Lost is my go to pizza spot when I'm in Memphis. This time i decided to order from the Southaven location and I regret it drastically. I placed my order via Local, which was easy. The wait time was only like 20 minutes. My pizza looks uncooked. My Popeye pizza barely has any toppings and I paid for sun-dried tomatoes and got regular :( There is no way my pizza's looked similar in the box. One was regular sauce and the other Alfredo. I will not be back to this location. I was not satisfied. read more

Lost Pizza Co - Popeye - Pizza Near Me - Southaven, Mississippi

See all

We've eaten here a lot. The pizza is good. Sometimes great. The place is always busy. They serve beer and it's a fun and kinda quirky establishment. I don't like that you have to ask for silverware. I don't care for the plates you get. Service is hit or miss. And as I said, the food can range from good to great. Just depends on the night. read more

See all

Loved the outside seating and my sandwich was 10/10!!!! Also the chips... so good. Will be trying the pizza next

Good pizza; I love the crust that they make! Everything is seasoned well, and I like the proportions of sauce, cheese, and toppings.

AMAZING FOOD! When I tried the Otis *angelic choir* amazing, would totally recommend, WAY better than Domino's.

What happened this Lost Pizza location? for several years it was my favorite pizza in the area, but no more. The young female obviously did not care anything about customer service. I ordered a thick crust Otis. The pizza I ordered was thin crust and had almost no meat or cheese. Plus, it was overcooked to the point of being crispy. Service was extremely slow even though the restaurant wasn't crowded. The young female who took my order also brought the finished pizza. When she brought it she pretty much just plopped it down on the table and started walking off. I asked her as she left if I could have a knife and fork, and she said over her shoulder she would bring them. of course she didn't. read more

Please, please, please start putting sauce on the pizza. I order extra sauce every time and there is hardly any. The pizza with "regular sauce", literally has NONE. It's just cheese and pepperoni on bread. read more

Lost Pizza Co - Where's the sauce? - Pizza Near Me - Southaven, Mississippi

Went for lunch. The pizza and salad combo is a great deal! The service was fast and the food was really fresh.

Great pizza but the timing is for shit. My point - we (4 of us) ordered a cheese bread appetizer and 4 individual pizzas, 3 thin and 1 thick. First came 1 thin, then a couple minutes later our cane thins 2 and 3. A couple more minutes later the thick. Does it seem like I forgot the breadsticks? I didn't but the staff sure did. I am presently 1/2 way through my pizza slow rolling like a mug trying to see if my cheese bread is ever gonna get here. F it I'm heading up to get a refund. read more

the customer service is very good and the pizza is is perfect and a right amount of cheese also free refills, which is awesome part of the restaurant. The people at the counter are so nice and basically give you anything you want. read more

Lost Pizza Co - Pizza Near Me - Southaven, Mississippi

Amazing pizza and it's even better reheated! My son loves the Alfredo pasta as well. The cheese bread is another favorite that we order when there. Try it! read more

Very good! We got cheese bread and a two topping pizza for $20! Very cheesy! Cute, clean little place. read more

Lost Pizza Co - Mushroom pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Southaven, Mississippi

This Lost Pizza Co. is seriously lost. Hopefully they can find themselves and start providing more quality food. This was my first time visiting the Southaven, MS location. We started with the hot tamales and boneless wings as appetizers. They were average tasting but I would not order them again. We ordered a thin crust Kujo Pizza (something I've had multiple times at other locations). Don't get me wrong, the toppings were plenty BUT placed on the pizza inconsistently. The sausage was also weird, super chunky and there were way too much on the pizza AND the cheese was severely lacking. To top it off, the pizza was just barely warm when it was brought out. After a few slices, I just got disgusted. I've gone to Lost Pizza in Indianola, MS and Cleveland, MS and this location was subpar to both. read more

See all

The pizza was OK. It wasn't really anything to write home about but if you're craving pizza it'll fix your craving.

The food was delicious! We were in Southaven for a baseball tournament and decided to try this spot. Our group ordered spaghetti, Alfredo and pizza and they did not disappoint. I must add, the customer service we experienced was absolutely outstanding. I highly recommend giving it a try--you won't be disappointed! Rating: read more

I try to give restaurants a break because one bad aspect shouldn't reflect poorly on the restaurant as a whole HOWEVER, nothing positive remotely comes to mind regarding our visit. We eat at our local Lost Pizza weekly so we chose to eat at the one in Southaven while in town and it is definitely not ran the same. It was busy but not overly, there were empty tables the entire time we were here but service was terrible. My son and I were finished with our food and I had to ask about my husbands personal size pizza before he ever got it. When ordering we had to change our order several times because she kept telling us they were out of everything we had tried to order - at least 5 items at this point, no sign or anything to notify customers. We got our cups and were then told that they were out of ice so the tea and lemonade would be hot. My son does not drink any type of soft drink so he was going to drink his sweet tea hot, got to the tea and got a few drops of sweet tea and you guessed it, it was out also. We sat at our table and had to get condiments and paper towels off of another table since ours didn't have any. Once our salads came the lettuce was brown - very much past serving condition. We ended up with about half a salad each by the time we each got out the bad lettuce. I ordered the baked spaghetti and it was not baked - maybe stuck in the microwave to melt the very small amount of cheese but the dish was not baked. Sauce was cold and there was absolutely no seasoning or taste to my dish nor my sons chicken Alfredo. Not one staff member ever questioned the large pile of brown lettuce on the table, never asked how our food was or spoke to us after we got our food. We will NEVER be back to this location. Save yourself $65 for 3 people to eat very poorly made food. read more

Lost Pizza Co - Pizza Near Me - Southaven, Mississippi

See all

Employees not practicing social distancing or wearing mask. Ordered a to-go order and was told 20 minutes. Arrived and went in to pay 20 min later. They told me the printer had broke in the back and therefore they did not receive the order for it to be made. Must wait another 15 minutes. Hopefully the food is good... Update: food was good. A little pricey for what you get. read more

Fantastic pizza joint! Very chill atmosphere. Great for family also. The service is friendly and fast. My wife wanted to try a Tangerine Mikes Hard Lemonade and the cashier went to grab one out of the unopened case just specifically for her. The pizza is much better than the "chain" places. I prefer thin crust but they are both superb. Many options to pick from and you can customize your own. If you are in a pizza mood you gotta give Lost Pizza try! read more

Lost Pizza Co - The Otis - Pizza Near Me - Southaven, Mississippi

This place has been my favorite pizza in Desoto county for a few years. Today and the past couple times I came here, not as good. I paid for a large pizza. They brought my grandsons small personal pizza out first and the cheese was easily melty. He picked up a piece and cheese was melted and looked like it should. My wife and I pizza came out and it was lukewarm. Cheese was meted but not melty. I told them I expect pizza to be hot when I'm sitting 30 feet from the pizza oven. I've had delivery that was warmer than this. The pizza was dry as a bone....not enough sauce...and overcooked. They said they could throw it back in the oven or make another. Didn't feel like waiting another 20 minutes so I said if you can warm it up without burning it. It came out hotter but toppings were dried out and cheese still didn't melt. Probably won't be going back. Sad, it used to be my favorite. read more

Wings were good, pizza was good. Staff was friendly. Cost was moderate for a restaurant.

We have been to this location a couple of times and both times I have been pretty pleased with the food and the service. I dig the "quick service" feel by ordering at the counter along with the self serve drinks. It allows my kids the ability to get what they want without any fuss and you don't have to wait on anyone to bring you anything. Just don't forget silverware. This last visit my wife ordered for all of us. She ordered Tamales to start with. I am a bit of a Tamale snob so I have to admit I was scared eating them here. I anticipated the worst but was pleasantly surprised by the dish. They were actually good. They aren't your Mexican Tamales but the Delta style. They were steamed well and assembled correctly with just the right amount of heat and chili flavor. We also had a few pizzas to share and they were also good. Not the best by any means but a solid pie none the less. The BBQ pizza was probably the best we had because we had the kids to we had Cheese, Hawaiian, and Pepperoni. We had the BBQ on the Thick Crust and it was pretty awesome actually. They all had more than adequate cheese on them and were delivered hot, crunchy on the bottom, and gooey on the top just like they should be. Solid experience. I also dig the atmosphere and decor... Pretty groovy... man... read more

See all

This place is great excellent service great food and atmosphere we came in from Texas everyone told me go here and we did everything we had was perfect Thanks so much read more

In addition to pizza this place serves, subs, pasta dishes and they also serve beer. It is a nice decent sized place that has its own personality. There is ample space between tables, you wont be too close for comfort when sitting near other patrons. The staff is very friendly. The pizzas come in 3 sizes, individual, medium and large. You can pick from the menu or create your own. The crusts are thick crust or thin. Im not sure if they do anything other than traditional style. The desserts are pizza desserts, kind of like CiCi's pizza does their desserts. Cash/Credit/Debit cards are accepted here. read more

Lost Pizza Co - Lost Pizza has been found! By Me! - Pizza Near Me - Southaven, Mississippi

See all

Great choices for veggies and meatlovers. Casual atmosphere.i love the happy hippy. Love the blues decor with memorabilia.

The Southaven location never has a manager of any kind on site. The teenagers seem to run the place and therefore you are at the mercy of their timeframe which is nothing but talking amongst themselves. This evening while we were in we ordered toasted ravioli and a pizza... simple enough, right? Well the toasted ravioli came out with the pizza and were so hard we couldn't cut them. We've learned not even complain as there is no one there to deal with the issue. They apologized but didn't offer anything to fix their error. We actually love the pizza here so it's hard not to come back- just don't expect anything extra because you aren't going to get it. read more

Stopped by here off a whim. Pizza was a solid B+. I got the thin crust which was a good choice. Service was good and the pizza didn't take long to deliver. Great amount of pizza to topping ratio and would say the cheese is melted just right. One of the better pizza places I've had. I would give it 8/10 overall. read more

Lost Pizza Co - The Hot Chick - Pizza Near Me - Southaven, Mississippi

See all

This place is nice it has good pizza. Good service real nice people. Try this pizza if you get to MS it is really good pizza read more

Family wanted to try a place we haven't been. The Lost Pizza has been found in the cut. The wings were tasty they had a good mild flavor. FatBoy's Bacon Cheeseburger pizza were for the kids, they loved it, next time it will be a different one. All yeah the he Aunt Vickies Spinach an artichoke Dip is made fresh daily. read more

See all

This place used to be good but last 3 times it has been subpar. Pizza has hardly any cheese even though I ordered and paid for extra cheese. Other toppings are lacking too. Not a good value- overpriced and you are better off ordering papa John's read more

One of the BEST pizza/Italian places in town with GREAT, very friendly service!!! They really cheese up their pizza so unless your wanting an overload I wouldn't order "extra cheese"!! And absolutely be sure to try their "olive bread"....it's DELISH!! read more

Great pizza joint! Great atmosphere... a little on the pricier side but combinations was delicious. We got their version of supreme and Hawaiian. Boys got cheese and pepperoni. We also got cheese sticks. We got two thin crust and one thick crust. I prefer an even thinner crust, and that is the only reason I didn't give it 5 stars, and the price being just a little high. Definitely go back, and they serve Coke!! Go and Enjoy! read more

I have absolutely fallen in love with Lost Pizza Company. If it wasn't for trying to lose some weight, I could probably eat there every night. :) The thin crust Lucille is just right if you want a pizza that is delicious but doesn't feel too heavy. The Buffalo wings hit just right too! Can't wait for my next visit. read more

They have a great lunch special. I always try to stop there when Memphis for work. Very roomy interior, always kept clean. Even the day that we were there, that they were very busy. Food still came out in a very timely fashion. I was there with a friend, he had the pasta, was not impressed. I told him that's because they're known for their pizza. Will return read more

Went here told me friend how good it was bragging , and it was terrible I was embarrassed, the ingredients were dumped in the middle of the pizza so actually it was a medium lol ordered a large Kujo. Actually a medium because 3 inches off the crust I couldn't eat! If you want good pizza I recommend you drive to COLLETAS. GOOGLE THEM. I didn't even complain, I'm just never going back and it's obvious there didn't want me to come back I don't recommend this place! YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED read more

Ordered 3 personals, cheese, Popeye (thin) and the Kujo (thin). The pizzas were good but since they don't delivery, picked up and pizzas were not piping hot by the time we drove back to the house, less than 10 miles. It'd be nice to add a foil in the personal box to keep hot, something, or DELIVER, the deduction of one star. read more

Awesome pizza especially for the price! We stayed at Graceland Guest House and spent way too much on all the must haves and well we were saved by Lost Pizza by not having to spend an arm and a leg on feeding the tribe! Thank you! read more

This wings are $13.99 a dozen .this things are so tiny I cant believe they could even sell these.!!! read more

Lost Pizza Co - Humming bird wings . - Pizza Near Me - Southaven, Mississippi

Just ordered the "hot" wings and I don't know what was put in those wings...it physically hurt to eat them by several people. I've had these wings many times and never have I eaten a wing this hot. read more

We went and ate there for dinner. The food was amazing. We were served this it very quickly and the service was great. We had the baked spaghetti and chicken Alfredo. Would definitely recommend for a casual dinner. read more

Lost Pizza Co - Baked Spaghetti - Pizza Near Me - Southaven, Mississippi

See all

Eaten here many times and pizza is average to above average. I just walked in at 7:15 PM on 11/27/20 and the only person wearing a mask that works there was the cashier to protect themselves. None of the people in the kitchen nor anyone moving the pizza from the window to the counter and serving drinks had a mask on. This tells me all you care about is yourselves and not your customers or the quality of your product. I am out out out. read more