I get a lot of pieces of meat the are "gristle-y" and or inedible in my burritos. I'm not sure if it's the quality of meat they use or the care that is taken while cutting it. The prices are a little high for what I would usually deem a "cheaper" meal. Salsa is no longer included with the meal, which is something to note. read more

Busy, the staff was kind the food was good but we did get out food prior to any drinks ordered. Very good food though, nice a steric and atmosphere read more

Mi Tequila - Burrito fajitas - Mexican Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan

See all

Absolutely the cleanest Mexican restaurant I have ever seen! Not even a crumb on my seat. Food was great. Service was great. There is nothing more enjoyable than having the above 3 when going out to eat. Thank you, and we will be back. read more

We had a large group of 15. They were very busy but still accommodated us. The food was yumm and we left satisfied.

Ordered Veggie tacos, which, according to menu are three soft tacos with bell peppers and onions and tomatoes. None of these items were in the tacos, only unseasoned refried beans and shredded iceberg lettuce in stale "hard" taco shells. This was the worst Mexican food I've had in a decade. read more

Tried this restaurant in Petosky based on the food reviews noting the comments on slow service. I was disappointed in not only the service the average food quality but then after slow service and mediocre food we paid an excessive amount for our meal. $10 bottle of Corona?! $1.50 for a very small basket of chips. Save your time and $ and go somewhere else. There are great places to eat in Petosky but I wouldn't recommend here. read more

Amazing service and food. Wonderful staff. Fast service and huge portions for the price. Best Margarita I have ever had.

Im in love with their food I'd live there if I could. Their food was great, great service, food came out quick. Great place to go out to eat for any event id recommend anyone. read more

So-so food/Unexpected add-on in check. I felt the flavor of the food was so-so. It was hot, came out fast and the staff was friendly. But nothing stood out about the meal. I have had better Mexican fare, and I've had worse. I was a bit surprised when I received the meal check. At the bottom was a 3% charge added on that was listed as a "Convenience Fee". I've seen many places that will add in such a charge for using a credit card. But I paid cash. And the charge was already added on the bill before they knew if I was paying with cash or card. It couldn't have been for a 'large party', because I was dining by myself. Just a new unexpected charge that I have never seen at a restaurant before. I still left the server a decent tip (around 25%), because this fee was not his fault. But, with that type of "money grab" and the food being just average, I probably won't return. I like trying new restaurants that I have never been to, and this was one such case. Now I know. read more

As for the food we have eaten here a few times. The food and service when it first opened was great. We went today and it was the worst service I have ever received as a customer. Also my carnitas was almost 3/4 fat and gristle. My wife asked for a double helping of rice rather than beans, lettuce and tomato, so the server charged us 3bucks after omitting beans and salad....... I felt disrespected and like it was a burden for my family to be served. We couldn't even get silverware after we asked, had to go and get it ourselves. I don't think we will be returning to this establishment. I have owned Restaurants and know how customers should feel to pay to eat and be served. This place should be ashamed of service like that. read more

Food just average and was cold. They give you chips and salsa without asking and then charge you 1.50

We've dined in once before and had carryout a couple of times. It's always been good. Tonight was a disappointment. Kids meal was a cheese quesadilla and it was DRY and had very little cheese. Chicken enchilada were the same. Very dry chicken inside, nothing else. Very, very, very small amount of enchilada sauce with a tiny amount of white cheese. Not flavorful at all. El Pastor tacos were good. Chips and salsa came at a charge and we're very good. We won't give up but tonight was not a great experience. read more

Great food! We got the fajita burrito and it was amazing! The chips and salsa were a great filler but we were both full by the time we got halfway through our meal read more

Very pleasantly surprised with our meals --our party of three enjoyed our food. Chips and salsa are worth the $1.50 charge. Building is newer, clean and comfortable. Give them a try--really good food. read more

In town on vacation and visited Mi Tequila for dinner. Like all establishments these days they are short handed, but those at Mi Tequila are busting butt to make it happen. I had chicken breast covered with grilled onions, peppers and tomatoes. It was fantastic. I can't recommend it enough. My wife had a taco salad and said it was delicious. Thanks to the whole crew there, working hard in tough times and providing a fun visit. read more

Top Notch place. Great atmosphere. Great flavor food. Great service. The HOT salsa is the best ever, but only for people experienced with Hot/Spicy food. read more

Middle of the afternoon on a Monday and we waited for every step of service. Margaritas are watered down. Queso was cold. Half plate of nachos were about a dozen chips with the stuff on em. Waitress was clearly overwhelmed with about 3 tables. read more

AMAZING SERVICE! and I must say for being all the way in northern Michigan the food is very good as well. They have a great tequila selection. The staff is very knowledgeable. The price point is great and the portions are very large even shareable.. I would not recommend any other Mexican cuisine in a 50 mile radius over these guys they're doing a phenomenal job read more

Very disappointed, 1 quesadilla for $10. I've been to other restaurants and have come home with leftovers. I won't be back and I will let my friends know. I now give it 1star. This was a tortilla folded over and call it a quesadilla for $12. read more

It was our first time and we loved our food. Our waiter and staff were very nice. We will be back for sure. Our only critique was the lack of liquor in the margaritas. They were good but had to be missing liquor. I look forward to trying it in the future! read more

Always a good meal at a fair price. Wife and I share a fajitas. Plenty of food for both of us

We ordered the combination platter to try different items. All the items had the same ground beef, which was super salty. A chicken item would have been nice. The food was also luke warm when it came to the table and cold by the time we were finished. read more

Great food and great service! Food was fresh, service was prompt and environment was cheerful. I have no idea where some of these negative reviews generated from. We saw none of it. read more

Food portions were small and they add on a convenience fee on top of what you owe and of course taxes I've never been to a restaurant that had a convenience fee until I stopped in at mi tequila. I doubt I'll ever go back and if I do the portion size better be bigger. read more

We stopped here today and happy we did! Great food! We loved the refried beans. The service was ok but we'd go back for the food.

Amazing authentic Mexican food! Wonderful service! Hector was attentive, kind, and efficient. Amazing top shelf margaritas! Great prices for the quality! Very Clean and nice ambiance. We will definitely go back when we are back in town. read more