I'm torn. The food is awesome, but everything else at Mexicali Blue is painful. When I order takeout, their order system seems to require everyone in the store to process the order, find the item, process the credit card. I just watched an order take 6 minutes for a single person, and sadly I was in line behind them. I've sat down to write this, and two people are huddled around the machine trying to make it function. When I eat in, their staff is very friendly, but often the order is wrong or items are forgotten. I love the food, but so so wish they'd pick it all up a notch. read more

Let me start by saying that I have never been to the original Mexicali Blue in New Paltz. I am not sure if that makes my review any more or less valid, but I thought I'd be completely honest before I pretty much raved about my experience so far at their new establishment in Wappingers Falls. I have also only purchased take out and have not dined in yet. I think I'll make this a Pro/Con review. Pros: -Really fresh delicious seafood, meats, veggies, cheese and assorted toppings in all of their burritos and tacos. -Delicious combinations of these ingredients that create a flavor explosion upon eating. -Kick ass soups (black bean and chicken tortilla are not to be missed). - Friendly as heck service from the takeout counter. -Homemade hot sauces. -Great vegetarian options. Cons (Just 2): -The guacamole is just OK, it could use a little more BAM (not to get all Emeril Lagasse on you). -It is a TAD pricey for the amount of food you get. I say a tad because the quality is really worth the price. Overall, a great place for quick and healthy Mexican food. Shoot, now I am craving a shrimp taco (my favorite taco there so far). read more

Been here a few times and was happy with the food, had my first dine in experience today. AWESOME! Shrimp taco was so freakin delicious. Raspberry aioli... Mind blown! The pork belly taco was amazing as well as the steak! Steak and shrimp burrito... AMAZING! Even the quesadillas were delicious! The ratio of meat to cheese was excellent! Great atmosphere, really wonderful staff. Did I mention the myriad of hot sauces! Coconut hot sauce! Try it! It was delicious! Definitely get here and give it a shot! I am leaving more than satisfied!!! read more

My favorite taco spot and I'll tell you why! The food is always great, fresh and well prepared. Excellent drinks and the staff is friendly and on point. The atmosphere is comfortable and welcoming whether you want to bring the kids or have a fun night out. My favorite is the beef brisket taco, even though they are all delicious! read more

This place has become a favorite with me and my co-workers. My job requires me to spend one week out of every two in Fishkill, and finding good restaurants is key to making life as a road warrior bearable. I think one week we ate here four days in a row. I've probably eaten here ten or fifteen times by now and we just discovered it last fall. I haven't had anything here that was disappointing, and I've had many things here that are exceptionally delicious. You pretty much can't go wrong. Having said that: the fishbowl size frozen lime margaritas are a must-have. The chorizo rice side dish may be some of the best rice you'll ever taste, with chunks of grilled chorizo mixed in along with kernels of corn, cilantro, spices, and other goodness. Mexicali has about six to ten off-the-beaten-path house hot sauces in squeeze bottles.... with flavors like roasted garlic, blueberry, pineapple, and coconut... try adding a bit to the rice for a little kick and an extra dimension of flavor. The tacos are amazing -- the pork belly taco and the ahi tuna taco (I always ask for it seared and as rare as possible) are to die for. The specials are always good -- today my co-worker and I shared a plate of pibil nachos and between the two of us we could only finish about half of it and it was AMAZING. I've also tried a couple of the desserts which were un freaking believable -- the tres leches and the bread pudding (I believe they offer two different types, for sure I have tried one that was made with raisin bread) were some of the most delicious desserts I have ever eaten. It's a family run restaurant, the dad, mom, son, and daughter all work here and are all very friendly. Will be back again and again and again. Keep up the good work. read more

Tuesday at 4:30pm and only one server should have have been a indication of things to come. Should have left but others wanted to stay and give it a try. My mistake. High prices, mediocre food and SLOW service. Enough said. read more

Yesterday my family and I went here for the very time on a recommendations from Friends...I am glad we made this decision As we approached the front door we were greeted by I presumed the owner and a young lady by the name of Destiny (who was very sweet) so she sat us down near the door (which I don't mind) as we we sat down she gave us menus and asked her what we would like to drink , my 2 girls and husband ordered water and Lemonade and I asked for Frozen Mango Margarita with Salt , we told destiny "EXACTLY" how I wanted it and she hit it right on the nose it was sooo delicious I took my time to drink it . So destiny came around again and we ordered the appetizers OMG the sample guacamole sauce and chips were out of this world, when diner was ordered, I ordered a steak and shrimp burrito it was so awesomely delicious.I was so intrigued with the decor with the place and the nicest people to work in this establishment ....so worth coming here for any occasion you won't be disappointed if you get Destiny she was the reason she made our day and dinner enjoyable ....thank you again Destiny for that awesome frozen margarita you made for me and taking the time with your patience and professionalism you have brought to me my family you have definitely gained a new customers because of YOU!!!! The best part the owner gave me the time and day to tell me they also deliver to Fishkill which that is a plus in my eyes....thank you for allowing myself and my family for having a wonderful dinner in your place so worth the drive where ever you are coming from you won't be disappointed!!!!!!!! read more

Food = awesome We both had the steak burrito. It was fantastic. However - it came w a tiny side of cole slaw or potato salad. The meal looked lost in a sea of blue. Big burrito on a plate w a tiny souffle cup of cole slaw. Kind of a weird combo. For $15.00 I thought there would have been something more exciting for a side (beans and rice, maybe?). I noticed some others complain about the service. I would rate it right down the middle. Not bad, not stellar. I give it 3 stars because I think the price is high, compared to what you get. It was underwhelming, albeit delicious - if that makes sense. read more

So damn good. I see other people saying they find it over priced.....I don't at all. I think if anything they are cheaper then other Mexican restaurants in the area. And the food is amazing! Lots of flavor!!!! I will definitely come back again. read more

Mexicali Blue - Mexican Restaurant & Happy Hour - Cummin Delight Quesadas. - Mexican Near Me - Wappingers Falls, New York

My first time here. Our server Paul, was prompt, and charming. He even put up with my odd sense of humor, and general harassment. The food was delicious, hot, fresh, and fast. The restaurant was clean and simply, yet tastefully decorated. In all a very nice experience. I look forward to future visits. read more

Mexicali Blue - Mexican Restaurant & Happy Hour - Mexican Near Me - Wappingers Falls, New York

I ate here the other day with my boyfriend after reading a positive review on facebook and I must say...the food here is delicious! I ordered a Chipoltle chicken quesadilla.. amazing! The service was also wonderful. While waiting for our food to come out, our waitress gave us samples of their soups. Which I loved! They also have a wide variety of hot sauces for example coconut and roasted garlic. Which our waitress suggested that one of these sauces would go great with my food. I also loved I had leftovers for lunch and it was even better the 2nd time around! I would absolutely come here again and suggest to my friends read more

This place was horrible they really fell off the margarita had no flavor and I bit into my pork and pineapple burrito to come across a bone and they had still had the nerve to charge me for it wouldn't go back if it was the last place on earth. read more

While visiting the in-laws in Wappingers Falls I had the hankering for some Mexican food. After several days of the best Italian served up by my mother and father in-law it was time for something different. I had to pick up a prescription at Walgreens and the wait was over half an hour. I walked to the parking lot and saw Mexacali Blue. I had no idea what I was in store for. I sat at the counter/bar and ordered a Pacifico draft and some chips and salsa. The salsa was so darn fresh and delicious that this California boy had to peruse the menu and order something else. I opted for an ahi taco. SCORE...it was as good as anything I get here on the West Coast. Sadly because of all the snow I was unable to visit Mexacali Blue prior to my return home. I guarantee that I will be back upon my return in the springtime. If you live in the Wappingers area and want delicious Tex-Mex...make sure you visit Mexacali Blue! read more

I'm not one to write bad reviews especially with a place we have frequented in the past and enjoyed. Well used to. Today we decided to do take out. I walked in and placed the order and was told 25 minutes. 45 minutes later after watching people come and go and just one table occupied my order was still nowhere in sight. When asked it seemed like nobody knew what was happening despite the fact I sat in clear view of the staff the entire time. I made the mistake of prepaying the 60.00 which is pricey to be polite but it's to be expected here but for the price one expects efficiency but sadly not here anymore. I noticed the owner was nowhere to be found and I suspect that's a large portion of the issues going on It's a shame as this used to be a great place but seemingly the price has gone through the roof and the Mexicali Steaks service has gone through the basement. read more

Okay so yeah, it's Mexican style food, but I would not say it's a Mexican restaurant. A tasty take on Mexican with fresh ingredients and good recipes. I was here with a colleague and had some time so spoke to the hostess and chatted a bit, turns out it restaurant número dos of this family owned "chain". No, it's not a chain... Bottom line is the food is pretty damn good. Open kitchen so you can watch them prepare your meal. I personally saw them cleaning the hood filters, at the close, over the flat top...as a former short order cook in my college days, this was a good sign to see. CLEAN! We had a few drinks and then got some food. If you don't order something with pork here, you're doing it wrong. You fancy yourself a burrito aficionado? The Achiote burrito was gold. Pork and citrus, beans, rice, guac, and a very subtle coconut sauce. Yeah, it's a bit pricy, my large margarita was $13...but, it's seriously a large effing drink. Don't know what kind of drink you may want? ASK! The bartender/waiter knew the stock and easily suggested a tequila I would enjoy. On the rocks with salt and no flavors...well mixed and delicious. I will be coming back, only wished this place was closer than 6 hrs from home... You'll spend a little money, but eat some good eats, drink some good drinks and be merry! read more

Finally I am satisfied with the service Tom was great the food was great love the shrimp tacos and the steak yummy. read more

Mexicali Blue - Mexican Restaurant & Happy Hour - Mojito - Mexican Near Me - Wappingers Falls, New York

Don't think of this as a Mexican restaurant, but rather as a taco joint (you'll order chips and salsa from the appetizer menu). This isn't an inexpensive regular lunch spot that will fill you up, but rather a clean place that offers fresh ingredients and full flavors. With that understanding, you can enjoy the distinctive blue corn tortillas and friendly service. I ate with two other frequent travelers and we were all impressed with the flavors and simple presentation. I went with the Cali catfish taco and the tuna taco, but if I lived in the area, I certainly would be returning to try their burritos and quesadillas. The guacamole was good and I really wondered about the veggie stuffed Portobello (appetizer). The real intriguing detail to Mexicali Blue was the plethora of hot sauces that they had to try. Located on a side counter, I almost forgot and sampled them at the end with the remaining chips. This certainly isn't a place I'd go to all the time if I were on a student budget, but definitely someplace I'd recommend! read more

I love this place. The food is fresh, the quesadilla and burrito portions are large, and this place has some of my favorite gauc. The owner will check on with you, and samples of soup and chili are pretty freely given. The black bean and chicken tortilla soup are solid and yummy choices. I haven't had a burrito I didn't like the tuna, salmon, steak and shrimp, and pork are super yummy. The chicken is good, but generic. Oh and trust me go get yourself some hot sauce from the bar, roasted garlic and their coconut are my favorite. I would advise staying away from the the tacos, they are smaller and I am not in love with the blue corn taco shells, but that's me. Go into this place expecting southern Cali style Mexican food rather than more traditional fair and you will be a happy customer. read more

Today was my second sit down visit.I have also picked up an order from them. Their emphasis on FRESH food is warranted but does not tell the whole story.Using fresh tomatoes for pico de gallo(they do not have any real salsa) is not worthwhile when you use a terrible,unripened product. No Mexican or even a Californian, would use this pink,tasteless tomato. The Avocado and Chicken Salad I had today was as tasteless--from the chicken to the dressing. Perhaps they believe everyone will use hot sauce. The take out food was a pork taco--completely soggy and cold when I got it home from an 8 minute trip and an insulated bag. The wait staff is indifferent and almost non-existent.Soda and water not brought.Had to wait until half through my salad to get some salt and then because I grabbed her before she could get away. The music is loud and annoying in a small,attractive little place. Sad to say I will not return to this uncaring,overpriced and not very tasty place. R.R. Corey Wappingers Falls read more

Not a big place, and you might drive right by it, but you won't want to. Great food, cooked fresh to order, no fryers, all fresh ingredients. Nice beer selection. The guacamole & chips are a generous serving & the pulled pork and the catfish burritos are excellent. Service staff is attentive, prices reasonable and to top it off they had live music from a singer on guitar, The Mighty Flynn (look him up on YouTube) If you've never tried this place, you need to. I usually don't give 5 stars but between the food, service and music it earned it! read more

Ok let me start by saying that I've eaten here 20-30 times. Food is good every single time. (That's where the 2 stars come in) We have had some service issues. But not even server issues, owner issues. One time, they sat my wife and I at a 4 top. When a two top opened up and a larger party came in the owner asked us to move mid-meal to accommodate the party. I'm not difficult and didn't care, so we moved. However, no offer for dessert, drinks, or apps off the bill as a thank you. Strike one for Mexicali Blue. Today I ordered from their website (through Grubhub) at 550 and requested a 700 pickup. I was leaving work and had something I had to get to at home, so it seemed convenient that it would be ready. I paid on grubhub ahead of time AND left a tip. So I got the follow up texts from grub hub that it would be ready at 710. Annoying because I gave you ample time to do my burritos but whatever. So I get there at 710 and I tell the young lady that I'm there to pick up my order. She asked for my name, didn't find it, and asked if I called ahead. I told her I ordered through grub hub and the owner magically appears. He very blankly states that he didn't get it, blamed the equipment, grubhub, the company who grub hub apparently just bought, the internet, and his tone blamed me. Stated I should've called it in instead. Ok. He acted as if it was no big deal and I would have to deal with it. His attitude annoyed me to a level that I haven't been annoyed in awhile. He told me that he knows how to make great food, not work that equipment. I told him that if he doesn't know how to work that equipment, he should take it off his website. He didn't care. So he took my order and it was ready in 15 minutes. (Maybe I'm being a baby) During those 15 minutes I was never offered a soda, chips, hot sauce, a hug... nothing. For 15 minutes he should've treated me like Jesus Christ or Santa Claus. Instead, he acted like Judas and the Grinch. I don't see myself going back anytime soon. Strike 2 and 3. I would like to note that all of the employees have been great to me. Kyle and all of the ladies know how to take care of customers. The one guy who says "boss" and "chief" way too much is slightly obnoxious, but whatever. It is just the owner who has been the problem. This is a customer service ground ball. Any gesture in either situation would've been fine. Nope. UPDATE: I see your response. I won't be back because you didn't offer me a soda while I waited on your screw up. Please keep this BS off my review because anyone who has had any interaction with you knows that it's nonsense. However, your burritos are bangin' and I've considered going back despite your awful customer service. Kyle rocks. read more

I would never go to this place again!! I went in to pick up my food and the manager Maria had her mask below her nose and was extremely close to customers. Customers (5 to be exact in 10 minutes) walked in and around without masks - not seated at table and nothing was said to them. The kid at desk kept taking his mask off and the cook staff didn't have masks on either!!! Taco Bell would have been better and at least they adhere to health department guidelines. There are plenty of other restaurants in Dutchess that are clean and safe. Spend your money at another establishment. I will be calling Board if Health in the morning. read more

I have been here quite a few times and never had a bad experience! The service and the food is always on par. I give for starts because it is pricey for some of the options like the tacos. If you add on appetizers and drinks its probably going to be at least $60 for two people. I usually get a steak burrito. It's always cooked perfectly with quality steak. I love trying all of the different sauces, with the raspberry being one of my favorites. We usually see the manager and he always stops to ask how everything is and makes sure our experience is a good one. read more

Food tasted really fresh and the portions were pretty generous. My quesadilla was pretty huge and was stuffed with chicken which I was happy about. My boyfriend got the catfish tacos which were actually fairly small for the price. $7 per taco. Overall the atmosphere was nice, the service was quick, the place looked clean and the food tasted great! read more

See all

Mexicali is so wonderful. The staff is so inviting and the food is always good. We've never waited long for a meal or a drink refill. The drinks are always great and ice cold. A great place to sit at the bar and eat or enjoy a nice sit down dinner!! read more

Mexicali Blue is one of our musts whenever we visit The Wappingers Falls/Poughkeepsie area. The menu items are so abundant that it's hard to decide! We always come with enough friends & family to order our favorites. Always fresh and part of our order is the Ahi Tuna Burrito with Guacamole & Wasabi Aioli, which is TOTALLY AWESOME, The Skirt Steak Burrito, BBQ Brisket, Pulled Pork, Maple Mango Chicken, Grilled Hanger Steak & Shrimp, and please keep those Amazing Margarita's coming! They do get busy so be sure to call ahead for reservations! The family-owned restaurant serves and treats us as if we are part of their family. We need one in Merrick, NY. I can't wait to go back to Mexicali Blue after Thanksgiving! read more

I'm from Philadelphia, but any time I visit my boyfriend's family, I always beg my boyfriend to stop here for lunch or dinner! Their guacamole is extremely fresh, and their burritos and tacos never disappoint. The atmosphere is a lot of fun, with super attentive staff too. Nothing in Phila quite measures up to Mexicali Blue, so the cravings for this place are real! Can't wait to return around the holidays. read more

One of my favorite spots. The raspberry shrimp burrito and the mexicali steak taco are my go-to's. The steak taco has a coconut aioli which is to die for. Everything is fresh and the flavors are truly like no other. On the lighter side, Mexicali Cobb salad is my go to salad with either steak or chicken. Doesn't even need dressing. The hot sauce bar is a bonus! read more

The nachos supreme are far from supreme. They consisted of chips, semi melted cheese, a little portion of chicken and jalapeños. Very dry to say the least. Nobody told me about the hot sauce bar. That would have been nice. Margarita was good. Service was mediocre. Never again. read more

My boyfriend and I absolutely LOVE Mexicali! I was craving it the other day and we drove nearly an hour from CT to have dinner there...that's saying something! Their drinks are delicious, guac is addicting and you honestly can't go wrong with anything you order. From quesadillas to tacos to burritos, I have not met a dish that I did not LOVE! You have got to try their hot sauce bar; they have awesome flavors like blueberry, coconut, apricot, chili lime and probably a dozen other flavors--I've never had this anywhere else! Atmosphere is great and staff are super attentive. Ask about their beer specials too! read more

See all

Kind of pricy but they do give you a lot of food. My favorites are the garlic shrimp burrito with the raspberry aioli and the garlic chicken burrito. The potato salad is out of this world. They have a lot of great hot sauces including raspberry, strawberry, and coconut. The wait times can be really long at times, but their food is fresh and so good. read more

Outstanding food. We had the tuna taco, Mexicali steak taco, mango catfish and the calicatfish tacos. All are great and their hot sauces are amazing. The prices are fair too. The only downside is paying $7.00 for chips and salsa. Most places this is on the house. I have ordered out many times also. Never a bad meal. Burritos are also great. read more

I visited this location for the first time last Saturday with 3 adults and a toddler. It was chaotic and confusing. We ended up waiting 40mins for a table, but the manager was kind enough to distribute drinks and chips to those who were waiting. Our waitress was very friendly, but there were mistakes with our orders due to all of the chaos with the restaurant being new and jam-packed. But the most important thing is the food, and all I have to say about that is EXCELLENT. The burritos are ginormous and the guac is fresh. Overall, we'll definitely go back. *Update: Been back a dozen more times since February and the food is consistently fresh and delicious. They've also added a couple more tables inside and outside to help with the traffic jams. Keep up the good work, Mexicali! read more

Pretty good, overall. Hubby and I met there for lunch during the work week. Service was great: super up-beat, prompt and friendly. The establishment was not busy at all. In fact, when we first sat down we were the only ones there, but then a few more tables showed up during our visit. The decor is great. Mexicali Blue strikes me as being a good place for lunch, but I don't think I'd be inclined to go there for dinner. Just seems like more of a casual, quick-bite type of place. What added to my impression was the fact that my taco was served in a basket with food-grade tissue paper as my "plate". Yes, I agree with other reviewers; prices are too steep for what they give you. In general, the food flavors and presentation are really nice. I had the black bean soup, which was different in texture and flavor than most that I've had (which is a lot, and I've made my own, also) but very tasty. I had a Cajun catfish taco and Hubby had the Cumin-lovers (or something like that) Quesadilla. My 6" taco was $6.50 and his dish was $13.00, and a SMALL side serving of guacamole was $3.50 - all of which was over-priced, even by today's standard high-pricing. Perhaps their rent is astronomical in the relatively new plaza that they rent space in. I liked the fact that they make several versions of their own hot-sauces, available for any diner to try and use with their meals. I did notice that the drink prices seemed rather reasonable. Hubby had a beer, but who knows what the mixed drinks are like. In my personal experience, when ordering a mixed cocktail in most places, you're lucky if you even get a full shot of liquor in your drink! I'll be back for lunch or take-out for sure. It was good for lunch. read more

The achiote burrito! That's my go to order here at Mexicali Blue. The grilled pineapples and achiote seasoning are to die for. It's the perfect flavor combination and it's the perfect meal to satisfy your hunger. It fills you up! And what I love about this place is the array of hot sauces they provide and the unexpected flavors... apricot hot sauce, anyone? It's great. I took off one star because some of the pricing is steep in my opinion, but it is worth it! read more

Heard about their award winning burrito so I had to go and evaluate it myself. My friend and I both ordered the short rib burrito. No complaints on the quality and serving size. The burrito was plump and delicious, melt in your mouth chunks of steak, rice, black beans, onions, slaw, with a spicy, smoky taste. Not your typical Mexican food and not your typical Mexican Food prices. The Burritos were $17 apiece, $7 for a basket of chips with diced tomato salsa. Nothing special. (Complimentary in most Mex Joints). God knows how much the 2 sodas were but the total was $52. Ridiculously expensive but it was good. Think I'll stick with my typical Mexican Food with typical Mexican Food prices. read more

Very good and fresh food. Happy hour with $5 margaritas can be dangerously delicious.

Went there a few weeks ago for lunch. The margaritas were fantastic. Started witha spicy butternut squash soup that was really good. I love butternut squash. Usually soup is on the sweeter side. This was a nice change. My entree was a pablano pepper stuffed with portabello mushroom and other veggies that was out of this world. The food is all very fresh, and the service was friendly and accomodating. I would definatly return. read more

Best mexican food in the area, hands down! Food is always fresh and full of flavor. From their burritos, to their tacos and quesadillas, everything I've gotten here has exceeded my expectations. There are virtually endless options on the menu, and they are always adding new plates to the menu! The staff always makes you feel welcome, and constantly makes sure you are more than satisfied with your order. They also deliver, which just goes to show how hard to beat this place is. AND there's live music and trivia on the weekends! You are bound to have the best entertainment there is. I am currently a college student and I crave their food constantly! Waiting until I return home so I can get another delicious plate from Mexicali Blue again! read more

I really love the food. Great flavor and nice sized portions. I usually go for their great burritos. Also a very enjoyable atmosphere. read more