Ordered a custom built with cupping pepperoni. You have to pick between thick or thin crust. No regular. So I erred on the side of caution and went thin. Waited half an hour and got what looked like a cheese pizza with 1 pepperoni on it and no cupping pepperoni. Told one person and they said maybe it's under the cheese and the cupping pepperoni just flattens out as a result. I gave her the "c'mon now" look as their own pictures show it on top and nicely cupped. She said hey I just work here. Told the cashier and she said she entered it correctly and then the same story about how maybe it's just under the cheese. Then she just shrugged and smiled. Then Spoke with someone else and they said it's definitely wrong but that they could fix it. I heard them telling the back guys to just rebake the same pizza and I stopped them because I knew the bottom would be burnt af. She said she would have them make a new one. It came out faster. Maybe 15 minutes. when I finally got my pizza there weren't a ton of pepperoni. Taste wise it wasn't anything special. I'd say just average at best. Lots of customers here but they do have a prime location. Not sure what "lost" means in the name but I sure hope they find their way someday given their prime location. read more

See all

Stopped by when dropping off my son to work. It was our first time eating here so he recommended certain dishes that he thought we might like. When we first walked in there was one party ordering in front of us. Gave us time to fully look over the menu. We ended up ordering half cheese (cause my little one and I love a plain cheese pizza) and half Otis (cause my husband is a meat lovers). We also got an order of the cheese nuggies which were pretty good and had a great cheese pull. When the pizza came out the cheese did not disappoint. The meats on the Otis were actually really good and sliced perfect. Whoever does prep of the meats does a really great job. read more

See all

We use to love getting pizza from here on Friday nights but we have been highly disappointed the last few times we have ordered from them. The food does not seem to be cooked to the standards they use to. In our last order the cinnamon and cheese sticks were so bad we didn't even eat them. read more

Lost Pizza Co - Cinnamon Sticks - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

See all

Building, inside & seating, and service are all fairly good. Presentation and menu are very presentable. However, I have never tasted a more mundane pizza in my life, save for maybe CiCi's. I had a Kujo medium pizza, very little sauce on it, and the recipe of the sauce bore absolutely no flavor. In my world, sauce volume and taste are what makes the pie. Also, I got the feeling that the staff of youngster here were all players in some Halloween Broadway show, black clothes, odd makeup/hair colors, and perhaps actors in a Rocky Horror production. After reading other reviews on Yelp here, I see why. read more

Lost Pizza Co - 4 pizzas and ordinary sauce flavor! - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

People rave about this place but I don't get the hype. The taste of the pizza was okay but the crust had a strange texture. Our group came in a couple of hours before closing and the staff were all sitting at a table booth and talking instead of standing behind the counter. At some point while we were eating, the staff started goofing off and chasing each other around the restaurant which was very strange. The decor inside was cute. read more

Lost Pizza Co - El Diablo (SM) - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

It was my first time at this location and it seemed pretty hectic. The cashier seemed pretty flustered and in the back you could hear other employees argue about people's orders. The food was good, but took a while to come out. I didn't like how they limit you to one drink at a time. I couldn't bring my two drinks at once because the cashier didn't believe I was going to drink both myself. She wanted to make sure I wasn't sharing with anyone else. It seemed a bit weird. Probably won't be coming back. read more

Lost Pizza Co - Pepperoni with jalapeños - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

Good food, support local businesses, good atmosphere. Great service. Always nice time to go.

The cheese bread and pizza were both very good. Always looking for more places that offer thick crust and was glad to see they offer it. I got a veggie pizza without cheese to make it vegan and it was very good. Pizza sauce has a nice amount of herbs. Filling food, good service and friendly staff. read more

Lost Pizza Co - The Hippie Veggie pizza small, garlic instead of black olive - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

See all

Very good, pizza was delicious and the size of the gluten free was more than enough for two to share for lunch. The queso was really really good and the chips were super crisp and tasty. We also got our food lightening fast for being made to order pizza. Highly recommend this location. read more

See all

Cheese all the way to the edges, the way it should be!! 4 stars because staff should know which beers are local, especially since the taps had the word Memphis on them. Hey management, great job with the chefs! Work on the front end. If they are old enough to serve it then they should know something about it. I'll be back when I'm in town next time anyway. read more

Delivery all wrong! Like many area restaurants our order was wrong once again! Missing an item from our order. The pizza and food in general is not even that good! Many other options! Never going back! Tell the kids working there to layoff the weed when working!!!! read more

Workers friendly. Food not great. Worst artichoke dip I've ever tasted. Those who got spaghetti enjoyed it.

I know that all of my reviews have been five stars lately, but I've not been out much until recently and I'm making all of my outings count. We were apparently very hungry when we ordered. We ordered a Greek salad, tamales and a medium Kujo pizza. We could have split any of the three instead of splitting all three and bringing home another two meals. Who doesn't like cold pizza for breakfast though? Both the service and the food were great. We will be going back again. Next time I'll order the tamales and nothing else. I failed on taking tamale and pizza photos, but got one of the salad. read more

Lost Pizza Co - Greek Salad - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

I tried the Lost Pizza Co. today in Collierville. This was a delicious pizza and the individual size was perfect for lunch. I ordered the Lucille and a drink and my total was a little over $15. The crust was crunchy and buttery and the toppings tasted very fresh. I'll definitely go back to try another style of pizza! The atmosphere was very unique which I enjoyed. It had a little grunge with a little rock 'n roll. Definitely try this place if you're in the Memphis area. read more

See all

Was talked into goving this place another try by my wife. Whoever owns/manages this place needs to do some serious house keeping when it comes to employees. The kid behind the counter barely speaks to you, just says ok and stands there. Im so tired of dealing with retards. read more

I'm so excited for this restaurant! I've only eaten here one or twice and I've had a few samples at Yelp events. I brought my family here after we saw Avengers: End Game. It was a good finale to the night. The decorations were pretty cool and we sat in the back room so we could discuss the movie. They describe their seating as a bar area and back area but I didn't really see a bar. The pizza's pretty expensive so we only ordered two. We didn't want to worry about being hungry after so we opted for regular crust instead of thin crust. It was really good but I definitely preferred the Lucille over the Kujo. I'd love to come back and try some more stuff. To Try: The Islander Grilled Chicken Alfredo The Otis Sandwiches: Mr. G Love: - Italian Sausage and Pepperoni - Lucille - Pepperoni and Pineapple Like: - Cheese - Pepperoni Ok: - Happy Hippie - Hot Chick - Kujo Dislike: - El Diablo - Mississippi Delta Hot Tamales - Pit Boss - Queso Dip read more

Lost Pizza Co - The Kujo - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

See all

We ordered the spinach artichoke dip and it came out so cold that the chips couldn't go through the top layer of cheese. We sent it back and it came back out slightly warm to the touch. We took it back a second time and it finally came out hot but it was either so old or the cheddar cheese they put on it the third time around messed with the flavor. Our pizza was good, especially the crust. The bathroom was a wreck. I hate to give a bad review to any restaurant on the square but this is our 5th visit and the service is always bad. Please do better! We like the concept and the food is usually better. read more

As an international traveling food critic and unbeknownst to the staff, the following is what I experienced: + Hostess was very welcoming and personable. + Pleasurable atmosphere. + Quality of food was excellent. If you are in the area and don't take the time to dine here, you missed out on a superb experience. read more

If you want to wait almost an hour for a to-go order then this is the place for you. After reading other reviews on this restaurant, my experience is not a one-off. There were approximately 12 other people waiting in the lobby for their to-go orders. Staffing doesn't seem to be a problem at this place because I saw plenty of staff wandering around, some of them standing around not doing much. While I was waiting in the lobby, I saw no less than three dine-in customers who had to go to the front counter to ask for plates, silver ware, etc. Again, staffing is not the issue, that's just an excuse. Management needs to get it together or this place won't last. read more

Delicious food love the atmosphere an friendly staff. Great family place to eat an stroll around the square. read more

i echo many others comments. It's Friday night at 4:24pm and i just spent the last 10 minutes trying to get them to answer the phone. I used to be a fan of this local pizza place but i haven't ordered from them recently because of their terrible customer service. If you happen to get them on the phone and go to pick up your order, they have 1 line for those who have pickup orders and those who are dining in and only 1 register open so you spend 20 minutes waiting in line while everyone in front of you places orders for dining in. why can't you have someone take of those who are just picking up already done orders? On top of that they have an order but on their website but it's disabled so young even order there. Too many other good pizza places in town (Memphis Pizza Cafe and NY Style Pizza) to put up with horrible customer service. After not getting them on the phone tonight I placed my order at Memphis Pizza Cafe and they answered in a couple rings. They were busy also when i picked up but they've been trained on how to take orders. You lost my business again. maybe forever. You get one star because zero isn't an option. read more

Our student organization was working to raise funds for a student in the community, and Lost Pizza graciously agreed to donate a portion of the proceeds of the sales to our mission. Love the support of local businesses when they pour into the community- and the fried ravioli is delicious! Thank you so much for working with us! read more

The best freakin pizza and beer a man could ask for. Staff was amazing. Will be going again very soon.

Really enjoyed the pizza and atmosphere. Highly recommend the large pizza for two people thin crust. read more

Tried the Islander and diablo pizza tonight with house salads. Pizza was really good. Didn't feel heavy nor packed with cheese. All the flavors came through nicely balanced. Love the decor too. Will go back for sure. When my husband asked the waitress why it was called Lost Pizza she said she didn't know but that they do tend to lose a lot of pizzas on Friday nights. ?!? So, heads up if you order on Friday. read more

Been meaning to write this review for some time now and never got the opportunity. Going to take a brief second to knock one out. Is this place worth trying? Absolutely! If I faulted them for anything, it would have been my wife's selection. She order the baked spaghetti. What she got wasn't baked spaghetti. It was just spaghetti. The server should have known that, but hey...she said she was new so I'm going to let them off on that note because the rest of the food was excellent. Large selection to choose from and the atmosphere was great. read more

Lost Pizza Co - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

See all

They don't answer their phone. So I drive there to order. Plenty of parking and tables available and no line to order but they can't answer their phone?!? I order repeating myself and asking for confirmation yet they still screwed up the order. Their pizza is not so terrific that this situation is acceptable. I would recommend that you consider any other pizza option vs this one. Mark read more

Fantastic atmosphere with great decorations, the food came out really fast, and was absolutely delicious and the cashiers were very friendly, you should always get thick crust pizzas, will definitely be coming back. read more

Lost Pizza Co - Individual thick crust pizza Italian sausage and pork sausage - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

Was in the Collierville area so stopped in at a fave, Lost Pizza. Weekend crew. Was courteously greeted and my order was taken right away. Pizza came out in a timely manner. J.B. and Makayla went over-the-top in making sure I had a great experience & quality eats! Thanks for a great meal. read more

Would have given a one star but at least the restaurant itself was cool to look around. But here goes the real review. We've eaten at allll the lost pizzas. This by far was the worst as far as service. Yes alll get super busy on a Friday night. I get that. But no one was bussing tables. NO ONE. The table we used we cleaned off and put stuff on another messy table. Some people came after us and moved the stuff we put on it on another messy table. And until we left did someone clean off THAT table that now how THREE tables mess on. Ridiculous!! As far as the staff. They all looked lost. And unorganized. That would be funny considering your restaurant name. But it isn't. It's easy. Someone take orders. Someone cooks it. Someone serves it. And someone cleans up after. Nope they all looked like they were hovering over the exit window for the food to come out. Lost. Lost. Lost. As I watched the orders taken out of the kitchen...So much of the food was going OUT of the restaurant. Must have been Uber eats or something bc more food was going OUT than staying in the restaurant. If you want to make this a to go place only then close the dining room doors ORRRR get someone who is more organized to show how to do both in building and out building orders. The food was okay. We probably will order to go from now on or if ever again. Bc we can serve ourselves better than we got in the restaurant. Literally bc we cleaned our own tables. Suggestion. Hire competent people. Hire someone to manage them. And hire someone to train to do their JOBS!! Sooo disappointed. read more

I have had Lost Pizza in the past and I ordered the pizza. For some reason, I thought I wasn't that hungry, so I ordered a half order of spaghetti & meatballs. It was ok. The garlic bread was a nice addition. However, I regret not ordering pizza. I ordered my husband Jamaican Jerk wings to go and he enjoyed them. I will give this location props for being a bright new spot off the square and having a nice meeting space for groups. It's a lovely location. I would stick with the pizza & wings. read more

Lost Pizza Co - Spaghetti & Meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

Pizza was just ok. Beef was overcooked. Took 37 minutes to get the pizza. Appetizer arrived 5 minutes after the pizza. Workers looked like they were not excited to be working Had issues 2 times before. Maybe it's me read more

This is a great neighborhood spot with unique and delicious pizza. My family always makes great memories here in the comfortable and spacious restaurant. After trying a few different items, my favorites are the Diablo and the bbq pizza (I can't remember the name). I prefer the think crust because in my opinion the thick doesn't get quite done enough. The wings are really good too! And my son loves the cheese bread! Great family place! read more

See all

Good food but waaaaay overpriced. A medium pizza with the cauliflower crust was $20? Really?

Very good crust did not care for the sauce , price abut steep . It's a ok, but I prefer a few others or them!

I'm the first to review!! So far this place looks neat. I will update my review later with the food. It just opened like yesterday so I am happy to try them. Next time we need to get The Otis. read more

Not thrilled with the quality of this salad! Then I tasted it and was even more unimpressed. Probably the worst salad I've had. read more

Lost Pizza Co - Chef salad $6.99 - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

Pizza Mid, if you want a pie. There are cheaper & better options. Price don't reflect what you get & the taste is Mid.

We were a party of 5 and ordered pizza, a sandwich and tamales. The dessert pizza came out first followed by two pizzas. 15 mins later the sandwich but no tamales. We had to finally go ask and they said it was unfortunately put in a to go box and had been sitting there. They just put it on a plate without getting new ones or putting the chili on top so we had to ask for that. The girls that waited on us just could care less that the people eating pizza were done by the time the last person in the party got their food. I have tried to call the manager Kristy and Tim. Left message for Kristy to call me back and left my number but never received a call. Won't go back. read more

Just ok. I generally get an all-meat pizza from one of the many options in Collierville - Memphis Pizza Cafe, 3 Guys, Ciao Baby, etc. I have to say this was the most disappointing of the aforementioned eateries while also being the most expensive (my medium "Otis" pizza was $18.99). I'm not sure if the pizza would have been better fresh out of the oven (I did carry out), but the picture says enough for the pizza that's supposedly, "the daddy of all meat-lovers". My wife got a custom gluten-free pizza which she said was better than most in town so those with gluten sensitivity/celiac's may keep that in mind. If you're looking for quality and value, this is probably not the place. I'd maybe give it another shot as dine-in, with a group, and maybe try some other options since it does have a great location and seemingly good variety. read more

Lost Pizza Co - "The Otis" - not as meaty as I'd hoped.... - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee