Stopped for an impromptu visit with my husband and we just shared a pepperoni slice for $3.50 and…read moreit was SUPER good! It was thin but crispy and had a lot of flavor, so much that we want to stop by a second time to get our own! The service and ambiance did feel like I walked straight into New York, a kind of good chaotic feel to it. Lots of flyers on the wall which I love so that was fun too! We'll be back

Straight From New York Pizza was good and it's a small restaurant with seating inside and out…read more Slices are about $5. The slices are less if you go within the hour before closing. Service was friendly. I didn't look at the specials and the woman preparing my food to go pointed them out. I ordered three slices of pizza: pepperoni, chicken bacon ranch, and bbq chicken. I liked all three of them. If I had more time in Salem, I'd go back! Try it out if you're in the area

I've eaten at G3 multiple times, a always amazing burgers excellent fries, excellent appetizers…read moreexcellent pizza, the cheese sticks super good chicken wings fantastic Today I tried their s'mores pizza....... This is stupid good. This is what you crave. This is what you request instead of cake for your birthday. It's amazing. You have to try it.

I've given this place more chances than I should have, hoping each bad experience was just an off…read moreday. After our last visit, we won't be returning. The manager, I believe her name is Carissa, would benefit greatly from training on how to treat both customers and employees. Her attitude has come across as rude, dismissive, and unprofessional every time we've been in. Watching the way the staff operated under that kind of management was uncomfortable and honestly embarrassing. Our server, Angalina, appeared to be nodding off or falling asleep mid-sentence while taking our order and while explaining the specials. On top of that, we watched her leave the bathroom without washing her hands, which is completely unacceptable and a clear health concern. When our pizza came out undercooked, we decided not to send it back because, at that point, we no longer trusted the food handling practices. The salad looked decent, but after everything we witnessed, it was hard to feel comfortable eating there at all. There may not be many dining options in Aumsville, but the cafe down the road has excellent salads and a much better overall atmosphere and there's always Figaro's for a pizza!

My sil and I split a 16 inch 1/2 loaded bake potatoe and 1/2 drunken goat. Pizza was awesome…read more Crist was thinking with good tooth and toppings were plentiful and yummy. We also had the calamansi cider which was the perfect amount of citrus and tart to cut thru the rich pizza flavors. We will be back!

sourdough crust like nowhere else in the county. pleasant…read morevibes of a college town pizza shop it was a good selection of brews. whether I'm getting a single slice to go or eating in with family this is the spot for unique salads and flavor combinations highlighted by helpful friendly workers! Come with an appetite and order one of their awesome salads to go with your slice or your whole pie!

A bunch of kids run this place. Playing grab ass and rude on the phone. Lived in West Salem for…read more23 years and this was the place to go until the old owners sold during covid. Quality and quantity of toppings has gone down the tube. No adult supervision is on site and it shows. Last pizza I got there the workers were constantly walking out of the kitchen chewing a mouthful of food, gross. Lately I have been making the drive to Paddington's on Pine street. You can't go wrong with them.

We love Walery's! We've been coming here for over 25 years. We no longer live locally but we make…read moresure and stop in for a pepperoni pizza when we are in town.

Absolutely phenomenal pizza! We went this evening, I ordered the BBQ chicken pizza and the chef's…read morespecial, husband ordered pepperoni, meat lovers, and chicken bacon ranch. The crust was perfectly cooked. Pizza was incredible. Staff were so kind and friendly. We love going here whenever we need a pizza fix, and we'd recommend it every time. Keep doing what you're doing!

Been coming here for years now and it's always great! I prefer this location over their othersread more

Always had good pizza. They are not fast usually cause of how busy they are all the time. I get…read morepizza to go since it's a fully open inside and can get very noisy. Only order on occasion due to price but I like the thin crust pizza and cup pepperoni. The sliced fresh tomatoes they add are always fresh. I've tried all the others and they are by far my favorite in South Salem.

This review is for the South Salem Padington's Pizza. I don't usually leave reviews but this was…read moreabsolutely the worst pizza I have ever had. The crust was thin and like hardtack cracker. No taste whatsoever. The sauce was just a red color on the crust. No moisture in it at all. If it wouldn't have had green peppers on it there would have been no taste at all. Very, very little cheese. For $35. I expected much better. 7-11 Pizza is better and that is sad! My first time eating it and I won't waste money on them again. I did get waited on quickly and the pizza came out pretty quick. They were very busy. The pizza itself was the only disappointment.

Came back to visit in July, 2026 and enjoyed two more, delicious gluten free pies. Consistency is…read morekey, and they nailed it again. Also got to enjoy a bonus Friday night concert in the park! Will be back again!

I stopped here to have dinner with the family after a long drive from the Bay Area in California…read more We were in Oregon to watch our son graduate from Oregon State. Go Beavs! After a long drive and getting settled in to the hotel we decided to go get some grub. Pizza was the consensus. We walked from our hotel to New York Squares. When we walked in we were immediately greeted. The first thing I noticed were the NY Giants pictures on the wall. Pretty cool. The atmosphere was pretty nice. You feel like you're inside a pizzeria in Brooklyn. We ordered the The Grandma and a Pepperoni. The pizza was crispy around the edges, but soft in the middle. For everyone but me the grandma was the favorite. I personally loved the pepperoni. The pizza was overall good, not my all-time favorite, but a solid 4 out of 5. The owner was awesome and the atmosphere was great too. When we're back in Independence (we love Independence) we'll definitely be back for another pie or two.

They offer a weekday lunch buffet for $10.99 which I believe runs from 11:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. It's…read morea great value, especially if you enjoy salad. The salad bar has a nice variety of fresh toppings, and they do a good job keeping the pizza stocked throughout lunch. The buffet includes pizza, garlic knots, and a cinnamon dessert pizza. They don't include the potatoes or wings during lunch, and the buffet itself is fairly small--it's just set up on the counter where you pay--but it's still well worth the price. There's also a very small arcade if you have kids or want a little entertainment while you wait. If you're planning to order carryout, create an account on their website and enter your phone number. New customers can get a first-order discount..I believe it was 15% off. There's a good amount of seating but it gets pretty full for the lunch buffet. They do a good job of keeping things clean and stocked.

Tried this place for the first time and I would go back. The restaurant was clean and the staff…read morewere polite. The food was good and came out quickly.