Cancel

Open app

Search

Mel's Magickal Meals

4.7 (3 reviews)

Mel's Magickal Meals Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Mel's Magickal Meals

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

1 month ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of K B.
0
4
0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Caterers 2,508 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Tanglewood Catering

Tanglewood Catering

(10 reviews)

Nick and his team at Tanglewood are wonderful! As an event coordinator, I have hired Nick for…read moreseveral times, as well as for my own backyard wedding! His staff is so polite and jumped right into with any requests that I had. They were flexible and able to adjust their normal routine to work at this wedding as our event was an unusual location hosting a wedding at a horse farm. Nick was able to come up with unique ideas on how to set up and cater an amazing wedding in a unique location with under circumstances that are very different from a typical venue. As always, the food was incredible. Breakdown at the end of the night was quick and tidy! 10/10 would recommend!

Nick and his crew did an outstanding job at my son's wedding. First off, he sat and listened to my…read moreson and his fiancé and then captured all their wishes into a fairy tale experience. Nick set up a 40 x 40 ft tent flawlessly, provided all the lighting and the table chairs, dishes etc etc - basically everything. He then set up an on-site kitchen that delivered with some of the best food: His chateaubriand grilled on a charcoal grill was outrageous. His calamari was tender and cooked on sight. His salads were fantastic, and even the asparagus was great. For dessert his Banana foster garnered rave reviews. Likewise for his shrimp, salmon and lamb chops. No one left hungry or disappointed. Nick had the good thought at our home based wedding located on the Great South Bay to drop the flaps on the tent when the wind picked up at the end of the ceremony. We didn't have to tell him - he anticipated what we needed for the event to be a success. That is Nick's secret - his experience and cooking expertise makes him anticipate your needs before you do! His crew of 6 were so helpful and caring. Every guest told us it was the best wedding they had been to. Why? Great food, caring help, smart plentiful choices. When the great evening was done, the backyard was left spotless with almost no reminders a great event occurred there. I wish I had photos to add but we were all busy enjoying ourselves, so I will post when we get them from the photographer Thank you Nick and the Tanglewood crew- you are the best!

Riviera Waterfront Mansion

Riviera Waterfront Mansion

(98 reviews)

Beautiful Wedding, Disappointing Ending…read more Our experience with this venue was very positive throughout most of my Niece's wedding day, which makes the evening ending especially disappointing. At approximately 11:45 p.m. there were only our immediate family and two cars remaining. We were not socializing or lingering--we were actively packing up a large number of wedding items. Unfortunately, the staff became extremely aggressive about getting us out, despite the fact that there was a torrential storm outside. They closed the ballroom doors while we were still trying to retrieve our belongings, and the staff repeatedly rushed us. The maitre d' was particularly unpleasant and even confrontational. At one point, she even screamed at the DJ because they were seven minutes over the scheduled time. What was most upsetting to me was how the bride herself was treated on her wedding night. My Niece was trying to make sure everything had been collected, including the gift/money box and a large stack of photo-booth pictures. She was told the money box had been packed into a bin, but when she asked to verify it, it wasnt there! She politely asked if she could go back into the ballroom to look, since the doors were closed up already. They very reluctantly allowed her to do so, and lo and behold, she thankfully found the money box still sitting inside the ballroom, along with the photo booth pictures. I had actually been worried about leaving those items unattended but they rushed me out saying they would take care of moving them to the lobby, They did not! There was also an expensive package of large sparklers unused that the venue was making an exception for. While everyone was being rushed out, the large package of sparklers disappeared. We never found them and the staff played dumb. The staff also argued repeatedly with my Niece when she asked if she could return the next morning to pick up some larger items that simply could not fit into our vehicles because the tool to break them down was missing. She was told in no uncertain terms no it wasnt allowed. Other wedding venues allow you to pick up the next day cheerfully. These people wouldn't budge. The maitre d' lady was Especially Disappointing. As the person in charge at the end of the evening, she had the opportunity to show leadership, patience, basic empathy and grace, particularly toward a bride who was simply trying to collect here belongings during a rainstorm. Instead, her tone was harsh, confrontational, and completely lacking in compassion, stressing out my beloved Niece and ruining the end of the evening. Truly avoidable. More concerning, she appeared to be directing or encouraging the staff to take an unnecessarily rude and aggressive approach rather than helping us finish packing safely and efficiently. They were actually standing there glaring at us. I'm not kidding! Her behavior set the tone for the entire ending of the night and made an already stressful situation even worse. A person in a leadership position should model professionalism and courtesy, not instruct or permit staff to treat a bride and her family as though they were a problem to be removed. We are calm nice people and we completely understand that a venue has a closing time and that the staff need to finish their work. But there is a huge difference between efficiently wrapping up an event and treating a bride and her family as though they are a huge inconvenience, particularly when they are actively packing and trying as fast as they can to leave in a downpour. We have attended many weddings, and it is common for venues to allow a little extra time when guests are genuinely trying to finish packing, plus the venues also have no problem letting you pick up items the next morning if needed. A little patience and courtesy would have made all the difference. Maybe we just had the bad luck to get this particular staff that night. What should have been a happy, joyous final moments of my Niece's wedding night were filled with stress, arguing and the staff rushing her and her family out into a torrential storm. Not to mention the staff was tipped very well in advance. The wedding itself was beautiful and the staff that helped my Niece with the planning were good, but the end of the night staff were just low class. The way they handled the end of the night left a very bad impression and overshadowed what should have been a wonderful final memory for the bride. A bride should never have to spend the end of her wedding might arguing with venue staff over retrieving her own belongings. Or overhearing the maitre d' yelling at a DJ who did a fantastic job saying they would never work there again! Very disappointing display.

We had my daughter's wedding there last Saturday. They were wonderful. The service was terrific…read morefrom the owners to the waiters, everyone was helpful and a calming influence! The food was outrageously delicious. The viennese table was ridiculously great! This location is absolutely breathtaking and the team there was the very best at what they do. Highly recommend!

Mel's Magickal Meals - catering - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...