Great food. Best Sunday after church restaurant in Collierville. Fresh mozzarella made on site,…read moreother ingredients imported directly from Italy. Owner is present to ensure the best quality. BIG FANS!!

Real ingredients truly make a difference. The pizzas here taste like pizza- not cardboard…read more I love to watch them make the pizza and fire it in the pizza oven. The only thing making this a 4 star instead of 5 star is both pizzas were very wet in the center. You had to eat it with a fork until you got close to the crust. There was no way you could pick it up and eat it. The restaurant and bathrooms were nice and clean. Friendly service.

Amazing pizza. The cheese fries appetizer was on point. The service was good. We don't enjoy any of…read morethe tasty looking beverages from the bar, but next time, for sure. Really good food and I wanted to drop a 5-star rating.

We visited Rotolo's today around 2:30pm and it was the perfect time to go! There was hardly anyone…read morethere, so we were seated immediately with no wait. If you're looking for a quieter time with quick service, mid-afternoon is definitely the way to do it. This was actually our second time here, and it's been amazing both times. It's so nice to find a place that's consistent with both food and service. We ordered the Classic Cracker Thin pizza and it was incredible. The crust was perfectly crispy, the flavor was on point, and the toppings were generous. It's also a HUGE pizza and could easily feed 3-4 people, which makes it a great value for the price. Our server was also so friendly and attentive. I can't remember his name, but he was one of the bartenders. We'll definitely be back again!

The pizza is so delicious! Pizzas were Piping hot and full of flavor! We will definitely return!…read more Salads were cold and crisp!

Good place with good food. I wouldn't say the flavor is exactly what pizza tastes like in NY (needs…read moremore sauce and the crust felt too thin and didn't taste the same but it's probably the difference in water used) but it's probably the best pizza I've had in all of Memphis and the surrounding areas. My husband and I grabbed a couple of plain slices, a buffalo chicken slice (the buffalo sauce was too runny but not bad taste wise) and some knots for the toad and were overall happy with the quality and service. This place has a couple of tables to sit down and eat at just like at a typical NY pizza joint. Next time, I'll be trying the chicken roll and seeing if it's similar to the ones in Brooklyn. If you're looking for a traditional NY type place, this will be your best bet but the taste of the crust is completely different than back home, just keep that in mind. Still good though.

As an international traveling food critic and unbeknownst to the staff, the following is what I…read moreexperienced: + Hostess was very welcoming and personable. + Pleasurable atmosphere. + Quality of food was excellent. If you are in the area and don't take the time to dine here, you missed out on a superb experience.

Ordered a custom built with cupping pepperoni. You have to pick between thick or thin crust. No…read moreregular. So I erred on the side of caution and went thin. Waited half an hour and got what looked like a cheese pizza with 1 pepperoni on it and no cupping pepperoni. Told one person and they said maybe it's under the cheese and the cupping pepperoni just flattens out as a result. I gave her the "c'mon now" look as their own pictures show it on top and nicely cupped. She said hey I just work here. Told the cashier and she said she entered it correctly and then the same story about how maybe it's just under the cheese. Then she just shrugged and smiled. Then Spoke with someone else and they said it's definitely wrong but that they could fix it. I heard them telling the back guys to just rebake the same pizza and I stopped them because I knew the bottom would be burnt af. She said she would have them make a new one. It came out faster. Maybe 15 minutes. when I finally got my pizza there weren't a ton of pepperoni. Taste wise it wasn't anything special. I'd say just average at best. Lots of customers here but they do have a prime location. Not sure what "lost" means in the name but I sure hope they find their way someday given their prime location.

Pros: This is the best pizza I've had in the Memphis area. Especially the Bella's 6 cheese. Very…read morevery good. Our 3 kids agreed with that and asked to go back. Might not sound like a big endorsement but Bella's made my kids actually like pizza! To me that's huge. Also, their prices are reasonable. The staff was very friendly. And thankfully they were open "late" by COVID standards and had indoor dining available. The bathrooms were clean. They had TVs going for patrons to watch. Their menu had plenty to offer without it being an overwhelmingly & unnecessarily long menu. Cons: They weren't super strict about proper mask wearing. (I get it. But it's an honest observation.) The place could use some TLC - particularly the booths. We got overcharged by several dollars for our very basic salad. According to the menu it was a $4.99 salad and we were charged $6.99. (Not huge in the long run but was off-putting AND I should have definitely said something about this before leaving.) That's about it! We were happy with the taste of all of our food items -- the salad and the two pizzas we ordered. I think we will be back because that was some DANG good pizza.

Waitress is rude, non friendly, acts like she hates her job. Doesn't listen to customer. My…read morerating is a zero

This place has the best pizza I have ever had. They never get our order wrong and they are very…read morenice. Can't go wrong with this place.

We ordered and had it delivered via Door Dash. It was OK. the sauce was decent. The crust, not bad…read more But we ordered a pizza that mushrooms and they used CANNED mushrooms!! Blech!! Other than that, it was not bad. I may try this place again...next time, definitely without mushrooms!

Hubby loves this place specifically for the old fashioned pepperoni. It's not my thing but that's…read moreok. To Try: Hawaiian Chicken Love: - Pizza: Pepperoni and Pineapple - Side: Inferno Cheezybread - Side: Fiery Cheezybread Like: - Pizza: All Meat - Pizza: Chicken and Tomato and Bacon with white cheese sauce instead of marinara - Pizza: Grilled Chicken Florentine - Pizza: Pepperoni and Pineapple and Jalapeño Ok: - Pizza: Black Olive and Mushroom - Pizza: Chicken Fresco - Pizza: Meat Supremo - Pizza: The Philly - Pizza: Triple Pepperoni Magnifico - Side: Cheezybread Disliked: - Pizza: Grilled Chicken Florentine - Pizza: Pepperoni Magnifico

I love the old fashioned pepperoni from here. I go here just for that pizza the pepperoni…read moremagnicifico. The triple pepperoni magnifico is ok but I really just want the old fashioned pepperoni not the regular one so I will stick to the regular one.

It's been years since I last visited a Mellow Mushroom. I decided to go with their sausagefest…read morecalzone, and it was incredibly satisfying. The crust had that signature doughy texture, and they definitely didn't short the fillings. Every bite was meaty and loaded with cheese. My only small adjustment was that I needed to order extra sauce on the side, for the second half. The one sauce didn't quite cut it for the whole 'zone. I'd definitely recommend it. Also, their Caesar salad was actually very tasty! The salad I asked for it lightly dressed, and they brought it perfectly. Overall the service was great and it had the quirky mellow vibe.

I went to mellow mushroom in search of some good pizza ! Man did I hit the jackpot. They had all…read moretypes of pizza for my liking's. I recommend the funky q chicken pizza. The caramelized onions and bbq are something special to that pizza. I love the option of having the whole or split pizza toppings. I also recommend the cloud 9 garlic Parmesan wings. Also get the 10 piece 5 is a tease. The service was pretty fast and attentive , as the food was made fresh to order. The ambiance gives me like a stoner vibe with the mushrooms and outstanding colors lit around. Definitely recommend and I will be back!!

I've been here a few times... The food and the wait staff is always excellent! Plus, I grew up in…read moreCollierville, so visiting the square is a very nostalgic thing for me...

We enjoyed a patio dinner on a cool March evening…read more The Pros: --Friendliness of the Hostess --Waitstaff Service (timely and personable) --The ambiance of the patio overlooking the square --The Brie pizza (big thanks to the recommendations here) The Cons: --TN Mosquitos (post-7pm they made their appearance) --Chicken Parm (pasta was dry, chicken was soggy) The Indifferent: --Lasagna (hubby said mine is better and I am by no means a chef!) --Cheese bread appetizer Overall, we enjoyed ourselves but much of that had to do with service and ambiance, not the food. Previous visits offered a lot more/better by the way of food, so we'll likely to give it another try and hope for a better experience.

Ordered to-go pizza for two people. I personally customized both pizzas to be vegetarian and one to…read morebe vegan. Ingredients were fresh, crust was crispy and tasty. The extra side drizzles and sauces really elevate the flavor. I would really recommend a mix of the spicy marinara and pesto sauces for any pizza. The spicy ranch and honey make for fantastic drizzles. Overall, a great option for a vegan/vegetarian meal.

Popped in for a quick bite. I ordered the BBQ salad and the shredded pork tasted like shoe…read moreleather that's been sitting around. The salad was mostly lettuce with about 4 big, tough pieces of meat. My son got a gluten free pizza that looked decent...the crust wasn't that great but the pizza itself was just ok. Nothing to scream in delight about.